There isn't a plethora of good pizza, wings, & sub shops in the area, and Fritz has been my goto for quite a few years, mainly because their Buffalo wings are solid, and they used to have an excellent chicken parm sub... emphasis on "used to". As you can see from picture, it is no longer very big, and the roll went from being a beautiful, freshly baked with a slightly toasted crust, to what is now an slightly oversized & soggy hot dog bun. It used to come with peppers, but now you apparently have to ask for that add-on... it needs something for sure! Anyway, the wings are still good, but ordering extra crispy still leaves them not-so-crispy (pic), but they're still tasty. Fritz's staff is always courteous and take out process is smooth. read more

See all

Haven't tried the ''new'' Fritz's yet, but we're a little leery thanks to the old one. They used to have an excellent chef salad, but the last one we got barely gave two of us enough salad to go with lasagna I had made. It used to fill a large container, but not anymore, apparently. The lettuce was limp, scarce and the meats tasted old. Pizza we've gotten was either undercooked or burnt, so we stopped getting that from there years ago. Pizza Supreme's pizza is far superior, and their 8-cut is MUCH bigger for the same price, or maybe even a bit less. Fritz's also used to have great grinders, but the roast beef in the last one I got from there was a lot of gristle and sliced so thick all the meat pulled out when trying to take a bite. Calling them was always pointless, so all we can do now is hope the new owners have improved. Maybe someday we'll get the nerve to try it again, but at prices today, we're waiting to see some reviews since the new owners took over. read more

Absolutely horrid. Got undercooked pizza, called and got told off by owner. Dont waste your money. Guy is not a businessman. Sold a bad pizza and then had the balls to tell me it was fine. Tried him again for subs....they were super skimpy on meat and bread was semi stale on 2 of the 3 subs we ordered. He has kids working there too.....wonder if he treats them as badly as customers?? read more

Let's get a quick slice she said to bad it was this place to get it, Slices are not their thing pbviously since the Gas Station has more of a choice and quality than this ie (insert pizza place)- Guess when your in the middle of ummm somewhere your choices are limited- well step it up make it happen- "American" pizza I guess expected from "Fritz" I should have known. - Also nice to see they are hiring the youth of today who hang around in the small dining area awaiting to deliver...Awesome! read more

Terrible food not impressed ordered two Hot subs they were cold and expensive won't be back

Ordered the Regular Calzone (ham, ricotta, mozz). The calzone was enormous and very shareable. But, I felt the bread and cheeses overwhelmed the amount of ham inside. Most ham was towards the middle while outer was just cheeses. Very rich! Had to drink quite a bit of water to wash down throughout. The marinara alone had a strong bitter flavor from the oregano that stood out, but tasted good when eaten with the calzone because the dough was sweet. Nice balance. Also tried the mild wings and was disappointed they weren't tossed in any sauce, just fried. Couldn't try the bleu cheese dressing because I'm allergic, but it looked and smelled like it would be thick and tasty. read more

See all

SUPER DISAPPOINTED!!! We will NOT be giving this establishment our business again!!! After going to pick up our food and finding out our pizzas were never made, we were ok and willing to just come back. No big deal. When we came back, we were given 2 of the worst looking pizzas I've ever seen, along with our fried food. Our fried food had sat for about a half hour and instead of owning their mistake and just making new food, they just re-fried everything. We got oil soaked nasty food that we couldn't eat. Also, our wings (which we ordered crispy) were soggy and greasy. Not at all eatable. When we called, the man on the phone actually said "I wondered how that food was going to be". We took a third trip to get this corrected and were only given replacements for a few items, and only compensated for one order of wings, which we couldn't even eat. We paid over $80 to eat chicken tenders and fries! The only thing worse than the food, was the service! I feel bad for anyone else who had to deal with this tonight. We used to love getting food here, but never again! read more

$140 food order for a group of us An hour and a half for delivery with cold food, soggy barely cooked chicken wings and missing food! Called about missing food and it was gonna be a while before they could even bring it to us! So we sent some one so the food would be hot and it was ice cold! The prices in the take out menu aren't what they charged us! This place is absolutely disgusting we definitely won't be ordering again EVER!!!!! read more

The pizza is ok, unfortunately the delivery is terrible, often forgetting things and claiming "they didn't tell me". Shouldn't you check the order before you leave? Last time I ordered they forgot our 2 liter, driver said he'd be right back. We waited 45 mins to eat our pizza until the driver came back, and that was only after we called to complain, so might of been more time. Other times have been 30 mins or more to pic something back up and we only live 2 min away. read more

Love the food! Recommend to go there. This pizza is popular around here since I saw many people ordered take out also dine in. read more

See all

We always stop when we're in town and get the two-slices and a drink special. Excellent food, great prices, quaint and friendly atmosphere. Every inch is of the place is spotlessly clean. Spacious bathrooms and a tv for their patrons to watch while they eat. read more

Being my husband and I are both from Queens NY, we have been searching for a place that has New York City style pizza for years. Ironically today we found THE best pizzeria in this area -having tried them all I can safely say that! Best, best, best pizza I've had since moving to the area nine years ago! read more

Four years ago we stopped purchasing our weekly pizza and salad dinner from Fritz's as they had forgotten how to properly cook a pie even after being asked to prepare it correctly, ie: cooked! Lol. Anyways, in a recent pinch, we had a necessary opportunity to try their pie again and were more than pleasantly surprised! They're back on track with completely cooking their pizza and their sauce is better than ever! Yummy! We agree that their individual slices, while slightly more expensive, are most definitely better than a freshly prepared pie. Nevertheless, it's great news for our corner pizzeria to be rockin once again! Just hope they don't forget how to turn the oven on again! read more

Fritz Pizza is honestly one of the greatest pizza places I've ever been to! Their slices are so delicious but my favorite thing to get here is their mozzarella sticks. The breading is crunchy and the cheese is perfectly melted every time I get them. Writing this about their food is making my mouth water. If you are in the area, stop by for a great meal! read more

Fritz's Pizza & Subs - Mozzarella Sticks from Fritz - Pizza Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

If I could give zero stars, I would. Ordered food around 6:30 and was told the wait would be 30-40 minutes, mind you all we ordered was a sub and wrap. The food wasn't delivered for at least an hour and when it finally got here, both the wrap and sub were soggy. The wraps chicken wasn't cooked thoroughly and the wrap was impossible to eat with an overwhelming amount of dressing that soaked the wrap so much that it ripped. The entire container in which the wrap was held had a puddle of dressing, there was THAT much. For a first time experience here, I can surely say we will not be returning. I am shocked a business would send food out in such a poor condition. read more

Been about 3 years since we have ordered and now I remember why. Ordered a green pepper pizza received a sausage and pepperoni. Which reluctantly they did correct. Also a half a dozen mozzarella sticks equals only 3, must have common core students working for them. Also waited and hour and a half, not worth the wait. Even if you do not have a car it is worth walking to Pizza Supreme. Never again!!!!!! read more

Usually a pretty good place to get a pizza pie. They has been inconsistent with the pizza, sometimes its good, and sometimes not so good. I'd prefer to go to Greasy Pete's where I know I'll always get a good pizza. But besides that, best mozzarella sticks and pretty good subs too! read more

Very good pizza, wings, subs and calzones. The delivery was timely. I've ordered there quite a bit in the past and I've never waited longer than 45 minutes for my meal to arrive. They have a drive thru which is a cool feature. A read more