This was our third visit to the Fence & Post. Our first visit was in June of 2017 and we were simply amazed by the food, service and decor. We had the chicken, steak and a mushroom pastry for an appy. Best food we've ever had in Cochrane, barre none. Everything cooked to perfection.
The second time we went was in September, 2017 and the menu had changed a bit. Still ok, but that mushroom tart wasn't on the menu anymore (a tragedy) and the chicken was different somehow. Different sauce, maybe? Different sides? Not as good as the first time. This time it was served with spaetzle and it's not something I would order again, I find it quite tasteless.
Last night, we went again and ordered the scallops as an appy and told our server we would share. One would think that would indicate it would be a good idea to serve an even number for sharing but we got three. Only pan-seared and still clear in the middle. We simply couldn't eat it and called our server over. She asked us if we wanted them cooked ALL the way through (as if this was unheard of). We told her that yes, we did. They came back out fully cooked and were just ok. $17 for 3 scallops. Granted, they were on the large size.
My husband ordered the steak and I ordered the fish. He ordered his steak medium, not medium rare and it came out on the rare side of medium rare. His baked potato had been cooked hours previously, no longer white but more grey and on the cold side. We had already sent one thing back so we didnt feel good doing it again as we already got the feeling our server was losing patience with us. He got most of the way through the steak but just couldn't finish. The owner came over and we showed her how raw the steak still was. She took it away and said she'd "do something". The bill came shortly after that and there was no adjustment. In fairness, he did eat most of the steak but when we asked the server if there was going to be an adjustment because of the steak, she just said "No." Hmm. Not the service we first experienced here.
My fish was ok but not something I'd order again. We were disappointed with our third visit to Fence & Post and hope they can get back to how amazing they were out of the gate! Hopefully, it was just an off night for them, because they really do have a shot at being a great addition to Cochrane. read more