-Drive thru pizza ? Yay! Pittsford Dairy Farms Ice cream ? Yippee! Good crust , quick service. They don't char the bottom. Little bit of Indian flair for those who like those flavors and a great Create Your Own Pizza. It's almost a perfect family place , except I found the BBQ sauce a little ketchupy. read more

We went for ice cream, and what's not to love about Pittsford Farms Dairy ice cream? Nothing, if you get it at Pittsford Farms! As we waited to be served we noticed some of the flavors were melting at the top but didn't think too much of it. My husband ordered the mint chocolate chip and I got the pistachio. Mine was fine, but my husband's was so grainy in texture that he didn't even get halfway through it before giving up. We went to the patio area to eat our desserts and the music that was coming through the speakers was nowhere near professional with all of the curse words and lewd content in the first song alone. We're not usually affected by things like that, but it was over the top too much. Lastly, the cleanliness was lacking. Sadly, we won't be back. read more

WOW ... I completely stumbled upon this place! My local Pizza joint did not take orders after 8 pm, so I took to Yelp to help me out ... and low and behold found Fire Crust on West Henrietta Road (was looking for delivery). Not knowing a thing about this place, I ordered the Chicken Tikka Pizza and the Sweet Chili Fire roasted wings ... AMAZING! The flavor profile in the pizza was dead on of what a great chicken tikka should taste like, beautiful spice with a touch of heat ... and the wings were smokey and tasty! Delivery was on time; food was still nice and hot and again ... worth mentioning ... so flavorful. I am seriously looking forward to working my way through this menu ... and perhaps pop in one day! This is definitely a must try if you want an elevated Pizza and Wing experience that won't break the bank and deliver a flavorful punch! read more

I went to fire stick the second day they were open! I had a pretty good experience, the food was good. The wait was not long and we had great customer service! The ice cream was very expensive...at Pittsford dairy you definitely get more for your money. If you don't want to go to Pittsford then this is the best option read more

See all

Very fast service for pizza. Tastes great! Create your own or they have some styles to choose from. I really like that the toppings are out on display to pick from. Very clean! Beer and wine options available. Also they have this blue ice cream that is so flippin good. I ate it and didn't take a picture, my bad. read more

Fire Crust - pizza pizza - Pizza Near Me - Henrietta, New York

Being from NYC, this might not be a fair review, bc NYC has the best pizza in the world!! That being said, the pies that we ordered were as advertised. I didn't care for the crust, too spongy. It was not crisp at all. It tasted better than cafeteria pizza, but left me still craving pizza, even though I just had it. I didn't get the satisfaction of folding a decent sized slice, turning it sideways and taking a huge bite. Had I done that, the whole slice would have been gone. For the money paid, I was left unimpressed. Delivery was great!! I believe Grubhub was the delivery service. read more

Best kept secret in the made-to-order pizza market. Their ingredients seems very, very fresh. When I came in, I saw them roasting fresh garlic for example. Three other reasons why I really like this place: 1. Flat priced pizza. They don't nickel and dime you for toppings. One price. Whatever you want. As much as you want. Yay! 2. They serve Pittsford Dairy ice cream and made-to-order shakes. Yummy! 3. About 6-8 beers on draft, plus assorted bottles. Also locally sourced fountain drinks. What's not to like? Give it a shot....my kids always insist we come here instead of other choices. read more

Cool concept. An employee presses dough into a 12" round pie, you select a sauce and choose from a variety of fresh toppings or go with one of their combinations. My husband loved his Classic Margherita Pizza. My daughter had the I'm Meating Pizza, and I had the White Out. Yum. I will say we probably could have gotten away with splitting two pies for three of us, but we got boxes for take home. The pies are cooked pretty quick. They had plenty of seating. They have beer and wine, soda and milkshakes. We managed to indulge in ice cream, because it is from a dairy farm. Again, home run. The kiddie size at $3.50 is a healthy scoop. Would definitely go back. You order everything from a counter, then sit. They call you up when it is ready. No tableside service. read more

You definitely can't go wrong with Fire Crust! The price is great, you create your own pizza from a large variety of fresh toppings, and within minutes it's ready! read more

Surprisingly delicious and quick pizza. It's an interesting assembly line format that one is used to at many fast food chain restaurants but with very fresh ingredients and a brick oven stove that cooks the thing crust, ample cheese and toppings very well. We had the chicken pesto and enjoyed it very much. One suggestion: provide plates for consumers sharing your delicious pies! We used napkins but it was hard to keep the grease off the table. read more

This place is so much fun!!! The perfect date night spot to take your spouse or one of your kids. They have excellent, flavorful pizza, a great soda selection, and Pittsford Dairy ice cream. Yum!! They did have a sign that more food options, like paninis, are coming soon. I can't wait to go back.. the question is will I get something new or have to go for the super amazing Greek pizza again?? read more

Fire Crust - Greek pizza - Pizza Near Me - Henrietta, New York

Best Amazingly Fast Fresh oven baked Pizza. My husband and I each ordered a pizza, about 10 bucks - great price. 10 mins it came to us hot, perfectly cooked and tasted way beyond anything anywhere in ROC ! Environment was clean , super friendly helpful ...i thought I was the south , Customer service was actually cheery & happy music was fun and the wall art- very funny! You Have TO GO. Plenty to bring home for tomorrow too-thinking breakfast read more

See all

The food was amazing!! This is our new go to pizza restaurant. I highly recommend trying this place.

Loooove the pesto chicken pizza and the wings can definitely be eaten for breakfast (dont judge me). Great meal if you have the munchies.

Great pizza and friendly staff!! I came during a rush hour so it was pretty busy. Pizza comes in one size and you can choose whatever topping you would like on it when you down the row. The owner looks like a cross between Mr. Colonial Sanders from KFC and Wilson from Home Improvement if they had a babychild. Super nice guy and will help you with any questions that you may have. A few things that differentiates them from others is the fire grilled wings. The mango habanero has a nice kick to it if you like spicy. Also they sell pittsford ice cream which you can get in a scoop, cone or float. The reason I didn't give it a 5 is cause they are still in the early stages. I noticed that it was so busy 1) every single person that cashed out wasn't asked if they wanted to add a drink or anything else with it unless you specifically asked. 2) Forgot what you ordered so you would need to them again what you ordered cause the order sheet goes into the box it would be unsanitary if they reopened the box and check after handing cash 3) after you cash out if you order more stuff, you'll have to wait on the side if it's not ready yet but they are so scattered that they'll ask you if you've already paid or not. Pizza was fresh and cooked to perfection. It wasn't burnt on the bottom like other places. I would definitely go back!! read more

Everything about our take out order was terrible. First: They wouldn't apply our valid coupon. When asked to speak to a manager, no one was available to help with our issues. Second: The "fire cooked" wings were so soggy that we could barely eat them. Almost inedible. Unreal for the price of chicken wings these days. To top that off, the mushy wings didn't even have flavor. We drive by this place everyday and I can honestly that we will keep driving right on by. read more

I ordered through uber eats and was extremely disappointed. The pizza was ice cold. They forgot a bunch of toppings. The pizza looked as if they literally just threw everything on at the end because you could not pick up a slice without all the toppings just rolling right off. Such a waste of money. Obvious they didn't care at all. Will not be purchasing again. read more

Fire Crust - Pizza Near Me - Henrietta, New York

Portions for days. Definitely will need a to go bag! Best food ever! So fresh and tasty too! Will definitely be back.

Had a simple Hawaiian style pizza. Crust was light and crisp toppings were fresh. Place was nice and quick. They were nice enough to take my order 15 min before closing as we got into town late. Staff was friendly and service was good. read more

I and my friend tried Chicken Tikka pizza which was good. Just a little dry as compared to Pi Craft pizza. But overall, liked the taste and an Indian would definitely love this place! read more

Really good pizza. Would definitely eat there again. My husband and I split one pizza. We each got everything we wanted on our half. Got a 6 piece wing and 2 soft drinks. Comfortably full. The pizza is thin crust very flavorful. Wings were best I've had in a while. Whole thing was 22.00. Very reasonable. Dining room is modern and comfortable. Food was ready quickly. read more

Value for money. We went with 'create your own' pizza and they had a variety of different options. It was also super inexpensive. I love that they had a lot of dressing/sauces options. read more

Fire Crust - Make Create Your Own Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Henrietta, New York

See all

Vegan pizza? YES PLEASE!! What, no up charge for vegan cheese or extra toppings??! Best value pizza around, hands down. Friendly staff and always very clean inside. read more

Great product and great price. Continues to be my place to go for brick oven pizza. One of my favorite places in Henrietta and love that they have online ordering. I will continue to go back. Love that it's the same price for as many toppings as you want. I only hate trying to do half and half as the toppings merge so avoid that if you can't stand your partners toppings. read more

Great idea! Truly Custom Pizza and FAST! Family friendly. Delicious Pizza! Pittsford Dairy Ice Cream too! Indoor or outdoor seating. Beer and large selection of pop on tap. Good service. Excellent value. We will be back! read more

Got take out at Fire Crust in Webster NY this weekend. It was quick and easy. They have done a nice job with the inside of the building and the food - had pizza and wings and they were were good. Need to put up some umbrellas on the patio for outdoor dining. read more

Delicious and well priced. The staff is courteous and welcoming as well. This new establishment has become my new favorite artisan pizza shop. read more

Been here 3 times when staying over in Henrietta, NY. Love this place for Pizza and Ice Cream. Staff is extremely accommodating. A kid friendly place per my 4 year old grandson!!! read more

Best pizza crust make ur own everything was perfect but the red sauce could be better this is my only comment wonderful stuff forget about the wings very delicious but ask for extra crispy which we have one in Bayridge read more

So much better then we expected. Pick from menu or design your own, can't go wrong here. Super friendly staff and fresh ingredients. Oh and btw, the price was very reasonable. If I wasn't passing through on my way to Pennsylvania, I would make this a regular stop. Thanks Fire Crust!!!! read more

Fire Crust - Pizza Near Me - Henrietta, New York

Stopped in for my son's birthday. Manager went over everything in great detail and was very patient with a spontaneous large party ordering. The staff was very friendly, the food was very good, and we were impressed to see local soda and local ice cream offered instead of corporate affiliation. Will definitely be stopping again! read more

Good pizza and plenty of ingredients to choose from for a slightly high price. The interior is quite nice too. Dodge the wings at all costs. Those things are probably the fattiest pieces of chicken I've ever had. Like, 50% just slivers of fat. Service is hit-or-miss as well. Employees tend to chat and not pay attention to you, sometimes even continuing conversations from across the entire dining room. I learned way more than I needed to about one of the employee's past drinking problem. Other times they are fairly friendly and attentive. I just feel like it could be better considering I'm there paying $14 for a medium pizza and a single drink. I come back though because the pizza is good and, hey, they have locally-made ice cream. read more

Creativity is one thing the Rochester pizza scene has lacked for a long time, and when it emerges, it comes at the expense of quality. However, the emergence of Fire crust has changed that all! This was our second order from them. Choosing what to order is the most challenging part of the experience given the wide variety of very cool and creative choices they have. Despite the variety of choices the pizza is compromise free. It's a then tasty, with just the right crunch crust that has the flavour of an authentic Italian oven. The cheese and sauce mix is well cultivated and just right, and the items are fresh and tasty. Our chicken tikka pizza was perfect. And our kids who never eat anything other than cheese pizza can't stop talking about the fact that they had two of their favourite meals in one - a Mac and Cheese Pizza! And as a plus, you can order Pittsford Dairy shakes and floats to accompany our pizza. A Covid evening at home does not get much better than this! read more

Great pizza. And the mango habenaro wings had the perfect amount of heat and sweet. The staff are very nice and helpful

The pizza here is amazing! It is handmade in front of you, and there are a ton of different ingredients that you can choose from. There are also milkshakes from Pittsford dairy farms. My personal favorite is the pistachio milkshake. The milkshakes ice cream comes from a local farm and it complements the pizza very well. The personal Pizza is large enough for one meal for an average person. If you have a smaller appetite like myself, you may end up only eating half of the pizza and saving the other half for tomorrow! The environment is trendy and chic, it is great for teams and friendly meetups. That they use sharpie to write down your order on the paper that they placed underneath the pizza. This makes it possible for the ink to transfer onto your food. This is not the most sanitary. read more

Pizza, beer, chicken wings, ice cream. Tasty food, fast, friendly service, great prices. What more could you ask for in a pizza joint?

New pizza spot close to home. Same set up at blaze and pi craft. It's been open just 3 days so still working out some kinks. They have beer on tap and serve ice cream also. Nice decor and plenty of seating. $9.75 for a create your pizza which is a good price point. read more

Pizzas are superb!! Visiting here for a week and tried most of the pizza places but this place's pizza tasted best. Paneer/ chicken tikka pizza are must haves. Will definitely recommend stopping by here. read more

Our first visit. Ordered a create your own pizza. Toppings are fresh and right in front of you to see to pick and choose in order to create your own masterpiece. Cooked fast in a super hot oven. Dough was outstanding. Pittsford Dairy Farms ice cream served here too as a bonus! read more

Fire Crust - Create your own pizza extravaganza. - Pizza Near Me - Henrietta, New York

Our family stopped here for a late lunch/early dinner and were very impressed. Great tasting food, friendly service, and reasonably priced. We shared a cheese/pepperoni/ sausage/black olive/banana pepper pizza and a Mediterranean veggie. I love that you can add as many toppings as you'd like without being up charged. 'd love to see salads on the menu in the future. We'll be back for sure! read more