Broken Spoke

MY RATING SYSTEM 5/4 = Exceeds expectations.Yes…read more3 = Meets expectations. No. 2/1 = Does not meet expectations. No. OVERALL POINTS RATING (0 - 5 1. AMBIANCE = 5 I like to setup. Nice place to hang. 2. FOOD/DRIINKS = 5 Great meals. We did the brunch. Enjoyed it very much. 3. SERVICE = 5 Joslyn did a great job. Attentive. Smiles. Quick to exceed expectations. 4. BATHROOM = 3 5. PRICING = 4 I felt for what we had it was priced and it exceeded my expectations for food on the island. 6. OBSERVATION Sat quickly. Taking care of in a timely fashion. I would recommend this for a place to eat. 7. POINTS 22 out of 25 25 points out expecting. 20 to 25 = Exceeds expectations. 10 to 19 = Meets expectations. 0 to 9 = Does not meet expections.

Our service was good, our food was good. It was cool to sit in a window seat at a restaurant on…read moreMackinac island. I would go back. Love me some Irish food

Fish Ale Sandwich with chips and cole slaw

See all

The Broken Spoke

3.7(43 reviews)

Needed a place to eat and found the Broken Spoke! The place next door had an hour wait, so we…read morechecked out the Broken Spoke. The wait was about 15-20 minutes - so much better of a wait time! I like the theme and vibe of the place - the play on bikes and name of the restaurant is perfect. Decor is bike themed but not overly done. Rustic and laid back. Our waitress was excellent - very friendly and attentive. All staff were wearing masks. Good drink menu in addition to food. A lot of small plate options but the portion sizes of the small plates could feed at least 2-4 people. I went with sweet potato fries and steak tender bites - delicious! The dipping sauces for the fries had three different options - sweet/savory, loved trying each one. The sweet potato fries were not mushy and had a good crunch. The steak was cooked to perfection - I asked for medium and I got medium! Everyone seemed happy with their food. Restrooms were downstairs. Nice dining option in the city - only con there was no outdoor seating. Picking up on social media - looks like this place used to be Huron St. Pub & Grill not sure if it was a re-branding or new owners. Either way, I hope Broken Spoke is here to stay on the island!

Went for dinner and the place had a great vibe, chill music, good food, and amazing service. Our…read morewaitress was super nice, helpful, and attentive. The Po' Boy was our favorite, definitely would go back again. Update: Went for dinner, still a great atmosphere and great service. The tomato basil soup was too salty and we couldn't finish it, the fish tacos were a little fishy, but the Po' Boy was still really good.

Drink menu

Most of the interior

See all

Bar area

Pink Pony

4.0(957 reviews)

This is a beautiful restaurant on the water and the brunch was amazing (except the blueberry…read moremuffin)!

I brought my mother here for Mother's Day, and I'm really glad I did. Our waiter was very friendly…read moreand greeted us with a smile every time he came to the table. He even wished my mom a happy Mother's Day before taking our order, which was a nice touch. We started with the Street Corn Nachos as an appetizer, then ordered a pulled pork sandwich and a grilled portobello mushroom sandwich, both with fries on the side (an additional $4 each). This was an excellent place to bring my mom since she's vegetarian, and the restaurant had plenty of vegetarian-friendly options. The food was excellent, especially the nachos -- the queso was amazing. The restaurant also gives you a lot of customization options, like swapping chips for fries for an extra $4 or adding protein to the nachos for an additional charge. That said, while the nachos were really good, they were still $18 without any protein, which honestly felt overpriced for chips, cheese, and vegetables. We came during lunch service, and overall the food, service, and view made for a great experience. However, it is definitely on the expensive side. Most entrees seemed to range from around $20-30. Still, if you're willing to spend a little more for quality food, generous portions, and a great atmosphere, it's definitely worth visiting.

Pink Pony gift shop

Fish & chips

See all

Whitefish Sandwich

Millie's on Main

4.1(256 reviews)

Millie's is one of those restaurants that has something for everyone, and will appease everyone,…read morebut to be honest, I forgot what we ordered and ate as soon as we left. I had to look at my photos in order to remember our meal. That's not to say it was bad. Not at all! Just that the only thing I remember is that the prices are slightly higher than I think they should be. (Although, that seems to be the case at every restaurant on Mackinac Island. They have you trapped, and they know it.) We started with the smoked whitefish dip, which is a popular thing in this part of Michigan. It came piping hot with melted cheese on it, and served with crispy pita chips and crostini. I'm glad I tried it! I love me a good meatloaf sandwich, so when I saw meatloaf sliders in the menu, I had to get them. These sliders are made with pretzel buns, which are not my favorite because I feel like they're never soft enough. A nice white bun would have been so much better. I got a side Caesar salad, and it was fine. We also ordered a chicken tenders basket, the Low Carb Platter (just a cheeseburger without a bun and a side of cottage cheese), and a kids' cheeseburger. They do have a kids menu here -- just ask. Millie's gets very busy! We had to wait almost 30 minutes for a table. But it's centrally located in the middle of downtown Mackinac, so I wouldn't expect anything less.

We checked out Millie's on Main for lunch at the recommendation of a staff member (and year-round…read moreresident) at Hotel Iroquois. A great spot, located right where visitors board for the public carriage tours! We stopped in around 12pm and by the time we left, every table was filled. Our party enjoyed a beautiful kale salmon salad, delicious and slightly spicy whitefish tacos with mango salsa, and a pasty with coleslaw and gravy. If I were to go there again, I would definitely get the pasty, hands down.

Caesar salad

See all

Smoked Whitefish Dip

Seabiscuit Cafe

4.0(547 reviews)

0.0 mi

Drinks and dessert was the main focus for a visit to Seabiscuit Cafe. Did I procure any real food…read moreat this horse-themed restaurant? Neigh! But they had what I wanted: sugar and alky hall. I just wanted a little (big) glass of red wine and something sweet to cap off the night, and I left satisfied. Key lime pie was the special dessert of the day, so that's what I got. I can't pass up a special dessert that's here today, but might be gone tomorrow. The kitchen didn't just give me a slice of pie: They dusted my plate with powdered sugar in the shape of a horse! It's these little touches that make all the difference, and you can tell that they're not horsing around here. (Or maybe they are?) My glass of Cabernet was great, and I was told that the beer was great, too. They were very busy, considering it was the end of the season. Nevertheless, we got a seat right away, and the service was great. If you visit Seabiscuit Cafe during the evening, you'll see that it's a cozy little spot with dim lighting, where you can relax and have a meal (or just drinks and dessert, like me).

Came here back in August during prime tourist season. Attempted to go to Pink Pony Club, but the…read morewait was too long, so decided to stop by here instead. They were able to seat us right away, but wasn't a fan of the seating arrangements: booth seating for eight persons including two seniors with mobility issues. It was especially cold in the corner and the TV was right above us! I kept thinking the TV would come down on us and what a safety risk it was. Also, it was super cold inside especially where we were seated. We asked for some hot water and had to follow up on it since I think our waitress forgot. Seating aside the food was quite good. They have a decent selection of signature cocktails to choose from. Portion sizes were generous and easily shareable between two persons (sensing a trend here in Michigan). I enjoyed the Crab Louie salad and the sweet potato fries. In summary, the seating arrangements could've been better, but the food and drink made up for it.

Interior

Creole Salmon

See all

Beer

Great Turtle Brewery and Distillery

3.6(179 reviews)

We were visiting the super touristy Mackinaw island. We needed somewhere dog, friendly, some good…read morefood this place is huge right in the middle of the drive. But we decided to try we were pleasantly surprised They had a huge beer selection. We got a flight of their beers. You are all really good! Food really hit the spot. Everyone in our large group of 12 of very happy. Great service and great food here. And a nice patio if you're with dogs. I recommend this place if you're on the island!

Came for a cold drink & bite. The local drafts were appealing on their big porch. Riley was a…read morewaitress, she was efficient, personable, and on point. I ordered a two block draft Amber with a toffee vanilla oak flavor. My husband did a no cars allowed a cream ale, light and smooth. We started by sharing the Great Lakes, smoked whitefish dip topped with mozzarella capers, and red onions. The dip was very rich & filling! The only negative was it was very very loud. There was a woman at the table next to us screaming at everybody that walked by and interjecting her opinions in neighboring conversations. She even got all the dogs on the porch barking.

Great Turtle Brewery and Distillery - Bar

Bar

Vegan chorizo tacos

See all

My flight of beers.

Mustang Lounge

3.2(167 reviews)

Popped in for a quick cheeky drink. I didn't have any children with me, and I didn't see any…read morechildren or families while I was at Mustang Lounge, so I'm thinking this place is more geared toward adults. It's a lounge and tavern! Those words, and kids, do not usually go together. But looking at the food menu, it's pretty appealing to all ages, so I'm sure kids are not turned away. I didn't get any food when I visited Mustang Lounge, just drinks. I almost never get a cocktail because they're usually too sweet, but I got some sort of citrus and honey cocktail, the name of which escapes me. It was really good! We also got a beer, and the beer was served in a cold, frosty glass. They have a lot of beer options here. Mustang Lounge is quiet and intimate -- a nice place to get a drink and relax for a while.

Hamburger was very good. Service was good. The cherry cordial hit the spot after being out in the…read morecold.

Double Ladder 2 burger with tots

See all

Some lemony drink that I forgot the name of, but it was good

Yankee Rebel Tavern

3.9(270 reviews)

Had the prime rib which came with roasted potatoes, heirloom carrots and a flower that was edible!…read more Root beer with the meal and a root beer float for desert. Kristina was our server and was very attentive and knowledgeable of the food fare. Very enjoyable setting and a pleasant evening.

One of my favorite places to come on the island. The bar tenders are always friendly and we have a…read moregood conversation every time. Casual spot, nothing fancy. The food is good, but we didn't eat this time around, but there are options for everyone including vegan/vegetarian options. My favorite thing to get here is the root beer on tap and add a shot of vanilla vodka. This is always my go to. Yankee Rebel is a must stop when you're on the island.

Summer Salad

See all

Yankee Rebel Tavern

Winchester's Whiskey & Bourbon Room

3.7(96 reviews)

0.0 mi

Who goes to a whiskey and bourbon bar and orders a glass of wine and an espresso martini? This…read moreperson right here. Sometimes, I need to zig when you thought I was going to zag. I like to keep it fresh up in here. The thing is, the prices for the bourbon were a touch overpriced, but the cocktails and wine were decent. That's the reason for my decision, but I think if you're in the mood for whiskey or bourbon and you're on Mackinac Island, then this is a good place to find it. They have a large variety of many different brands. I didn't get any food -- just popped in for a cheeky drink. The bar area is a nice place to sit, enjoy a drink and contemplate your visit to the island.

Loved chicken burger and fish and chips The best waffle…read morefries Good service, nice ambiance and amazing food