Toppings are good but you can't really mess up on toppings can you? The crust, the most import part, is a bit tough, lacks good flavor and really makes this pizza unenjoyable. I need to try another place in Paso Robles on my next visit. read more

Everything was " just about right" which in pizza world means: damn good pizza. The crust wasn't too thick or too thin, it was just about right. The pizza didn't have too much sauce or not enough, it was just about right. The cheese to topping ratio wasn't completely off in either respects, it was just about right. I only kind of like sausage pizza so when I came in with a friend a few days ago I thought, if we're going to 1 top this for that amazing deal I'll get a sausage. I had very low expectations. All the pizza place's where I live can't wrap their head around a solid good, 1-topping pizza. They're like the old fashioned donuts of the pizza world. If you can't make this classic good, what are you doing making pizza? Let me tell you this, that sausage pizza was so damn good I practically scarfed down the entire pizza the second I got home. With only a few slices remaining I refrigerated it and the next day it tasted just as good. Next time I'm in the area, I'm going to go here and hopefully turn this place into a bad pizza habit. A habit I'll never quit. read more

Pretty good pizza place for the price. I am a big fan of their BOGO that they offer all day every day. The deal is for every pizza except their personal mini and their prices are very reasonable even if you were only to get one. Now lets talk about the pizza. I ordered a mini pepperoni and I didn't call it in I walked in and ordered it. They told me it would be about ten to fifteen minutes so I decided to walk around the shopping center and actually spent most of my time and the CVS a couple of stores away. After about ten minutes I walked back in to the store and my pizza was ready. The only down side of Fatte's is isn't set up to eat in the store. There is a small table with a couple of chairs but no more then two people can actually eat there comfortably. Back to the Pizza. It was actually really good, it wasn't a thin pizza it was about an inch thick and there was the perfect amount of sauce and pepperoni pieces. The next time I'm in Paso I will return. read more

Recommended by hotel where I had just checked in. Was looking for pizza delivery and was told how good they were. Called, got order and enjoyed the heck out of it. A bit pricey, but I got exactly what I wanted. read more

Ordered a meat lovers and a vegetarian pizza. Received two vegetarian pizzas and no meat lovers. Upon calling Fatte's they said they could offer 20% off on our next pizza or bring a new pizza and take back the incorrect one. Of course we wanted what we ordered and a half hour later the correct pizza was delivered. What concerns me is that Fatte's required the incorrect pizza in return. During Covid-19 I find it amazing that a business would take back food that was in someone's home for over 45 minutes. The delivery driver put it back in her car with other pizza orders. Does our returned pizza go back into the business? I can't believe management doesn't see the risk they are putting their customers and the community in. Another customer for Dominos. read more

They stop delivering way to early compared to their actual hours of operation. They don't want my money I guess.

We order fattes all the time and usually love it! The pizza is good for the price and we are long time customers! Although tonight we were super disappointed! The pizza was good as usual, however the delivery person was an absolute idiot! We have two very large, very protective Great Danes and he didn't knock or ring the bell and tried to enter our home without any warning or permission!!! He doesn't realize how close he came to a very bad situation!!! Very disappointed that someone lacking any common sense is delivery food to family's and their pets!!! read more

Very good pizza definitely , they are always on time and the delivery drivers are super nice

Fatte's is a GREAT pizza place. The service is fast, and friendly. The pizza is awesome! I love their sauce! I highly recommend! read more

We ordered the Italian sausage and cheese sandwich with marinara sauce and added grilled green peppers for lunch today. The sandwich is HUGE, big enough to split between us; the quality is spot on. My expectations were exceeded; our go to restaurant in SoCal was Cortina's Italian deli in Anaheim,CA, this sandwich was better tasting and much larger. read more

Order pizza for delivery and the person said 45 minutes. One hour and 45 minutes later called to ask where it was. The person that answered the phone was unintelligible and spoke too fast. Only offered that the delivery person would arrive any minute. No apology or sympathy. Then we asked what happened. He said the driver got lost on his first deliver and he would call him, but the driver should arrive any minute. Still no apology. No sense of remorse. One hour and 50 minutes to get our pizza, and it was far from hot. Very disappointed in the service. Then found out I was probably talking to the Manager on the phone. Pitiful that a Manager doesn't know how to apologize and take care of business better. Sorry way to run a business. You want people to use your business, yet you treat customers this way, ridiculous. read more

I love Faye's pizzas. I had a sausage, mushroom and jalapeño and a ham, mushroom and pineapple. Both were excellent.

Really nice employees but super non creative pizza without super high quality toppings. This is also a super basic crust. If cheapest is all you want go here. read more

I will NEVER give these assholes my business. The owner will not talk to one of their customers after his employee ran over her dog while delivering a pizza to her home . The pic of the injury is horrible. Shame on you read more

2 for one pizzas that are to die for! Best pizza in town and the price is allways 20$ less then the competitors! Phone girls are always polite and cater to you! Cooks are professional and will take little requests like how one time we got a heart shaped pizza We love Fattes at my house and nothing is greater then walking in and having the whole resterant crew recognize you! If thats not 5 star quality then i don't know what is!!! read more

They have the worst app! I ordered the three toppings on two pizzas special. They gave me two toppings on one pizza and the other a plain cheese pizza (the other topping according to their app). They said it was my fault because I used the app. They wouldn't refund me even 50% because the buyer is always wrong when they use the app. And "Breezy" at their Paso Robles store said the owners who could give me a refund won't return my phone call until at least sometime next week, if ever. So buyers beware, if you order using their app, DO NOT PAY USING THE APP. YOU CANNOT GET A REFUND. It's always your fault. read more

Was staying at the la Quinta few weeks back and for the price it wasn't bad at all !! The delivery was a bit slow that's why I gave a 4 star definitely be back !! read more

It's not the best but not the worst. They won't deliver to downtown Paso Robles on a Monday night. So I had to pick it up myself. I got the chicken bacon antichoc. Food was good as normal read more

I love Fatte's! They always come through with really good pizza. Tasty toppings, chewy cheeses, scrumptious crust. The staff is always helpful and friendly. read more

Wow just wow I'm never gonna get pizza from this place again we order a pizza and the lady on the phone was rude she wasn't polite saying the pizza will get there in 30 minutes, 1 hour and 50 minutes pas by and they barley decide to show up, not only that but they are scamming you we got 6 soda cans for 30 dollars they are paying 5 dollars for one can that's a total rip off if I would've known I would've bought my soda somewhere else I'm never gonna come here again the pizza wasn't that good either, it had my whole family waiting everyone was irritated most weren't even hungry any more, never coming here again. read more

Great tasting pizza. Very happy with my order. Delivery was right on time and driver was very helpful. I love there buy one get one free. Such a great deal. read more

Had a pizza here. I guess it is an OK place for pizza, if you don't mind the food preparers not wearing a face mask. In a time of a pandemic where a virus is extremely contagious and there is no cure, this is not very comforting. read more

Love there Pizza every time. Good prices. They don't skimp on the meats or vegetables.

Dude this shit was amazing, super cool people & One of the managers I think named Patrick was the best. Highly recommend.

The pizza is pretty good here, specially when its a 2 for 1 special, but its the meatball sub that will keep me coming back. the amount of cheese on the thing is almost perfect. it could have used a touch more sauce but we are talking not even another ounce or two. I will be going back for the subs again and again. read more

Stopping here is mandatory when I make a trip from Salinas to Bakersfield. This trip I stopped going down and coming home. I discovered this place about 6 years ago by accident, and have been stopping ever since. The buy 1 get 1 was what got my attention back then. They load on the cheese and toppings, and I can sub white sauce for red without issue. The Sticky Fingers and Garlic Chicken are my 2 favorites, but they have great online coupon deals too. On my way back, I used the 2 large, 5 topping pizzas for $21.99 coupon. When I got home an hour and a half later, the pizza was still fresh tasting, and the crust was great. I usually hate crust, but their's is delicious. The same young lady helped me both times, I believe her name was Randi, and she was extremely friendly! Their staff always is! Kudos to her for spelling my name correctly, because nobody ever does. Lol But both times they were fairly busy because it was dinner time, yet I was given a 20 minute time frame to pick up my pies both days. I went across the parking lot to Albertson's to shop for a few minutes the first day because I ordered at the counter, and got back with time to spare. Instead of having to wait, she got my pizzas. They were ready. On the way home, I stopped at a gas station off the 46 and figured I'd call my order in and just have to wait a bit to pick up, but again, it was waiting there ready. I already can't wait until my next road trip for more great pizza!! read more

Fatte's Pizza - Night one's pizzas were chicken garlic. I was so hungry, I ate almost half on the drive to Bakersfield! - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

I want to give them higher, since I've been eating their pizza for over 20 years. However, the PR location is going downhill in regards to service. I hope to revise this to a higher score later. read more

We really wanted to try this pizza since it is close to our house. We called multiple times on a Sunday evening and no one answered:( I don't know if they are still in business or if their phone is out of order. Probably one of the most important things to check is that your phone works and you have staff to answer the phone when you are a delivery service. read more

I've ordered a lot of pizza in town, and Fatte's right up there with the best of them. Every experience has been positive. I just ordered two, two topping medium pizza's for only $15. What sets Fatte's apart is there low price and faster delivery. I like a simple pepperoni and black olive.Oh, they have great coupons in the north county phone book. read more

Order ahead of time because apparently it takes 30 minutes to make two individual garden salads. Our sandwiche has been sitting on a shelf for 10 minutes getting cold while this girl cuts lettuce. There are exactly 3 ingredients in a garden salad that apparently takes this long to prepare. All while our sandwiche sits getting cold. read more

Pizza pizza pizza and you can always buy one get one free(not really free). Topping selection are pretty good, sometime they over baked. But most time it tastes good. Price is very competitive compare to other pizza place. read more

Oh Fattee's Pizza, you are my guilty pleasure. To reach you, your phone is often busy and I've been hung up on more times than I can count, yet I come back. Your two for one and lovely sauce keep me. We now only have pizza in a blue moon so I want it to be your best. Alas, the last couple of pizzas have had really tough dough/ crust. The "bite" isn't the same. It went from slightly chewey to tough. New cook? New recipe? Overworked dough? read more

Yeah, yeah, buy one get one free, nice gimmick. Luckily the pizza is delicious!!! The fam loves the sticky fingers and the garlic chicken and the deluxe Hawaiian. They're all great. Two large pizza with a plethora of toppings usually comes to about 25.00 and is well worth it. read more

THE best pizza in town. Been indulging for years ... Garlic Chicken Pizza & Pepperoni and Sausage are where it at! VERY good!

Every time I order from this place, something about my experience sucks. This time, I ordered two for 13.49 large. GREAT DEAL, right? No, I'd rather have quality than quantity. I ordered one of the two with extra sauce. EXTRA sauce. Yet, when I bite into one of my slices (my pizza is the one with the sharpie writing on it that says "extra sauce") I don't even see NORMAL sauce. I'm not exaggerating, I'm totally serious here: I don't even see ANY SAUCE!!! I asked for extra and I don't even taste the @#$@!!!!! That's bad enough... but I don't think the guy boxing the pizzas has ever worked at a pizza place before. I mean, seriously dude, it's okay if every now and then when slicing 100 pizzas a night you mess up a slice here and there, but really? My pizza was sliced so bad that every single cut never penetrated the crust at all. I have to rip apart the piece I want to eat, which means I have to get sloppy and messy and basically should've been prepared to cut the damn thing myself. I know something like slicing might not matter to some people, but to me, it means they don't give a shit. Like seriously, they don't care about satisfying their customer; they just wanna get the order off the screen and collect their pathetic hourly wage and move on to the next day serving more mediocre garbage food. Enjoy! read more

Went in about a year and a half ago and had hairs (3) in my pizza. Was so disgusted I've never been back. Never will be either. I will choose other local establishments instead. read more

This place is awful. The food is mediocre at best, the service is hit or miss, mostly miss and the wait time for pick up, yes folks, pick up sits at 45 mins to an hour. I've worked in pizza in the past and 45 mins is barely acceptable for delivery. During one experience, the girl at the counter told me that they forgot to make my order, after I've paid for it. Neighbors, friends, colleagues have all had similar experiences and it seems like the price has reeled people back to give them another try. There are about 6 other options in town and this would rank with the lowest, if not the worst. Do yourself a favor and pay the extra buck for Chubbies downtown or Mission where the staff genuinely cares about the customer. read more

Seriously how intelligent to you have to be to take a F*** pizza order. I am appalled at the level of service and comprehension these people have. I told them I needed to feed 35 people and they suggested I get 6 pizzas...that would feed about 18 people. I spend 15 mins on the phone two different people one of which was was the manager who barely spoke a speck of English. I had to repeat my card number 6 times as he could not get it right. I certainly hope these pizzas show up on time to the right place I am having my doubts. read more

We came here to pick up several pizzas for our crew while camping. Tasty pizza (though I wasn't a huge fan of the garlic chicken), pretty quick turnaround time from calling to order to having it ready for pickup, good service, and oh the best part was not having to cook while camping at the hot springs! read more

Ordered at 5:15 for pickup. They told me 20 minutes. Got there and I was told they were just " waiting on cheesey bread". Meanwhile I watch 4 orders of cheesey bread walk out with the delivery drivers. So I wait...and wait. They are obviously very busy as all hands are on deck in the back. I get out of there at 6:10. Just give me a realistic time for pickup rather than the standard " 20 minute" answer. If you're swamped, then tell me so when I call. read more