Dick's has a monopoly on track cleats, apparently. It's the only place I could find around Indy…read morethat actually sells them in person. Cleats are the kind of shoes you need to try on in person, because you don't want to eff around with running shoes. So if you're looking for cleats, they got a lotta them here! Lots of colors to choose from, and they range from $60 to $180. Guess which ones my kid gravitated to? We tried some on, which was easy to do because there were many people around to help us. But if you visit and you can't find someone, this Dick's has a kiosk in the shoe section where you can request shoes to try on, and someone will hypothetically materialize from somewhere and bring them to you. I like this Dick's in Castleton because it tends to have more product in stock than the one in Carmel. But I also like Dick's in general (that's what she said) because it was one of the stores I could convince my kids to visit with me when they were younger. We would ride the escalator up and down, and sit in the canoes, and climb into the tents, and see who could punch the punching bag the hardest. Who knew that Dick's could be entertaining as well as a place to find sporting goods? Good times. Now, my kids come with me to Dick's to try to convince me to drop $200 on shoes they're going to wear for four weeks. Take me back to the canoe!

This Dick's is under rated. I come frequently. The store is huge and packed with quality…read moremerchandise and name brands. The staff is friendly. Today, I asked for help finding the Crocs and a clerk stopped what he was doing and walked me over to the racks. On my previous visit, I was looking for running gloves and a manager went in the back to find some for me because they were off season. I am always happy to find brick and mortar options that I can examine, compare and try on, before purchasing. As I left today, a check thanked me for visiting. The store is clean. There is plenty of parking and the only negative I can think of to say is that the parking lot has multiple potholes. As I read the negative reviews, I am baffled.

I really love this location. It is always so clean, organized and I always get excellent service…read morefrom staff. Staff here are always so courteous and helpful. Although products tend to be pricey, it is often great quality. This is the ideal place for a wide selection of outdoor and hiking products.

Service is simply poor at this store. Online ordering is a challenge as well--it's difficult to…read morediscern what's on sale where. If you call the store, answers are ambiguous and you get the sense you're "bothering" the person. Similar experience with in person visits, except you get added pomposity. EVERY time. REI makes the customer work for the privilege of paying premium prices for products available elsewhere.

I would give this place half a star if I could. Way too crowded, not enough employees, music way…read moretoo loud. Have to stand in lines to get ingnored or walked in front of. I can take my $200.00 for my son's basketball shoes and go anywhere else, they just happened to have his size in the specific shoe we were looking for. Still, EVERYONE was rude to us. Did I mention they were RUDE? And very crowded?

In the mist of driving to Rhode Island from cali for work, I stopped by indy and checked out the…read moreCastleton mall. While I was there, I noticed that majority of the shoe stores had on display two adidas shoes that one simply cannot see in cali-the thriple white ultra boost, and the NMD's. Thinking to myself that the only size in stock were giant size-which is normal for the shoes-I was a bit pessimistic. However when asked to check the size in stock (8 and 8.5), I know... I have girly foot size, I was suprised that they had them! So, in effort to stock up on some hyped up shoes, I purchased three triple white ultra boosts (me, my wife, and sis in law) and one white nmd. All in all, champs, carried the shoes that other stores in the same mall did not carry. Likewise, the staff working at champs were easy to deal with and did not pressure me to quickly purchase my shoes. Thanks Champs!

I called ahead and provided the style number and they held the item for me to pickup…read more I also ordered another hat they didn't have in stock and that will be shipped to me at no charge since I ordered it in the store. The young man at the counter was very nice and helpful. The store is packed with goodies from Indiana, Ohio, Michigan and Kentucky. A little pricey but a onestopshop for fanatics

The clothing selection is almost overwhelming and as any sports fan knows that is exactly how we…read morewant it. I just came in out of curiosity passing by but now I plan on doing a lot of gift shopping here. I am an artist so I was greatly appreciative to see that there was a local artist section inside. The store manager is extremely kind and is very helpful in answering questions!

Large selection. Great deals. Friendly staff. The store is clean and inviting. I love the quality…read moreof the 5.11 brand and the store is great to try fits and see what works. The people who work there are always friendly and knowledgable.

Best local option for people looking for solid apparel and accessories for more functional and…read moretactical uses. Solid staff who are serving not peddling and you get what you pay for and it lasts.

Fantastic place Great for…read more Personalizing gifts Say hi to Mike, a very personable man.

Sometimes I wish that I could give 6 stars, because this would be one of those times. Amazing…read morepeople. Amazing service. I would recommend this shop to anyone who needs something embroidered and wants to have the absolute best service. If you're looking for mediocre service with average execution, go somewhere else. My experience with Webster's Sporting Goods could not have been any better. I had called several other embroidery shops in the area and I could not find a single one that would personally embroider one item. So, one week before Christmas, I walked into Webster's with a desperate plea to have an apron embroidered. Not only was it a week before Christmas, but I needed to have the item finished in 2.5 days. I was not expecting to be able to pull it off, but I thought it was worth a shot to ask them anyway. When I entered the shop, I was greeted by a man who was much friendlier than I expected for a busy shop employee around the holidays. He was so nice and not only took the apron but also helped me decide where and how to embroider it. He (Mike is his name) then helped me narrow down some fonts and ultimately I allowed him to use his discretion on what type of font to use in the location that we chose. Mike told me that he wasn't entirely sure if they would be able to finish the job by Friday, but he would give me a call either way so I could come pick it up. Mike and the rest of the team put me so at ease when I was in such a panic about getting this item embroidered on time. Even if they weren't able to get it finished, I was so happy about the way I was treated at their shop. Fast forward to the next day, yes the NEXT DAY, and I get a call from Mike telling me that the apron is finished. Not only did they get the job done for me, but they got it done EARLY. During the holiday season. WOW!!!! Color me impressed. I went to pick the item up, and I was again greeted by Mike, who remembered me BY NAME. He handed me the apron to review and I was stunned with how great it looked. It was better than I could have imagined on my own. To top it off, when I asked them if I could please tip since they did such an extraordinarily good job, I was told instead to donate to a charity of my choice. Holy smokes. I only wish I had more things to embroider so I could give Webster's more of my business. To say I'll be returning is an understatement.

1/20/26 In the area…read moreand after having dinner decided to walk to the mall.. Crazy cold but needed to get our steps in. Enjoyed seeing a few familiar retailers.. Glad they are conveniently located from the hotel too.

My first impression of Castleton Square: This mall has season better days. I'd bet this place was…read morehopping 10-15 years ago. Now, while there are still some good stores, it is showing its age and there are seemingly more local businesses than national chains. The food court has decent dining options. We opted for Chick-fil-A. There's a play area for kids, too, which was nice for killing time -- but, like the mall, could use a refresh. Overall, Castleton is a serviceable mall, but nothing special.

L.L. Bean is always the best quality. It's like, you can rest easy knowing that the L.L. Bean duvet…read morecover that your child just threw up on will wash and dry and come out looking like new. Ask me how I know! (Actually, don't ask me. I just want this day to end.) I have bought many L.L. Bean things (including duvet covers), but strangely not clothing. The clothes here are not really my style. But recently, I was in the market for a new travel toiletry bag for an upcoming trip, and after a little research, I found out that L.L. Bean makes a great toiletry bag. They didn't have any in stock when I visited the store, so I ordered one online. I got it today, and it might be the best toiletry bag I've ever had! It's so roomy yet compact, and the quality is great. Even though I didn't find the specific thing I was looking for in this Castleton store, there were lots of neat things, like outdoor gear, backpacks, and even kayaks! The store wasn't as big as I expected it to be, but they packed a lot into a little space.

I stumbled upon this L. L. Bean location which is filled with high quality recreational apparel and…read moreaccessories. I rarely get to go to brick and mortar stores where I can actually try things on. This was a treat! It was nice to find hiking gear and lightweight jackets that I wanted. They had a good selection of hiking boots, too. The prices were high (I thought), but the quality was there. The store is huge, well organized, immaculate and packed with merchandise. Spring colors were everywhere. I encountered several clerks who asked if I needed help. The check out area is in the back of the store, which I found a bit odd. There is plenty of parking in the strip mall lot. I'll be back.

This is my favorite of favorites for running shoes and apparel…read more - rewards program gets me $15 off most of my shoes purchases - they recycle my old shoes no matter what the shape - the are patient finding my perfect fit - the clothes are great quality - service is always friendly - the selection is great. If they don't habit in stock, they will order it Need running supplies? Come here!

I ordered a shoe online, Athletic Annex cancelled my order stating I asked for it to be cancelled…read more False. I sent them an email, they tried to gaslight me saying they sold out of the product and they tried to purchase the shoe online direct from Nike for me but it was sold out. I can prove they aren't telling the truth. I recommended Athletic Annex to friends who purchased the same shoe after me online and had their orders filled.