Excellent food: Philly steak sandwich was extremely delicious! Best I have tasted thus far!

I ordered a 42 there was a line my husbands order was finished right away and we asked for everything to go. I didn't get a chance to add anything to my 42 bowl wasn't even offered no fork. I asked were the lettuce and tomatoes were and they said the bowls didn't come with one read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Number 42 bowl - Fast Food Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

See all

The sandwiches, service are great. Ordered on the app. They made our sandwiches perfectly.

The first time I had Jersey Mike's subs was about a month and a half ago when our corporate office brought in Jersey Mike's for lunch, it was amazing! I could definitely do without the rosemary salt stuff on the sandwich, though. I've been wanting to go grab a sandwich for lunch a few times just don't get over that direction. This weekend I decided I was going to drive 20 miles to go have Jersey Mikes Sub for lunch. I walked in, the atmosphere is OK, it's not nothing fancy, but your greeted and service is fast and friendly. The ingredients on the sandwich is fresh. It's chilled. It's amazing! I absolutely love the oil and vinegar. I actually asked for them to put extra on for me. I had them keep off the rosemary salt sprinkle. This has now become my favorite place for sub sandwiches, hands down! read more

We came in on a Saturday at lunchtime and we received fast, friendly service. The food was fresh and delicious too. We will be back soon!

Had their sandwich for the first time today. Freaking amazing! Whoever hasn't had this place yet needs to call in sick tomorrow and go and get a sandwich and then reminisce on how good it was for the rest of the day. Wow wow wow. This Mike guy outdid himself. Subway who?! Jimmy John's who??? Blimpie WHOOOOOO??? Pretty sure this sandwich will cure your depression. Be prepared for a burst of happiness. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #13 The Original Italian - Fast Food Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

Staff is extremely friendly and eager to help you. They pay a lot of attention to the customers. They aren't distracted talking to each other like they are at most places. They were SUPER friendly. My sandwich was well made with lots of meat packed on, another thing I appreciate. Too many sandwich places go cheap and give you little meat, this place did not. This place was clean and well maintained. I had a good experience, and I would go again. I recommend this location. read more

I love East Coast style cold deli submarine sandwiches. Jersey Mike's makes them: Fresh bread rolls, oil & vinegar, salt and pepper. That's "Mike's Way". And my roast beef & provolone sub was made that way, with shredded lettuce, tomatoes, onions and pickled jalapeno peppers. For some added flavor I picked the Parmesan Rosemary White roll. But when I took the first bite, it was one of the blandest subs that I have ever tasted. So I tried the rare roast beef alone (which looked fantastic), and I discovered that it had no seasoning. While I appreciate the lack of sodium saturated meat, you can take the cause too far. Fortunately I was taking this sub home, so I added some more potassium salt, fresh ground black pepper, and Chipotle aioli sauce to save the sandwich. With that added flavor it was tasty, but the aioli disqualified it as a true East Coast sub. The service was good (Nina is amazing) but the sandwich was pretty disappointing. read more

Always greeted when I walk in. Ambience okay. Service is great! I've never had anything that wasn't absolutely delicious. I could eat there every day. Can't wait to try new things including subs turned into salads. read more

I love there subs has the best sauces for sandwiches jersey mikes. I have given 5 stars for caldwell. Service is awesome

I do recommend this place, food was great. unfortunately the service at my location wasn't exactly great. they were in a rush, which is typically fine it was lunch time. my mom and i were getting a sub to share, we wanted a club supreme, so we told the lady that and said please. she was making our sandwich and my mom was asking hey is this ours? because it wasnt ours (it was she misunderstood us) , it was a #8 which is fine it was a mistake, but when we told her thats not what we wanted she got visibly angry, and told us to tell her beforehand next time. I want to exaggerate this, my mom tried to ask if that was ours so she could correct it, but the lady just got more angry. We didnt get a name, but the employees were rushing and not being very kind in the meanwhile. it was just pretty loud for a little, i doubt its always like that though. I feel like i just had a bad experience. read more

Jersey Mikes sandwiches are tasty goodness! And the best part? When I tell any of the sandwich makers that I'm allergic to raw onions they get me clean lettuce instead of what's in the tray next to the onions! And today the guy actually got a clean knife to cut the sandwich in half!!!! What?! I am so grateful! I LOVE JERSEY MIKES! read more

Online order was supposed to be ready at 12:11 p.m. (four sandwiches). Waited 20 minutes for the order. When an employee handed me the order, I asked her to confirm its contents. She did. When I returned to the office with my order, only 3 of the four sandwiches was correct. read more

They were friendly and the food is good. The place was clean. We had a coupon so it really made it worth it.

My husband loves this new sandwich shop in Caldwell. They cut all the meat and cheeses right when they are making your sandwich. We had a coupon which made the $10/sandwich a little more affordable. They have white, wheat, sourdough, and Parmesan rosemary bread options. They also have Philly cheesesteak which looked interesting. The food was good- kind of a crunchy on the outside roll and a good amount of meat. They crew was a little rough around the edges- they didn't seem like a well oiled machine but I'm giving them slack since they've recently opened. Between cutting the meat and checking out there were 3-4 different people involved in the process which just seemed clunky and inefficient. We will definitely be trying them again, especially if we get another coupon! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Menu - Fast Food Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

See all

Well, I wrote a review about a month ago about this location to which Jersey Mike's replied and stated that the shared my concerns with management and to give them another try. Ok. I did. Today. And that will officially be the last time I go there until they really figure it out. Personally, I'm not a huge fan of the sandwiches but my family likes them. So they will have to go on their own if they want it. Anyway, today was a repeat of the same problems I had before, but worse. This time, the same lady who helped me before was back to cutting the meat, which really she shouldn't be doing. Her main job should be picking the music. Because not only was it blaring in there again (I'm talking like night club, have to scream over each other loud), she literally stopped cutting the meat for my sandwich so she could pick a new song. And not just like real quick. She walked away, stood back, scrolled through her phone with her gloves on, eventually called another employee over to come help her look and then eventually three of them gathered in a circle to find "her song". When they found it, they broke out on a dance, which is great, but it would've been better if they could've boot scoot boogied my sandwich to me at the same time. Once she finally cut the meat for the first one, she started working on the next person's and I could not believe when she turned halfway away from the meat and sneezed into her wrist, never once changing her gloves. Absolutely disgusting. The only thing that saved me from losing my mind was the cashier who was friendly and I think uncomfortable by this woman's actions because as she was in the middle of making a sandwich, the room suddenly went silent (which was a welcome relief from the super loud music), but when I looked over...it went silent because she answered a phone call on her personal cell (which was also controlling the music) and was talking on the phone ignoring her customer. Maybe customer service and not sneezing on your gloves is only important to me, but I'm not going back and if I'm forced to.. and she's there, I'm walking out because I'm not going to keep paying for an over priced sandwich to be met with that. I do have a picture of her if somebody from jersey mikes wants it. I don't think posting it here is at all appropriate, just like my visit there. read more

We've been in town since May and we're excited to see this new Jersey Mike's location opening. I came by on opening day, but it was so busy I couldn't wait. I ordered online the next day and was pleased to have our food ready 18 minutes after ordering--even though they seemed as busy as opening day. I ordered one of my usuals, the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak. It tasted great and the rosemary Parmesan must have come right out of the oven since it was so fresh. Definitely a great start for this new location. Hopefully they continue this quality after their big opening. read more

See all

I love this place and so happy they came to 2 C! Hands down one of my happy places. #43 can't say enough about hot beefy ,cheesy , perfectly cooked. Do yourself a favor and go seriously. And look forward to happy workers especially Nichole she always has a happy infectious smile and helpful. They all have smiles and fast. Hope ya go my husband likes the 13 . Ok now go lol read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #43 sandwiche - Fast Food Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

The past couple times that I have gone to Jersey Mike's , the service has been pretty good.. I have to get gluten free bread .. and both times the bread is very dry and tastes awful.. I can't even finish my sandwich at all , at least throw away most of the bread in the trash . It's crap ! The atmosphere is just okay .. nothing extravagant! read more

Really good sandwiches with pretty good ingredients. Friendly helpful staff. At lunch it can be a bit of a wait, but it's lunch...of course there's a wait. Recommend ordering ahead at lunch. read more

The Cancro Special, Mike's way, is the bomb. Will definitely be getting more sandwiches from Jersey Mike's

Love this place but they have messed up my order more then a few times. So when I'm in the mood for them I think twice about ordering .

Very slow and every time I use the app the San switches are always missing items or not even ready not impressed . Meridian location has always been great not sure what is happening here read more

We have enjoyed JM subs in other cities and were delighted when a new one opened up in Caldwell. The sandwiches, unique to JM, are prepared from scratch before your eyes and are of consistent excellent quality. The past few visits, we have noticed a young woman who puts the veggies etc. on the sandwiches has an acrylic septum piercing that looks an awful like like a drop of nose water ready to drip on your sandwich. It would enhance the lunch experience if she just changed the piercing to a metalic one or took it out altogether. We continue to be loyal customers of JM and regularly recommend it to our friends. read more

We went to Jersey Mikes this evening, Dee S. I have no idea what you are talking about. I have been going to Jersey Mike's locations for many years and this location is just as good, if not better, than other locations. I am sorry that you seem like you are a very unhappy person. Jersey Mike's keep up the great work!! read more

I was driving back from a long trip in Oregon and stopped at this JM before going home. The girl that made my subs was sooo awesome! I was so tired that night but she really made my night talking to me. And the subs were delicious when I got home of course. read more

Delicious sandwich but the wait is quite long especially if it's during the mealtime rush. The price is a little higher than competitors.

We order from here frequently. Best subs around. Bread, meat and veggies are always fresh and piled high on these amazing subs. We order delivery so I am not sure about their dining room. I assume the customer service is as good as the food. read more

Six people working, one on the grill, one cutting bread and the rest standing around talking. Loudmouth, obnoxious and zero customer service. No welcome, no help - just pitiful. I wish I didn't love the sandwiches. Get it together! I've had better customer service at the County Jail. read more

Came in and ordered a Philly Steak. Waited 10 minutes, no sandwich. Meanwhile, someone else came in and ordered a Philly Steak. Their sandwich was ready in 3 minutes, while mine wasn't even started. Therefore, I left in disgust. The management can't get their priorities straight. Additionally, they prioritize online orders over walk in's. The managers need some serious training and the employees manners need to be corrected. I will go to Meridian to get Jersey Mike's from now on. read more

Paying $18+ for a sandwich and they can't even get the order right. Witnessed the sandwich maker touch the inside of a garbage can and continued to make sandwiches after. YOU ARE HANDLING PEOPLES FOOD PAY ATTENTION TO WHERE YOUR HANDS ARE GOING WHILE HANDLING SOMEONES FOOD. Lots of angry customers that have been waiting a long time for their orders... looks like total chaos behind the counter. This place needs better structure and managing. read more

love the in restaurant service/food but lord help you if order via grubhub twice ive ordered and got the worng meat the recipe even says chicken but the sandwich is beef the chips are right read more

Worst service the ladie yelling to take paper up to front counter so they could start the order not sure why we gotta hand paper over with the things we order when it should be there job!!! First time here no welcome when walking in and confused on the line situation so we take our order then need to hand paper up to front counter makes no sense needs to be better system walking all around people to get to the counter read more

honest to god one of the worst places you can eat in Caldwell. I tried ordering an hour ahead and they said that the sandwiches were ready an hour late and when I went to go and get my order I waited another hour because they didn't prioritize my order. all of my hot sandwiches were bone cold when I finnally got them and the cold sandwiches had gone soggy. not the most pleasant experience but it has happened so many times now it's ridiculous. read more

First off, the employees need more training. When there are 10 people in line and you can see they have no sense of urgency at all it's a problem. Secondly, I have been to several other locations in the Treasure Valley area and the sandwiches are much fuller. These sandwich makers are not putting as much meat on the sandwiches as the other locations. I have quit going to this location altogether because of poor service. Dissapointed because I was so happy to see one go up closer to us. Sorry to say, but this location needs some management attention for sure. read more