Papa Luigi's in Oldtown is super. The New York style Pizza is outstanding, and the owner has a heart of gold. He consistently does fundraisers and contributes proceeds to families in need. The service is always great and even though it's primarily a take out business, he and his helpers go above and beyond to set a good atmosphere! read more

My first visit at Papa Luigi's pizza . Small place with a couple table . We ordered a 16 inch Margarita Pie and it was very delicious. I love thin crust pizza and enjoyed every bite. Papa Luigi is very friendly and entertaining. read more

Papa Luigi's - Margarita Pie - Pizza Near Me - Old Town, Florida

Amazing people and food. Feels like going home super fun environment thanks to Papa Luigi a staple in Dixie County!

Love the pizza love the owners. Always happy and always on time. Definitely give it a try.

I had the Margherita pizza with thin crust, garlic, and a drizzle of good olive oil--it was absolutely delicious! The flavors were fresh and balanced, and the crust was perfectly crisp. What made the visit even better was the people: Lugi, the owner, was so kind and welcoming, and I really enjoyed our conversation. Dylan, who made our pizza, did a fantastic job--it was cooked to perfection. Great food, great people, and a wonderful atmosphere. read more

Thin crust New York style.. great crust and sauce. Nice People. It's very small inside so plan around that. Definitely best in town .. skip that fast food and give it a try. read more

Stayed in the area for a few days and tried the local Pizza Shop. And yes, if we're in the area again we'll get another pie there.

Great fast service, easy ordering and friendly staff. Miles better than H*ngry H*wie's LOLZ. We'll for sure be making the 30 minute drive to try more menu items. read more

Papa Luigi's - The house special pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Old Town, Florida

We were looking for something local, and you can't get much more local than this place. They are in a run down shopping center near where we camped. I suggest using cash. The prices are really really good compared to chain pizza places. We got the buffalo chicken ranch and cheese pizzas and both were great! They only offer thin crust, which was fine, but some people probably wouldn't like that. The garlic knots were really yummy and only $2. The calzone was pretty dry and cold when it got there. I've had way better. Overall, it was just what we needed after a long day. read more

What a surprise! Was returning from a long trip, late in the evening, and trying to find a place to eat for the family. Stumbled upon this place and what a surprise it was. Don't expect bells and whistles, but if you want some of the best tasting New York-style, thin crust pizza, this is the spot. We even got to spend time talking with Papa Luigi while eating. read more

it seems like every time someone opens a new business in Dixie County or cross city where we live is walking distance only survives for three months, maybe four. read more

Great pizza and food in general. I have eaten various items of there menu and has always been impressed.

Excellent food, good value, friendly service! I also applaud him for his support of Dixie County during past natural disasters!

Great pick up pizza thin cracker crust and nice guy to greet you. Stopped there on trip to Gainesville.

Good pizza! A must have if you find your self in the area! A nice thin crispy crust with fresh ingredients. I ordered the 18" yes I said 18" pepperoni with black olives and mushrooms. The pizza is still crispy even when cooled unlike some that turn into soggy mess. My wife can attest that even cold it was good! The owner is a very charismatic guy with the New York accent! He does come close to that great New York,New Jersey pizza that folks in the south long for but, not quite.. prices are good I highly recommend! read more

Best pizza in Dixie county Papa Luigi makes a great pizza, local businesses with great owner I like the meats pizza and my kids get the cheese and the wings are good so is the salad worth a try if you're anywhere near old town read more

This pizza is amazing. If you are traveling through this is a must stop. Don't let the outside fool you, you will not find better pizza or garlic knots. The owner is also one of the nicest guys you will ever meet and is very active in the local community. read more

Had there pizza many times and always good. Owner is a great guy always having specials going on so take advantage of them One the top pizza places ever been to. There garlic knots are wonderful would recommend ever time. read more

We are always looking for a place to eat in old town. Great pizza is hard to find. This place is fantastic!! The pizza is awesome and so is the lasagna! Garlic rolls are pretty darn good also. Give this place a try you will not be disappointed. read more

My husband grabbed us a large meat lovers and their garlic knots today.... it's was amazing!! Plus the service was super fast and they upgraded us to an xl just because!! Y'all rock! We travel around in our RV and we highly recommend them!!! Thank you! read more

While visiting my mom in Old Town we are always looking for a good pizza joint. This is my favorite place in the area. The owner works alone most of the time. He has always been pleasant to my husband and me! The price is right and he usually gives us a larger pizza or a discount. I will continue to go here as it is my first choice in the area! The place is small and take out only. My mom lives 5 minutes away and it is perfect for us! read more

Wow this pizza was EXCELLENT!!!! Got a white sauce spinach and pepperoni medium came with a thin crust which is my preference!!!! Support a local business, a retired military man who appreciates America!!!! I will definitely be back when in the area for another pizza! read more

The worst 'pizza' I've ever had in my life and I've had many. The crust was like cardboard, no flavor, can't even describe it other than...welp, cardboard. Scraped the toppings off and ended up with a pile of grease. The cheapest grocery store pizza is 1000% better than that mess. A friend of mine bought it as a 'take out' and if I'd been the one who paid for it, I would have taken it back and demanded my money back. I thank the owner for his military service, but maybe he should stick to 'all American' hot dogs instead of pizza. Heh, and here I thought Pizza Hut was the worst. I only rated this place one star because I couldn't post without a 'star' rating. I'd say it's a -10. read more

Great place. I had the special of a BLT pizza and stuffed shells. The pizza was very good. I was in a mood for something different. Exactly as it is named. A BLT on baked pizza dough. Now for the best part. The stuffed shells are beyond delicious. Stuffed full of ricotta cheese in a wonderful red sauce. And the garlic knots were also delicious. read more

Just tried the place for the first time. Asked a simple question, got a loud and obnoxious response. Got my pizza, came home. Took a bite, tasted like there was half a can of morton salt in it. I won't be going back. Felt bad for the girl working there making excuses for his attitude. read more

This place sucks. The pizza was disgusting, greasy and the crust was soggy. There were roaches on the floor. The owner was rude to his employers, and me and was being creepy around my kids, The Owner needs to focus on making pizza instead of making passes at children POS You couldn't pay me to eat at this place again. This place is NOT family friendly. read more