Delicious food! I had the Patty Melt with their famous Rum Runner, which is a frozen slushie type…read moredrink. They had a fun summertime topper of a pink pony duck to make your drink a "Quacktail" instead of a "Cocktail". FUN! Sit outside if possible for their gorgeous view of the water!!

Pink Pony is an absolute must when visiting Mackinac Island. The servers are great, the food is…read moreexcellent, and the vibe is relaxed. There is almost always a wait to get seated so get there early to get your reservation in. They will text you when your table is ready. Today, I had the Apple, Brie, and Walnut Flatbread and Boneless Chicken Wings with Mild Buffalo sauce. I typically order a salad with the flatbread but trying to be cautious right now with the lettuce issues. I rave about this flatbread - it has never disappointed. The taste is so good combined with the honey drizzle on top. The Wings were good - fried perfectly - and the Buffalo sauce complemented them nicely. We will be back on our next trip to the island!

After a full day of walking, biking, and convincing myself I definitely wasn't tired, Millie's on…read moreMain hit the spot. My daughter ordered the burger, and it was a winner. The patty was juicy, the bun was soft and fluffy, and somehow she still managed to have room for dessert. Kids are magical like that. My husband and I both ordered the pan-fried whitefish because, come on... you're on Mackinac Island. You have to. The fish was fresh, flaky, and perfectly cooked with a light, crispy crust that let the flavor of the whitefish shine. Exactly what we were hoping for. The restaurant has a fun, laid-back atmosphere that feels like the perfect place to recharge before heading back out to explore the island. The service was friendly, the food came out quickly, and everything tasted fresh. If you're visiting Mackinac, don't overthink it. Order the whitefish, steal a fry from whoever you're eating with (it's vacation, calories are on island time), and enjoy a great meal.

We stopped by here on a weekend in the summer- we were able to get a table quickly and were just…read moreasked to wait outside for a couple minutes while they got our table ready. Our server was excellent- very thoughtful and attentive. We shared the soup of the day (chicken and wild rice) and fresh whitefish chowder. The chicken soup reminded me of a soup you have when you have a cold and make some fresh soup at home. The chowder did not have much of a fish flavor. Our entire table devoured the whipped goat cheese with pepper jam and the fried green beans, however, there were mixed reviews on the beef pastie. All in all we really enjoyed our meal here; it was the perfect casual stop for us on our trip.

Forget 5 starts we give it 10 stars! This spot may be overlooked because it's not on the main drag,…read moreit doesn't have views, it's definitely got the old tavern vibes but it's worth the stop. It's been awhile since we've experienced some food like this, shout out to our tour guide for the recommendation because yall we stuffed our face with goodness. We ordered the white fish and the steak to share. We added the 2nd filet of fish and it was a great mistake because it was so delicious, a mistake because it was SO MUCH FOOD. It was crusted in pistachio and served with Parmesan whipped mashed potatoes- oh my goodness so good. The steak - oh my gawd the steak. So tender so juicy so perfectly cooked and seasoned we were having eyes rolling moments more often than one should have while eating a steak. Unbelievable. Slow clap. And don't even get me started on their in house Crème brûlée - typically not my favorite dessert but oh man this was perfect.

We came in for lunch and the service was quick and efficient. All of our dishes were good and the…read moreportions were large! Love this place and felt it was much better than the other reviews we read!

Great place to stop for lunch! The food is cheaper for the island while still really good! It's…read morenothing fancy, but sometimes you need that for a quick lunch before back to exploring the island.

This lively cafe has a varied menu with probably some of the best prices you will find on the…read moreisland super friendly staff. Limited seating for sure, tight spaces along the wall and a few larger tables in the back. Found the food not too greasy and the place very clean.

Fantastic restaurant and service! Dishes are all well made and high quality. Wine selection is ok…read morebut could be better and higher end. Cocktails and desserts were all good.

We really enjoyed the food here! I had the steak delmonico and it was very tender and tasty. The…read moreplace does have a cool atmosphere but seems to struggle with whether it is "fine dining" or not. The service was fine, but not really what I expected for the price point.

Delicious dinner in a beautiful location. Service was attentive - maybe a little slow. Expensive…read morebut a special treat.

The food was delicious!!! The kids ate everything!!! It is a bit pricey, so be prepared. Service…read morewas kind but on the slow side. Beautiful dining area and decor!

Had the smoked beef brisket nachos. Very good as the meat was not overly smoked. Could have feed 2…read moreto 3 people easily. We sat outside as the music was very loud inside but it was still a little too loud outside for our liking even though they had a great playlist.

Had dinner here with margaritas (which were very tasty), but the disappointing part were the extra…read morefees they slapped on our tab without informing us or asking. One was a preservation fee! What the heck is that? They do t even have flowers anywhere near where we sat. I do t appreciate high prices to begin with then extra crap without asking.

My girlfriend and I came here for our 2 year anniversary. It was incredible! The ambiance and view…read morewere awesome. Regarding the food, since we left my girlfriend hasn't stopped talking about the sauce the steamed mussels came in and we ate here over 2 days ago. She needs to know what's in that sauce!

What an experience! My husband and I visited for our 2 year anniversary and it was such a wonderful…read morechoice. The view is amazing, and a pianist was playing the entire dinner service. The service was top tier. Eddie was so personable and kind. And the food, impeccable. We had the bread delicious wine, whitefish, and lamb chops. I have not stopped talking about the whitefish dish. I would absolutely love to return one day!