If you're looking for good ANYTHING, especially lobster, go here! The lobster, shellfish, and sandwiches are amazing. If you're debating between a 5 minute drive to someplace closer and Five Island an hour away, go to Five Island. Just go, stop debating. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

The bottom line: The best Maine lobster (and other delicious seafood) as well as unbeatable atmosphere. The deep, cold waters around the five islands create the sweetest and most delicious lobster. The fried clams and oysters are also tremendously fresh and tasty. (I'd opt away from the corn and other useless fillers when there's so much deliciousness to be had.) Sitting on a dock, overlooking the sea-swaying boats and the five islands, the atmosphere also can't be beat. But don't forget a sweatshirt and some bugspray (this is Maine people!). read more

Five Islands Lobster - Twins - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

Just one of the best lobster spots in Maine. Great by boat or car. Great onion rings as well.

Fresh lobster rolls which looked like they just got brought in from the lobster boats nearby, and beautiful views of the water - what more do you need to know?? Go! read more

Five Islands Lobster - Views of the water - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

As we were leaving Reid State Park, I decided to go right instead of left hoping the the road would end at the Sea and we would get some nice views of the coast. We got waaay more than we bargained for at this place! After driving through a small village, the road ended at a dock on a small harbor and on the dock was this place and some picnic tables. There was actually 3 buildings, one for ice cream, one for some fried seafood (including a reasonably priced fried clam basket that looked very tempting) and then the last building featuring live or cooked lobsters, steamers, corn and Cole slaw. And talk about atmosphere! This was a working dock so boats were coming in as we were sitting there taking it all in. I had the steamers-cooked to perfection and very sweet and she had a new shell lobster. For food quality and view, this will be my new go to when people from away come for a visit and you want to show off the best that Maine has to offer! read more

See all

I am actually replying to a previous review by Ada R about an unnannounced closure. Please note the chef/owner died a few days before. Give them a break and remove that negative review. read more

It was a little confusing trying to figure out where to order (they have another building right next to it which is a lobster pound) but once we figured that out we were golden. I got the lobster roll (normal sized) and it was absolutely loaded with meat. If there was any mayo on it, it was undetectable. My companion, balking at the price of seafood (it's been a tough season, I explained) opted for a burger to make up for a disappointing one he'd had the night before. He said it was good and definitely worth the mess, and I could see that it was juicy. All the staff were friendly and it was nice to sit next to the water and eat. We also watched staff from the lobster pound pull crates up from the water-- you don't get lobster fresher than that! read more

This place was one of the highlights of our trip to Maine. Delicious, reasonably priced lobster and lobster rolls. Extremely friendly staff. Bring your own booze. And the views were absolutely spectacular. read more

See all

Five (or ten?) years later, I was just able to return to a truly special place; this beautiful harbor with amazing lobster. It's BYOB, so stop at the small farm stand shop on the right before going down the hill to the dock, where they first turned me on to La Playa Sauvignon Blanc and now it's many cases of that wine later. Great steamers flavorfully cooked in their clean seawater, along with potatoes and corn to compliment your lobster. And the lobster? Right off the boats and the best I've ever had. Another part sells lobster rolls and other cooked items if you're tired of lobster (if that's possible) and a third part sells ice cream if you have any room left. Perfection! read more

Fresh boiled lobsters... didn't try anything else. Really good and the staff were nice.

Worth the drive. Great rolls. Solid fries. Amazing views. No fuss, low key greatness.

Loved this spot!!! It made our day a perfect one. Delicious lobsters (steamed) didn't love the rolls and onion rings. The views are spectacular! read more

My boyfriend and I found Five Islands on a whim. I was really in the mood for some seafood over Memorial Day weekend, and I am pleased to say that I was VERY pleased! My boyfriend's father and I both ordered the regular lobster roll (priced at $15.95 which isn't terrible), his mother ordered the Fish 'n Chips, and Jared had the Fried Scallop basket with Onion Rings. The lobster roll was delicious. Very lightly dressed in mayo (which I prefer) and on a traditional hot dog bun with a large lettuce leaf. I would have preferred to have a most toasted bun, to give the sandwich some good crunch, but overall I was very happy. I was told the Fish & Chips were fried to perfection and that it was also quite flavorful. The scallops were delicious, as were the onion rings. I had never had fried scallops, and so I managed to steal one from Jared's plate and was so surprised as to how much I enjoyed them! I'm excited to make some scallops of my own now :D The seating is all outdoors, so in the summer be ready to wear some sunscreen. It can get pretty toasty, I'm sure. There's a few tables under a smaller awning-type area on the wharf, so look out for any available spots there! Overall, I'm very happy with Five Islands. I'd definitely be up for going again. (: read more

Some of the best lobster I had while in Maine. Big boy roll was nicely toasted with enough butter, not overpowering. A fantastic roll. Lobster in the shell was sweet and tasty. Can't beat it. Corn and potatoes are standard. Unfortunately we had planned to go a second time when they had a full menu but they actually closed. Not sure if it was weather related or staff related but Red's was open during the same time. I thought the roll tasted a little better than Red's but the price is much steeper. Because it's in a more remote location, I hear they have a harder time finding help so the prices seem to reflect that. Otherwise, if I'm in the area I would definitely go back. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Eat it before it eats me. - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

We ordered steamed lobsters. They were fresh and perfect. We ate at a picnic table, overlooking a working wharf, on a perfect day. The lobsters were reasonably priced, and were cooked in no time flat. This is a byob place, and some of the other guests brought coolers with drinks. It looked like they planned to stay for a bit, and enjoy the food, the weather, and the view. When we return next year, we'll follow their excellent example! read more

Five Islands Lobster - The view from the wharf. - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

Great lobster roll - just a hint of mayo and piled high. I did pull out the piece of lettuce - but others said it was fine. Very good fries. Also got the fried clams - and they were some of the best I've had. Actually better than Sea Basket - which had been my mid coast standard. read more

An unrealistically realistically rustic dining experience-- Five Islands Lobster Co indulges its patrons' dream of eating seafood in what feels like a picture perfect New England train set (except, er, boat set because it's a dock and the water and lack of trains). Rounding the corner, through the rambling hills and woods, you come upon a cluster of red houses on an ageless dock. Seagulls and terns laugh in the distance (and from inside the trash cans) while people from all walks of life crack into steaming red lobsters and clams. The joyful sound of lobster boats bubbling into the harbor is rivaled only by the pleasurable screams of grubby children running after dogs while holding their dripping ice cream cones. It's almost enough to make you believe in that rural serenity you knew in your innermost thoughts simply must exist outside of storybooks......... Real talk tho- the place looks like a postcard, can be a little on the expensive side because of it but the lobster is mad tasty so whatevs. read more

I love Maine. What I love even more, is a relaxing and fun road trip with friends and lobster. Lotsa lobsta. Having just returned from a weekend getaway to Vacationland, or what I now know as summer camp, I'm thinking of making another trip back in the Fall. For the time being, let's start at the beginning. We had grand plans to go to the Maine Lobsterfest in Rockland; but while planning for our gastro road trip, we found so many other wonderful places to eat lobster as well. Thus began our very own Maine Lobster Roll Tasting. Lobster Roll #1: 5 Islands Lobster Co., $16/lobster roll - Light on the mayo - One slice of lettuce - Buttered, toasted white roll - Super fresh lobster, right from the dock; portion was decent - Ruffles potato chips on the side Overall rating: 4 lobster claws for the big chunks of fresh lobster They skimped on the lettuce, were light on the mayo, and the lobster portion was decent but not as generous as we'd hoped. For me, however, it was just enough lettuce and just enough mayo. Why deprive your taste buds of the good stuff? First bite of lobster + sitting on the dock playing travel Scrabble + views of "the prettiest harbour" in Maine, we were happy as a clam times 4. We also ordered a half pint of clam steamers ($8), served with clam brine and butter. Salty, but salty in the best way possible. It will be difficult to find steamers as fresh as these, that's for sure. One lobster roll down. read more

Five Islands Lobster - half pint of clam steamers, ($8) - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

My favorite lobster place in the mid-coast. It sits on a super charming spot at the tip of Georgetown. Even though we were there for an early dinner at 5pm, they already ran out of the 2lb+ lobsters. We settled for the next biggest size lobsters and they were still quite big and meaty. The order process very super efficient and the only lobster pound in the area we tried that actually bring your food to the tables outside. We also tried the fried scallops and they were fried to perfection with super light breading. The only drawback is that they didn't have any desserts, there was an ice cream place in the property but it wasn't open at the time. Overall, love the ambiance, the friendliness of the staff and the delicious food. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Fried Scallops - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

If there is such a thing as 5-star dining on a picnic table, with disposable utensils, THIS is it!!! The steamed lobster went from frolicking with friends, to my plate in 15 minutes. I chose the "soft shell" variety for sweetness & ease of eating. Sides of corn, coleslaw & onion rings from the adjoining "fried" stand completed the quintessential Maine experience. Everything about the dinner was amazing and the view was off the charts! The only way the experience could have been more perfect, was if I'd paid more attention to earlier reviews and packed a tablecloth and bottle of wine. Next time!!! read more

The food was okay. I would call it pretty regular. The chowder, the lobster, the lobster rolls - pretty standard stuff. You can get this almost anywhere. No bathrooms with running water. Only port a potties and salt water sinks. Depending on the time a year you go that water is unbearably cold. Pro-tip: on the way in there is an inconspicuous shop on the right hand side. STOP there before stopping here. You can pick up beer and wine for your lobster meal. Otherwise, it's soda or water. read more

Why does Lobster taste so much better in Maine than in NYC? The lobsters here were cooked to sweet perfection and the locally grown yellow corn was superbly crisp and juicy. Both were cooked in the exact same seawater from which the lobster was extracted. I also enjoyed a basket of fried clams and fries. The homemade tartar sauce was a perfect complement. The clams could have stayed in the fryer another minute or two, but this is only a minor complaint. I hightly recommend sailing here (although it's accessible by car). It's a pretty little working harbor with a lot of character. read more

Great, fresh seafood!! Lobster rolls were amazing and the pier is very scenic! Would recommend!

Very good food. On a sunny day the views are great. I had lobster which had plenty of meat. Wife had lobster roll and that also had plenty meat. read more

Scenery - can't get better Service - lobster shack ladies Lobster Roll - 5 star 5 star 5 star The best no-butter no-mayo sweet meat lobstah roll yet! It was so good I bought a hat! read more

See all

Tourist trap...Check. Overpriced Lobster Roll...Check. Haddock Sandwich...Check. Fried (everything) seafood...Check. Amazing views...Check. Double Check. Yeah I'll be back...do yourself one favor tho...don't order the burger. It's horrible! Literally McD's is better. Its really bad! It's all kids working there, so the food is only going to be marginal at best. Stick to the lobster and the grilled haddock and you'll be fine. read more

Eating here is the quintessential experience of what one dreams of when they imagine eating lobster in Maine. It is what memories of Maine are made of. Dining on a remote and breathtakingly picturesque waterside dock, where real lobsterman bring in their harvest and where diners enjoy the freshest lobster imaginable. It's not exactly what I'd call a "restaurant", because the experience here is picking out your live lobster from a tank (along with corn, coleslaw, fries, etc.) and eating it at one of the adjacent picnic tables, in the fresh ocean air, watching the boats, birds, sunset... This is Maine at its best. read more

See all

For fresh lobster and clams (with grit and all lol), eating in the outdoor dining area on a dock to get a good feel of what Maine is about, this SMALL and quaint place may be ideal... it's definitely nothing fancy but it's a local dive experience. The only thing I will criticize is the chowder...It was pretty tasteless and watery. However I did go during the first week of Oct when they were closung the season so there's no telling if it was the timeframe or if their chowder is always like that. And for a local joint with an abundance of their primary Staple, it was pretty pricey read more

See all

Amazing views, no frills lobster place. You line up to order food (they take cash and credit cards) and when it's your turn they put your lobster in a plastic bucket to be weighed. Our lobster was very lively! After your food is cooked they call your name and you can bring your food to one of many picnic tables (both open and covered options). The prices were very reasonable and everything was delicious. Their hours and offerings do vary as the season winds down (we were there in late August) so you should call to check before heading down. We were there on a Friday night and they were opened until 7 pm and had a limited menu of lobsters, lobster rolls, steamers and sides. The line was about 30 minutes and they did stay open pasts 7 to make sure everyone in line was served. read more

See all

I was kind of disappointed with Five Islands. I thought Red's Eats was a better. The piece of green that they added to the lobster roll didn't do much. The lobster was fresh, as is most lobster pounds/shacks, but the quantity was average. I know the sides usually aren't the main selling point, but they could do away with the chips with the lobster rolls. A coleslaw or something would've been better. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

In May, they were only open two days a week (Sat. and Sun.), but it's best to call before you go anyways. It was closed when we got there the first time on Wednesday, but at least we got a good view of the five islands surrounding the restaurant. We returned on Sunday, and tried the lobster rolls with fries. The fries were great, and they had a good selection of ketchup (and other sauces). However, the lobster roll at ~$17 was absolutely phenomenal. They serve it cold together with a piece of lettuce in a warm, toasted bun. The portion isn't large, but filling enough. The lobster seemed to have some sauce on it, but I wasn't able to figure out what it was, but it went quite well. The toasted bun had a crisp that went well with the soft lobster, and the crunchy lettuce also added to this meal. My mouth is literally watering as I type this. They also have many other items on the menu (onion rings and burgers) which other people seemed to also enjoy as well. (5/5) read more

Five Islands Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

My fiancée and I had lobster rolls, chips and homemade onion rings. All of which were tasty and fresh. The lobster rolls are loaded with so much lobster! Yum! We also had a 1-1/2 pound live cooked lobster and it was absolutely delicious. Seating is outside and the scenery is beautiful! There is a seating area that's covered, so even if it's raining, you're good. Also, the staff is impressively efficient at keeping the seagulls away. I highly recommend this place!! read more

See all

I arrived at Five Islands right as a large tour bus group was getting off the bus. At first I thought I would waiting in line forever; however, the sandwich line moved ridiculously fast and the orders came out quick. The lobster roll was delicious and the lobster meat tasted so fresh. My wife and I each ordered 1.25 lb lobsters, which were just as good. In addition to eating great tasting lobster, eating on the water and enjoying the view was exactly how I imagined my first trip to a lobster shack. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

We have never been here before, but a friend in Florida recommended it to us. The drive up there was delightful, lots to see. The food when you get there is outstanding. We did twin lobsters, and they were fresh and sweet! The fried food looked awesome, But we were too full to try any of it. If you like onion rings, this would be worth the drive. The fried clams also look delicious. Well worth the time to visit the spot. Bring your own beer, or even a bottle of wine to have with your dinner. They don't serve alcohol there. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

We went for lunch on Friday, 14 Jun 2019. Yelp says is opens at 11:30am, we waited for a while, then we asked, they are closed today. They were getting ready for tomorrow. Please correct your schedule. Very disappointed, coming from MA on the way to Boothbay. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Beautiful area. - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

Absolutely amazing, spectacular setting. Make a pilgrimage if you are anywhere near this place. The food was great. Were they the best fried clams I've ever had, no, but they were great. Were they the best onion rings I've ever had, no, but they were great. The only seating is outside, so go on a nice day. Note that you can get coleslaw, red potatoes and/or corn in the lobster building to go with anything you get in the fried/grilled/lobster roll building. I missed this fact and ended up with only onion rings and French fries to go with my fried clams. Bring your own alcohol, and wet wipes (only restroom is a porta potty). read more

Five islands lobster co is the ultimate lobster meal venue. They offer picnic bench style outdoor seating right on the waterfront where are you can watch the boats going by as you wait for your fresh lobster to be prepared. (Or you can take it to go) When selecting your lobster is done right in front of you with the option to choose what you want to eat by weight of the lobster. The food is so fresh and delicious. There is also space to order other things such as sandwiches and ice cream on the same pier area. This is the meal we most look forward to when we are all in the area. You can also order things such as a side of corn or potato with your lobster. They do have tools to crack the lobster and get the meat as well as butter to dip your lobster in for flavor. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Yum - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

Absolutely the best freshest lobstah in maine. Very scenic too. The jennie sandwich is wonderful. Nice ride out there too read more

Don't have Lobster in Portland, it is worth the short drive to Five Island Lobster. What a wonderful gem! The staff is great, friendly and helpful. The Lobster is fabulous. The atmosphere is exactly where you want to be when eating Lobster! read more

See all

The Lobster rolls were great and the view from the patio was really nice. We were disappointed that they'd run out of onion rings before we got there, but also understood how time-intensive they are to make. The wait wasn't as bad as we'd feared when we first got in line...things move right along. This isn't fancy but it's definitely tasty! read more