Amazing Pizza amazing atmosphere kinda a long wait but no biggie if you can wait a bit

Here visiting from Los Angels CA. Our family here kept raving about the pizza. We ordered the family deal and a "James favorite" pizza. Well, sadly to say we never got to taste James favorite. The server forgot to put in the order. The pepperoni pizza was good, thin crust. Buffalo wings were good too. Service was ok, place was nice. We waited 1 1/2 hours not really worth the wait. read more

See all

So bad. It was delivery, so I get that might been out of the control of the restaurant. No, just horrible pizza and salad. The delivery was the best thing about this order. Check my reviews, it has to really bad for me to post a negative review. Two pizzas, both scorched crust and still raw. Not even edible. If they were trying to be expedient on a delivery, just make it right. We get it, it it's Sunday night before a holiday, we will wait. But terrible pizza's. Not okay for $90+ read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tacoma, Washington

See all

The food here was delicious! We came for lunch and there was a decent number of people but it wasn't too crowded. We got a seat on the bar side in one of the booths by the window, which was really nice. We got quite a number of items - caesar salad, chicken wings, and two pizzas. This was more than enough food and we had plenty of leftovers to take home. The wings were absolutely fantastic - the sweet chili garlic glaze was so addictingly good, and I would definitely get those again. We chose one of the specialty pizzas and also made our own, which was a combination of pesto, onions, and pulled pork. The pizza crust itself was perfect - thin and crispy, with great flavor. Overall, I really enjoyed this spot and would definitely recommend it! read more

See all

This place is located on 6th Ave. there is a little lot on the side for parking. Fills up quickly on a busy day. We've been here twice in maybe a month and both times have been excellent. We sit on the bar side which is 21 and up. I'm appreciative of this option. It's well lit with popular music and a pool table. The server is always quick and friendly. Solid service in my opinion. I didn't care for my drinks the first visit. Barely tasted like a shot was in my drink. The second time this was not the case at all so bartenders may matter. The food is soooo delicious. It's my favorite pizza in the area. It's becoming a regular spot for me. read more

See all

My wife had gone here before (without me) and raved about how good it was and so we finally got around to trying it together. We ordered takeout, and the pizza was ready right when we arrived, but still very warm, so they clearly had the timing right! We ordered the Meateater's and it was delicious and so filling! They do not hold back on the toppings. In this case, though, I did find that with all the meats on there, it was a little bit greasy. I don't believe there's anything the restaurant could do to change this, that's just the price you pay when you get a meat heavy pizza. We will certainly be coming back and you all should try it too! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Meateater's - Pizza Near Me - Tacoma, Washington

Overall a really good experience at Farrelli's Pizza. The service/staff were all nice and courteous, but absent at time. Asking for a refill on beverages went a little bit longer than we would have liked. The pizzas were really good. We all had more slices than we could actually stomach. We did the "one bite, everybody knows the rules" approach, and the pizza definitely didn't disappoint. Definitely a 7.7. Great location and view. Overall a really good experience. read more

See all

It was open late, no wait, and fit the bill for pizza and a beer. The pizza was ok, not memorable. We asked for Shaker cheese and received packets and also a side of hot honey. Tried one of their beers on draft. They offered a sample which was nice. read more

We stopped by Farrelli's today. Our experiences have always been good. The staff was friendly, as usual. Two things that bothered me, however. First, and most importantly, my daughter got the kids meal with cheesy breadsticks. She kept telling me they tasted like olive oil or something was off. Finally, I tried them and there was a ranch dressing under the cheese on top of the bread. Not good at all! She did not eat it. I probably should have said something, but we were pretty far along in our meal at that point. The second thing is that my favorite menu item is the veggie pizza. Where is it? I saw the margherita (which I ended up getting by default) and the Mediterranean. So sad not to see my fave. Anyhow, I can handle me not getting what I want, although not happily, but am sad when my kid is displeased (and rightfully so). Darn. read more

See all

We love the fresh tossed pizzas. The pasta meals are great. We love the service and the environment. Great place to watch football games too. read more

Really good pizza! I definitely recommend it! They have to be using better ingredients than most places too because I don't have a negative reaction like I do after some pizza! read more

Happy Hour! Prices are fair, sat in bar area, bartender Faith was kind, works with a sense of urgency, and is helpful. Bring your cash for pull tabs as the ATM isn't working at the moment. Full large screen TVs in the bar. Good spacious tables. Food came out fresh, beer and drinks came out cold. Food came out quickly. Keep in mind this is happy hour times on a Monday in mid October as the rain is pouring outside. Music isn't too loud and the ambiance is calm. I recommend checking them out if you are out in the area. read more

I am born and raised here and I love to support our businesses and I have always loved to come here with the kids but I have to make this post because this needs to be taken more serious. I came in late with my Husband before a movie and ordered a gluten free vegan pizza a salad and a drink for him. we ate sat there for 30 min then paid and tipped well. As we are getting up to leave the waitress comes over and tells me the pizza we just ate was acrually a wheat pizza Not a gluten free crust. The waitress clearly put it in the order and somewhere down that line someone didn't read it and just made whatever they wanted? No one came and gave us a refund no manager came out to talk to us when they clearly knew they messed up. I will never go back because it's ridiculous how much of a point I made it and how completely over looked it was. I get it if I cant trust food I shouldn't eat there. if you are celiac DO NOT eat here. I have been puking blood since 12. No thanks. read more

I typically only come here for HH because it's never busy at this location. Pizzas are 25% off which is nice because they recently raised prices. You might as well just pay $30 plus for a 16 inch pizza rather than $18 for a personal size. Just my opinion. Service is good and pizzas are made pretty fast considering they are wood fired. Can't beat the cheap large mug of beer for $5.50. read more

See all

Cindy was a great server. Kids Alfredo was 5* approved by my kiddo. Canzone was a great option outside of pizza. Good pizza place right on the middle of Tacoma. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Kids Menu Chicken Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Tacoma, Washington

See all

They updated their pasta menu in an obvious attempt to be uniform in their options probably due to costs. This changed ruined their pasta options. No one wants cavatappi noodles. It's all noodle, no saMy go-to meal is no longer an option. This is my only yelp review ever that's how upset I am. I will come back when my pasta is back to normal. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tacoma, Washington

This was supposedly the National Winner. Not enough sauce, cream cheese hardly relevant and Honey? Pretty sure there wasn't any. Pepperoni (due to demand) less than relevant and there were NO red pepper flakes... I.am TIRED of paying 23.00 for a 12 inch pizza thay is NEVER as ordered! I'd rather go to Half Pint! Cheaper, better quality, get what you order and WORTH what you pay. Farellis, aim breaking up with you. Your point system, app and rewards DONT WORK....ever. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - National Winner disappointed - Pizza Near Me - Tacoma, Washington

28 June 2024 11:18pm Farrelli's pizza of the month of June I really enjoyed was called The Eye of The Tiger. Server named Kaijah H was super pleasant to me. I ordered a personal size pizza and two refreshing beverages while waiting for my order. I had a really stressful and chaotic day at work so it was nice that it was quiet in there. Kaijah H had a great smile on her face and her customer service was excellent. I will definitely return to the 6th Avenue location. Thank you, Kaijah H! read more

I was on my way for a nice cup o' decaf at Valhalla Coffee down the street when I decided on a whim to watch the game a bit here. Nice spacious pizza joint. Big standard sports-oriented bar area on left, standard dining area on right and center kitchen area in-between with building restrooms down far right hallway. Fairly run-of-the-mill vegan options which isn't bad; always great in a pinch or convenient. In this case, just convenient. Got my coffee, the game happened to be on, as well, so let's check 'er out. Gimme a custom 12" red sauce no ch33se with a handful of veggie variety and basil/herbs fresh at the end. Super bummer for no oregano(!). Pizza and no oregano is no bueno. They did manage some parsley. While my coffee run took a bit long (grabbed it while I waited), the server put my pizza under a heat window thing which wilted my fresh basil. She gladly brought me some fresh extra. Apparently my pizza tray wasn't cleaned sufficiently as beneath one slice I discovered a melted cheese thumb print from a past order. Overall the waitress was pleasantly friendly if a bit slow and a bit underwhelming flavor. Great selection & angle for watching games, though. That sharp bump past the driveway is rather gnarly; get that fixed. read more

5 because this is a pizza place and not geared towards their other food Pizza- bacon chicken ranch with jalapeno cream cheese base absolutely delightful Appetizer fire sticks- so good. Great with ranch Big ol mug - original mix. So good. Decent amount of alcohol in it! Pasta was subpar, my partner ordered the Italian Mac and cheese. Service was great, nice family restaurant! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Food - Pizza Near Me - Tacoma, Washington

I explained so many times about my celiac disease to my waitress that I felt that comfortably she could deliver me a bread, free meal. I ordered a salad and it came with a triangular piece of bread laid all on top. The salad had to be returned and a new salad had to be made, which was delivered 23 minutes later after everyone else in my party had eaten. Lettuce was pink and brown dying. Thanks for a horrible Mother's Day dinner (on Saturday) The place wasn't that busy. Only 1 tea refill offered. Someone in the building needs to know what salad dressings/options are gluten-free so the ordering process can be easier.... Clearly, clueless, waitress, sad that the whole entire salad had to be wasted. It looked beautiful otherwise read more

We were told by three different restaurants that we would have to wait almost an hour on a Saturday afternoon, which made sense but also made us hungry. Luckily, Farrelli's Pizza had a 20-30 minute wait so we gave our information. I never got a text so we went in near the time that we were supposed to get one, and the hostess told us that she sent a text just now but I still have not received it so be wary. We had a party of 5 but they gave us a table for 8. Our waitress Jami was an absolute sweetheart who genuinely cares about her customers. She was attentive to not only our table but other tables as well. She was patient and knowledge as well. We orders 2 strawberry lemonades, 12" deluxe classic, 12" James' Favorite, Meatballs Marinara, Sweet chili and garlic boneless wings, and bread sticks. The lemonades were the best, they remind of Red Robin's Freckled Lemonade but with more strawberry flavor. The pizzas were absolutely divine, especially the deluxe classic! The appetizers were also wonderful, and the boneless wings were so juicy and flavorful! We want to come back to try more like the pastas and desserts! They also have a rewards program and you get $10 immediately when you sign up! They also have free wifi as well! read more

See all

I just went there for the first time, I have to say that it is my new favorite pizza. Our waitress was very nice and the place was so clean, and the pizza was amazing. read more

Cooked to perfection even after waiting still so fucking good!! Definitely will order from here again! Even called to let them know the pizza was good and they answered the phone very fast and was also happy about the call read more

Service is great im writing this while in the restaurant but the waiter was amazing his name was Bradley L he seemed overwhelmed but he didnt stop serving with kindness read more

I come here for the sweet chili wings. They be smacking every time! The pizza is good too. Their staff is friendly. The establishment is clean. read more

Great service and food. Daelynn at the bar took great care of us and very pleasant server. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Spinach Artichoke Dip and Bonterra Rose - Pizza Near Me - Tacoma, Washington

See all

Ok so I'm sad to post a one star. Farellis. We love loved coming here for date night and getting the italia pizza. We loved the bits of loose sausage and the thick strips of old world pepperoni. The bits of parsley and best were the mama lil peppers added to make this pizza one of a kind and absolutely top shelf..., bur we came in this past Friday and we're told that the italia pizza no longer came w mama Lil .. now it's pepperoncini. No big deal right...WRONG... big deal! Not only was there no peppers but the thinly sliced the old work pepperoni... no sausage. Saddest pizza ever. Not worth the 38$. Won't be going back. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - The new version of the Italia- sucks - Pizza Near Me - Tacoma, Washington

Ordered a pizza to go. It's supposed to have caramelized onions on it, has pickled onions all over. It smells disgusting and the pizza is gross even with picking them off. Very disappointed. read more

I take my elderly mother here frequently because she has a gluten and dairy intolerance so the Dairy Free cheese and Cauliflower crust are go-to's for us. We came in today and sat in the bar. We ordered drinks and then had a few other questions that the bartender checked on for us. After being there for about 20 min and ordering our food the bartender returned and advised there was no dairy free cheese in house. Super bummed that we weren't notified sooner. After she repeatedly asked me if we wanted the pizza sans cheese (the reason why we come here and pay the exorbitant prices is because of the allergen options, a pizza isn't a pizza without cheese!) I told her we'd have to head over to Ruston Farelli's. We were brought a bill for the beer I had. I'm sad to see how far downhill this place has come. I'm a restaurant manager, eat the $7 for the beer and keep a customer coming back. To make matters worse, the service at Pt. Ruston was even worse. We were 1 of 3 tables in the bar. I really wanted to come and have a nice lunch but after 2 Farelli's visits it was apparent that wasn't happening today. read more

The staff was great and very nice! They checked what items were gluten free for me. But I asked for the Mamas mediterranean with no olives and it was covered in it. I was greatly disappointed. We got it to go and our pizza was cold and we only live 6 minutes away. I've been to the Lacey one and had a great experience. I may try this location again but to be determined. read more

Love going here and eating a pizza and having a Margueritas. Also love sitting by the fire but it has been broken the last two times we have been in there. read more

The pizza dough tasted raw. I ordered the pizza around 11:30 in the morning and when I got it the pizza was cold the ham tasted sour the cheese wasn't cooked all the way and the dough was raw. I spent 19$ on this individual size pizza. Was not worth it. Threw half of it away read more

I went here the evening of February 18th and I must I had some of the greatest service I have ever had! You ever go somewhere and service is "so" good that you end up ordering more and more food! lol I don't know if Farreli's was banking on me doing this, but let's just say I won't have any car insurance for this month! On this occasion I had the happy hour all meat pizza (with salami substituted for jalapeño's). It was "amazing"! The toppings were fresh, the meat was extremely flavorful, and jalapeño were perfectly pickled! I want to go back just thinking about it! While the pizza's here can get a bit expensive we went during happy hour so the pizza which would've normally been about $14 for a personal size was half off so it was a good deal. My friends ordered the spicy Italian which they said was "super" good and the loaded mac and cheese which they also said was really good. We also tried the hot wings which were some of the "best pizza joint" (oven baked wings) I have ever tired! Needless to say I "will" be back! PROS: - Service, Service, Service - Great Food - Nice interior - Incredible wings for being oven baked CONS: - Can be expensive - Kind of dead on weak nights read more

See all

This was my favorite place to go and its 2-3minutes away from my house. Wife and I used to go here every Thursday. But today I ordered the ice cream chocolate chuck cookie sammie (warmed up chocolate chip cookies, ice cream, carmel drizzle, chocolate drizzle, and oreo cookie crumble to go which took 45 mins to get it. It came out not put together, not warm, and missing toppings. I get it that I ask for it togo but to not even make it at all just a bunch of side items to put together, nooo I don't want that. Waitress nicely offered to remake it and ask if I still wanted it to go since we were staying now. First it took 45 more minutes to come out. Second it came out with the cookies not warm and missing toppings, dressed on a plate. The more I go here the more I not like this place. I still tipped my waitress though. Probably won't go here any more. read more

This place is really close to home and convenient. The staff are fun to talk to, they know their stuff. They recently added Deep Eddy Lime vodka to their menu. I am not a vodka fan, but this one is sweeter than any I've previously had. It goes well with grapefruit. Plus the bottle and vodka is green, and it's certified gluten free! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Deep Eddy lime with both grapefrui soda and grapefruit tonic! Perfect combination of sweet and sour! - Pizza Near Me - Tacoma, Washington

Since the farrellis pizza in Ruston was a two hour wait with two kiddos that wasn't going to be an option so we went to the next best thing ! Definitely a complete different vibe , way smaller atmosphere, only a few booths and tables for the family side . The quality of food was still pretty good I enjoyed my personal pizza and my husband had the Beer cheese Philly pizza devoured that ! So they brought out my youngest kids first which would of been better to wait for both since Elijah is only 1 and Atticus is 3, my older is sitting there asking me "why I have no food and he's hungry " when he's watching his younger brother eat Mac and cheese . Also the guy dropped it off with no spoon as we had to flag down someone to give us a Spoon, then they gave the "wrong Mac and cheese " it was supposed to be for the adorable gal behind us but my kid already put his hand in it and was already trying to chow down . Young servers and expos which I give endless respect too but I definitely prefer the larger one better being in the back looked dark may add some mood lighting ? and the lighter open airy section was for the bar only which kinda was sad since families enjoy looking outside too ! I will definitely eat endless pizzas from here and the kiddos ate their food ! Still a yummy experience! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Create your own - Pizza Near Me - Tacoma, Washington

I love Farrelli's usually, but my most recent experience has left a bad taste in my mouth. I called in an order at 3:30 pm for four pizzas to be picked up at 5:30 pm for my sister's engagement party with our family. I got there at 5:15 pm and I was told they were just coming out of the oven. 15 minutes go by, then 30 (I was trying to be patient because it was busy). At 5:45 pm I asked for an update. I explained the situation and the worker said she'd check... and I never heard from her again. Another customer waiting asked me if I'd ordered a certain pizza and I said yes, and he's the one who told me they lost it. Never heard from a worker again other than asking me to pay. I get it, you're busy. But the lack of communication was laughable and I won't be eating there again. I was late to the engagement party I was hosting for my sister and the first thing I heard about the pizza was that it was cold. Thanks, Farrelli's. It was a night I'll never forget. read more

I went here yesterday on my birthday And it was okay.. we were greeted by a REALLY nice waiter, but the food wasn't that good. I just wouldn't come here again. We got the biggest meat eaters pizza and it had huge slices of ham on it which made the whole pizza taste like a ham pizza! They should cut down the ingredients more! Do not try the salsa!!! Omg! It honestly tasted really bad like they put fish sauce or something in it!! We also found 2 penne noodles in our nachos ? So that's kinda strange. You can see the penne noodle in the nachos picture! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tacoma, Washington

See all

I ordered online from the Farrelli's on 176th in Fredrickson, WA and somehow, they didn't realize that they didn't have a door dash driver assigned to my order almost an hour later. So, I called and talked to the manager Max, and he told me that he was sorry and that they were remaking our food and sending it out ASAP. So, we got our food 15 minutes after that and a surprise as well! Thank you, Max, for the 6-layer death by chocolate cake it was enjoyed by the entire staff! This folks is true customer service. When a company goes above and beyond without being asked to do so but because they want to make up for an inconvenience. In this day and age, it is a rarity. Thank you Farrelli's for the great service. Kerry Nicholls read more