Don't let the negative reviews fool you, this place is great! We just arrived back on the island for new years and this was our first stop. It is as good as we remember it. It's cheap, great pizza. Don't pass the opportunity to eat wonderful pizza read more

Had the eggplant parm sandwich. Greasy, battered and fried, not baked, barely any sauce. Bread was good. Thats about it. Fries were greasy and undercooked. Staff was friendly enough but didn't have to hear (loudly) about a boyfriend's suing her for defamation and other issues of the day. Wish I had read the other reviews before coming here. read more

Edgartown Pizza - Greasy fried "Eggplant parm" with a scant layer of sauce on the roll, atop greasy fries. - Pizza Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Best pizza. Best service, best ambiance , simple the better! Melhor pizza, atendimento ótimo read more

Forget about this place. A friend picked up a whole pie. Half plain and half with pepperoni. Worst pie we ever had. Slices were like wet noodles. The pepperoni slices were the only decent thing. 1 STAR. read more

Edgartown Pizza - Forget about this pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Great pizza with integrity! We had two thin crust pizzas. Thin crust pizzas with ample ample fresh toppings, a meat lovers and a veggie pizza were delicious. Edgartown Pizza staff have high integrity as I lost my credit card in the pizza parlor and a customer returned it to EP staff who kept it for 4 days and returned it when I called. " Yes, we have it." " Hallelujah!" I was monitoring the credit card and there were no fraudulent charges. I thanked and tipped the staff. The pizza with integrity was great. read more

Uncooked crust. Had to throw it in the oven when we got home. Very disappointing after a solid experience the other day

Edgartown Pizza, congratulations! Worst meat lovers pizza of my life. I will leave another review when you're dethroned.

Poor customer service. The guy that served me was very rude for no reason. I can see they don't like black people. Their pizza is tasteless after all. They need to do something else. The pizza is not working out for them. So nasty This guy place the pizza on the other table while I was seated behind that table. How rude! How arrogant. Kmt read more

It was pretty awful. The pizza showed up an hour and half later and was cold. Sad part is that I don't think it would have tasted much better had been hot or even warm. read more

The most disgusting pizza I have ever had. it looked burned and didn't look like it would be that bad but it was soggy and WET it ripped and fall apart when I picked it up. I actually ACTUALLY started to gag on my second bite and through the rest out. I wanted to tell them how bad it was I can't believe how terrible it was read more

I ordered a slice of pizza and the cashier replied "did you want a large" to which I replied "yes please". She did not tell me I was ordering AN ENTIRE PIZZA. She didn't bother telling me they didn't sell pizzas by the slices. Then I was stuck with a large pizza when I was driving a mopped. I explained this to her and she didn't apologize or even try to make things better. I'm extremely disappointed. read more

So we usually have Edgartown House of Pizza once during our yearly visit to the island. It has been predictable and decent. Well. We got in yesterday and ordered dinner late - a cheese pizza, a veggie pizza and a meatball sub. The sub and cheese pizza were standard. The star of the show was the veggie! It was loaded with veggies, the crust was crisp and it was so cheesy and delicious. I think we ordered extra cheese. The best veggie pizza I have ever had. We are from Boston and we enjoy amazing Italian food and pizza from the North End. This veggie pizza was beyond the beyond. We ordered online through the app and we received notice that the order was pushed back because they were busy - which I totally get because it is a Saturday night. Well done Edgartown HOP! read more

I have been here numerous times and enjoyed the pizza every time , most recently the veggie pizza. The dough was a bit thicker than my preference but it was tasteful and fresh. Our toppings were plentiful and the combo cheese of cheddar and mozzarella were very complementary to the veggies and sauce. The veggie included broccoli spinach artichoke and mushrooms. A local place- not fancy and not pretentious read more

Edgartown Pizza - Veggie pie with spinach, broccoli, mushrooms and artichoke - Pizza Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Ordered pizza for delivery. It was abt 45 min late. It was cold. It wasn't good at all, lesson learned.

Just awful pizza. Old fashioned frozen Elios' pizza is better. I think they steam the pizza rather than bake it. It was soggy. My son had a slice and a half, looked at me and said "i feel ill". We just threw it out. The price is low for here so I understand you get what you pay for. Of course I'm never going back but I would have paid double for better. read more

We eat a lot of pizza and I hate to say it but this pizza was terrible! It was totally rubbery and difficult to eat, first of all, but more importantly it literally had no taste. Ordered a whole pie for the fam, we ate half and threw the rest away. Wish I'd read the reviews before coming here. read more

Pizza was good & staff was friendly. I'd give a 4 stars for pizza but giving five stars because of service & creative fun menue with some Brazilian twists read more

Vegan pizza was amazing!!! They have vegan cheese and we loaded up on veggies. One of the best vegan pizzas I've ever had.

I found some reviews that said this is good ... Perhaps if you never had pizza in ny Philadelphia or New Jersey before Barely cooked Barely edible It appears to be a frozen pizza on the style of Ellio's Huge disappointment read more

Amazing achievement , Edgartown Pizza manages to burn the crust yet still produce a tasteless soggy pizza with uncooked toppings.

I can't believe how a business can mess up a pizza but this place does that. Ordered a half buffalo chicken and half barbecue chicken pizza. The pizza took quite awhile ans when it came out there was a thin crust, some sauce, overcooked cheese and one half indeed did have prices of BBQ chicken but the other half and deep fried chicken finger cut in pieces. The *most* disgusting topping ever. I have had this combo at many other pizza places and the buffalo chicken is cooked, not fried ever and tossed in a buffalo sauce. Usually with red onions and sometimes places add cilantro. This was only pieces of chicken on a crust sprinkled with bbq sauce and the aforementioned awful fried chicken fingers that had no spice whatsoever. All burnt beyond recognition. The crust was the consistency of thicardboard. This colossal mess cost $25. In addition, the counter staff just sat the entire time on their phones and when they had to serve the pizza, no hand washing nor use of hand sanitizer. Might be nice if management went over the science of hygiene and food handling. This was by far the worst "pizza" I have ever had the misfortune to eat. Unfortunately for us this and another pizza place was the only place open in Edgartown. Never again. This was vomit worthy so-called pizza. read more

Edgartown Pizza - "Buffalo Chicken part of pizza" - Pizza Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Not sure what's going on here. The sauce, toppings and cheese are good. Fresh veggies, nice sauce. The crust reminded me of boboli. Thick and spongy, not even a little crispy. It's definitely made off site and likely was frozen at one point. It's cheap pizza. Perfectly edible just not great. They could greatly improve if they found a better solution to the crust issue. read more

Love the loaded pizza without bacon. A classic deluxe pizza pie. Felt comfortable with their COVID-conscious set up. Looking forward to my next pizza! read more

Worst pizza ever. $64.00 island rip off. 2 large and 1 small. Cardboard pizza, seems like store bought frozen dough. read more

Edgartown Pizza - Pesto pizza, not even warm. Like cardboard. $64 for 2 large and 1 small. Island rip off. - Pizza Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Convenient and easy to get to and park but very poor quality pizza. Ordered a pepperoni pie and chicken buffalo pie one weekend evening (Aug 6) and they were both very very disappointing. Sauce was fair but cheese was nonexistent or tasteless. However the crust was terrible. Mushy and bland. Also quite pricey. But staff was friendly. Look for another pizzeria in Edgartown. read more

seriously the worst pizza I've ever had. any supermarket frozen pizza would be better than this.

We ordered 3 sandwiches which took 30 minutes to arrive in to-go boxes - we had said we were eating there. The fries were cold and soggy, melted cheese was burnt, lettuce brown. Absolutely the worst food we've had on the island. Took it home, and actually threw it all away. So many great places to eat, even early in the season. This is NOT one of them. read more

The pizza here is just ok, not as good as it looks to be honest. BUT the steak tips were outstanding, highly recommend those.

On the island for business and walked to this place for lunch as it is close to the Edgar Hotel. Was greeted promptly with lukewarm greetings by the guy behind the counter I assume was the owner. He wasn't rude or mean just wasn't welcoming or friendly. Ordered a pizza with pepperoni and extra cheese. Pizza arrived fairly quickly. Kind of flat and greasy style pizza. Taste was okay at best- not the worst I have ever had but not great either. Definitely not worth the $19.28 for the pizza and two cans of soda. I wish now I would have tried the other foods they had on their menu as others seem to enjoy theirs. But since pizza was in the name of the business and I love pizza that is what I settled for. read more

Went two nights in a row. They greet you as you walk in and the portions are vey generous. We had a bunch of different things but by far the cauliflower chicken Alfredo pizza was amazing. I'm usually a meat-lovers type. Great value and even better service. read more

Big thumbs up to Edgartown Pizza! I mentioned to the lovely employee that I had Celiacs and requested the gluten free crust. The manager overheard my discussion and asked to speak with me. He expressed a lot of genuine concern about my condition and explained the restaurant's limitations (gluten free crust available but not a gluten free kitchen). He personally delivered my GF pizza and we talked more about the GF world. Pizza was amazing! If concerned about cross contamination, may not be the place for you, but I don't have significant concerns with that and very much appreciated this restaurant for their candor and delicious GF option. read more

The pizza was easily one of the worst pizzas I have ever had (I got their version of the meat lovers), and I eat a lot of pizza. Very greasy even by meat lover standards. Bland sauce. Crust was nothing to write home about. While it is hard to make an excellent pizza, it is also hard to make a really bad one. This was a really bad one. (In fairness, my wife got the veggie pizza and said it was ok.) The pluses were easy parking and kid friendly. There was a tv playing the Disney channel. read more

The food is super expensive but hey, what isn't expensive in Martha's Vineyard??? What also sucks is their kid's menu is just for kids. The cashier actually questioned us when I asked for the kid's meal but luckily my son was there...even though it wasn't for him. The kid's meal - chicken tenders - had a couple pieces of chicken and fries and the regular chicken tenders came with 4-5 pieces of chicken but was more than DOUBLE the price. I ordered a pesto chicken sandwich and whatever sauce was in it definitely was not pesto. read more

I stopped in the Edgartown pizza Shoppe once this past Memorial day weekend for a dinner time sub to eat before a night out with the fellas. I wanted to indulge my steak cravings with a large steak and cheese so I ordered one. I kept it simple ordering a large steak and cheese with american cheese, nothing on it to go. The order took longer than I expected for such a simple order and when it arrived I expected a larger sub that was wrapped. After returning to the house I opened the sub and the cheese was basically laid on the steak after it was placed in the sub roll and was not even melted in the meat. The sub tasted just awful. After a few bites the steak was overcooked, burnt and dry. The steak was tasteless and after paying eight bucks for this awful sub I felt ripped off. If it wasn't for the fact that I was going out in less than a hour, I would have returned to the Edgartown pizza shoppe and asked for either my money back or another properly prepared sub. How in blazes can you screw up a simple steak sub!!. I will not make the mistake of going to the Edgartown Pizza Shoppe again. read more

This place sucks. By the way, do you know they serve breakfast? Resonating words every time I walked in here. Take the 1 minute drive and go to Fresh Pasta Shop for pizza. It buries EPS. read more

You only get 3 safe choices here: Get the Brazilian dinner with beef. This is good and filling and wont make you sick Get the crispy chicken finger sub (add herb cheese to make it better) Get a small personal pizza... the larger pizza's get weirder read more

$42 on 3 XL pizzas that were probably made in microwave. To be most accurate... the pizza resembles Ellios frozen pizza waaay too closely. Cannot have possibly been made in an oven, the "crust" was pale, mushy and virtually nonexistent. The second star was given only because my kids are not picky and still devoured it ‍. read more

Tastes like the pizza they served in my elementary school. This place used to be so much better. I don't know what happened... I will say the staff is friendly. So kudos for that. I hate to say this, but go to Stop and Shop and get a Tombstone pizza. read more

Me and my family went hear for a quick bite. We each got a slice of pizza. I'm pretty sure it was elios pizza. There was absolutley no crust and the bread was chewy and gross. We didn't even get forks! Our waitress was nice she came all the way over to our table to serve us. I do NOT recommend this place for pizza! read more

Hands down the best pizza on the island. The people was above average nice and again the pizza - flavorful, bendy, juicy, charred around the edges. Delicious. read more