Very nice people and the food was amazing. And the restaurant was very clean and maintained.

Excellent enchiladas served with rice, beans and sliced fresh avocado, with a nice red sauce and melted cheese. Friendly service and decent prices. The food was piping hot and delicious. The restaurant is also next door to Ofelia's Bakery which is a real winner. read more

El Pastorcito - Enchiladas de pollo with red sauce - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Was looking for a spot to ease that Mexican food craving and found this spot in a small strip center not to far away from home. Due to the favorable Yelp reviews here I am. It is a tiny spot with six booth tables and four, four top tables. Simple interior with ceramic tile floor and wainscot. There are two decorative wood awnings, and two flat screen TV's with dueling shows. When I walked in I was greeted by a friendly and helpful waitress, I placed my Togo order and waited with an ice cold Diet Coke. We ordered the chicken fajitas and they were well prepared and quite tasty! This is a great neighborhood spot with good food! read more

El Pastorcito - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Decent food, fast service on a weeknight. We ordered huevos rancheros and carne asada. When we got there only one other table but it quickly filled up. Food came out quickly. Only one server but she was efficient. Will try there again. read more

I honestly didn't expect to give this place a 5 star rating when I ordered take out, but what a pleasant surprise! I ordered a vegetarian burrito, side order of refried beans and chips with pico and guacamole. In the dead of winter, everything was so fresh and it was clearly made from scratch. The guacamole was the real thing and no weird creamy filler (as some restaurants add, which is a real pet peeve of mine). I was very impressed with the burrito, which was filled with fajita style veggies and Mexican cheese...it also came with rice as a side! The portions were HUGE, I had 2 full meals from the order. Their prices can't be beat, either! I can't speak to their authenticity (I'm a born and raised Indiana gal) but the flavors and freshness will keep me coming back. read more

See all

Tried El Pastocito for the first time and had the pastor tacos. Excellent flavor, decent price, friendly proprietors. I'll be back again soon! read more

Walked in, the waitress made eye contact with me and walked to the back, so I sat myself - nobody came out to greet me. My friend joined me and we sat for a few, their were two other tables who had menu and drinks - we left b/c a racist establishment such as this will not receive our money. read more

El Pastorcito - Store Front - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Definitely a solid spot. Food was authentic, minus the chips, which I had seen in other reviews. I love the chip brand they serve though so I could care less about that. Guac was fresh and had good chunks of avo. I got 2 Al Pastor and 1 carnitas tacos. Both were good. The carnitas had a bit of char on the edges which gave it a little crisp which I was a big fan of. I would have liked to see more pineapple chunks in the pastor, but that seems to be lacking in the Indy area. Not my favorite Mexican spot in the area, but have to give them credit for the authenticity and great taste! read more

El Pastorcito - Al Pastor Taco - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Another good dish... Marjolla del a Diabla. Yummy. Full perch scored and fried in Diabla sauce. Perfectly cooked and happily supplemented with tortillas and fresh picante. Happy Hombre'. This was served with rice and accompanied tomato lettuce onion and lime wedges. read more

El Pastorcito - Enchiladas Lunch Special - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Love this place! It's a little hole in the wall on the west side but it's amazing and so authentic!! I been going to this location for the past 7 years! It's worth the trip! They have one of the best horchatas! A definite must try! read more

El Pastorcito - El molcajete - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The lady that takes your order was really nice but about it there was a cockroach in the wall the guy that's in the kitchen did not seemed very happy, do not recommend this place at all. read more

Good authentic Mexican grub. We had the chicken fajitas and chicken quesadilla. They brought out a carousel of salsas (salsa verde, tomatilla salsa, pico de gallo) but it didn't have the usual salsa served in most Mexican restaurants which was a bummer to me but others in my party enjoyed it. The tomatilla salsa was SUPER spicy, so be forewarned!! The queso was watery and pretty disappointing. The corn tortillas for the fajitas were super good. Overall it's a decent place to grab a bite of Mexican cuisine and I would probably return if I am in this area again. read more

El Pastorcito - Carousel of salsas. The red one is HOT! Beware! - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Secluded little gem with Authentic Mexican flavors. In my never-ending quest for the best tacos in Indy, a friend and I visited El Pastorcito on an early Saturday evening and were pleasently surprised by the foods authenticity and freshiness. I went straight for the street tacos (corn tortilla, onions, cilantro) and had the El Pastor, Lengua, Carnitas, Barbacoba, and Suadero. Tacos arrived on freshly made tortillas with your traditional lime...And slices of fresh radish and cucumber which provided a nice change in pallet to the tacos, providing that crisp fresh taste you want (something I've never seen in a Mexican restaurant in the states before). Flavors were on Point! Especially the El pastor and the Lengua, both of which were perfectly cooked and seasoned. The other tacos we're good, but didn't wow me as much as the El pastor and Lengua. Interestingly, Pastorcito does NOT provide Free chips and salsa like your usual Tex Mex. Instead it's 1.99 for an order of chips and salsa. Do yourself a favor, and just order the chips and salsa. Sure, the chips are quite literally from a bag (like tostitos chips), but the salsa verde and pico de gallo are Fantastic! Though the red salsa wasnt my favorite as it was a bit bitter due to the peppers they used, they did try to balance that by sweetening it with pineapple juice. However, the salsa verde was fresh and acidic, providing that great lime and cilantro flavor. And the pico de gallo was perfectly seasoned, just enough salt and acid to bring out the flavors of the tomatoes and onions. Yea, the chips came from a bag....but who hasn't devoured a bag of tostitos... they're delicious! So coupling that with some stellar salsas, and the 1.99 is well worth it. Ok, there have been a lot of compliants on Yelp about the service at Pastorcito, and I get it. But you have to realize that 1) the constantly checking-on-you service we get in American restaurants is NOT the norm around the world, and 2) Not all of the service staff speak or understand English well. So be proactive but respectful when you need something. Flag/Wave down your waitress and they will come to you. Since they weren't busy when we visited, I literally got up and walked over to the waitress who was busy in the kitchen to ask for things. I do so respectfully and was met with friendly and immediate attention. If you know this before going in, you'll be quite satisfied with the service. Also the menu has been updated from other previous yelp reviews, so this review includes the most updated version as of April 27th. All in all, I'll definitely be checking out Pastorcito again. I still won't crown it as the best taco shop in Indy, but it's definitely up there. Check it out and enjoy yourself! read more

See all

Terrific hole in the wall taco joint. I'm tired of these pseudo-fancy taquerias that think if they have hardwood floors and chevre cheese on their menu that they can charge $4 for a tiny taco. When I get tacos, I'm not looking for arugula. Give me goat. Give me tongue. Give me tripe. For under $3. That's exactly what this place does. My wife and I had dinner here for $20...tax and tip included. Can't beat that. I would advise against getting their quest fundido, though. It's just microwaved shredded cheese. I do highly recommend the chips and salsa though. It comes with green tomatillo salsa, tomato salsa and pico de gallo. read more

My boyfriend and I were looking for some good eats in the area so this became, I think, the first restaurant I've visited based solely on its Yelp reviews. Unfortunately, it left me wanting. El Pastorcito is tucked inside a strip mall on 79th & Michigan. At 5:00 on a Wednesday evening, we were the only diners inside the clean, orange stucco-interior establishment. I was surprised to see two "dining" rooms. I say "dining" because I definitely noticed a pool table, so I'm not sure if room #2 actually houses many patrons. The super bonus of the evening was that El Pastorcito has horchata, which is pretty rare in Indy. Not only this, but they make it in-house! Whaaaat! This was like when Tim Curry finds the lost city of Zinj in Congo, but without the ultra violent gorillas. Man, I was excited. (I realize that Congo is a terrible movie that's 15 years old and therefore pretty much irrelevant, but it's on Netflix and I couldn't help myself, okay?) I'm also not ashamed to admit that my entire reason for choosing El Pastorcito was because they serve brain tacos. Seeing myself as adventurous and never having had brain, I knew it was destiny. As someone mentioned earlier, chips do not magically appear at your table. $1.25 or so buys you a basket of tortilla chips they pour out of a bag, and honestly I only had about five of them. They just weren't very good. If you're going to charge for tortilla chips (something that's generally on the house), learn to make and fry them yourselves. This would make it worth the additional charge. I ordered the carnitas en salsa verde (pork meat in green sauce) along with one of the aforementioned brain tacos, and my boyfriend ordered the carne enchilada (spicy steak with rice and beans). Our food arrived piping hot not too long after. While my carnitas were generally pretty appetizing, I had two or three large chunks of nothing but solid fat. And don't get me wrong, this girl loves marbled meat. But I don't want a whole piece of pork fat that's slightly larger than a tblsp of stick butter. The carne enchilada is no standard wrapped enchilada covered with red sauce. It's literally what the menu states - some strips of "spicy" steak with a side of rice and beans and a plate of tortillas. Dry steak and no spice here. Wah wah. In regards to the brain taco: I can't say much about how it fared on a scale of 1-10 as I'd never eaten it before. I suppose I'd describe it as a hot, seasoned slightly creamy gelatin. Needless to say, the texture doesn't bode well in taco form unless you stuff it with some onions and tomatoes for a crunch factor. I LOVE lengua (tongue) tacos, but brain just isn't for me. I do want to make note that the waitress was friendly and attentive, though she had no other tables at the time. All in all, a completely lack luster experience which makes me a little sad because I was so excited to go based on previous reviews. Nothing here put me totally off, but I don't think I'll have a reason to go back. Sad. Face. read more

See all

Always delicious. Best kept secret

Large portions with not large prices? Yay! I'm a fan. Friday is go out to lunch day at work so I came here with my coworkers. Lunch averaged about $10 per person after tax and tip. Not too bad for a restaurant with waiter service! I had the chicken enchiladas rojas- so good. The three enchiladas came with a salad, rice, and refried beans. When your food comes out, so does a trio of dipping sauces: a spicy red pepper sauce (and boy is it HOT), a green salsa, and pico de gallo. Refried beans are one of my favorite foods and El Pastorcito had the best refried beans I've ever had. I could have had a meal of solely refried beans. Now I want them again since I've been thinking about them. I'm glad we gave this place a try! read more

El Pastorcito - Trio of dipping sauces: pico de gallo, salsa verde, and something really hot - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

A bustling joint on a Friday night! We had tacos and our fave were the chorizo and the carnitas. The chorizo had amazing flavor and texture, the carnitas were so tender! Tacos are simply dressed with onions and cilantro, as they should be. Roja and verde salsa on the table to compliment were good. Simple dining area, friendly waitress, great food. read more

El Pastorcito - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Authentic and delicious food with great service. This is a must once a week if you like good fresh food!

Bad service! Do not recommend. The lady that takes care of the customers is rude and acts like she doesn't want to be there.

This is one of my absolute favorite taquerias in Indy. The owners even indulge me in selling me meats by the 1/4lb. The lengua (tongue), tripa (tripe), cabeza (head), barbacoa (goat), and sesos (brain) are all so phenomenal I have trouble picking just two each time I go. It's all cooked absolutely perfectly, and the taste transports you to Mexico. Their salsas are fantastic, and the menudo is decadent. The nopales are a bit slimy, but worth it (IMHO). For years, this place was my absolute favorite place, and I've only found two (one central and one south) that even compare. Take some time to visit one of the two locations -- they're both fantastic! read more

Unlike many of the taquerias in the area, this is a full-fledged restaurant, with table service and fountain drinks. The tacos were freshly made and generously proportioned, but not extremely flavorful. They bring a bowl of pico de gallo with your order, which was very good, along with cucumber and radish slices. For flavor, I would go to Super Taco or Antojitos on this same corner, but for a full service restaurant experience, I would go here. read more

The best Mexican place we've found since moving here from L.A. two years ago. The carne asada tacos are legit. The queso fundido is AMAZING. Feels like home when we come here. read more

My favorite Mexican food in Indianapolis. I love the pastor burrito and quesadilla. I've been to there only for take out about 10 times.

Very much an authentic Mexican restaurant. If your fluent in Spanish you will love this place. Everyone we saw in this restaurant spoke Spanish and they had Spanish Karaoke. The food choice were normal to crazy. They have Brain, tongue, and Goat.. We had Chicken Fajitas. Our individual reviews of the food: Chicken Fajitas 3/5 Refried beans 4/5 Rice 4.5/5. Fiancé reviewed this Chips and salsa 1/5 The Chips come with 3 salsa's or sauces but none of them are very good. Also I believe they charge for the chips and salsa. The Chips and Salsa is like the bread and butter of Mexican resturants so it was kinda a dissapointment there. The rest of the food was pretty good and very filling. read more

El Pastorcito - Chicken Fajitas and the chips and 3 salsas - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We eat a lot of Mexican. This place was disappointing. Chips literally from a bag. Steak fajitas were chewy and gross. Large group and nobody was impressed. Guacamole was good. read more

Excellent burrito, tamales, and rice. The tomato slices and shredded lettuce were very fresh. Good prices. Bilingual menu. Waitress spoke English very well. Appetizer chips are not included in meal prices, so they're not automatic. But the prices are so good, it takes that into account. I was the only dine-in customer about 6:00 pm, but there were several carry-out customers. The meal came with a refrigerated sampler of 3 salsas: a chipotle type sauce, a green sauce, and pico-de-gallo. All 3 were excellent. I really, really, really liked that burrito; it was a large portion, excellent value. My meal was served on a real ceramic (not disposable) plate, and the utensils were stainless steel (not disposable). read more

LOVE THIS PLACE!! First off, GET THE CHIPS AND SALSA!! The chips are these great thick chips that are great for dipping into their 3 sauces. Notice I said sauces...not salsas. The orange one in delicious, the pico de gallo looking one has just the right amount of cilantro and I don't know what the tomatilla one is, but it's great as well. The last time I went I got the fajitas and they are HANDS DOWN the best fajitas I've ever had. I chose chicken but my friend got the chicken, steak, and shrimp ones. We both devoured ALL OF IT. Go here. Eat well. And don't be scared when you see tongue on the menu. Just because it's there, doesn't mean you have to eat it. read more

The food is really great, and the food is generally served with three different kinds of salsa, depending on what you order if you're dining in. The last time I was there, I had the carne enchilada, but there's a lot on the menu that's very good, and there's quite the diversity of items on there (including beef tongue and tripe, if that piques your fancy). Everything I've tried there is good. I was very surprised how inexpensive this restaurant was, considering the portions you receive, as well. If you're in the mood for Mexican, it's a solid bet. read more

If you're looking for endless chips and "salsa" or runny cheese and chili sauce before your smothered burrito, you probably aren't looking to eat at El pastorcito. This restaurant is real Mexican offering different regional options. There are a number of Tex-mex or Ameri-mex options on the northwest side of Indy that may be a better option for you. El pastorcito carries your typical Mexican quick food such a street tacos and tortas, They also offer large burritos that seems to be a necessity in American Mexican restaurants. The filling are pretty typical for authentic street tacos. The chips that they have available are hearty corn chips for dipping and not the standard thin wheat chips offered at many places. The chips (if you choose to order them) are great with the homemade guacamole and the trio of pico and 2 salsas that are brought with them. The chips can be used to scoop beans and the salsa can be spread over other food, if you choose. Also offered are authentic Mexican seafood dishes in various combinations with various sauces. Dishes more typical of the costal regions of Mexico. The hearty dinners of various meats in different styles and sauces plus rice and beans (in most cases) provide a lot of food. My go-to dinner is the mole poblano. Bring an appetite for all of the meals. Don't overlook the daily specials that are offered. Many times there are fish, rabbit, pigeon dishes offered on the special board. Also offered often are pozole and menudo good for cold winter days. The only issue I have is that they do not offer tamales and sopes on a more regular basis (both items show up on their specials menu). read more

The absolute worst Mexican food I've ever had in my life. I ordered queso and the sent out microwaved cheese that was in a puddle of oil. Horrible service too. I seriously recommend not going. read more

El Pastorcito - Their "queso" so disgusting - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This food is cheap, delicious, and quick. Perfect little lunch spot if you work in the area. Eat here a couple times a month and have had consistently good food each time. Chips are extra here -- just a warning. It is worth ponying up the extra 1.5 dollars because a trio of delicious sauces (green, orange, and pico) come out with the meal. Always want to try a torta (5-6 dollars) but haven't gotten past the delicious taco (2 dollars -- sometimes on special for less) section of the menu. The decor is bare bones but the flavor, good service, and quick food make up it easily. read more

Really interesting find. Going out for lunch with a colleague and wanted to try something new. Not a very attractive store front and interior is dated. One TV running Mexican programs all the time. Only one young chef and a elderly lady was waiting and managing front desk. We ordered chicken and beef tacos and they were delicious. The price is very reasonable; under $10. This place is unassuming but serve really good food. Worth the try, read more

Honestly - I was craving Mexican food... and this was the closest spot I could find. My review (my being up front) may or may not hold water. When I want Mexican food, I want El Rodeo or something similar. El Pastorcito may be more authentic Mexican food - but if it is... I'm just not a fan. The service was really good, but they only serve beer. No wine and no other alcohol is served. read more

By fair the best authentic Mexican restaurant in Indy so far yet. If you enjoy real Mexican and are a foodie of foods that aren't get for the American taste buds, then let your soul glow read more

El Pastorcito - The first time I tried brains. Not too bad. Rich and creamy. - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I came to try the molcajete dinner, there was flavorless no taste at all,, i didn't eat much,, very, customer service was petty low,, the waitress never showed up to check our table,,, this is the first time and last time on this place read more

I was wanting some good Mexican food and was reading the reviews on yelp plus I saw that they deliver with Door Dash. 1st door dash is awesome. Secondly the food was Hot,fresh, and very generous portions for the money. I work with a Hispanic coworker and she ordered as well and that it was authentic and good. They have a lot to choose from so I will be ordering again soon read more

Food is good. But I never feel welcome here. Im a BF. Slow service and I was ignored for a long time, however those that spoke Spanish were greeted with smiles and prompt service. Not returning. read more

I basically went here after looking through places in the area on Yelp. I like trying strange foods, so the brain, tongue, and goat tacos peaked me interest. They were all definitely edible. The place was very clean. It is definitely a place that would serve you well to know Spanish, but I do not and still managed fine. Overall it was fun to try something new, but I tried them and then moved on to a "normal" restaurant for dinner. read more

A total disappointment. Watery cheese sauce, flavorless steak tacos, tiny shrimp quesadillas, old pico de gallo. Don't waste your money.