Great pizza, great pricing, great people. Small dining room with only four tables but we had a great experience when dining in from out of town. This place was one of my daughter's highlights of our springs trip. We will absolutely go again next time we're in the area! read more

Hours on the door state they are open till 9 PM. At 8:40 PM, we were told the lobby was closed and had to leave! Posted an hour said nothing about when the lobby was closed! read more

Pepperoni's Pizza - Horrible customer service making us leave after we paid and sat down with plates that they gave us!!! - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

Ordered 2 large pizzas double cut it was so good I love the cup pepperonis nice and crunchy and flavorful thank you I couldn't get a pic because it was gone by the time it got here hahah we devoured it ! read more

Not trying to bash this business, but this has to have been the greasiest pizza I've ever had. I literally blotted it with paper towels to try to soak up the grease before eating. I ordered a medium "pepperoni explosion" pizza. And I think someone forgot the extra pepperoni. Each slice seemed to have one circle of pepperoni on it. The menu said it was also extra cheese and the cheese did seem about right, but definitely not the pepperoni. A medium pizza was $17, and to be honest, it really isn't enough for 2 people. I guess it would be enough probably for 2 women, but it definitely would not be enough for 2 guys! The pizza tasted good, but just seemed to be rather expensive for what we got. Also, the crust probably could have been baked a little bit longer as it was more doughey than crispy. I would probably try them again in the future. But if it wasn't any better the second time, I would probably go to one of the other pizza places that High Springs has to offer. read more

Good pizza, nice undercarriage, slight flop on the pizza but was perfect. Sauce has almost a tangy flavor which was a plus, but only one downside, it was a little to greasy for me personally. I had to blotch it a few times because of it. Overall a good slice . read more

5 Stars - A Hidden Gem in High Springs! Pepperoni's Pizza in High Springs absolutely hit the spot! From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel right at home--super friendly, fast, and genuinely happy to be there. You can tell this place takes pride in what they do. We ordered a supreme pepperoni pizza and it was perfect--crispy on the edges, cheesy in the middle, and loaded with bold, savory flavor. The crust had that ideal balance of chew and crunch, and the sauce had just the right amount of tang. You can taste the quality in every bite. They've got a great selection of toppings and some really creative specialty pies too--we're already planning to come back to try more next time we visit the springs! Plus, the atmosphere is clean and casual, making it a great spot for a quick bite or a relaxed dinner with friends or family. Support your local pizza spot and give Pepperoni's a try. You won't regret it! read more

Great service and unexpected great food. Pizza light crust was amazing and the greek salad was 100% what you would want from a greek salad they had all the ingredients - no skimping. The boneless wings were also good, not greasy at all. Highly recommend. read more

Went here in the middle of a road trip, the guy at the front was nice and very polite.. pizza was good and affordable too

Love their pizza and calzones!! Small dining area but great for take-out. Best pizza in High Springs!

The pizza is old school AMAZING! Still under $25 also and worth rhe trip to oick it up

all of the ingredients were fresh, I had the Italian salad and a side of meatballs and ricotta cheese. Absolutely delicious.

I haven't eaten at Pepperoni's since we moved here over 15 years ago so I decided to try them again. I am still not fond of their pizza. It has always been overcooked and dry. It seems to not have enough sauce and cheese. I am not fond of the taste of their sauce either. Their garlic knots were very dense and not very garlicky. Perfectly round like store manufactured. So sorry I really wanted it to be better. Tough situation since High Springs now has several other pizza places and competitors are many. The young man who waited on me was very sweet and helpful. read more

super friendly service with great food. Pizza was super filling and portions were generous

Great food and fair prices. Lots of choices and great specials. Something for everyone in your family.

Everyone in town will tell you it is the best pizza and that may be true or at least a tie. By far the best garlic bread sticks. So why not 5 stars?? Only because a limited menu and minimal indoor seating. They are however right next to subway (why they don't do sandwiches they have an agreement) so if someone in your group don't want pizza they can still get a sandwich. read more

I'm currently addicted to the super deluxe cooked extra crispy. See previous reviews. That is all. read more

Pepperoni's Pizza - Oh heck yeah. - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

See all

Great food and service! Stuffed shells are so good! Pizza is great and fresh too. Garlic sticks are a favorite of the kids as well.

This pizza location is closest to my new home we moved too and it really is good for a small town. There sauce is not heavy on a regular cheese pizza and the dough is not thick. The sizes are good and they always have specials going on that helps with your budget. For my fellow divers this is a great place to grab a grub after coming from the springs nearby. Give this place a shot it will not disappoint. The location is very small so keep that in mind it's better to order to go. The staff is very friendly. read more

Pepperoni's Pizza - I have been here several times and I never checked in so my apologies! - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

Very disappointed. I've eaten here three times and won't again. The pizza was exactly like Pizza Hut, that's to say incredibly average. The calzone was also average. Today, when I walked in, the first thing I noticed was that the dining area was not clean. All the table tops were dirty. They remained that way the entire time I was there (10 minutes). How hard is it to bus and wipe 4 tables? Whenever I see a dirty dining area, I always have to wonder "if what I can see is this neglected, how bad is what I can't see (the kitchen)?" I got the meat lasagna, it was hefty, a decent portion size but it had slices of gray meat....they looked like leftover breakfast sausage. Very, very disappointed, to say the least. read more

Pepperoni's Pizza - The gray mystery meat in the lasagna. - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

I'm not much of an American pizza aficionado but I do appreciates good and tasty pizza and this place nailed it! Ordered 3 larges for a group of divers and they made them up in 15 minutes flat! Hot, fresh, tasty! Tomato sauce was flavourful with a hint of garlic, cheese was good, fresh veggies on the veggie pizza, Hawaiian was great and my fave was no surprise my usual pepperoni, bacon and pineapple. A couple people mentioned the cost was high. Got 3 larges and 2 2L pops for $65us. Fair if you ask me and the customer service was spectacular! Thanks for a great night. I'll be back for more sometime soon. read more

We are fairly new to the area & were looking for delicious pizza close to our new home. We tried Pepperonis & love it! I am hard to please with crust & theirs is great! Try this little place for great pizza! read more

Good pizza but it's expensive. I can't justify the cost when there's other pizza locations nearby unfortunately.

Great lunch specials. A bit pricy. Staff always friendly. Wife don't like spaghetti so I go by myself. Take out or eat in.

There are only 2 pizza places the other one was close so I when there. The pizza is average. Good toasty crust. However the sauce was too elementary. One can tell the sauce is made at home but it is missing many ingredients. No the worse pizza I had it just could be improved. read more

Pepperoni's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

See all

I love this pizza place. Their garlic rolls and breadsticks are so good! They have great deals as well.

This was a little slice of heaven. Probably some of the best pizza I've eaten in Florida. I would highly recommend this place to anyone traveling through high Springs. read more

Everytime we get pizza from here, it taste more and more like cardboard. Tonight it was cold cardboard. Waited and waited and finally asked, pizza had been sitting for a good while and they didn't care. read more

Pretty good pizza and other simple Italian food like Greek and Italian salads. Not much dine-in space, so I figure they do most of their business in take-away. They often have pizza-by-the-slice on hand and are open on Sundays, which is rare for places in High Springs. read more

The good: The pizza is the best you can get in High Springs. It's made with quality ingredients, the people who work there are friendly , and it is fast/convenient. The bad: The pizza is expensive. Two pizzas and bread sticks $40-50 dollars. Tonight I bought 60 wings for $67. I'm not sure the price to quality ratio is there. The ugly: They don't deliver. I guess that's ok, but if they did it would be even more convenient. Note: I gave them 3 stars because of the prices. The food is actually 4 star worthy. read more

Good NY style pies. Friendly staff. Fast service. Definitely deserves at least 4 stars. Aaaaaand good deserts too.

Hands down the best pizza ever. Although they need to train new employees how to garlic butter the crust and load those bread sticks up like a champ! No need to be shy guys!!! read more

We've been getting pizza from Pepperoni's for years. They're always prompt, staff is friendly, and the food is decent. Is it the best NaY style pizza I've ever had...probably not but they're decent and consistent which I appreciate. Probably the one thing I'd like is a little more sauce on their pizzas. Sometimes they can taste either a little dry or a little overcooked. Fairly standard mom and pop place for our area. We've enjoyed both their pizza and their stuffed shells and will continue ordering from them. What I am very pleased with is how above and beyond they've gone during the pandemic to keep both their staff and customers safe down to tiny details like making sure the pen you sign your bill with isn't the same one the last customer used before they have a chance to clean them. While not everyone in our town is doing their best to help protect each other Pepperoni's staff is and it's truly appreciated in these crazy times. read more

Amazing pizza!!!! We got the original house pepperoni pizza and the supreme calzone and as much as we wanted to save some for tomorrow we couldn't stop eating it bc it was sooooo good!!! The staff was very friendly and helpful. We will definitely be back when we are in the area again!!! read more

Pepperoni's Pizza - House specialty pizza. AMAZING!!! - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

We are camping down the road and decided to dine out. We were pleasantly surprised by the huge stuffed calzones!!! Sooooo good! One can be shared by 2+people, they are that big! You won't be disappointed! read more

First time here and they have Really great pizza. Customer service was wonderful Will be coming back soon. read more

Great local friendly pizza joint. Exactly what you expect hat ovens n good smelling cooking. Lunch special is always good, calzones are awesome. I dunno if the still have lasagna but get it if the do. The Greek salad is very Greek n good, garlic knots are drenched in buttery garlic sauce. read more

The pizza was OK, nothing special. The price was high, and I'd much rather order Domino's than pay this much for eh pizza. My son hated the wings, btw, and he hates the place. I think it is expensive, but passable. read more

Whenever I eat pizza I always eat veggie pizza. This place has the absolutely best I have tried. The veggies are fresh, generously portioned and are cut the right size which means they are neither over cooked or undercooked. The sauce doesn't overpower and just enough cheese. I'm impressed!! This is my new favorite pizza place!! Now if only they had garlic rolls. read more

I used to love this place and would recommend it to anyone. Over the last couple years I've noticed that the quality of their food has decreased and the prices keep going up. They're wings are fatty and don't bother paying for extra cheese on your cheese bread because you won't actually get it. The customer service in this place is horrible. The owners are rude and do not care about making their customers happy. I have been giving them second chances but this last time, I got a smirk after pointing out an issue with my order. I doubt I will be back again. read more

Pizza is very greasy and way overpriced. Manager is also very rude. Won't be back again. Other pizza places in the area that are much better. read more