This amazing, beautiful building sits at the center of town and cannot be missed! The restaurant and taproom is under new management as of spring 2025 and the difference is night and day! Where it used to be high priced and stuffy, now it's approachable yet really beautifully executed plates! There are a variety of seating options from the more casual taproom side to the elegant dining room and beautiful porch overlooking Main Street! Service is warm and attentive. You can tell that the staff really cares about the customer experience! The menu has a little bit of everything, from tasty wings with special "Hotel" sauce, green curry mussels, which were probably one of the best appetizers I've ever had... there are a variety of handhelds on the menu, their burger was huge and from a nearby farm - probably the best burger I've had in a long time! For entrées, the chicken Parm looked delicious.... There were a number of seafood dishes available, but the Osso Buco feature was the stuff that dreams are made of! The bartenders were really knowledgeable and friendly, servers seemedlike they were all best friends and the food runner was memorable as well! We are so happy to see the Naples Hotel on the upswing after a rocky few years. I would confidently recommend this restaurant to any of my friends passing through town. read more

Naples Hotel Restaurant - Osso Buco feature - Restaurants Near Me - Naples, New York

See all

I always want to love this place, but every-time we come here they are out of a lot with a limited menu or the service is slow. We ordered calamari and on the menu it claimed to have cherry peppers added. No cherry peppers here. Our waitress passed by us a lot without coming to our table to refill drinks. I had to literally wave her down. The food took two hours. Now the food once it arrived was very yummy. They have great potential, but this always happens when we come here. read more

Naples Hotel Restaurant - Calamari - Restaurants Near Me - Naples, New York

We had visited the hotel in 2021 and the hotel etc was under construction. We had a wonderful time then. We are back in the area and visited again last night. We were greeted by the owner and he gave us a tour talked about the renovations and checked in on us during dinner. We had a lovely dinner. The food was very good and the dining area was so inviting. We sat inside but when we left many others had opted to eat at tables on the porch. The waitress was very friendly and attentive. We were so glad we stopped in and will visit again when we are in the area read more

We came here while staying at the hotel to see a concert in town. We sat down and ordered drinks and appetizers. Drinks came quickly but then proceeded to wait for over an hour while watching other tables be seated and served both appetizers and dinners while nothing came out. When we stopped the waitress to ask what the issue was there was no apology, explanation or any attempt to make it right. The food was good, not great. But the service and issues on delivery means we wouldn't risk a return. read more

FINALLY we made it to Naples to check out the Hotel! It was everything we had hoped it would be & more. We made 4:30 reservations for a Friday. We like early especially when driving any distances to avoid night driving. We had a choice of outside or inside dining. We chose inside & by the bar area. Appetizers were great. We had the pork belly burnt ends served over Thai noodles & mushrooms in a cream sauce over arancini both were fabulous. Our meals were perfect - sirloin with shrimp scampi, French fries & seasonal veggie everything was cooked perfectly. Also braised short ribs served over cheese grits. Again can't say enough about the meals. Staff was outgoing , friendly, attentive & very efficient. A special thank you for making our meal a memorable one & for bringing back the beauty to the Hotel. Naples is a beautiful quant village with several unique places to shop & eat. read more

Naples Hotel Restaurant - Pork Belly burnt ends! - Restaurants Near Me - Naples, New York

Really old and cool building with history! The bar tender never came over to our high top so someone from our party got up and ordered at the bar. The French onion soup was good, not so much the artichoke appetizer. Fun cocktails and mocktails to choose from. I'd go back and try a sit down dinner, service may be a little better! read more

See all

Friday night fish fry with family was nice experience. Food was quite good and service was fine. When one dish did not come as ordered, the staff was quick to remedy the situation and provided a complimentary dessert for the experience. A varied menu and good selection of drinks. Special thanks to barkeeper who was quick to make amends for undercooked item. We will return. read more

Lovely hotel in Naples,NY. Hotel was very clean and had nice touches throughout. Feels like we were living in a Victorian era! Inside the room was a personalized thank you note from the owners. Bed was comfy and room was very spacious. Bathroom had an abundance of plush white towels and nice complimentary toiletries. Our "Cabernet" room was on the second floor and was close to an outdoor patio with Adirondack chairs overlooking the town and green hills. Second floor also had a nice suite with complimentary teas, coffee, breakfast snacks and more. Lots of breweries, distilleries, and wineries nearby. We met the owners - very nice young couple with a family - they checked in to see if we were settled in good and happy with our accommodations. read more

Been looking for the Holy Grail of casual delicious lunches and found it last Friday at the Naples Hotel. Beef on Weck Sliders with french fries and a Stella. It was perfect and the only thin better were the ba tendresses, Sarah and Alyssa who could have not been sweeter or helpful. APefect Lunch! read more

Ambiance old and charming, server was just okay, Food we went for a haddock fish fry which we had on a previous visit but were told that it wasn't in the restaurant price point.? Had a limited menu and kinda pricey. For two the bill ended at just over $100.00 plus tip. three drafts a chicken Marsala and Pork chop with mashed. Just thought I would let you know read more

Very disappointed in the food and service. Do not eat the Crabcake Benedict. Poor quality canned crab and curdled hollandaise. The other brunch items were better, but still subpar. Price point was high. Service was slow and coffee was cold. We expected much better! read more

A new favorite spot ! Friendly, great food and drink, with a charming atmosphere. We hope to be back soon!

Water smelled and tasted like well water after it rains. (Fishy smell) There were some brown spots on my salad which means not fresh. $23 for a soup and salad.... a bit overpriced. My husband couldn't finish his food as he said it was awful. Asked for medium well, got medium rare. Went once, never again. read more

I have to write this review because of my experience on a Saturday night. The waitress came to our table and took our drink order. I ordered a seltzer and my husband had a glass of water. We decided on an appetizer, Brie en croute. It came it was delicious. Then we ordered lobster bisque and a house salad for me and a wedge salad for my husband. As soon as the salads were delivered fruit flies attached our dinner. We complained to the waitress and all she said was that they couldn't control the flies. The bill came to , with tip, 95.00!!!!! Won't be back there no matter how good the food is. Also, the waitress didn't tell us the specials as we over heard others hearing them . read more

I was pleasantly surprised by my recent visit to the Naples Hotel! The staff was most welcoming and pleasant! The drink size was of adequate size, the onion soup was top notch and the beef Kims were nice size. The larger dinner selection are limited and I believe a little pricey for Naples. Two suggestions-their website need work it is lacking details of hours and second they need to offer more details on their menu. Yes, I will return, keeping in mind I will pay a little more for a pleasant experience! Welcome to Naples, good luck! read more

Reservations were made for a table of 4 on the evening of 12/27/2023 for dinner. When we arrived, the restaurant was closed - nobody inside or in sight anywhere! Why would they even accept our reservation, if they knew they were going to be closed on that day? Just lost our business forever. read more

My wife and I both ordered the Roast Beef Sliders on Kimmelweck rolls. We both were a bit disappointed. The sliced beef tasted ok but was chewy. I thought that the beef was sliced too thick. The fries were good. There were left overs. We didn't take them. We're not the type of people who complain about food, we just don't go back. The place is a local landmark and is nice. The restaurant/rest rooms were clean. We ate at the bar. The bartender was very pleasant. The pours were good. She was very knowledgeable about the area and made several very good suggestions that we used. read more

Forget the previous reviews of this place. New management, staff and an extremely talented chef now reside here. The fact that they have just reopened and don't have their liquor license yet should not deter you. And that's coming from a seasoned drinker. Service was exceptional, friendly, knowledgeable and attentive. But the food, the food. One of the most creative and delicious meals I've ever experienced. The brie en croute with a slivered almond, raspberry sauce with toasted bread was ridiculous as an appetizer, light and delicious. The etouffee of squid ink pasta, shrimp, scallops and sun dried tomatoes in a light cream sauce was so very tasty, great depth of flavor. Would eat there again in a heartbeat. Great creativity from an obviously talented chef. Good luck to your whole team. read more

Wow. How dare they have the ordacity to provide such great service to such a large group. The sweet, southern bell Skyler, who waited on us, putbbn on her most pleasant face and dared to laugh with us and give us an overall great experience. You best believe i will be going back. Oh, food was good too, but skyler really made the experience whole. If she is mot running the while restaurant by August 23rd next year by midnight, i will remove a star plus an additional every year after. Your move, Naples Hotel. read more

Was not expecting the full, amazing plate of food we received! We actually "stumbled" on this place and are really glad we did!! read more

Naples Hotel Restaurant - Restaurants Near Me - Naples, New York

Pass on this little quaint restaurant that is located right downtown. The restaurant is cute enough...inside what looks like an old home or hotel. The lunch was below meh! but the bar was doing a good business. I had the chicken salad, hub had the sausage. Both were bland. The sausage sat on a burnt bun with a pile of undressed spinach. The fries were good...that is mostly what we ate. The chicken in my salad was "pre-cooked," dry, and tough. The small slices of garlic bread and the frico on the side were were also "pre-fabbed" and stale as were the croutons. How hard is it to saute a fresh chicken breast and toast some bread? Methinks this is more of a "watering hole" than a restaurant. read more

My husband and I stopped for dinner for our anniversary while out touring some wineries on Canadaguia lake. The restaurant is clean and the staff is friendly. We enjoyed the atmosphere and the prices are very reasonable. I ordered the clams over linguine and it was AMAZING. Our ONLY complaint was that my husband's spaghetti and meatballs came with frozen meatballs..... which was a HUGE disappointment. In fact, they would have received a 5 start if not for that. We will definitely be back to give it a second try. read more

Naples Hotel Restaurant - a plate of pasta with clams - Restaurants Near Me - Naples, New York

Arrived at noon on a Saturday to a virtually empty restaurant. Little did we know that the party of thirteen seated immediately before us would bring their entire kitchen to a grinding halt. Definitely not worth an hour wait for two mediocre sandwiches off their limited menu. read more

Fantastic food and service. A wonderful seafood platter creation and a terrific chef and wait staff!! Looking forward to more opportunities to have great experiences! read more

We had a lovely dinner here on Friday night. Excellent service, very good food, and reasonable prices. Got the surf and turf which was very good. Plenty of salad is provided. They now offer wine selections and just started doing so. Solid three plus and recommended. Oh and make sure you ask the wait staff about their ghost stories. read more

Skyler is the best server ever !!!! She was so friendly and perosnable ! She was able to handle our ridiculous sense of humor and our outrageous large group ! She was so great about checking on us, refilling water and drinks, and helping us find a fun bar afterwards! We were so impressed with her expertise ! read more

I think we ordered the wrong thing-- salad shared was fresh and yummy but then our seafood (mussels, clams and haddock) was average..for $25 should have come with a side of pasta or more fish. The bread served was too soft for an italian restaurant...expected a nice crunchy one. Service was great and we had a good laugh as the couple next to us were all over each other !! and we liked kidding about how weird it was... read more

What a pleasant surprise. I was looking for a hearty meal the day before can 50 race. This place hit the spot. I had the grilled chicken sandwich and sweet potato fries and it was fresh, tender and fantastic. The special (chicken philly and chili) also looked great! This is the best food I've had in naples. read more

Recently visited with my parents and my wife, and all our entrees were tasty. My wife had a scallop special, I had a vegetarian pasta dish and my parents both had chicken parmigiana. I would have given 5 stars but at the time they didn't have their liquor license so we had to walk into the adjacent bar to get some glasses of wine. Not a huge nuisance but it was quite rowdy and enough of a pain for a 1 star demotion. I'm sure it will live up to 5 stars when they get that license! read more

Worst experience I have ever had in a hotel. Bright street lights outside the window, the awful band playing in the bar below the room and people constantly going in and out of the bar and slamming the door behind them each time kept us up all night. read more

Don't be tempted by this haunted and historical hotel/restaurant in downtown Naples. The food is toxic and the wine is way over priced. Fishy and grey calamari was unpleasant - especially served in plastic cereal bowl full of Ragu! read more

I was there today at the end of the Sunday brunch. We wandered in after the staff already started picking up the food. They promptly went to the back and brought out anything we wanted. We felt terrible but stayed foe what ended up being a great meal. The staff was friendly and courteous. The chef came out to apologize to us when it was us who apologized to him. We will definitely eat here again, but will be more observant of the time when we get there. read more