Obviously, everyone is making the comparisons to Five Guys, as that is the dominant local burger joint...but I might be in the minority in saying that Five Guys has really stagnated in quality while their prices have risen considerably over the years. With the aggressive expansion the concept of Five Guys is really starting to lose some of its charm for me.
At five guys, you get an extremely greasy and stingy patty (or two) of ground beef. Yes the meat is fresh and not frozen, but it's also really dull in flavor outside of the preponderance of fat. Fosters Grille has a chargrilled patty that is a bit thicker then five guys' double stuffed "regular" burger and comes with cheese as a free extra. The burger is not greasy and has better texture and flavor then five guys...though I assume the patties to be frozen instead of fresh which can impact the evenness of the cooking. The wealth of toppings offered by five guys is not equaled by Foster's...Mayo, ketchup, mustard, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and cheese are all offered at no charge...bacon comes in at $0.75 extra. Your price includes fries and a drink, making it a better value then five guys in most cases as well.
My problem with Five Guys recently is that the consistency of their fry cooking has gone in the toilet completely. Sometimes you'll get a batch of barely fried greasy limp sticks and sometimes you get the batch of divinely crispy and well seasoned fries you expected. More often then not, you're getting something in between...underdone, over greased and limp to a fault. Foster's fries aren't anything surprising, but the texture is currently surpassing Five Guys standards as of late. They come out crisp and dark, ready for a dousing of malt vinegar...though you should be forwarned, when taking your food to go, the Styrofoam container will quickly ruin the texture of your fries...so assume they don't travel well and eat in the restaurant.
Finally, Fosters offers considerably more variety then Five Guys. Chicken Sandwiches, oven roasted turkey and roast beef, two salads and buffalo wings. Options like chili cheese fries, milkshakes, draft beer and fresh squeezed lemonade (yes they have lemons and a squeezer right behind the counter) provide a lot more variety then Five Guys and the "kids menu" of smaller burgers, grilled cheese, hot dogs and chicken fingers make the place a little more family friendly.
Don't get me wrong, the place is quite corny with local advertisements plastered into the tables, a gigantic race-car body hangs from the ceiling and there is a selection of neo-vintage tin signs with lots of "attitude"...so it's far from perfect. But the food is decent, the prices are respectable, there's a happy hour for beer and I won't be sliding out the door on a river of burger grease...so this place gets my vote over five guys for right now. read more