Our annual Maine vacation was underway! We made plans to stop in Boothbay for a a few days before heading to Northern Maine. So our dinner stop before heading to Boothbay was Five Islands Lobster. We arrived around 4pm, just before a dinner rush. Parking is tight, but you make do. I was able to find a spot to accommodate my care and the small packing trailer on the hitch. Once we were parked we made our way to the buildings. The one building you order your lobster, another building you order other items. It was a very easy and simple process. Between all of us there was so much lobster and other fine dining options. The lobster was fresh and sweet. It was very delicious. The lobster came with corn and potatoes. The butter was perfect! It had that foaming too I love! My husband enjoyed his fried haddock sandwich and the fried scallops. He raved about the fried scallops. The staff were great. They were kind, helpful and hard working. The view was stunning. I saw a loon and was able to adventure on the rocks during low tide. Overall this was a beautiful spot to start our Maine vacation. I highly recommend checking out Five Islands Lobster read more

See all

Five Islands Lobster is a must when visiting Maine. We made our way up from Massachusetts and we were not disappointed after passing other stands along the way. We ordered 2 2lb lobsters, onion rings, and fried oysters. The lobster meat came right out of the shell (shout out to some man on the dock who helped us Marylanders with some verbal direction) and were full and flavorful! We are big crab eaters but it takes about 6 or more XL crabs to feel as full as we did with one lobster! The onion rings and oysters were perfectly fried and just as delicious. The oysters came with fries (which explains the ketchup) as well and all were large portions. It was the perfect location too! Not noisy, beautiful scenery, and just all around a great atmosphere. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Lobsters, onion rings, fried oysters with fries. - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

Sitting on The prettiest harbor in Maine in an unspoiled fishing village. Featuring fresh caught local lobster (sold by the pound). The waters are the coldest and deepest on the coast making delicious lobsters. They also have local dug clams, corn on the cob all cooked together giving it a delicious flavor. The fried onion rings are very good and large enough to share. The lobster rolls are delicious but the steamed lobsters are the best you can buy. We had 2 twin lobsters (1.25 lbs each) and corn on the cob for $30. You place your order at the Lobster hut (or other seafood and non seafood items at the Love Shack) and find a table on the docks. You can bring your own wine or beer. The water front view is breathtaking. Hands down the best lobster shack anywhere. Don't forget to get some ice cream before you leave. I had Wild Maine Blueberry and it was SO good!! Note... warning !! the only restrooms are 3 porta-John's and not very clean when we were there. read more

See all

I make a yearly week-long pilgrimage to Maine for my personal Lobsterfest, and always spend a night at Five Islands. It is the quintessential Maine lobster shack. The gorgeous setting on the rugged coastline, a wonderful view of the harbor while you enjoy your meal, college kids who are pleasant and hard working to make and serve your meal(be generous when you tip!), and of course the delicious food. You pay for your lobster by the pound, (mine last night was 2.7), and I ordered it from the lobster shack with a pound of steamers, potatoes and corn. More food than I usually eat, but hey, it's my week to indulge. You eat dockside at long picnic tables, and get to meet and enjoy the company of really nice people with the same passion for great food. Just a wonderful culinary experience, one which I will enjoy every year until I can't. read more

See all

Not our first time here and we had a lobster roll, the whole belly clams with fries and of course our favorite the onion rings! ALL of it was delicious and we can't wait for our next time Keep up the good work and cooking! read more

A great little example of quintessential Maine! The food was outstanding and the setting perfect. read more

See all

So this place was highly recommended by our Airbnb hosts and we thought let's go. It was at least an hour or longer for us to drive here. When we showed up there was a slow moving line to get I. The door to order. The weather was showing impending doom but we were not deterred. I have had quite a few lobsters in my life but this goes down as some of the largest ones I've ever eaten. You order your lobster by relative poundage and the. They get them and weight them to figure out your total. Everything except for butter is an extra. We ordered 3 2+ lb lobsters and one 1.5 lb lobster. Mine was huge and man the shell was so thick you could not even break it with crackers and we had to beg the staff to bring out something industrial and then it was even a challenge. It was amazing as these come pretty much straight off the boat to table. We just finished as the storms came crashing down. This is due. And sorry ambiance but well worth it b read more

See all

The views and food makes you looking up real-estate websites for homes. Lobster, ocean breeze and unending views. Best meal I've had in 2025. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

Beautiful little spot to sit outside by the harbor and eat fresh-caught lobster. Our friend's parents took us here for dinner, and the wait was looong. But eventually we got our food. It was my first time have lobster, but it wasn't bad at all! And everybody else at the table loves it. I'm afraid I'm just not very used to it, but I think it's definitely worth trying if you're in Maine! The fries on the side and onion rings were delicious. My friend also had a hamburger which was yum! We got ice cream after and it was sooo good. You gotta get a scoop of cannoli ice cream. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Lobster roll with fries - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

Five Islands is my favorite lobster place in Maine, and that's saying a lot. All the way at the end of the road, Five Islands sports tons of outside picnic tables with a great view of the local harbor where the lobstermen pull right up at the dock next to you to bring up their crates. Everything is takeout. There's an eatery will extensive menu including lobster rolls, clams, haddock sandwiches, fish&chips, even a burger. If you just want lobster, order by the lb right next door- best prices anywhere, and you can watch as they pick out your lobster and cook it 4 u. Ice cream shack serves desert! read more

The seafood is as fresh as it can get. If you are looking for clams, lobster, haddock, salmon...this is the place. The service is self-serve, place your order and wait for your number. Seating is first come, first serve with stunning ocean views. A lot of tourist traps around...this isn't one of those. BYOB with alcohol or other drinks. Soft drinks in bottles available. Snack shack has fried seafood, lobster shack also has steamers, Potatoes and boiled corn. They also have an I've cream shack if you have room left after the feast for something sweet. Whether you are a local or "from away"...don't miss this place! read more

** Card accepted for the Food ** ** Cash Only at the Icecream Shack ** I came here on the Saturday after Labor Day. We were on an excursion in Boothbay and HAD TO stop by here before heading back in to Boston for some lobster recommended by our friend. We arrived around 5:30pm just 30minutes before closing. There was a line and we were able to get our order in by 5:53pm (cutting it close I know!). Plenty of seating outdoors with a beautiful view of the water and the islands. It got a little spooky when the fog started coming in from the ocean. Since it was an overcast day and close to sun set the sandflies were out and huge - I was in shorts but thankfully I wasn't bitten which is shocking because I'm usually a target. We ordered from the red shack and got the lobster rolls served with Ruffles plain chips, corn, slaw as well as a haddock chowder and a new shell lobster to share. The cashier will bring out a lobster and weigh it on the scale in front of you. They take about 15-20minutes to have your order ready. By far some of the freshest lobster I've ever had. The whole lobster is boiled in salted water - I'm not sure if a lot of places do this or not but it was new to me. read more

We stopped here at the recommendation of a friend and absolutely loved our experience! It's post-Labor Day so only the Lobster shack was open, but that was what we were here for. The line was daunting but it moved fast. Trust the process! Lobsters aren't any fresher than what you get here. There are picnic tables spread out in various areas for you to sit and enjoy your meal. It is one of the most peaceful settings I have experienced. They also have an ice cream shack serving Gifford brand ice cream. Portions are GENEROUS but the ice cream shack is cash only. Super friendly workers. Highly recommend! read more

See all

I had the somewhat unusual experience of going here as a non-seafood eater. It's a charming little shack with lots of seafood items and a few non-seafood, with lots of tables outside on the dock so you sit right by the water. I went with my friend on a gorgeous Sunday at noon and the line was pretty long but moved quickly. I'd say we stood in line for about 15 minutes and waited another 10 or so for our orders to be called. We managed to find a place to sit for the two of us but it would have been difficult with a bigger group. I ordered the veggie burger and split onion rings with my friend. The veggie burger was ok - the patty itself seemed to be rice-based and was rather flavorless, but I'm not surprised that vegetarian food isn't their forte. It came with chips, though I could have upgraded to fries for $2. The onion rings were amazing - perfectly crispy with a flavorful batter. It was definitely worth the visit for the ambiance and the onion rings, even if the veggie burger was a little lacking. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Veggie burger with lettuce, pickles, and mustard - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

I have been coming to Five Islands since 2008 and I think the quality was not what I expected at this visit. I just do not believe you are getting a premium lobster roll for the price anymore. The service is counter service and it was fine. The tables have a spectacular view and you might enjoy it just to eat seafood in suck a lovely location. But I can get better lobster rolls at other places. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Lobster Shack - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

Beautiful view, clams were great. Fried haddock sandwich was flimsy, and could have used more dredging, before fry. Onion rings were doughy and slightly undercooked in spots(would not order again). I prefer the lighter crunchy fry shack style, which is available at many NE summer spots. The French fries seemed shack made and were better than average, they come with the clams. Would definitely order the clams again, but would forgo the other items and get twin lobsters etc from the steamer hut. We saw a couple people with cans of beer but didn't find anywhere to purchase. Not sure if it's legal to bring your own? That's definitely a question I have before we go back. There are picnic tables all around. I brought water and soda from our car. There is no proper bathroom to wash your hands. So you may want to bring wet wipes if things are messy. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Fried whole belly clams, fried haddock sandwich, and onion rings - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

Worth the drive. There was a line when we got there, but it was moving. It's a beautiful scenery while enjoying your meal. Most of all, the best tasting lobsters I have tried in my life! The lobsters in Portland is amazing! But boy these were sweet, juicy and amazingly fresh! The clams and corn were next level. It's a must visit! read more

See all

We finally found the Five Islands Lobster Pound and it is a beautiful place to spend a Maine dinner! Let me start with the most obvious thing about Five Islands Lobster Pound - THE SETTING IS GORGEOUS!!! The surrounding water, the actual 5 islands, the quaint boats gently bobbing in the tidewater around us - all conspire to create a quintessential Maine location that cannot be outdone anywhere! The restaurant itself is very rustic. It is outside - you sit on park benches to eat. You peepee in porta-potties and there is no soap to wash your hands. So, please be prepared for all of this. You have to understand that you are walking back into time about a generation. There simply are very few places left in the world like Five Islands. That is part of the charm! If you want a place that reminds you of the very best of Maine, this is it! There are 3 shacks on the pier: (1) for handheld sandwiches and tshirts; and (2) one for full lobster meals; and (3) one for ice cream. You might want to have someone in your party go sit at a table because it will be crowded. We were there on a cool July day (I cannot even imagine how the words "cool" and "July" go together but they do in Georgetown Maine. So be sure to take a light jacket. Plus you are surrounded by ocean on 3 sides so there will always be a nice cool breeze. We got the haddock chowder, the haddock sandwich, full lobster meal, hamburger (not recommended) and onion rings. All delicious and all so big that it will be a challenge to finish them. I do not recommend the hamburger here; it was clearly a pre-formed patty that was probably purchased that way. But, seriously, why in the heck are you going to a place called "Five Island Lobster Pound" for a hamburger??? That judgement must be questioned to begin with. Whatever - the seafood is fresh, plentiful and you can see it on the boats that surround the lobster pound. This place is the real deal! You place your order and then you wait for them to call your order number. This is the hard part! The picnic tables are far away from the food so it is hard to hear them. But, again, that does not change my opinion of this place. Indeed, it's all part of the charm! I recommend Five Islands Lobster Pound for anyone visiting Maine who wants a great seafood meal!!! read more

Best lobster roll we had in Coastal Maine, hands-down. 'nuff said. Gorgeous views to boot. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Sorry about the half-eaten roll. ;) - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

Delicious lobsters straight off the boat onto your plate. Outdoor eating only which offered an amazing view of the coastline. Friendly locals served up everything fresh and quick. It was exactly the Maine lobster experience I came looking for and so much more. read more

See all

Fun authentic lobster joint on the docks. Order fresh seafood, lobsters, even steak and cheese. We ordered a clam cake sandwich, scallops and onion rings. The onion rings were just ok for me, but it was just a personal preference. Heavy batter .. I'd go back in a heartbeat! read more

See all

This place has really grown on me over the years of visiting. The scallops are really good (lightly fried) and I finally tried the big boy lobster roll (a bit pricey but it's HUGE and has .5 lb meat). I even got a really soft hoodie this time. Definitely splurged this year but it was worth it. Ice cream is good as usual though I think the portion sizes shrunk. We also bought some cooked soft shell lobsters to bring back to NJ, and the price wasn't too bad. Prices have been steadily going up every year (everywhere, not just here). read more

See all

Super cute spot. Lots of seating on the dock. Came on their last day so menu was limited. Got a roll and a pound of steamers. Everything was solid. Staff super friendly. Plenty of parking. read more

Went here around 3pm today and it did not disappoint. We got fried whole belly clams to share and they were delicious. We also got grilled haddock sandwiches and I highly recommend the mustard dill with it, it was also delicious. Seafood is fresh and made well here, I would love to come back. The service was fast and friendly and there is lots of nice outdoor seating. Definitely come here on a nice day, the view is beautiful. read more

See all

The absolute best place in Maine for lobster AND onion rings! I've been coming here for since I was a kid and it's remained stellar food and experience. With plenty of outdoor picnic tables overlooking the water and Maine islands, this lobster shack is perfect for a messy family dinner or a nice meal off the boat. Make sure to stop by the ice cream shed after your meal for a sweet treat! You can even enjoy a short stroll down the road to the gift shop. Quick notes: - Lobster and onion rings are a MUST. The fried clams are amazing too. - Guy Fieri has been here for his show even! - get there early for onion rings because they do tend to sell out :) - soft shell lobster is sweeter than hard shell - get your lobster in the red lobster shack. All other food like fish and chips are in the snack shack. - parking at the pier or up the road a little bit by the pond - very dog friendly read more

See all

If you are looking for a fresh farm to table experience, look no further than Five Islands Lobster! It is a bit out of the way, but extremely worth it. There are serval shacks when you pull up, so it is important to know if you are looking for freshly steamed lobster and clams, or if you are looking for a lobster roll and chowder. Ultimately we had to get both! While in Maine, might as well gorge yourself on fresh caught lobster . The lobster is so fresh, that the fishermen pull up their boat and sell their freshly caught lobster right at the dock next to the restaurant. The red shack is where you will order fresh lobster by the pound, specials such as clams or any catch of the day. We got the twin lobster special, which are 2 identical lobsters for $24!! Your order is not called by a number or your name, but by the boat that caught the lobsters you are about to feast on! The grey shack is where the grilled items and lobster rolls are served. We thought... go big or go home. So, we both got the Big Boy Lobster Roll, which was complete unnecessary but well worth it. This footlong lobster roll was so fresh and the lobster so sweet, it was delightful. We also got the clam chowder or course, which complimented the rolls nicely. All of the tables are outside with amazing view of the Maine waters. It is hard to explain how picturesque this area is. You just have to come see it and eat it to believe it. Make your way to Five Island Lobster. I guarantee you it is worth it. read more

See all

Not worth the extra drive. The food was average at best and the lobster roll is over priced at $61.

Location is quite impressive. Seafood choices are very fresh. You can get fresh lobster (cooked or take home) right from the water. My family got the lobster roll, homemade onion rings, and Jenny's special (with the mustard dill sauce, which was packed with great flavor). I'm not a big fan of food from the ocean, but that lobster roll may have changed my mind. Staff is friendly and helpful. Views from the deck are impressive. read more

Five Islands Lobster - Menu board (as of June 26, 2024) - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

Cheap ingredients, with expensive prices. Steamed lobster: The butter tastes like it's diluted with Whirl. An artificial butter substitute. The Haddock Chowder had no flavor other than "butter" a hint of cream but mostly tasted like milk. They are 100% NOT using a fish stick or base. Onion rings. Though they are freshly made, no effort was made to keep them from being a giant inedible hunk of onion in a batter pile. It's all hype and they do not deliver. No bathroom, no running water. Not even Heinz ketchup. Not the name brand crackers for the soup. Definitely cutting corners. read more

See all

Thay dont bee opening in tha winters time. But I stillbee thinkin thay tha bestest places to get lobsters and also fish sandwiches. Thay make tha best oniun rings too. My mar like to bee going thare because she grew up near tha waters. Since she been havin tha allzhammers diseases it makes her bee happey to be goung to places like that. And I got hit on my head along times ago, but I can still be driving her around. Tha people who work thaere are always beein nice to everrey body. Not just us. I all ways bee leaving good tip. Cause not everrey where's is this nice to people like me. I tell everrey one to be going there when thay be open. In tha winter times I bee saving up my money so I can take mar and me their everrey week. Thanks you. read more

Amazing prices for the twin lobster special would 100 percent recommend vetoing the twin lobster special. Great taste and great view of the water. You can see them make and prepare and catch the lobster. Food came fast and great. Great service read more

Awesome lobster place in Georgetown. Lobster roll was the best evah. The lobster boats come and unload their catch right on the dock in front of you, one right after another. There was a boat that caught a huge tuna and was unloading it onto a truck. This is the real deal and the real maine. Prices are very good. They have a menu board that changes daily. Sandwiches, fish, lobster etc. Lobster dinners steamed. Great staff. Fun place. Nothing fancy at all, picnic tables to eat at, port o potties for bathrooms. Clean though. Rocks to climb on. Large docks with scenic views. The best. read more

Pretty darned good boiled seabug! It's a tourist thing, but it's fun and pleasant. Maybe not for the lobstah, sure they'd prefer to not be boiled to death and eaten. But for the humans it's fun and tasty. read more

First off, you won't find a better view, no matter the price you spend on lunch. The haddock portions aren't huge, but big enough to be filling. My daughter got the chicken fingers, which WAS a huge portion for the price! It was all very tasty. The kids working the counter were all very friendly, and we watched the waterman carry a fresh catch up the dock. Can't get better quality than that! read more

Best lobster roll as well as least expensive I have found Outdoor setting with view of fishing boats Friendly staff despite their busyness read more

Five Islands Lobster - Boats in cove - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

Absolutely the perfect Maine spot to have a lobster roll, amazing onion rings and amazing time with your family! The regular lobster roll has the perfect amount of fresh Maine lobster. We prefer it with just some good melted butter to taste the sweet taste lobster has. The onion rings are my absolute favorite and you get a lot of them!! The fish and chips is a perfect filling meal. We will be back for sure!! read more

See all

GEORGETOWN, ME / LOBSTER, SEAFOOD / 08-12-21 / LUNCH +Fresh Maine lobsters and amazing view! +Get the new shell (soft shell) lobster, it's sweeter and more tender than hard shell. +The steamed clams are excellent; they give you a broth to dip them in. +The view alone is four stars. +Grab a bottle of Moxie, order a couple boiled lobsters and chow down in the cool breeze at one of the picnic tables. +The pricing is great. I noticed a lot of locals coming by to buy their lobsters, as well. This is a must-visit if you're on a Maine food tour! read more

See all

The freshest lobster in New England. Go there for the best lobster rolls and an authentic experience of getting lobster fresh from the fisherman. Don't go when it's raining as there are no indoor seating spots. read more

See all

Generous portions of lobster on the lobster roll, for the price it's pretty good. There is a larger seating area and a smaller seating (4-5 double benches) area off to the side. We came around 5:30-6pm, and there was a moderately long wait on line and some time to wait and find seats. Many tourists on the line too. Overall, it was very calming and relaxing to eat our delicious lobster rolls with such a great calming view! read more

Five Islands Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Georgetown, Maine

See all

Cheap ingredients, overpriced, mediocre service, small portions, weird customer attitudes. This is a supposed hidden gem, but Down East Magazine took care of that. Let's start with the drive. It's in the middle of a neighborhood on the water. The locals will practically push you off the road for traveling the speed limit. Once there, good luck with parking. Going there during low tide is NOT recommended. However, the view is picturesque. Being burned out on fried fast sea food, I thought I'd try the steak and cheese. It's a chopped hamburger and certainly not steak and it was $11. The lobster roll is lump meat and $25 for 4oz of lobster. It comes with a very small side of frozen fries. There are better lobster rolls in much more accessible areas. Fish and chips is $18 and you get one piece of fish. There seemed to be an inordinate amount of people posturing and making sure people overheard their conversations. If you want to brag and show off, go to Coachella. I can't forget the screaming. They don't just announce the names, they scream them repeatedly at the top of their lungs. I don't know if it's a gimmick or if the average customer is that aloof. Overall, it's a tourist trap with attitudes. You'd be better served heading north to Wiscasset and waiting at Red's Eats. read more