One of my favorite bakeries I look forward to going to when I visit Anchorage. The variety of pastries breads, soups and sandwich they have always look mouthwatering. It's just a cute place to vibe at and be around the community.There is a coffee shop, plant shop, juice shop and small market in the same building which makes it worth the stop. The seasonal ginger bread chia tea from the coffee shop is like Christmas in your mouth. The turkey sandwich is like thanksgiving with cranberry sauce and pecans. The sweet potato burban cupcake was actually to die for. The cake was moist with a carm filling of pecans and bourbon topped with a light cream cheese frosting. I'm never disappointed with fire island. A jem in anchorage. read more

See all

- breakfast focaccia with sausage: a bit on the bland side, it's missing something. Maybe a pesto or red pepper sauce. The sausage was good though, and a bit salty, which might have balanced the seasoning in this item but the chunks were too few and big to be balanced. - messy egg salad sandwich: a lot of dill, heavy on the pickled flavor, and good red onion crunch. This was just ok. It looked better than it tasted, unless you're a fan of dill. Mainly got this sandwich to try their bread but the bread was an afterthought. - maple rhubarb muffin: hard pass. Can't taste the rhubarb and barely any maple. The bottom also was more burnt than anything. It seems they may have over mixed their batter, muffin didn't have a tender crumb. read more

See all

This place was wonderful! I definitely recommend coming here if you're in town, delicious breakfast sandwiches and great hospitality! My partner and I ordered the breakfast sandwich and it was phenomenal! Even though it was cold, it was still great, I think you can ask them to warm it up but we took it as it is. We came around 10am? It was my favorite item from this bakery. The sausage isn't your typical McDonalds or fast food premade patty (which I cannot stand), I'm pretty sure they make this in house. The sausage was peppery (black pepper) and savory, highly recommend this! The holiday turkey sandwich was okay, it wasn't terrible but it wasn't WOW! I felt like the flavors were all over the place. This was not a good balance between flavors and I just didn't think it worked well together. I think it was too much cranberry sauce that just overpowered everything. If you want to get this and try it, you better love cranberry. BUT it is aesthetically pleasing. The roast beef sandwich was much better in my opinion compared to the turkey. The pickled onions gave it a nice crisp crunch and acidity that I really enjoyed. Everything worked well together and the flavors didn't fight against one another. I'd definitely would get this again! ( the breakfast sandwich was so good we came back twice during our visit) read more

See all

It's fine.... A Toyota Camry is also fine. Focaccia is pretty bland. Not a Berkeley Cheeseboard, or White Salmon Bakery experience. More of a good "Safeway" bakery. Clean, and friendly staff. Not cheap, but not ridiculous either. Probably won't come back unless I'm in a pinch. read more

A must stop if you're visiting in Anchorage!! The shop is very quaint & offers a lot different variety of bakery, breakfast, & lunch options. Everything is made from scratch & you can tell. The shop is also very cool because there are other business connected into the building. Was so good we went back twice! read more

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

Great looking and great tasting croissants! Fantastic bread sold too. Wish I can try all of it. So far, we have tried the scones, muffins and croissants. Will be back while we are still here in Anchorage. Service is quick. Lots of crew to help customers. read more

See all

Scones were delicious and coffees were really good. Love the rustic ambiance and the counter is in front of the bakery kitchen. You can see the goods coming out of the oven. Service is from a counter, fast and had enough people. We didn't get to try the sandwiches because it was a Monday and Tuesday. But we'll be back for sure. read more

See all

Great place to grab a morning treat! Popped in here to grab a few pastries before road tripping from Anchorage. What a great decision! The birdseed bars were great for travel and the muffins were delicious! Everything was very reasonably priced and happy to support a local bake shop. If you're in the area and looking for some treats, try Fire Island Bakeshop. Enjoy! read more

See all

This place was overall great! I was about to give 4 starts because of how incredibly busy this place was + the anxiety of not being able to find a table to sit! (seat yourself place but we did end up snagging a table last minute!) BUT that is not the businesses fault and actually is a testament to how good the place is! This is NOT a quick pit stop place though, you will wait in line for a good amount of time if you come but I would say it's worth it. The sandwiches we got were pretty good and the worker I interacted with was very nice and gave a great recommendation since what we originally wanted was sold out. I got the ham and swiss sandwich which was perfect and the peruvian chicken sandwich was full of flavor! Since it is a little marketplace, just note that you do buy the food and drinks in separate areas. I don't think that is a big deal just something to note since you'll have to wait in two seperate lines! The atmosphere is cute and cozy and has plenty of natural light which is nice! And for how busy it was, I don't' recall it being overly loud in there! If you are looking for a cute place to check out in the area, I would check this place out! Plus, look how pretty the coffee cups are!!! read more

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

See all

Real ones know... THIS is the spot. I've seldom visited a bake shop that is Fire Island's equal, much less anywhere as good. I never had a bad dessert here and the breads are out of this world. On a weekend morning, this is worth going out of your way for if only for the desserts. Take some bread home too... you won't regret it! A+ read more

Loved this place. This place surprised me from the quality and taste of the food to the ambience. Super quaint. I'm vegetarian so I got the vegan and gluten free corn chowder with bread. On the spicier side but tolerable with bread. Perfect for those who can handle a little spice. I also got the beet sandwich which was surprisingly amazing. I can eat that multiple times. The cafe is great. Chat tea latte was perfect. They charge an extra dollar, I believe, for milk substitution. Love that this place has a bakery, cafe, and smoothie joint. Definitely a place to visit when visiting Anchorage. read more

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

See all

My friends and I came here on a weekday and the place was packed! We were hoping to have a meal here but the kitchen was closed which was disappointing. There wasn't enough seating to sit down and work so we ended up just getting coffee and leaving. read more

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

See all

Started our day with an amazing experience at this local bake shop! Easily walkable from most downtown Anchorage. Everything is baked fresh daily, in-house. While waiting to order, you can watch all the bakers perfecting their craft creating tasty treats. The ambiance is lively, bright and airy. My wife had the Croissant with chocolate. It was very buttery, flaky and tasty. I had the mixed berry scone. It was packed with strawberries, blueberries and rhubarb. Definitely need to check it out if I'm downtown Anchorage. read more

See all

Customer service: 4 Affordability: 4 Cleanliness: 5 Location: 5 Parking: 4 We visited this bakery this summer, while we were visiting the Anchorage area. We decided to stop by based on their Google and Yelp reviews. They have a small parking lot, so we had to find nearby street parking. It's a popular local bakery, so we had to wait a few minutes to get 2 muffins to go. The staff was very friendly and professional. The muffins were kind of dry, but they were served warm. read more

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

Beautiful bakery that offers a variety of sweet and savoury croissants. The breakfast sandwich and the ham and cheese croissant were really good. Loved their chocolate cake as well. Everything is freshly baked. read more

Review #10 of 2025 We went to Anchorage last month for an Alaskan adventure and I had bookmarked this place. We went here on a day they normally don't open I guess as the worker told us, so the menu was limited and whatever is out is all there is for the day and that was unfortunate because there was so much stuff I wanted to try. I really wanted to get some sandwiches for our day of exploring. There was a line that moved quick but unfortunately many items were already sold out! Wanting something a bit more filling, we got a savory scone with ham, chives and cheddar as there were a handful left, like 3. My husband said he wasn't big on scones, so I only got one. Once we tasted it, we wished we bought all of them!! It was the best scone I have ever tasted! No joke! Even my husband who says he doesn't like scones LOVED it. It was crispy on the outside and inside was fluffy and oh so tasty!!! I wish we had been able to make our way back here on other day to try other stuff!! No wonder this place sells out all the time. The hype were was legit! My baby LOVED the scone too and he was on a picky streak during this trip! The scone I believe cost $4.50 and for goodness it was, worth EVERY penny!! This place is really cute! It's located in a big building that shares many other shops. Parking was busy for this shop, but we found a spot right away. Parking is also free here. Would I be back here? OMG, yes, this place is definitely on my list of places to eat at next time I come back to Alaska which might be sooner than we think because my family and I absolutely LOVED our time in Alaska and already want to go back. I can't wait to come back to this bakeshop and seriously try everything! read more

What a cool fantastic spot. I picked up a ham and cheese herb scone and an Alaskan berry scone. In not a big Scone person but that savory scone was the best I've ever had. It's an open concept bakery in you, see everyone baking in the back. The team at the front desk were simply awesome and the place was clean and organized. I asked if they had espresso and they informed me that the coffee shop across from them had espresso. There is also a large seating area where you can get your scones, coffee and cookies macaroons muffins, and enjoy. read more

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Main Entrance - Bakeries Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

Very cute shared space with other shops at K Street Market! The workers were very nice and helpful. I got a handful of baked goods (ham, chive, cheddar scone and strawberry mango cupcake) and a Peruvian chicken sandwich! Everything I consumed was delightful and delicious. Plenty of seating inside. Would highly recommend if you're looking for a snack or quick lunch in the Anchorage area. read more

See all

Discovered this hidden gem late last week by accident! Ended up going back not only for coffee and breakfast sandwiches but for lunch as well. I'm happily to see that they are expanding their current location!!! read more

Bright, cute bakery with lots of seating. Serving cakes, pastries, and savoury items (soups and sandwiches). Omg the SCONES *drool* - dense, buttery, NOT dry, not to sweet. Crispy on the outside, a touch of salt. Fresh raspberries. We tried them right out of the oven. My sister said the alfajore ($5.50) was excellent, not to sweet too. On the pricier side but you are paying for real quality items. read more

See all

My husband and I were out on a little stroll and stumbled upon Fire Island. While I absolutely loved the quick paced, packed family vibes I was slightly disappointed with the flavor of the brown butter walnut brownie. The line was very long when we got there but only ended up spending a max of five to ten minutes waiting in line! The chocolate chip cookies were good and if we had more time I would've tried more! Overall very clean and well kept location and I really enjoy the rest of the market read more

We visited this place on our way to Seward and what a great place discovered. Here is the summary of our experience at this bakery heaven: 1. Ambiance 5/5: This place was brimming with people and you can clearly see employees baking hundreds of fresh breads, scones, and everything drool-worthy. The place has a great vibe and was very busy 2. Service 5/5: Even though the place was crowded and superbusy , the counter person was friendly and the service was fast. 3. Food 5/5: We ordered a lot of food and bread - some of which I do not remember now but one thing is for sure - if you are looking for freshly baked items with great and unforgettable taste, then this is the place to be in. For breakfast we ordered, a) Breakfast (yes it is called breakfast): It is good for 1 person but insufficient if you are very hungry. b) Chicken Ceaser: It's a cold wrap that is delicious and good enough for one person. c) Different types of bread: We ordered a couple of big loaves of bread and finished within minutes d) Foccacia: They were like small slices of pizza with eggs and cheese and tasted delicious. 4) Value for Money 5/5: Although some might say it is costly but when you take into account the freshness and taste, this is a complete value for money and a breakfast that you will remember. Overall. If you are ever visiting Anchorage, this place should definitely be at the top of your list for breakfast. A must-visit for everyone The Good: 1) Everything - the baked items, the coffee, and the breakfast was delicious Not so good: 1) Parking in front is limited and is not free in any place nearby read more

See all

I love checking out local bakeries, and Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop was a great find! We arrived at about 9:30 am and found that they were out of a few items (based on the turned down item tags). Sad to have missed those, but there were still a bunch of great looking pastries that we ordered. We ordered: - Ham and cheese croissant: delicious, crispy croissant - Cranberry orange scone: I preferred this flavor to the lemon raspberry scone - Lemon raspberry scone - Chocolate babka - Monkey bread There was plenty of seating available, and there are also restrooms onsite. read more

This place is in a cool building with other stores that sell various items. The line was constant and long which must be a good sign! We got a savory tart and it was incredible and had such a flaky crust. read more

This place was slammed so definitely plan to wait. We ordered some coffee from next door while we waited in line for our baked goods. The coffee tasted great. The blueberry muffins we ordered were full of blueberries and tasted great. The texture was a bit dry but I feel like it's because it was a different flour than I'm used to. read more

My favorite spot in Anchorage. The bakery has a selection of delicious treats, sandwiches and more. It is attached to a coffee shop that also sells plants, and the whole thing has a relaxing, hippie vibe. The people were friendly and you could see things being made in the bakery while you eat. Highly recommend. read more

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

See all

Newer location is nice because of the other stores that accompany it. I too don't like their setup. There's got to be a better way. If I worked there I'm sure I would get tired of saying "have you been helped yet?" Somebody helps you then leaves you in the same spot in line as before they helped you so nobody knows. Then you follow them to a register. Today I got the BLT sandwich. It's different then ones they've had before, and unfortuantly less special. The old one was on a baguette and had pickled tomatoes. This one was on plain bread with shredded lettuce, bacon and regular tomato. $17. Didn't get a chocolate chip cookie this time but they are my favorite. Might be my second favorite because sewards resurrection coffee house has my first now. We also asked for a sourdough starter and they gave us one for free. read more

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - BLT sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

Several reviews have said you guys treat people that aren't Caucasian, differently. I used to brush it off, until I went this morning to the downtown shop & I experienced it myself. The only good things there are the breakfast focaccia & the breakfast egg sandwich. Everything else is dry. I guess I'd leave 1 star just for those two things, I wouldn't leave one if Yelp didnt make us rate places. read more

4.5 for stellar money bread and unique scones! I wish I was able to try their croissants but always miss the timing. Scones are more on the bread like side (texture wise) with a nice crust on the outside which sounds weird but it's good. I enjoyed their focaccia and sourdough bread as well. I like the layout of this location. They have a nice open seat area. read more

This bakery is on point! Had the chocolate chip and peanut butter cookies. Both were delicious! Might be the best I've had. The cupcakes were delicious too. Had a chocolate and a pineapple rum. 100% the best pineapple rum cupcake I've ever had. Love the setup... you have the bakery, a wine shop, and a plant/produce shop all in the same location. read more

If you're on the hunt for fresh out the oven baguettes, you need to visit this bakery. We came around 2p, so inventory was pretty cleared out. All that was left were the cookies, pre-packaged chocolate shortbread cookies, rosemary-lemon polenta cake, and a mint cupcake. They were out of baguettes, but a fresh batch was coming out in 25 minutes. Pretty cool that they're still baking so close to closing. We ordered one of everything, and each bite we took was so fulfilling. The polenta cake was delightfully crumbly yet dense enough to not fall apart. The rosemary-lemon icing was a sweet citrus and not overwhelming. I thought it would taste more on the earthy side, but it was heavenly. The baguette was one of my favorites - crisp but not painful to bite into and the inside was perfectly dense (not super doughy). I did the crunch test from the movie Ratatouille and it passed lol. The chocolate shortbread cookies didn't pass the kid-test since they were more of a dark chocolate, but I thought they were delicious! They had a subtle sweetness that I appreciated. If you're willing to wait for baguettes to come out the oven, there are two other shops in the same little plaza. One is a plant / coffee shop and the other is a wine shop, both of which were nice to visit and made the time fly. I super recommend going, and don't be discouraged if there is a long line. It goes fast! read more

We went on a Monday morning, so it was a limited menu. The service was friendly and it is a cute place. Well the breakfast pastries were good but needed a little more flavor/moisture. read more

Fire island is my go-to bakery for office treats, birthday cakes, and a sweet snack for myself! I keep going back for their breads, cupcakes, and pastries and recommend them to both Anchorage locals and tourists alike! read more

Friendly service. In the really cute market so you can get coffee in the same building :) I got a focaccia and chocolate chip cookie and a local tonic water. I just wish there were more vegetarian savory items. I really would love to get a nice veggie sandwich here because the bread is so good. Maybe eventually it'll be on the menu. read more

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Focaccia and soda water! Get the chocolate chip cookie! - Bakeries Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

Amazing food and Amazing clean restaurant friendly and helpful staff great food what more do you want read more

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

This must be one of the most interesting, delicious bakeries we have ever visited. Such a high-quality and fun menu. Plus, the businesses surrounding are great to visit as well. read more

Food is deliscious! Fresh baked goods (baked in-house) using quality ingredients. Deliscious soups, sandwiches, loaves of bread, cookies, cupcakes, scones tarts, all are absolutely deliscious!! We'll with the trip and money well spent. Great staff. read more

The egg salad sandwich is amazing! Goopy sloppy yummy goodness! I will definitely go again if ever in Alaska! Also, the vibe there is really nice and open! read more

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Pretty centerpieces - Bakeries Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

See all

This is the place to be. I came by for a later lunch and found all the sandwiches to be unavailable. I opted for the salmon chowder and monkey bread. The chowder was amazing and so delicious. The money bread was also lovely, pulling apart very easily. My friend and I stopped by again the next morning. We got there much earlier and sandwiches were still available. I opted for a pastry again and found it equally pleasant. It can get super busy there and even if you're in line and the cutoff time for breakfast sandwich comes up while you're in the queue, then you're out of luck. The cafe in the plant shop and juicery in the small grocery shop offer beverage options to complement the bakery. There's outdoor seating as well. It's a popular spot. read more

Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop - Salmon chowder - Bakeries Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

See all

A wonderful (and very busy) big-city bakery in small-town Anchorage; it's probably the best bakery this far north in the United States. But the prices are wild - very, very high, likely due to its remote location and challenges getting any ingredient this far out of the way. I went with a salami and pepper croissant (a nice, savory treat) and a peanut butter cookie sandwich (two cookies with a peanut butter filling). I'll probably be back tomorrow. Despite long lines, service moves quickly and is efficient but it isn't necessarily the kind of place you make friends with the staff. read more