We were craving pizza the other night and decided to try this pizza joint. Ordered on DD so can't tell you how the place looks nor customer service. We had the Large Everything pizza, two orders of the knots (buy one, get one promotion), and two garlic dips and an extra marinara sauce (.98 cents each). Everything Pizza: 6.5/10 - the pizza itself was HUGE and worth the $29 price tag. It had banana peppers, cheese, bell peppers, olives, pineapple, Canadian bacon, sausage, tomatoes, and jalapeños. I appreciate that they don't skim on the toppings but it was a bit much (flavor wise) all at once. All the flavors muddled together and after a few bites, it became super heavy and greasy. We could only stomach one slice at each time, because there was too much going on. The garlic dips were flavorful but had a slight aftertaste I wasn't a fan of. The crust was nice, toasty, and thick and we loved dipping it into the sauces. Garlic knots/rolls: 8.5/10 - these were delicious and coated in their signature garlic butter sauce! The knots were soft, buttery, and full of flavor! The marinara sauce was tangy and went well with them. We enjoyed the knots very much and were super excited that we got another one for free too! They give you a good amount of garlic knots in an order, like 6 big size pieces for $5 something ish. I think we need to try other pizzas as the one we had, wasn't really doing it for us. We will give it another try as the price for the portions were great! They have other things on the menu too like desserts, pepperoni bites, wings, cheesy bread, jalapeño curds, etc. read more

My new favorite pizza place. I was always hesitant to try them but, I'm so glad I finally did. 10/10 on the garlic knots and pepperoni pizza. Will definitely be ordering again. Easy to order online. They have deals available. And they're not skimping out. I'll definitely be a repeat customer. Just the classic comfort food you want and need from a pizza place. 10/10. read more

Whenever I am on that side of town, I get a large pepperoni pizza here. The pick up Price for the pizza is still very reasonable and the pizza is definitely delicious. I highly recommend trying this pizza place out. read more

Oh my! It's been too long! We ordered an 18 inch deluxe no green peps extra mushrooms, pepperoni rolls, Carolina sauce wings and a side of Hamilton sauce. I'd never had that sauce but I do love datil peppers. The service was very fast. I didn't time it but definitely less than an hour. The order was correct, yea! The pizza had generous toppings and well cooked. The wings were fall off the bone. I tasted the Hamilton sauce and it is tasty. Very spicy and a bit sweet. I'd say perfect for dipping wings or pizza, breadsticks, etc. I'd also say a 5 of 5 on the heat level. The pepperoni rolls were fresh homemade style dough with plenty of pepperoni, topped with garlic butter. I may try pics later. Too full to move right now and I'm busy watching Home Alone, for only the second time, it's still hilarious! Definitely try them out - delivery, takeout available. And the movie! read more

See all

We love some 5 Star pizza! Always our goto when looking for pizza!! Delivery is always fast and friendly!

If you have a big family or group to feed the Piezilla is a 24" round pizza that is huge. Crust is nice and thick and they are very generous with the toppings. Ordered and paid online so when I walked in it was a quick pick up. They also offer delivery for a fee. read more

See all

Ordered several pizzas for a birthday party. Very nice people, order was perfect and prompt. Great pricing and great quality. Would recommend! read more

they don't deliver 15 mins away and I called i live close and they act like they can't even come terrbile service

Veronica is a whole unprofessional mess!! I called to place an order and the lady was beyond rude, kept asking, "anything else?". She was beyond rude and she didn't care. I called back to speak to a manager and she gladly told me she was the manager and further told me that's the way she speaks to all her customers. Shame on you Rob for having a manager who can't truly lead a crew if she can't attract the customer with her nasty, unprofessional, disrespectful attitude. Veronica, you should find another place of business because if pizza isn't fun, you make it a miserable experience. After realizing that Veronica was self- indulged by her title, I cancelled my order. I work hard for my money and I will never spend my money where the business doesn't realize that without customers, there would be no business. It gets better!! Upon hanging up, she cynically tells me thanks for calling. Rob, the owner should remind Veronica that in his absence, she represents his business and bottom line. With an attitude and so many negative reviews regarding her attitude, you'd think Rob would make a few changes, beginning with a Customer Service class for his manager, Veronica. My grandchildren were really sad tonight because we regularly enjoy 5 Star but I'll patronize any other pizza shop, along with my business orders before I spend a dime where a manager can't even offer an apology- just excuses as to why her customer service skills are sub-par. What a disappointment because everyone that had ever taken our orders, both personal and business orders were treated with kindness and respect. I don't believe that's asking for too much when it comes to business. read more

Takeout specials value/delicious ratio of the charts. Affordable is rare these days and it feels like other pizza joints are charging an arm and leg these days. read more

Great pizza, good service and really quick, the people are friendly and they seem genuinely interested in the happiness of their customers.

Always hot always fresh and you fold it NY style while the hot grease pours out and you slightly burn your tongue and it's just the best slice in Orange Park and dare I say Jacksonville !!! read more

Five star is easily the best delivery pizza in the area. The crust has the perfect balance between soft and chewy. The sauce is just a touch on the sweet side and the toppings are fresh. Can I say you won't get a better pizza in the area? No, but five star is by far the best that delivers read more

One of our favorites for pizza and my boyfriend loves the wings. Delivery is typically fast, friendly and most importantly accurate.

At first things were ok here. Pizza was decent. (I'm originally from NJ). The last time we ordered it was super salty, the pizza. Today we ordered pick up I got home starving the pizza is so bad. Still super salty but just made so poorly. I'm sad cause I thought I found a decent pizza joint here. I refuse to order dominos or chain pizza. There goes my $40. read more

See all

The pizza was very fresh and tasty. I loved the thin crust Hawaiian pizza. I would give it a five star.

Yes. Just yes. The thin crust. Ample cheese and toppings. Super fast delivery. Can't wait to order again.

If I could give this store a 0 for customer service I definitely would. Robert the owner argued with my husband and I about the order THEY made wrong and didn't want to correct it and wanted me to pay for another pizza! We wanted garlic sauce and they made the pizza with marinara sauce. Simple fix. His employees are also unprofessional as well. He needs to train them on how to not escalate a situation with a customer as well! We order from here often, however, this was the worst experience we've ever had! read more

Five Star Pizza OP never disappoints. Delivery is always quick and the food is always hot and fresh. read more

Five Star Pizza - Cheese sticks - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

I grew up in upstate New York in a community that was 90% Italian. I have eaten pizza on 5 of 7 continents and 5 Star Pizza has no equal. I am blessed to have them in my community. read more

Usually we get amazing pizza from this establishment. However, we ordered an extra large pepperoni pizza and this inedible disc was read more

Five Star Pizza - Supposed to be an extra large pepperoni pizza. Instead it was a charred, burnt disc. - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Every year, my family does pizza and wings. Not wanting to cook ourselves. Usually when we order from chains, the wait time is multiplied even with pick up. I have been over to Five Star a few times and always amazed on how many people are here working and how everyone always has an upbeat attitude now matter how crazy busy it is. Like, they are always busy when I come in. I placed my order online and called after to check on the pick up time. He said, "15 to 20 minutes." Really? Even on Super bowl Sunday... Yep. No lie.. My pizzas and garlic knots where ready by the time I walked in (I live 15 minutes away.) Everyone was happy and smiling. Tons of drivers coming in and out picking up pizzas. Damn, they really do know how to run pizzas up in here. (In the past, other chains have made us wait an hour minimum for pick up.) Not to overlook that their pizzas are always good. No restrictions on how many *coupons I use and I can't recall their ever being an issue with our pizza. Yeah, they know what's up around here and I totally appreciate that. I get to enjoy pizza and watch the game without stressing out is really worth it! You guys rock! read more

Had five star at a friend's the other nite and was pretty good but not toppings I would've chosen. Ordered last nite at the house and was like hell yeah! Papa who Domino what and what the Hut. Forget the rest I've found my pizza hot spot. Ordered the Hawaiin and the everything for delivery and they were hot and fresh. More than an ample amount of toppings and the crust was incredible. If your looking for fresh really good pizza that isn't over seasond or has a sauce that has a gang then Five Star pizza is your place. read more

Good pizza. This place is definitely underrated. They deliver almost everywhere, I live easily 20 minutes away and they deliver to me so that's a plus. The quantity and the quality is always good. And the price for the amount of food you get is a win win. There online ordering menu is easy to navigate and they always have a $5 off coupon. read more

The site doesn't allow me to add screen shots 5 star of orange park does not require masks on workers. They state you have to request contactless delivery and authorize your card so you don't have to sign. Yet the website does not give that information. They do not do temp checks on their workers. And when privately contacted they stated they "do all the law requires". They took 3 days to respond and did not care. read more

Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

Just ordered delivery from here for the first time tonight (12/24/18) pizza was hot, fresh, and just the way we ordered it. They quoted us about an hour but it was to our front door in less than 30 min. Delivery driver was polite & friendly. We will definitely be ordering from here again. Great prices also! read more

Not sure about the food because I'm not even sure I want to eat anything from there. Not one of the workers was wearing a mask or gloves. There were guys with beards without any hair nets on. No social distancing. The people that came in right after me also commented how no one was following COVID protocols. I plan to steer clear of this place from now on. read more

Thank you for the pizza you donated to the hospital employees during COVID-19. We appreciated it so much!

The pizza here is a good value. I love the pepperoni rolls. They are pepperonis and cheese rolled up in a flaky bread. Yummy! The delivery times in my area are shorter than going to Papa Johns or Dominos. read more

My best friend and I get the $10 18" carryout pizza super often and it's always the best $10 ever spent. We work crazy hours so we really appreciate the hours the employees at five star work, Erin is my favorite person that works there she's so nice and won't skimp you on extra parmesan and crushed red peppers, such an angel read more

Five Star Pizza - 18" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Get your pizza the way THEY like it, NOT the way you like it!!! Burnt pizza time after time. When I ordered my pizza I said- "please don't overcook it". I got an overcooked pizza so I asked the manager (Jacob) and he says, "well that's how we make it". So he sends me another pizza because he won't refund my money and I ask, please don't over cook my pizza, yet be sends me another overcooked pizza. I called to complain and he says, "that pizza was fine". Well maybe for him, but not for me, but I guess the customer doesn't really matter. You pay for pizza the way they like it. Definitely doesn't look like the pizza they advertise. read more

Five Star Pizza - Overcooked pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

The pizza tasted great. It was no lobger warm when I got home, but that was on me. Heated it up and just wow!!! It was prepared just the way I wanted it. Service was friendly and I didn't have to wait at all. I ordered online and left right away. Hoghly recommend 5 Star Pizza if you want a reasonably priced pizza and don't want to cook. Oh, and don't forget the garlic rolls...delicious! read more

Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

If I could give this place a minus score, I would. Horrible experience! We've ordered the exact same pizza every week for over a year. Picked up order and it's cut into bite size pieces. Christina asked "was that not ok?"!no it's not as I'm not feeding toddlers. Remake it, 25 mins later it's done. Checked and it's cut properly. On the wAy home I try a slice and the dough is RAW!!!! Call them, they'll make me a 3rd pizza. Take back bad pizza, remake is cold. They make ANOTHER one, handed it over, drive home and noticed it's cold. Drive a the way back, make yet another pizza. Christina laughs and thought I he prank she pulled was so funny. If you like being screwed around and waiting over 2 hrs for then to get your order right, then eat here. I'm taking my business elsewhere read more

So last night I ordered the special large 2 topping garlic knots and a 2 Liter of soda. Delivered with out the soda driver said she would be right back never showed. Called the store spoke to the manager he said he would fix it and apologized and said it was on the way still nothing. At this point it's not about the soda. It's about the lack of confidence I have in this business to make it right with the customer. Even the manager lied to me over the phone. Like I said it's not about the soda I don't even drink that much it's about the principle now. read more

We had a meat pizza and Hawaiian pizza. Meat pizza was overly greasy but tasted good (probably comes with the territory of ordering one). The Hawaiian pizza was definitely more balanced and had a ton of cheese on it, which tasted phenomenal! Went into the store for a carry out and was less than impressed with the cleanliness and amount of clutter that was present. Seemed like someone got carried away with constructing pizza boxes. 4 stars for taste of pizza, probably better than most chains 2 stars for overall appearance of store/employees read more

The best pizza place in Orange Park hands down huge pizza excellent garlic knots excellent cinnamon buns you just can't beat it and the crust is made fresh daily on the site. Fast fresh friendly on a Friday night! read more

Five Star Pizza - My amazing plate - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

They're making their pepperoni and garlic rolls with a different dough and not put together very well. Last two pizzas came with the handful of very finely chopped, canned mushrooms literally in one hand sized spot. It was ridiculous. They haven't ever really had great customer service, but at least the food WAS good! Current looking for a new pizza spot as several local spots have really started to drop on quality. read more

It was a ridiculous situation. A co-worker of mine wanted to get pizza (in celebration of most of us being promoted to managers at our own restaurant) and split the cost so everyone's pockets were happy. Okay, 45 dollars worth of food split 3 ways isn't bad at all for an XL pizza, cheesy bread, a 2 Liter, and 20 wings. Decent deal, really. Lots of food for hungry people. They said it would take 30-45 minutes. We place the order at midnight. 1 AM rolls around and they give us a call. "Yeah, we'll be 15 minutes out." I say okay and pass the phone over to my co-worker. We call at the restaurant to see what's up, because, even in a rush, it's not acceptable to take more than twice as long as your lowest possible time. (30 minutes +30 minutes =/= 1:30) We get the food at about 1:20 in the morning, and, by that point, we've all had it. The delivery guy has to take 10 minutes to call his manager and confirm it, but we get the food for free. We take it inside after tipping him 3 bucks. Now I don't even think we should have done that. The order was wrong. The bleu cheese was under the hot wings and probably spoiled (I didn't open it to find out because of food danger zones). At first, we didn't even think we got it. It was buried under all the wings. We also got Parmesan, two marinara, and crushed red peppers. We didn't order Parmesan nor two marinara sauces. Then we get to the garlic dip for the bread. This stuff is so greasy, I can't even dip my cheesy bread in the stuff. It's disgusting and cold and almost solid on the edges. In fact, most of the food was cold. The cheese wasn't melted anymore, and the bread wasn't warm at all. Okay, so the pizza. We had ordered the 3 toppings on a XL. We wanted onions, chicken, and bacon. I got one piece of bacon on one piece of pizza in the whole box, and I couldn't find a single piece of onion on any of my slices. The chicken, too, was scarce. We had to play 'find the toppings'. It was like they hadn't even thought to put anything on until that last second of 'oh wait, it needs toppings!' or something. We call back to complain that we didn't get what we ordered. Yes, we got a refund after a lot of arguing (unprofessional on their part), but the order was wrong. The manager is pissed off, for whatever reason and literally, literally said there was nothing he could do to fix our order. He says to wait, puts the phone on the counter, and hangs up later. We call back because that was rude. The manager on Wednesday night-shift says 'he doesn't care, we got the order, it doesn't matter if it's wrong, we refunded it' and continues to put the phone on the counter every time we call. Then it goes to them answering and hanging up on us. We call back a little later to try to talk to a higher up manager. The best part is, since there's no general manager, only owners, we try to find a corporate number. There's not one. We call the Five Star in freaking Gainesville to try to get a hold of a corporate number. There really aren't any, but there need to be. A very nice guy, named Brandon, helps us out. He tells us how to get into contact with the owner and all that. So we get a hold of someone. They say that they can give us one free pizza of equal value to what we had before in compensation for the teenage-like, silly behavior we had to endure. That sounds perfect to us. A great ending to a terrible weekend for us, since those were our days off. Okay, we accept this. B.B.B, here we go. We can't take it the very next day because of work schedule conflicts. Can't accept a pizza when you're running a shift at a different diner, right? Yeah, we talked to the owner. Turns out, Orange Park's owner isn't very friendly. He doesn't uphold the agreement. He doesn't think of the customer. We even ask 'why won't you hold up to the agreement your other manager said they'd do? As in, why not back up their decisions, why break their promise' and so on. Turns out, the owner just isn't willing to back up the authority of their other managers. By the way, they went to the wrong address first. read more

I still have a lot of exploring to do in regards to local pizza joints and though this wasn't the best pizza I have ever had, it definitely deserves a strong 4 stars! Mind you, I am not a Pizza Connoisseur and other then during my Fleet Weeks in NYC I have never ventured outside of Pizza Hut, Domino's or Papa Johns. Yes I know, shame on me...especially since I am not a big fan of either franchise but for some reason I never thought to try local. Tonight I had a strong hankering for pizza and didn't feel like settling for the previously listed; I am SO glad I checked this place out! As soon as I walked in it seemed like the entire staff greeted me (if you have read my previous reviews then you know I am a glutton for hospitality) and were all smiles the entire time, even giving me an extra discount on top of the discounted special! I ordered a 16 inch pizza and 10 wings for about $14. 3 slices and 4 wings later, I'm very satisfied. Not overly greasy, a nice thin crust, big slices of pepperoni and the perfect amount of cheese (in my opinion). I have definitely had better hot wings but these hit the spot and go very well with the pizza. The best part of all is that I don't have that gonna-be-on-the-toilet-for-awhile feeling that usually accompanies one of the franchise pizza joints :-) All in all, this is a great little spot to get good pizza on a budget and will definitely help me wean myself off of the mainstream crap. Bonus: they deliver! So if you and your pals find yourself drunk and starving in the middle of the night (like me and mine sometimes tend to do lol) and want to be responsible by not driving (or cooking), then as long as it's by 3 am yawl now have a potential go-to spot! :-) read more

First time here but definitely NOT the last! The guys were so cool! The pizza was huge, delicious and ahhh-mazing! Thank you 5 Star Pizza... Love, you newest biggest fan! read more

Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida