Custom birthday cake!! I ordered a custom lemon birthday cake and it turned out awesome! The cake was amazing and the buttercream frosting was perfect! They did it quickly and had great service throughout. Highly recommend! read more

I wanted to door dash some birthday treats for a friend in the area and came across this bakery. I ordered her various treats and the bakery reached out with some questions on flavors for certain items. My friend later sent a photo of the cutest little box of treats that she received. The bakery even included a birthday sign and message - very cute and I appreciated them going above and beyond to make the order special! read more

Forest Fairy Bakery - Birthday treat box :) - Bakeries Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

I pitched some chocolate zucchini bread from the Federal Way farmers market . When I got the bread home and went to cut it just sated to crumble because it was so dry. I really wanted to enjoy the bread but didn't even taste it . It was a total waste of $$ read more

Drove by many times and finally walked by so I could stop. I will stop again! The sourdough bread round is delicious! The Sticky Nutty(walnut) Bun is a perfect balance of bread, cinnamon sweet and nuts ($4.00). Very patient service. Cozy place to sit and enjoy A cappuccino with the fresh baked treats. Lots of cookie selections as well! Order fresh pies and decadent cakes of all sizes. Yummy! Enjoy! read more

I was visiting from out of town on my son's birthday so I decided to buy a cake for everyone to share. I ordered this cake 07/07/2024 to be picked up on 07/11/2024. I was looking forward to trying the cake. I was able to add customization's. I was emailed my receipt verifying the date I was to come pick up. I called the day before to confirm that I would be there the following day. The next day (Saturday) I get to the cake shop the sign says they're temporarily closed Saturdays. I wouldn't be able to get my order until Monday. Even though I placed the order through their system for Saturday! I attempted to get a refund. Called Monday morning and the person who I spoke with gave me a terrible attitude and basically told me she wasn't going to refund my money and hung up. From there I filed a dispute with my bank and had to wait 3 months for the dispute to go through. Spare yourself the hassle of dealing with these people. read more

We make every effort we can to stop in. This place is so cute and magical it draws my family back and we all have our favorite items. I always get a loaf of something, a few cookies, a batch of dough for later and whatever little seasonal item we can share with teachers, medical friends and more. Look for them at farmers markets and buy their freshest bread baked literally walking distance from the Pickering barn tent! read more

Found a farmers market today in federal way and what a super sweet fund did I discover. Delicious and delightful! Yummy beyond belief! Very friendly gentle man helped me and made my day. Wonderful read more

Purchased a cheesy (like focaccia) bread here at Issaquah Farmers market. You could see the steam inside the bags to tell us it was freshly made! We ate most of it when we got home. It had a great balance of not too much cheese and fresh bread. We finished it up the next day with it sitting in our pantry and was just as good. $7.50 well spent supporting a local small business. read more

See all

My mom's 80th birthday cake was a hit!! It was beautifully decorated and delicious. I live out of state and I was grateful for such artistry. I strongly recommend this bakery. read more

Forest Fairy Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

See all

I'm SO DISAPPOINTED! I was so excited to support this local business. I ordered 2 smash cakes. The cake decorator and I communicated over text. The ONLY really specific thing I wanted was to have PASTEL rainbow. I sent a few pictures for reference. She seemed to understand. When I picked up the cakes they were really dark in color and the frosting was sloppy. She told me if I didn't like the cakes I " didn't have to take them!" It felt like a really snarky rude response. I didn't want to offend her but it was not at all what we discussed. She told me that I could "just go to a grocery store then" I'm sorry on time. The party is tomorrow. I feel like she could have had better customer service and probably should charge for "decorating" if the cake looks like this. $120.00 read more

See all

We were waiting for our friends for lunch so decided to check this place out. It's a little off the main downtown Issaquah area and in this weird little corridor, so you would definitely miss it if you aren't looking for it. Anyways, we asked the lady what was good and what she recommended and we ended up with the chocolate zucchini bread with walnuts and the orange and apricot bread. Both were ok. My friends and I like the orange and apricot better just because of the citrusy flavor. The zucchini bread was too crumbly. It would be a messy eat. But nothing really special. I might come back to try their savory breads or their cupcakes/cookies to see read more

See all

We bought a 6 inch cake here for about $30? The sponge cake was super dry. The icing was fine. It was a basic cake. I was trying to support local business. See my photos. They do have challah bread which I will need to try next time. read more

See all

A small family run business, using the finest ingredients to provide the public with Top quality baked products. Served with a smile behind the mask ! read more

The cake was absolutely delicious and beautifully decorated ! Totally will be going there again !

Came across them at the Burien farmers market. I picked up the cheese bread and pumpkin nut loaves, both were very tasty

Paid $23 for a lemon bread, whole wheat banana bread with walnuts, cinnamon roll, and red velvet cake. I got this from the farmers market. I wanted to support a local business and didn't mind paying this steep price for a super tiny loaf of breads, but it's tough because the cinnamon roll and red velvet were so dry and overly sweet in the icing. I was honestly hoping for a bit more cream cheese but it's like 80% sugar and 20% cream cheese. The lemon bread was not bad. I just wish they used more lemon and probably fresh lemon too. It taste very sweet as will and more like lemon extract. The banana bread was the safest bet and taste like what I expected. Overall their sweet breads are very moist but everything else, avoid. read more

The baker was super helpful in making custom branded cookies for my recent one-year anniversary event. They were reasonably priced and made them with very little notice. They were very well-made and one of the better tasting "designer" cookies that I've had as they can sometimes be too dry and bland. I look forward to going back again and trying some of the many delicious looking desserts they had to offer. read more

We wanted a baseball themed cake with the typical red, white and blue signature color scheme for my son's first birthday. What we got was not along those lines. The blue was like an ocean blue rather than the navy blue as shown on the photo we sent. Didn't go with our cake topper nor banner nor any other blue we would have thought acceptable. The flavoring we chose was almond with the strawberry filling and buttercream frosting. We picked up the day before serving, cut in to the cake, and it was dry. We stored it as we were told as well. When we reached out to the bakery, she said the color could not be made as the dye would seep in to the flavor of the cake. We did get an apology however, she mentioned she 'intentionally' used less dye due to the flavor transferring. Had I known the color would be off and the cake would be dry, I would not have ordered from the bakery. I attached our 'desired' cake with the name Jackson and a photo of what we received with the name Nolan. read more

Forest Fairy Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

See all

It is super cute in a kitschy way. In keeping with the name, the shop is fairy themed right up to the guy wearing green fairy wings behind the counter. My daughter loved it. In keeping with the theme, they have mini bread loaves along with their full sized loaves for sale. I loved this idea as I love bread but never want to buy too much. They also have fairy decorated cookies. You get the idea. I bought a mini loaf of the multi-grain, a brioche roll for my daughter, and a honey nut bar (made with local honey). I really wanted a challah bread, but it was too big and my daughter insisted on the small brioche roll. She loves little versions of things so this bakery was just right for her. All of the baked goods were good quality. The bread was delicious. It gets only three stars because the baked items are really basic (as another reviewer has pointed out) and there isn't a lot of variety. This bakery really is best to go to for the breads. Even those are pretty standard. Still, I'll definitely be back to buy more. read more

I bought a beautiful FRESH chocolate cake for a friend's birthday. The baker frosted it and decorated it in 15 minutes. I was lucky! It was three layers of rich wonderful cake. words fail me. read more

Tiny little family owned bakery in Front Street...a blink and you'll miss it kind of place. It's a great place to get breads and loaves, but if you're looking for a beautifully decorated dessert created by someone who went to pastry school then you're out of luck. Everything's very basic, rounds of soft breads with different flavors, sticky buns, cookies, and brownies. I'm really not fond of basic desserts like just a chocolate chip cookie so it's not my kind of place, but everything tastes on point. I really don't have the biggest sweet tooth so if I'm going to eat a dessert, I want it to be the best one ever with complex flavors and a little something extra. Their bread is where they really excel though! No preservatives or anything, so if you buy one then MAKE SURE you refrigerate it. Assuming you have anything left. I have a big love affair with their jalapeño bread so if you can take the heat then get it. read more

Forest Fairy Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

My boyfriend ordered a cake for my birthday. It was delicious! Chocolate cake with mocha icing. They also added a drawing of my dog, which was adorable. Good cake, east ordering and east pick up. Would highly recommend read more

Forest Fairy Bakery - a birthday cake with a dachshund on it - Bakeries Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

OMG! These guys are awesome! I spotted them first at the Kirkland Wednesday Market. I saw the owner's son's girlfriend at the booth wearing fairy wings! That was my cue to go see what was going on. And what I found did not disappoint! They had an amazing selection of breads, and cookies and cupcakes. It was pure fairy heaven! I didn't buy anything that time but I did recruit them to come sell at my show, I Heart Rummage. They agreed, and they were an instant hit! At the show I bought about $30 worth of snacky goodies to take home. Even my husband was raving about how amazing the Pumpkin Spice Cake tasted. And I found my absolute new favorite: Chocolate Zuccini Cake. This is the most devilishly delicious cake ever! I hope they come to IHR every month, then we can share their fabulousness with everyone else! read more

Forest Fairy Bakery - Owner Linda Hays and Fairy Daughter - Bakeries Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

This bakery was able to make custom turtle bread for a super reasonable price. I was amazed how cute they turned out and they tasted really good. Will definitely use them again in the future! read more

Forest Fairy Bakery - Custom Turtle bread - Bakeries Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

Wonderful bread, cookies, and cupcakes that we came across at the opening day of the Auburn Farmers Market. I hope they come back! the carrot cake was spicy and the chocolate cupcakes featured a German chocolate style cake and a sugary milk chocolate frosting. Nice clam shell packaging got out tender finds home safe! All natural, all moist, all good :-)! read more

Forest Fairy Bakery - Chocolate and Carrot Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

See all

Omg! Just bought a carrot cake. After bringing it home, i couldn't resist. It was amazing!!!

It's okay. Like others have mentioned, it's pretty basic. I may be biased because I love to bake and nothing stood out as amazing or something I couldn't make at home. I was hoping for some pastries that I don't have the patience to make at home such as opera cake, profiteroles, macarons, etc. I probably won't be back but if you have no skills or patience to make bread or chocolate chip cookies then it's worth a visit. read more

I ordered pies here for the holidays- they were amazing! We especially enjoyed their raspberry pie. It was a hit!

Simple , very small family run bakery. Basic very basic. Don't expect over the top French pastry . Good simple cookies and bread.

Stopped in today with the kiddo's because we've been wanting to try the new bakery in town. The shop itself is decorated nicely and has some great touches like the mural on the wall and the fantastic wood bench/shelf, etc. We all loved the fact that almost every item sold has a regular sized version and a "fairy sized" version. Perfect for when you just want that sweet little treat (but not too many calories) or have a little someone with you. Also perfect for your doll, should you happen to have one who goes everywhere with your little someone. The carrot cake had a nice gingery flavor and we liked the texture and taste of the chocolate chip cookies. They had a table of day old items at a special price, so we picked up some fairy brownies that had salted caramel on the top. YUM! This is a place you go to pick something up and not necessarily to eat it there. They're just getting started though, so I have high hopes that things will progress nicely as they gain momentum and customers, especially with all the other new eateries going in on Front street. The lady who helped us was very personable. We'll be back. read more

Stopped in the store last week. The store interior was charming and the staff was very friendly. They had a variety of goods available (mid Saturday afternoon). The pumpkin spice bread that was available for sampling was very moist and tasty. Their zucchini bread was one of the best that I've had recently! It had the right balance of moisture without being too dense or feeling soggy and was well spiced. We also tried a variety of cookies and enjoyed all of them thoroughly. Overall, we enjoyed everything that we bought. The hardest part was convincing ourselves that didn't need to buy 1 (or more) of everything in the store. We'll definitely be going back. read more

We need a bakery in Issaquah!! First visit: Very bad. Challah dry and stale. Cookies dry and stale. Brownie ok. Cupcake ok. Very disappointed. I'll try again, they deserve a second chance, and update then. But seriously, not one thing we bought was delicious or fresh. read more

Delicious baked goods right in downtown Issaquah. Lover the cinnamon rolls.

For someone who spent couple years in Paris, I know when I see quality baked treats (Or I wish I am lol) they are truly known for their breads, mini breads and basic deserts like simply decorated cookies and brownies. If you are looking for an intricate cake decorator you won't find them here. Clean and organized and varied themed-events featured at this location. They really cater to kids and big kids at heart. Employees acknowledge almost every customer with a huge smile, and when it is morning, and you are hungry, it is a lovely way to start a day. read more

I've had their food before and loved every bite, however after today I don't think I'll return until the pandemic is over. I went into the bakery and saw several employees maskless behind the counter, who hurriedly put masks on when I came in. They were well within 6 feet of the racks in the center of the room where everything out of the oven goes to cool. I bought something out of a feeling of social obligation, but threw it away before getting home. I live with a healthcare worker and an at-risk individual, and I will not risk their health for cookies, as delicious as they may be. I choose to not risk myself or my family, and wanted others to be able to make that same choice. I will absolutely come back - when I know for sure it's safe. read more

Lots of nice treats, frosted cookies and really good cinnamon rolls. The cheese breads are really good too. They've been around a bunch of local farmer's markets for a while but this is their new permanent retail space with the bakery in the back. Really cute mural on the wall but there isn't much of sitting area. This is more of a buy to go place and definitely not somewhere you could camp out and work. read more

Last weekend we were in Issaquah for the Village Theatre Weekend of Musicals. Before the Saturday Matinee, we needed a little dessert and cappuccino. We walked about two blocks down to the FF Bakery. They were closed and we started walking back to town when the door opened and the bakery person told us to come in and she would make our coffees. What a nice gesture in today's world !!! We ended up with a huge chocolate chip cookie for dessert, chock full of yummy chocolate chips. Thank you FF Bakery ! We will be back soon... read more

I love this place. Amazing baked goods, family-run and always a delight. In the interest of full-transparency, though, I must also note that on my most recent visit I inquired after a cookie to learn its composition. I was told it's oatmeal chocolate chip. My favorite. It was not. It was oatmeal raisin. I know better than to blindly trust the difference between those 2 options. One is heaven; the other is hell. It is unforgivable to make that baked goods error. So while I'll return to this lovely shop, I will forever have my guard up. read more

Have had their baked goods at local farmers markets and quite honestly, the goods tasted old. The cookies tasted like they were baked days before and the cheese bread while tasty to some degree seemed a bit on the stale side of things. Doesn't take like it was just baked that day and brought to market. read more

This is the second year in a row that we have used Forest Fairy Bakery for Thanksgiving goodies. We ordered rolls and 3 different pies. Everything was off the chart!!!! They had my order ready to go when I arrived. The staff is always friendly and very helpful. I will continue to frequent this location until I can't fit through the door. read more