So we accidentally stumbled upon this place and had to try the giant 24" pizza, because it's just…read moreone of those things in life you have to do! We ordered online and arrived to plenty of parking and very friendly staff. The inside was really clean, and we were impressed with the shop right away. Our pizza was ready in a timely manner as well. The box is huge, we joked that if you have a small car, be careful because it might change the radio station on the drive home. The pizza was still piping hot when we got home. Our teenager was in pure amazement! The pizza was cooked to perfection, with not too much cheese or sauce, the perfect consistency, and perfectly placed meats... All three of us loved it and ended up eating it all weekend for lunch! DD highly recommends this pizza place, and we'll definitely be back when family and friends visit so we can share a huge slice of pie with them.

My son wanted pizza and I usually order from Domino's and I did and I noticed through the tracker…read morethat my pizza was out of the oven however my pizza was not delivered until till over an hour later it was cold. I actually called them and have them take it back but 15 minutes before then I had ordered from five star. And right after Dominos left five star pulled up not even 16 minutes after I had ordered a pizza. Their pizza was unbelievable. It was piping hot. There were so many toppings on it. It was heavy unloaded up. The cheese then that nice hot melted stretch when you pulled it apart, and I don't know why I didn't order from them from the beginning because usually I do, but I had a coupon for Dominos and I was using it but not anymore. I will never order from them again, but I will definitely order from five star. They were absolutely delicious.

This is THE BEST pizza we've had anywhere in a long time. Ordered two kinds ... primavera and…read moremargarita ... Fantastic. And I have to say .... just moved from NE Pennsylvania where they brag about pizza. THIS is FAR better than anything we had there ... and you're talking about a lot of people who know NYC very well. We WILL order again and again. Also ... re: the review by Crystal C, January 3 .. Crystal ... please, if you're displeased, you tell the management. They'll make it right as any decent business does.

We ordered to go but when we picked it up it was a clean restaurant with seating. The pizza was…read morewell made and it was NY style! The service was quick and I recommend checking them out!

I absolutely love the type of pizza they make! The fluffy crust and personal size isn't easy to…read morefind and it tastes SO GOOD! The only caveat is that the pizza could use a little more time in the oven to add that nice crunch to the bottom of the pie. Also, I personally got the 4 Cheese White Pizza primarily because I wanted White Pizza. It was way too cheesy for me and I was actually pulling the cheese off But I love bread and doughy pizza. I'll definitely be giving this place another try and getting the Mushroom Ricotta Pizza next time

Gainesville has a new pizza place! Bring on the parade!…read more So I went here recently to try them out... I waited until after they had gotten through at least some of their initial opening problems that always seem to crop up with a freshly opened restaurant. It is located in what used to be Gainesville's best ice cream parlor (which in turn was previously a Starbucks before they moved down the road and became Gainesville's biggest traffic problem for 13th). Given this pedigree, I had high hopes. Sadly, I don't think they are going to last. Entering, the place is decorated decently. Figuring out how the place works takes a couple seconds of standing there and looking around, but eventually it becomes clear that they will either do counter ordering or you can order through electronic kiosks. I went with the kiosk since there was a family in front of me that was ordering at the counter. Looking through the menu, I found that they have only one size of pizza, the 11". This is fine if you are one or two people, but if you are a family you are going to be ordering more than one. This is kind of the reason why I think they are doomed. While the pizza toppings are the full variety, the fact that you only have one choice in size and that is the only thing on the menu for food (no wings, no breadsticks, etc. All they have is pizza) means that your choices are fairly narrow. Combine that with being located a fair distance from the university campus, which means that the clientele are coming in from the suburbs, and this appears to me to be a recipe for disaster. Don't get me wrong... the pizza is good. The problem here is not the quality of the product, nor the staffing or even the decor. The problem is a combination of the lack of variety combined with proximity to a customer base that will support a single-product enterprise. If they were located on University Ave across the street from UF, they might have a chance assuming they could balance their sales against the cost of a lease along there, or if they offered a wider variety of food options at their current location, I think they could make a proper go of it, but as it stands now, I (sadly) am expecting to see something new in that location in a year or two.

We were taking back our granddaughter to UF and stopped here for dinner. We got the Italian…read moredressing covered rolls, Caesar salad, &pepperoni rolls . Everyone was very friendly. The place was clean and not too loud for having TVs. The Caesar salad was excellent. My granddaughter absolutely loves the Italian dressing, covered rolls. The pepperoni rolls were definitely a hit. It's a very nice place with good food. We will frequent more often.

We were visiting Gainesville and found this hidden gem. The food was amazing. We got the pizza with…read morericotta and meatballs along with the wings. Everything was very hot temperature and delicious. Would love to try sitting inside next time as we took this order to go. Looked really nice and comfy inside. Staff was super friendly.

I found this spot on Yelp while craving a true giant NY style pizza, and even though it had minimal…read morereviews, we had to check it out. For reference, I have had NY pizza in NYC, so I am a tough judge First off, we went on a Friday night and downtown was absolutely crazy. Definitely college season energy. They only have a pickup window, so parking can be a challenge. Pro tip, have one person hop out while the other drives around the block. It made things much easier for us. When I walked up, the staff was super friendly. We chatted about how we moved here from Massachusetts almost two years ago but had never ventured this far downtown before. I really enjoyed the vibe of the area. They do accept cards, and I updated the pricing here to reflect current costs. Now for the pizza. We are always on the hunt for those monster size pies, and this 20 inch pizza did not disappoint. The box barely fit in our truck which gave us a good laugh. We got it home and between us and our teenager, the whole thing was gone. The taste was fantastic and honestly reminded me of one of those little spots in Times Square. There was very minimal grease and none of that heavy heartburn sauce we always joke about. Overall, highly recommend. Our whole pizza was ready in about 10 minutes which was impressive. If you are in the area, even grabbing a slice might just hit that perfect comfort food spot.

Italian Gator is a staple for Gainesville students, residents, and visitors. Did you even come to…read moreGainesville if you didn't stop by for a slice?! This hole-in-the-wall spot has retained its usual charm and flavor despite exploding with popularity! If you want a slice for lunch, a slice post club, a slice because you're hungry, a slice because you're bored - Italian gator is always the answer. Their thin, crispy pizza slices have won hearts over so many years and their absolutely delicious pizza flavor has remained the same through it all! They keep their menu simple with a cheese or pepperoni slice, but both are the most incredible slices of pizza I've ever tasted! If you're ever in Gainesville for any reason, plsssss do yourself a favor and stop by for the best slice Florida has to offer! While you're at it, walk through the most beautiful campus you'll ever see

The food was very VERY good! The staff was nice and friendly. Something you don't see in…read morerestaurants today! I highly recommend NY Pizza Plus for anyone dining in the area. You will not be disappointed!

Food was delicious. Calamari was a bit heavy on the coating, but it was still good. Pizza was great…read moreas well! Peyton was attentive and friendly too.

The place was slammed with only one waitress and i waited 15 minits to get my drink…read more Finally got another waitress. Shrimp Alfredo was good but Zuchini Fries was the hit for me!

Do not, and I repeat do not order take out from here. Done it twice now thinking the first time was…read morea fluke but it's not. They said 20 minutes, and I waited almost an hour for my takeout. I ordered 2 large plain-ish pizzas, small pizza, and 2 salads, that's it. The girls there are in-competent and act like they have no idea what they are doing. Never again. Pizza and salad is average, nothing special.

A Pizza Party doesn't care who's there!…read more I'm a major pizza lover, I don't think that's a surprise to anyone because I can truly eat pizza on a daily basis. The patio is new to Gainesville, and it is truly worth the visit! Located right on Main Street in downtown Gainesville, the Patio Pizza and Provisions is a great song for a quick lunch, a cocktail or beer, or just a fun night out for a meal. With a specialty of pizza, the patio heater location processor provides salads, sandwiches, and so much more! On my last visit, I enjoyed a quick slice of pizza and beer, with wonderful customer service from the team on staff. So for a quick slice of pizza, a drink and a seat with a view of Main Street - The Patio Pizza & Provisions is a great choice!

This is a slept on gem. Don't let the construction around the Patio sway you. They have phenomenal…read morepizza. I almost forgot to take a picture before eating it. The crust is perfection. I forgot my card this trip and honestly said I'm gonna stop and eat my pizza before going back. Check out their brunch too!! The breakfast pizza is literally the best brunch in downtown.