The owner took my fish & fries takeout order, misunderstanding it due to a noisy background. She replaced it at my insistence with soggy fries and overcooked pieces of fish that must have come from the dregs of the fryer. Little fish and mostly crust (see photo). Guess this is the way she corrects an order or is it retribution? read more

Eastside Grill & Pub - Dregs of a fryer - Pubs Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

4.2, Ipa battered drunken mushrooms were amazing, crab cakes and french fries were also pretty good

Fun outdoor music! Unique menu and so delicious! Beef sandwiches, beet salad with shrimp, crab cakes, Reuben egg rolls , clam chowder and more. Waitress was kind and attentive. Out of town visitor - will come again. read more

We made our first visit on a Sunday, and it won't be our last. Hubby had Chicken Parm and I had Chicken French, both were delicious, and we appreciated the portion size. Our server was attentive and friendly. We sat inside but we peeked outside to get a look at the seating area, and we were surprised by how big it was. There was a large, covered area with plenty of seating and another area where you could enjoy the sun if you like, and apparently live music was coming on later. This friendly place is being added to our list of our regular spots and we urge others to do the same. read more

My husband and I decided to come here. I was with urgent care for a couple of hours. My stomach was so upset and I had a headache. My husband ordered a fish fry. I asked if I could order a grilled cheese sandwich. The server said no. She then asked the boss and her answer to us was an absolute no. They don't make enough money on it. So I backed off. What a way to lose customers! We live on the lake and I'll tell my neighbors that I was refused a grilled sandwich. Which was a kids meal. The server was sweet but not sweet enough to help my upset stomach and my husband said his fish fry was extremely greasy And we ordered clam chowder which was below acceptable. Was A very thin broth looked like dishwater. Never again! read more

Decided to try the Eastside Grill &Pub because of the good reviews. Well we wanted to try the Cubano and Boom Boom shrimp and were we surprised. The description of the Cubano said it was on a " pressed toasted roll" but I got a "Hot Dog" roll and the leftovers of pork! Next were the Boom Boom shrimp but the were" Bad Bad Shrimp", small over cooked hard shrimp splashed with a sauce. The picture shown to us by the waitress showed a mounded portion but what we got looked like a few of the leftovers. The ambiance was what you would expect and the waitress was very attentive. I normally do not write reviews but the food was not worth the visit. read more

Elka, Steve and Linda were all fantastic!! Both my friend and I had the steak dinner for $20! Amazing deal. Delicious! $6 margaritas! Huge space. Games to play. Indoor and outdoor seating. Great selection of beers and drinks. A bar to sit at. Covered seating outside. Nice selection of food. You cannot go wrong at this locally owned and run restaurant and bar. Don't forget the fish fry!!! Will definitely go back. read more

This is a nice cozy restaurant/pub near Canadaigua Lake in Canadaigua. The food was delicious. Staff was knowledgeable about questions about the food & drinks. read more

This was the absolute worst experience I have ever had at a restaurant! I never thought I'd write a review on a restaurant but I feel it is my responsibility to warn people about the atrocities I just experienced at the "eastside grill and bar". Unfortunately a few of the girls in this establishment were very nasty to my companions and myself, went out of their way to make us feel uncomfortable and harassed us when it was time to leave. If you'd like to enjoy a pleasant meal with your friends and family I would highly suggest visiting any of the other restaurants on that strip. Giving them a single star is extremely deceiving, but I can not post it without one.. read more

4 of us returning after restart of the restaurant. The place is fresh and the staff are very attentive. The service was great. The food was very good and came out in perfect order. Only one person wishing the shredded beef in her quesadilla was seasoned instead of being plain. Other than that we had a very nice evening. Will definitely return. read more

Great Service but when the food came that was it. Large salad was filled with soggy spinach. Told waitress and she said she would tell kitchen. You would think a manager would come see !! Their special Blackened Shrimp Scampi was like pasta soup with a few shrimp and stewed tomatoes. They got 4 out of 5 tails off the shrimp. Garlic bread was soggy. read more

We got takeout food so I know it is compromised however.....Irish egg rolls were obviously not homemade like they used to be - frozen and deep fried-- all dough- hardly any cabbage or corned beef----VERY DISAPPOINTING! The chicken fingers for my granddaughter were so over cooked she (a three year old) said " these are burnt - yuck!" The French fries were obviously in under hot grease because that's all you tasted was GREASE. The New England clam chowder was "overwhelmed with milk only" as said by my 81 year old father which was disappointing as that is all he really wanted to eat. I was so very disappointed as I have eaten here before and not had such terrible food. I gave a $15 tip because they were busy but wouldn't have if I ate my food first. Sorry but sometimes you need to know so you can make positive changes. Don't skimp to generate more business. Your service and food a year ago was much better. read more

Just reopened..Good food and service Very nice deck..had wings and a buffalo chicken wrap as well as pork chop.

I am hoping to see more patrons give this great little place a chance. Very warm and inviting inside, cute bar, small room for am intimate party or sit adjacent to bar in open concept room. My new fav fried confection?? Their beer battered thick sliced portabella mushrooms. Wow! We shall return from the other side of the lake soon. read more

See all

A short drive down the east side of Canandaigua Lake near the Crystal Beach FD. Spacious patio area outside, including some protected seating (in case of rain!) Between covid and a late-night fire, they're had their challenges. Re-opened with most of the previous staff, and my friend and I enjoyed our meals AND the live music on a Thursday night. She had the eggplant parm, and loved it - not soggy, full of flavor, with excellent sauce. My shrimp po'boy was chock full of shrimp and a spicy sauce that was perfect! Inside bar was expanded somewhat after the renovations, and they have a back room for a more private dining experience. If you haven't visited yet, now's the time to go!! read more

I have dined- in prior to Covid & have had several fish fries since Mar. The folks and service has been good but I am sorry to report after two fish fries that were overcooked with aged soggy fries, we will not be returning. The first time I called just to tell them about the quality & was challenged about my complaint. "Another customer just told me the the best fish fry ever" so how could mine be poor? This time it went straight to trash where they should have put it! read more

Another awesome dinner here! Well worth the drive. I had the chicken french special. It was so good! My last visit, I had the fish and chips special, best fish ever! And the drunken mushroom appetizer is amazing! read more

Absolutely the worst food and service we have ever had. The Chicken Parm was dried out and burned, the Fish Sandwiches were soggy and barely warm, French Fries were cold and old, Macaroni and Cheese was so watery it looked like soup and the Corned Beef on the Reuben was dried out. The only reason we tried this place was because of a review from "Eat Drink and be Murphy" we will never trust reviews from the Messenger Post again. My suggestion is to avoid this place at all costs. read more

Amazing service and food. I've never had a bad meal. Steve and Kathy are amazing! The portions are great & they have a great variety of everything. They also cook their wings in a gluten free method which is phenomenal! I highly recommend. read more

Great atmosphere, vast menu with something for everyone and excellent prices. Food was delicious. We tried drunken mushrooms, calamari, beet salad, BLT sandwich, buffalo chicken wrap, Reuben sandwich, salmon dinner, classic burger, pulled pork, and kids meals - All of it was yummy!!!! Fabulous outdoor setting with live music occasionally and fun games (ladder ball, giant jenga, and corn hole) to play too! Check it out, you won't be disappointed!! read more

Took a family group for the advertised Forth of July Buffet. On line menu listed hot dogs as menu item. When we arrived, we found no hot dogs but fancy sausages stuffed with jalapenos! The kids with us were quite disappointed! Whats' Forth of July without hot dogs, it's Un-American! Also disappointed that the salad had croutons in the salad instead of on the side, causing the folks with Gluten issues not being able to eat the salad. Suggestions to always put Gluten products on the side please. The chicken and ribs were moist and good. The other menu items on the buffet were alright. The restaurant is not really near the lake and many trees block the view of the lake. But it was open for the holiday and the wait staff are attentive. read more

This restaurant is near our home. They have live music that is not too loud so you can hear at the dinner table. First visit, I ordered the spaghetti and meatballs. Spaghetti was over cooked. Four small meatballs were rock hard. Sauce was good. I had a Knob Creek bourbon manhattan. It was $12.60, a bit pricey. Second visit, I ordered the haddock fish fry on Saturday. It was a few small pieces of haddock and fries in a basket. All were overcooked, hard and greasy. I prefer to eat off a plate, not a plastic basket with paper. Third visit on Friday, I ordered the calamari appetizer and haddock fish fry. Both were great. I had a glass of Cabernet for $5.00, a much better value. read more

Julie Y MUST have confused this with another place, maybe Murphy's Law? Dishes she mentioned are NOT on the menu at EG&P. Locals have been raving about the food, so I stopped by tonight, more to just grab a beverage and see how the former 'Captain Yogi's' was faring. Many of the old charms still, patio and indoor seating, with many upgrades. LOTS of parking, a plus in the Crystal Beach area. Had a cup of an amazing NE clam chowder; and am looking forward to checking out the variety of dishes - shrimp scampi, beet salad, and not one but TWO choices of veggie burgers (offered if you want a non-meat option for what looks to be an above average burger menu). Place was busy and lots of great people making sure they were well-fed and happy. Shannon and LeEtta behind the bar made the visit worth the 4 mile drive south. (from the Lakeshore intersection). They already have a good group of regulars, go find out why they love the place!! read more

We live 3 miles away, but somehow had dropped in. Our first experience there was extremely pleasant. Friendly waitstaff. Options for sitting inside or outside. We sat at the bar, had a couple of excellent cocktails, and an unusual but very freshly prepared and tasty appetizer. We look forward to going back soon! Including during football season, for some company,drinks, and comfort food. read more

Food was great service was great. They state they are dog friendly and I was asked to put my dogs in the car because other dogs showed up and my puppy was barking. If my child was crying would I be asked to put them in the car??Easy way to ruin a great day. read more