How can this place even be serious calling themselves an Italian deli?!?! The few specialty sandwiches I gotten here before were mediocre at best and way over priced for the quality. Decent place if you just need a sandwich or something quick to eat but by no means an Italian deli. This is a fake Italian deli. Go to sansotta in Cortlandt instead read more

Beware - this is not an Italian deli. Food is abysmal. Chicken cutlet was frozen and not fried long enough, bread was stale, they forgot the oil and vinegar, and the prosciutto was as dry as leather. All this for $28. Are you kidding? BTW - I went there a few weeks before for breakfast. How do you mess up two bacon, egg, cheese on a roll. read more

I am surprised that I have not done the review for this place. It is the place that I go out of my way to get the bacon, eggs and cheese on a bagel whenever I am in the area. I found this place before Covid on the way to Bear Mt. or Minnewaska State Park and fell in love with this place. We ordered the breakfast sandwich and Turkey Sandwich on a hero ( wedge). OMG, it was just awesome. We went back few more times and it was consistently good. I was in the area last week but couldn't get my bagel since it was too late. They do close too early for my taste but I will just have to catch them next time. I might get to take a picture before I take a bite next time. read more

Quintessential Italian deli with all the creative sandwiches you could possibly imagine everything is fresh and delicious. Must try anything in their vodka sauce so so yummy. don't miss their daily hot food specials. read more

One of my favorite places to go for food. Their Rueben's are so good, I like to get it with pastrami and provolone. 10/10 recommend :')

Delicious food - ordered 4 sandwiches were made correctly and rolls were very fresh. Helpful counter staff , he was patient. Clean storefront. read more

The food is good. The sandwiches are so good. The service is good and the place is big and nice

Food smelled pretty good!... I only had a BLT wrap, so nothing to rave about! Hahaha However! I'm a firm believer that hospitality makes the food taste even better! ...and the ppl in there were very welcoming! -Ayo Nish! read more

If I ask for double bacon/well done, on my bacon egg and cheese, then I should get double bacon/well done on my bacon egg and cheese. Multiple times I've arrived home after picking up food there only to discover that I have barely cooked, rubbery, bacon and only a slice and a half. In what world does a slice and a half count as double bacon? This is not a one-off thing either. The issue described above has happened more than a handful of times. Also, way too expensive It cost over $9.00 for the bacon/egg/cheese and a toasted bagel with cream cheese. If their food was on point I wouldn't mind the $9.00 price tag, but when you repeatedly mess up my sandwich, I'm done with you. read more

Okay y'all!!! This bagel spot is the JAM! We were in the area and I really wanted a bagel... I couldn't help but think this spot would be cool because of the name....welp my Yelp community it was ! Small joint but had all the fixins'! I got a everything bagel with bacon, egg and cheddar cheese and grilled onions and sweet peppers. It was DELICIOUS. Super fresh and tasty. They have tons of options from bagels, to the meats to the toppings (like veggies) and cream cheese! It took us 5 min just to figure out what breakfast bagel we wanted lol.y husband got a everything bagel with sausage, muenster cheese and egg and it was also good. The prices are very reasonable (to be honest the same as getting a bagel at a fast food join like McDonald's accept those are not good!) They also have pre-made sandwich for $3. My personal favorite "cool" thing I saw was not only could you make your hot coffee but cold coffee as well! They had whole milk, almond milk, simple syrup and flavored creamers to pick from and it was good coffee...I think next time I would go lighter on the ice though so it does not water down my coffee so much. The guys working were super friendly and it was just a good local spot! Check them out! read more

See all

The perfect NY deli/bagel joint. We came here hoping to get chewy bagels with yummy options for cream cheeses. This place did not disappoint. We got sesame bagel with lettuce, tomato, purple onion, and jalapeño cream cheese...delicious. Also a bacon egg and cheese on a toasted everything bagel...delicious. And a plain bagel with cream cheese...delicious. Guys were super friendly. Place is very clean. Their menu looks pretty incredible for lunch items/subs/sandwiches too. They had a good selection of drinks and snacks too. We will return whenever we are in the area. Fantastic find! read more

I would give zero stars if possible. Sandwiches are mediocre. Place went downhill since the beginning of the pandemic. Owner is confronted with issues and responds in childish, unfriendly and most importantly unprofessional manners. Spot is owned by a local and her friends defend the behavior solely because they're friends, not because the food is good. Prices are extremely unfair. Save your money and go elsewhere. read more

Get your breakfast sandwich on a bagel & thank me later. Been here hundreds of times & always left satisfied.

Wow, those are the best bagels I've ever had in my life! Well worth the drive. Congratulations, y'all are doing fantastic! Great product, great service, in a good value. Thank you so much! The Pyles read more

I was excited when this place opened back up after covid. However, I was very disappointed with this place. I ordered a steak bacon egg and cheese on a roll, and I got A steak and cheese on a roll. And it was tasteless. I also ordered chocolate chip pancakes and I got 2 chocolate chip pancakes that tasted like a burnt grill with bacon fat. The chocolate was only on the top and it was all burnt. I was SO DISAPPOINTED. I don't think I will be going back after the bad tasting food. How can u mess up on something so easy. read more

See all

Absolutely phenomenal, I would seriously give them 6 stars if I could. This place knows how to do a proper deli sandwich and it shows with how helpful the staff is with suggestions. Bagels are Bomb, and even the rolls are pillow soft and so fresh. Highly recommend! read more

My favorite deli in Peekskill. Amazing food and Sophia always has a smile. This place is definitely an amazing addition to an up and coming Peekskill. Stop by if you are on your way to hike. Stop by if you are on your way out or stop by if you just need some good quick eats. read more

This deli the bomb. The bagels are so soft and fresh. Vegetable cream cheese is so good. For lunch go for an Italian stallion. You will not regret it. They have hot lunches everyday too. Fountain sodas are a nice touch. They also are one of the only local places to sell the best Snapple flavor (troparocka). They do catering as well: wedges, antipastos, fried platters. This list goes on and on. Love this place and you will too! read more

I work right down the street from this spot and it took me awhile to stop in. Looks a little gaudy from the outside and as a proud Irish American sometimes I steer clear of the overly Italian spots (I kid). Fact of the matter is this place turns out some pretty high quality sandwiches and hot food. My go to would be the stallion - Chicken Cutlet, prosciutto, fresh mozz, oil & vinegar you know the story. Breakfast is pretty spot on as well. I drop in Friday mornings for the weekly sausage, egg & cheese and it's one of the best in the area. The staff is very friendly and it's nice to support local business owners doing their thing. Definitely worth a shot if you're in the Peekskill area. read more

Favorite deli in the hudson valley! Walking distance is dangerous. Fresh bagels, perfect bacon, and superb customer service!

Lived in NYC for 30 years. Bagels here are Extraordinary. The staff is Great. Nothing like the smell of A toasting onion bagel To make you smile. Coleslaw needs HELP. read more

Before covid they was hands down amazing would rate 5 s no questions asked. But now they went way down hill. Food don't taste like it did before and the owner is really rude when you have a complaint. Breakfast is a no go from now on. Lunch taste really good the food that is cooked fresh. read more

My review is 5 stars because that's all I can give. If you are in the area, go there and pick up a wrap and taste greatness for yourself.

Awesome deli for breakfast and lunch! The owner(Sophia) will bend over backwards to help you. Give them a try, you will not be disappointed!

My favorite deli! The breakfast and lunch is awesome. I order a ham egg and cheese for breakfast and it is always made to perfection and their burgers are better than anywhere else in town. If you are getting breakfast ask for the home fries they are delicious!! Their friendliness and service is 110%. I look forward to eating everything on their menu!! read more

Fuhgeddaboudit Deli is exactly what the city of Peeksill needed. The variety of fresh food, the people that work there and the location hit the trifecta of what a deli should be. read more

First time going to Fuhgeddaboudit and I ordered the Italian Stallion wedge. A few bites into the sandwich and I noticed the chicken cutlet was a FAKE fried chicken cutlet. The pressed and formed chicken cutlet that the fast food restaurants serve. It was gross! The worst part is that it cost $12 and you don't even get a real chicken cutlet. read more

I ordered a chicken cutlet sandwich from here, before ordering I explicitly asked them if it was fresh chicken and the lady at the counter said yes. I came home to eat the sandwich and it was a frozen patty that they fried. It was $8 for a frozen processed chicken patty and not a fresh chicken cutlet. I called to ask them and the manager on the phone said no they are fresh, which I know they weren't. I confronted her and she said well actually they are a frozen Tyson product but we fry them when you order!! She didn't offer to make it right at all. Totally ridiculous to go to a deli and get a frozen processed patty. read more

Great service, good sandwiches. Glad to have a deli in Peekskill that has quality food. Staff is friendly and place is clean

My first time here because my usual deli was closed today. A couple of really nice women greeted me and suggested the Italian stallion and it was delicious. I would come back to try another signature sandwich! read more

Great place with even better people. I'm here nearly every day for breakfast and lunch and the food and service never disappoints!! Best deli in Peekskill by far! read more

The best bacon egg and cheese sandwich I ever had. Excellent service and great prices too.

Just recently started coming here and can't get myself to stop coming now. Awesome breakfast sandwiches, deli sandwiches are great too and so many different options for snacks and drinks. The girls at the front are always so sweet and welcoming and I order crazy stuff and they are always very accommodating. Definitely would recommend!! :) read more

So I assumed from the name it was actually a real Italian Deli. Nope. I don't know any self-respecting Italian deli that would serve a chicken cutlet sandwich made from a frozen breaded chicken cutlet in a bag and thrown in a deep fryer. Then on top of it they put the roll that was to be used for my sandwich directly on a counter surface that was not meant for food (bags and stuff were in it) which grossed me out. They also took 20 minutes to make 2 sandwiches. The only reason I am not giving them 1 star is because they were super friendly and apologetic for the wait. read more

Best deli in all of Westchester Sophia is the best. Food is phenomenal. Not many places can do a bacon egg and cheese as good as they can.

I ate here yesterday and got food poisoning. They are using bad items, and should be shut down. I have not regained control of my bowels since. I was throwing up and everything. I can't believe this place is serving bad meats. They should be shut down. read more

Chicken parmigian wedge is delicious. One of the best I ever had. Can't wait to go back and try the hot food they serve on a daily basis.

Just discovered this delightful deli yesterday while taking a morning walk. Met owner Silvia, a recent college graduate and lifelong Peekskill resident, who is the brainchild of the idea for this deli and was impressed with her enthusiasm and determination to provide a quality source for good breakfasts and lunches to Peekskill residents. Had egg sandwiches on fresh rolls from Neri's Bakery which were delicious. Coffee is from a local roaster Big Bang Coffee Roasters and is also delicious! Place is still getting up to speed and promises to be a great addition to Peekskill's food options. Check out their menu at https://www.fgabdeli.com/menu read more

Absolutely the best delicatessen north of New York City. Food is outstanding, prices reasonable

the staff is by far one of the most pleasant staff out there. they will really go out of their way to provide a wonderful experience for you, especially the cashiers. the reason why i rate it as a two star is because i tend to notice sometimes when i ask for bagels they don't grab the bagels from a bin behind them( the fresh bagels) it just magically ends up in the toaster but when i ask for it not to be toasted they get the fresh back. kind of disappointed that they tend to use day or old how ever old the bagels are, and the cashiers are told to say they are fresh read more