Wow. Been getting delivered to our place for a year with no issues. Had great service. Always treated them awesome. Tonight they call to tell me (with a large group waiting) they no longer deliver to us. I offered an extra tip- which I did for one last delivery. It arrived, he was in a hurry and not friendly... tipped great anyway. Only to realize the order was totally wrong. Jalepenos instead of pineapple- seriously? Thats them being just assholes. 2 pizzas were doughy and undercooked, inedible. Just low class. So fair enough no business from us again. read more

Fatte's Pizza - A nice F-you from your local "friendly" pizza place we've supported for months. - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

I haven't had Fatte's for a couple years. Their deals and pizza were always good but it seems like they changed the dough. It was good and seemed like the crust was better. Toppings are always loaded as usual! read more

Fatte's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

We ordered 4 small pizzas and one mini, on the 2-for-1 special, Monday night. All the pizzas were perfect, hot, and delicious. The guy at the counter tonight was awesome, and provided excellent customer service. He was pleasant, and had a great attitude. We will most definitely be back! read more

What the heck, Fatte's?! I like your pizza but not tonight. Pizza was not cooked through, literally dough. The toppings were not assembled well with no sense of proportion. There was so much onion, it was overwhelming, especially raw. It's like they piled double of everything on raw dough. Both pizzas were raw and I had to cook them 10 minutes in a 400 degree air fryer to finish cooking. read more

Fast delivery good pizza in a time where pizza feels like it's from a mass produced assembly line. I was in the pizza business and can tell when pizza is a quality product read more

They have the best pizza! Plus you always get 2! The staff is always nice and friendly. My favorite place for pizza. read more

Delicious pizza always buy 1 get one free definitely great deal . Pizza is a a great size if you get the large

My son is autistic and is obsessed with Fatte's pizza so he earns points for good behavior each week to order Fatte's. Needless to say I spend a lot of money there! Lolllll. Today instead of deliver we stopped and picked it up. The young man at the counter was so nice, joyful and helpful. He had this positive outlook on the customers. I don't know his name but I think he is Hispanic and wears braids down the sides of his head. When people are nice and kind it makes so much difference. He deserves a thumbs up! read more

Pizzas always good and love the two for one deal. Works great cause the kids get their choice and we get ours.

I honestly though with new management their customer service would improve nope their was a baked hair inside our pizza I called spoked to manager would not replaced because we had started to eat the pizza the hair was baked inside the dam pizza super disgusted and they should honor the mistake and replaced it but because we had touched it they couldn't which is BS this is a way you loose customers honestly read more

Fatte's Pizza - Theirs a hair baked inside the pizza manager or supervisor of the day refused to replace because we had touched the freaking pizza - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

SO YUMMY. We ordered two large pizzas with pepperoni and mushroom; and jalapeno and pineapple. The young man was so kind in the front, and the workers behind him were working so hard. It was pretty warm in there so I felt bad that they were working hard in that temp or maybe there was A/C cold air blowing their way. Another great thing is that they offered paper plates, parms&peps, and napkins. They also offer ranch at . 50 cents each which is reasonable. Definitely support! 2 Pizzas for a price of 1, I mean why not?! read more

I have ordered pizza twice. Once,many pizzas, some gf, most not. Once, two gf for takeout. Pizzas were very good. Gluten free crust very nice. Will definitely return read more

Good pizza and a good price! It was ready on time and hot! Not much more I could want in take out pizza!

Our go to for pizza cravings. We always order lite bake since we like our crust a bit doughy. Seems to be ran by youngsters but seems they're getting trained well and they're pretty good with customer service. I don't agree with their refund policy if you're not satisfied with the product, but it's rare that we're not satisfied. Been ordering here for over a decade. Not a fine dining experience, but all in all, for the price and quality we really appreciate Fatte's. read more

I thought I'd give them a try They did great the last two times I ordered and had it delivered. No mistakes and right on time. Great job guys. read more

All wings in my order literally still raw all inside. Had to finish cooking myself........

Customer service is definitely not a priority here. Everyone working here is rude, the girls are wearing skimpy shirts and the cooks don't pay attention to how a pizza is supposed to be cooked or what the order says because they are too distracted. They aren't apologetic when the screw up an order they make it seem like it's your problem. I would definitely go elsewhere to order a pizza. Honestly dominos pizza would be better than this and at least they took a lesson on customer service and how to treat others. Go anywhere but here. They gave no options on fixing the pizza. read more

Lactose intolerant. Ordered a sub online and picked out all my toppings. Picked up my order and got home to dig in. Sandwich was covered in melted cheese on the inside. I did not specify any cheese in my order. Called the store and was told I would have to bring my sandwich back and they would make me a new one. I just wanted a refund since they are 30 minutes out of my way. Was offered 15% off my next order instead. Family didn't like their pizza so I will probably not be back. read more

I ordered two pizza's . Both of my pizzas where 5 topping pizzas. I got home one was correct the other was only cheese. I called to get the manager to remake the pizza. He refused. This is the first time ever I had a pizza place not correct their mistake. He was very rude! I will not be back. There are to many other good pizza places in town to deal with that bull----! read more

We ordered a pizza on line. The online system stated that it would take 45 minutes to a hour. It took an hour and 45 minutes plus for our pizza to be delivered. When we called to check to see when it would be delivered , we ended up finding out they took our order to the wrong address and had to do a do over. When the pizza finally arrived the driver couldn't even give me a receipt. Very slow, unorganized and lack of communication between the staff working there. read more

Made an delivery order today guy on the phone ERIC, had great customer service, didn't hurry me off the phone. Need people like this when calling restaurants. read more

The service was bad and the jalapeños were added when the pizza was fully cooked!! On top of that I had to wait while they reheated my pizza. read more

Fatte's Pizza - Added jalapeños after it's cooked because they forgot. - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

I was in the pizza industry for 20 years. The crust was undercooked in the middle and burnt around the edges they need to adjust what I'm assuming is a conveyer oven the temp and the timing. read more

Food was amazing I understand why it's busy every day, front workers are amazing they are very friendly helped me out with prices and topping the kind of customer service we need more nowadays read more

Bachelorette weekend and in need of carbs. This hit the spot! The pizza and cheese bread were so good. They delivered out to our hotel at CaliPaso. read more

Ordered a pizza from here today waited a little longer than expected to be delivered but it was so worth it whoever made it needs their ass ate ong - the jersey mikes staff read more

Avoid! What incredibly rude customer service! Don't waste your time here. Called in an order 40 mins prior to pick up, showed up..the kid says they forgot to put my order in. Then I ask him to cancel and return the charge on the card and he seemingly ignored me until I had to pull the manager to ask for a receipt of the cancelation, btw, that kid also has 0 customer service skills. Just a joke of an operation run by children. Will never return to that dump again! read more

Very bad customer service with the phone teller Dasha to the Manager Boulevard. So very disappointed that I was not taken care of as a customer. Placed a phone order with Dasha and when she repeated the order it was incorrect so I repeated my order again and had her repeat the order back to me and I agreed and paid for my order. Order came incorrect as it was missing our second salad and a Sprit Soda. Called them back as I wanted to be compensated for the incorrect order that was repeated twice. Was informed that this was my error and that I would need to pay for the salad and soda which made me ask for the manager Boulevard and he repeated the same line that it was my fault that Dasha was not paying enough attention to what I was ordering and she had my order incorrect even after repeating correctly back to me correctly as to what I wanted. Asked for contact information of the owner and was told that they would not give it to me nor would they guarantee that the owner would call me. They disparately need some customer service training meetings for their full staffing as this should have never happened. I knew what I wanted but they could not bring us what we ordered and through all the blame back on the customer...me! read more

Great deal for 2 small Unlimited toppings pizzas. For under $20 I fed my family of 4. I can customize it so that half is for us grown ups and half kid friendly. I use the online order form and can walk right in to pick up or have it delivered. I save this order has my favorite and with a few clicks I can reorder it time after time and specify if I need it ASAP or at a certain time- I can pay online or in store. They sure have made it easy- no more calling time after time until you could get thru. read more

See all

Got a referral from a friend to try this pizza place. Located in the same parking lot as Albertsons but on the other end. Ordered two large (Garlic Chicken & a Sticky Fingers) plus a small order of wings. All was really good and pretty cheap. Quick and easy....just the way it should be. read more

I was in from Redlands , ca visiting family. My family recommended this pizza place. I would recommend it anyone visits Paso Robles from all over the world. It was DELICIOUS pizza. The white sauce and red sauce pizza's were GREAT! Meat lovers ! They delivered 7 miles away in Templeton and was still very hot when it arrived. Thank you for a Great pizza! read more

Love their Garlic Chicken Combo pizza! I only eat here once a year, but every time i am in Paso I make sure to grab a pie. Totally worth it! read more

Fatte's Pizza - Can't even wait until we get home to snag a slice! So bomb! #nomnombomb - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

The customer service is horrible foul language from the girl on the phone incomprehensible to me ever answer the phone pizza is not as good as it used to be in customer service sucks really wish that they could get back to where they were would never go there again read more

The delivery driver ran over my friend's dog and they refused to acknowledge the incident! Never again will I order pizza from this company! read more

Fatte's Pizza - The driver of Paso Robles Fatte's Pizza hit my friend's dog during a delivery. - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

This is some of THE BEST pizza I have ever had!! Recommended by a coworker and holy smokes it was delicious. I'm so glad I decided to try it. They have buy one get one free and all their toppings are very fresh. I wish be going back!! read more

Not super stoked about their lack of safety protocols in regards to COVID. I placed a pickup order online and when we got there to pickup, maybe 1 of 12 employees was masked. Considering how the COVID situation is going in this county I am extremely hesitant to order from them in the future if this is how they are treating the health and safety of customers. The pizza is good though. read more

This is our to go pizza place, the pizza comes out and steamy the people there are really nice and friendly also easy to order online and they make food deliveries in 10-15 minutes. read more

Arrived hot and fresh. Was really impressed with the pizza. Presentation was great and tasted even better! Check out the pictures I posted of my order. So good!! Whoever cooked my pizza and cheese bread did an excellent job. All others should follow in this persons footsteps when making cheesebread and pizza cause it was a great night tonight cause of it! Keep it up! read more

See all

Toppings are good but you can't really mess up on toppings can you? The crust, the most import part, is a bit tough, lacks good flavor and really makes this pizza unenjoyable. I need to try another place in Paso Robles on my next visit. read more

Recommended by hotel where I had just checked in. Was looking for pizza delivery and was told how good they were. Called, got order and enjoyed the heck out of it. A bit pricey, but I got exactly what I wanted. read more