I tried a good amount of stuff in their menu. I remember craving for nachos and their melty, cheesy dip did not disappoint. I truly love the rotisserie chicken in this restaurant. I love that I can order the chicken (quarter or half) and it can come with two sides. My go-to is white rice and steamed veggies. I've also ordered their tacos and that usually hits the spot! One of my favorites is their burrito bowls. I've tried bistec and their rotiserrie chicken (makes for a good post-workout meal). Truly wonderful and the portions are amazing for the price. The servers here are nice and the drinks are amazing. I will definitely keep coming back/ordering to eat. read more

The quality here deserves recognition and celebration. You'll notice the spotless conditions and brightness immediately. The food here meets all expectations. The team creates a family-like atmosphere. This place offers a relaxed atmosphere. read more

One of my go to restaurants I must say the food is always delicious. Service is amazing. It's a 10 out of 10. I do recommend.

My girlfriend and I found a staple inside her chicken quesadilla. Luckily, she was able to spit it out before swallowing it. The only reason I gave the place 2 stars is because the food itself is very good and fresh. I understand mistakes happen but the cook NEEDS to be notified of this incident so it doesn't happen again. read more

Don Mario - Chicken Shop Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Was not impressed with this place. Dined in a Saturday early afternoon. A friend and I were the only customers there throughout our whole dine in experience. What we got: Crazy fries beef empanadas rotisserie chicken soft taco chorizo soft taco carnitas soft taco camaron soft taco pescado soft taco Honestly, everything was bland... except for the chorizo Only good thing I can say about the food was the portion size, especially with the soft tacos, a good mount of "filling" The crazy fries didnt look appetizing at all, like the cheese used looked like plastic. just overall sadly not good. If my pics are still there, thats exactly what the crazy fries looked like. Nothing different from being served "fresh" to me than being eaten as a left over the next day. The other good, was the place was spacious and clean and the wait staff was enjoyable. read more

Don Mario - Crazy Fries - sausage, cheese, bacon. Even tho this is a next day left over pic, this is what is looked like being served "fresh" to me... - Chicken Shop Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Recent reviews don't mention that location is no longer Don Mario's. It's Las Margaritas Mexican restaurant, and has been for about three years according to our server. the food is well plated with large portions. Servers are pleasant. The food is very salty and rather pricy, at nearly 30 dollars for most of the dinner plates, and close to 20 for the Mexican specialties. I don't recommend this place, but it's not terrible. Not much atmosphere! read more

I had such a pleasant experience here! The waitresses were so friendly, they were efficient in cleaning before and after guests leave. The food was also delicious!!! They provided free nachos and salsa which was a great appetizer before the entree. We ordered horchata, enchilada with green sauce and the cuban hero. Horchata is one of the best I've had! The Cuban hero was so goood (along with the crispy fresh fries), and the beef enchilada was so flavorful. Everything was so tender and the beef wasn't overdone either! The portions were enormous...!! You will not be disappointed :) read more

See all

Just want to start off my saying the customer service here is stupendous. The gentleman and all the ladies are very tentative, accommodating and overall friendly! The food here is also delicious. Please try the creamy green sauce!!!!! Highly recommend the tacos which come with onions, cilantro and guacamole! Favorites are the steak and the fried fish tacos. The only unremarkable dish for us was the empanadas- a little too soggy on the inside compared to what I prefer. read more

See all

Call it Mi Tierra or Don Mario, but either way, it's delicious. A few months back, my friend and I came by for takeout from Las Margaritas (next door) which is always a solid choice. While waiting for our food, we noticed a line that ended up wrapping around the block. And what was it for? Mi Tierra, formally known as Don Mario. With a large following of loyal customers willing to line up for their food pre-outdoor dining, you know this place has got to be good. Last night, I was able to stop in for takeout and the food did not disappoint. For my order, I went with the Arepa con Chorizo. At $5.95, I was expecting this to me a small little thing but it was actually HUGE and very filling, with melted cheese glorious-ness and tons of spicy chorizo. I also ordered a side of the Maduros which was extremely generous as well. It paired perfectly with their signature light green sauce. So yummy. My friend did a massive takeout order as well, which included the Family Combo #4 with Rotisserie Chicken. Another big portion for the price. Her larger order meant we experienced a longer wait time, as the restaurant was already busy with outdoor dining and delivery orders. For me, it was well worth it. I love Las Margaritas next door and so far, I love Mi Tierra just as much. I absolutely cannot wait to try more menu items. read more

Man, this place has really gone down in quality over the years. I wish I had heeded some of the warnings I saw on Google but I grew up in Bay Ridge and Don Mario used to be one of my go to spots. It's been years since I've had them, now they have a new location or two according to some reviews? They used to be across the street from Las Margaritas and now they're next door to each other. I never put two and two together that they were making Peruvian chicken back then but it used to be a fave of mine. I went with the whole chicken instead of the half combo because I wanted leftovers and I didn't want my food touching. Yellow rice and black beans on the side separately, $4.50 each. It was nothing like I remembered. I hated the yellow rice, I barely touched it. It's exactly the texture of Mexican rice that I do not like. I can't explain it, maybe I'll take a picture later. Not to mention that for almost FIVE DOLLARS, the container was halfway full. I kid you not, you could literally see that they only filled up half of the aluminum container when I opened the bag, it was all pushed to one side. The beans? F L A V O R L E S S. I love black beans man, theirs were so disappointing. There is such a thing called salt, use it! The most disappointing part of the meal however was the chicken. In my opinion, there's really no point in advertising that your chickens are marinated a day before roasting when they're bland as hell. I had to bring the adobo out. I hate when I have to do that. I gave them two stars simply because the chicken was cooked well, the breast wasn't dry which they deserve credit for. However, even with the green sauce, (which I also didn't like much) it gave nothing. I ended up only eating the chicken and now I have a another half sitting in my fridge that I'm not excited for whatsoever. Sad, I was hoping for a different outcome! read more

My go to healthy meal. Affordable and delicious, love just getting the half rotisserie chicken with beans & mixed vegetables. It's like 4 meals in one order. Love that green sauce too!! Delivery guys are also really fast & nice. Thanks for being you Don Mario!! read more

Glad was able to get good rotisserie chicken from Don Mario. Have ordered whole chicken, plata no maduro, bistec burrito, fried calamari hmm what else? Well the chicken is always hot and yummy. The burrito was good to say the least and platano maduro so frigging good. The calamari was excellent but the dipping sauce is meh . Really taste like barbecue sauce and not traditional marina sauce. I can over look this minor detail. I really love crunchy French fries and calamari was the same when ordered. Don't you hate when you pay for wet and mushy French fries. Oh why does it say business is closed omg? Am I dreaming lol ? Cause I got delivery last nite. read more

For context.. we ordered delivery several times large group orders... prices are very high for what this place is and for what they offer. Food is good but the portions are small and leave you hungry. They skimp out on sauce even when you elect to pay for it. We won't be ordering here again. read more

This place is great. This might be the one and only Columbian spot that I know of in Bay Ridge and I must say they did not disappoint. One of my favorite dishes of all time is enchiladas and the enchiladas here are delicious. As their name states they do have rotisserie chicken. What I love about this place is that you can get that rotisserie chicken in any of the chicken dishes or you can just have regular chicken. The rotisserie chicken is really good and definitely worth selecting as your protein. As for the drinks they makes some good Pina Coladas and a nice Margarita! On the same exact block as Don Mario there are literally 3 Mexican restaurants that they are competing with but I think this will be my new go to! read more

One of my favorite to go spots in bay ridge. They offer four options for family combo and I always go for combo #3. Whole chicken, rice and beans, small salad and fried green plantain. read more

Don Mario is a great place to have a few drinks if you're not in a rush. I have been to Don Mario quite a few times before and I always forget to leave a review. I will be honest the food here is just OK. I ordered some taquitos and they were severely severely over cooked/over fried. The chicken was bone dry and cooked well beyond done to the point of dryness/chicken jerky the beef was the same as well as the cheese guacamole is OK but not really anything special it needs a hefty amount of seasoning as well as spice to give it some flavor. I also mistakenly ordered the queso again which is basically nacho tortilla chips with a big thing of melted cheese. Every time I get this melted cheese I wonder why I order it because it is pretty bland and yet again black and flavor. Service is very very slow but I will blame that on The lack of servers and the amount of tables that they have. They really really do try hard to make you happy and they earn my respect and three stars are simply due to the fact that they really work hard and they try their best to keep up with everything but I feel that as a local you need to support a small local business. The people are warm and friendly I'll be at the service very slow, the food is OK but not something that I would return for, and while I really don't have too much to say regarding this business in terms of positive things such as tasting a shop of food, the prices are reasonable and reflect the type of food and service that you can. I would really love for this place to serve better, fresher food because I would make this a main stay in my rotation of local restaurants read more

Placed order at seamless 11:14am, received at 1247pm. Understand the guy is on a bike. Food was not hot upon arrival. Warm. The chicken is burnt, totally black on the skin * wish I can post pic with my review but it is on the photos I posted. read more

Don Mario - Guess what I had for lunch, a burnt chicken. I'm never going back if that's how they served their customers - Chicken Shop Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Always serving up great tacos!! I keep ordering them. And the amiga that brings it out to me is soooooo nice!! I love it. Keep eating these... read more

Don Mario - Bistec Taco - Chicken Shop Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Their Rotisserie chicken never, ever, disappoints. They have a big menu for whatever your like. full bar. friendly staff. clean. you can order take out or delivery or dine in. read more

I ordered a pico de Gallo and a roasted chicken. It looked good but... Nope. Sorry. See pic! There was a Cockroach in the Pico!!! I opened it up and there it was. Alive and kicking. Now I am revolted. Nauseous, and didn't touch their other food. I am sorry for posting this, truthfully their chicken looks good and tastes good but I will never order from them again after this bad experience. read more

Don Mario - I ordered a pico de gallo and Chicken. There was a COCKROACH in the pico!!! And it was alive.... Will never order again. =( - Chicken Shop Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

They moved across the street from the last time I've visited and the new place is nicely renovated with all glass windows. The food is as good as before and service and prices are great as per usual. I love this place. read more

Don Mario - Carne Asada with Tostones and steamed veggies. yum - Chicken Shop Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Got the rotisserie chicken sandwich and literally the driest chicken I've ever had in my life!! Can't even chew it! I ended up picking out and throwing away all the chicken and having everything else instead because I'm so hungry. And it's soo messsy! The chickens in tiny pieces and the lettuce is shredded like crazy.. everything was falling apart! If anyone were to watch me eat this I'd look like a caveman that's never had a sandwich before. Not sure how the rest of the food is but definitely do not get the chicken sandwich. The fries good though. read more

Just a quick review on a take-out order. My dining companion had a rotisserie chicken dinner while I had the avocado salad. He raved about the chicken between bites stating that it melted in his mouth and that it was the best rotisserie chicken he ever had. He devoured it. I was pleased by the impressive amount of avocado on my salad. I also appreciated that it came with some lime and orange slices. read more

Don Mario - Avocado Salad - Chicken Shop Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I placed an order, it took very long to arrive. When it was received, the order was in fact incomplete. Seems like this should be pretty cut and dry right? I called the restaurant to tell them that a portion of my order was missing. When I spoke with the gentleman, who must have been having a pretty awful day, I was told I would have to wait until the delivery guy returned and IF the chicken was in fact NOT received then they would give me the chicken I paid for. I explained that I wouldn't lie about not receiving a portion of the order. I also mentioned that I order from the restaurant all the time and have even sat in the actual storefront with my family. The gentleman was adamant that I was wrong and raised his voice then proceeded to tell me my voice sounds familiar. He proceeded to tell me that I had called before. I am not sure who he thought I was but I'm sure they are not friends. Since I place all my orders through GrubHub I explained that I hadn't called and had never had a problem before. He was aggressive and rude and plainly called me a liar, wanting me to wait for the delivery guy so he could see a receipt. A receipt I'm sure he could easily retrieve online for any information he may have needed. I am a long time Bay Ridge resident and have ordered from Don Mario's Rotisserie numerous times. I have never been treated like that. I would never deem it acceptable to treat a customer, any customer returning or otherwise, the way I was treated tonight. I will not return to Don Mario's and I will not recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants to be treated fairly, kindly and with respect. I was so disappointed and still am. read more

Don Mario - Chicken Shop Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Was looking for a take out place on a sunday night and came upon this on yelp. Seeing the positive reviews about their food made me come try this place. The restaurant is really small, probably can seat a maximum of 20 people. We had their guacamole and chips, pollo asado enchilada, and chicken quesadilla. The guacamole initially tasted good and fresh, but then realized there is a big piece of lettuce in it making it seem like there is more guac than it really is. Secondly, the guac tasted like they added a little water since it was a tiny bit watery and not as thick as it is supposed to be. The pollo asado enchilada was full of taste and really spicy. Just didn't like how they give big pieces of chicken. Usually it is shredded chicken at other places. The chicken quesadilla was ok. Overall, their food is mediocre but portions are big. The guy upfront was pretty friendly. Probably will come back and give it another try since everyone been raving about their rotisserie chicken. read more

See all

Food is fantastic, delivery is slow. Knowing this, the next time we ordered a whole chicken, plus grilled veggies, rice and beans, and french fries. My husband went to pick it up, which is really the way to go. The food is so delicious and it is CHEAP! If you don't feel like cooking, this is the perfect alternative. I'm sad it took us so long to discover it! read more

I was in the mood for some yellow rice and baked chicken (preferably Dominican style) and this was the closest thing I could get without having to leave my house (#lazysunday). This was my first time ordering and I had no prblme calling in placing the order. When the delivery guy came, he called me twice not knowing where my apartment was. This is not out of the norm per say but what was weird was that he did not have the total owed on the receipt. I assumed to know the total owed because I placed a mock order in seamless to make sure I had enough cash. After the delivery guy calling into the restaurant a few times, I realized this situation had nothing to do with me as I had technically paid (what I thought the amount was). I wanted to make sure I tipped him but standing in my building hallway for 10 minutes trying to figure this out was annoying. As for the food, the rice was eh and the beans were too watery. The chicken, however, was not half bad and the green sauce was delish. The dish was not as good as I expected but not awful. It was more than I would expect for the amount of food I got. Would I order again, probably if I had rotisserie chicken itch that I needed to scratch. I would definitely order the horchata again and even stop by for it. It's the best I've had in a while. If I have time to plan ahead, I would probably just get some exercise and go to my go to place. read more

We were staying in an airbnb and hungry and we stumbled upon Don Mario and oh my goodness this is the best food i've had in a long time. The plantains are mouth watering and the chicken so juicy and flavorful. If you're debating on if you should eat here or what to get take my advice- get more food than you think cause everything was delicious. We went back later for more! read more

Don Mario - 1/2 Rotisserie Chicken with 2 Sides - Chicken Shop Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

OK, but no more. The spicing of the rotisserie chicken was fine enough, but the meat was so soft that it was almost mushy--have encountered this with cheap supermarket chicken--the skin wasn't crunchy, and it wasn't heated enough. The yellow rice with vegetables had a slightly bitter aftertaste and the black beans were blah and kind of watery. read more

I walked in craving some Bandeja Paisa only to br told by the hostess that there would be a $15 cover fee per person due to the fact that a boxing match would be playing while we would be eating our meal. This instantly made me walk out. I hope they have a hell of a Bandeja Paisa because their customer service sucks. Anyway I enjoyed some delicious and authentic tacos up the block at a little spot called Mandato. Spend your money there read more

Terrible customer service hung up phone repeatedly when called about extremely long order not arriving. Will NOT ever order from here again and I advise others to do the same. read more

What a big disappointment they are known for their rotisserie chicken we were the first customer on a Saturday morning I had a carving for fresh chicken. I ordered the 1/2 rotisserie chicken with 2 sides tostones and Mac and cheese. The chicken was super dry even the thigh. I specifically ask her not to make it so dry she said she will tell them not to put it on the grill after it comes out of rotisserie . Boy it tasted like leftover reheated chicken. It was terrible the Mac and cheese tasted like it was from a box it had a grainy texture to it. Only thing that was good and tasted fresh was the tostones. Hubby had combo of chicken and beef enchilada both were super dry as well. read more

Don Mario - Chicken Shop Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Complex flavor, tons of different veggies in the salad, very reasonable for the amount of food you get, and the delivery went smoothly. I would definitely come back here!! read more

Don Mario - For $15 I got a half chicken, two sides (beans and salad) and two tacos (pastor and carne asada). Excellent! - Chicken Shop Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Fantastic food! They do not skimp, the portions were large and presented well. We had chimichangas, they were stuffed to the max with a very good sauce on top. The service was excellent, very attentive and patient. The drinks are good too - no alcohol, but they were so good it didn't matter much. When the bill came, it was very reasonable - two chimichangas with beans and salad on the side and a drink came to $33. Not bad at all. They do a lot of take-out and delivery as well. read more

The food is great, and delivery is fast. We like the guac, burritos, and tacos.

My friends and I decided to have lunch here after hearing about the Rotisserie chicken. We were greeted by a very friendly woman with a great smile which felt very welcoming. The restaurant was very clean and looked brand new! The woman serving us was very helpful answering questions about the menu. One of my friends is vegetarian and our server helped them customize a salad to meet their needs. My first friend ordered the Aguacate salad and had Salmon added. My other friend ordered the pollo rostizado burrito. I ordered three soft tacos including pollo rostizado, bistec and pescado. The soft shells were slightly crisped which keeps them from getting to soggy. Most places miss this small yet important step of preparation. The flavors were fresh and made me crave more! I'd definitely eat here again and highly recommend everyone nearby to try this place! read more

See all

This place definitely went down hill. The yucca is so hard after countless times of asking them to make it soft I gave up and stopped ordering it. Ordered from them again tonight against my husband's objections. Whole rotisserie and 2 orders of rice and beans. I get that they're busy now because they are always rushing you off the phone but please get the order right at least. When the food came I immediately noticed no beans on either order of rice so I called them and lady on phone said she'd send some. My big problem with this place is the quality of the food has gone down. The chicken is over done and dry when it used to be moist and juicy and they charge a$1 more now The yucca is hard and dry when it used to be soft. Really disappointed because I used to love this place. Finally ordered here last night after walking by it all the time and so glad I did!! I ordered the whole chicken which was very moist and tasty. The Yuca boiled is an absolute must! Best yuca I ever had. Rice and beans were good. Very reasonably priced. Will definitely order from here again soon! read more

I went to the place at 12 pm for lunch on a Saturday, ordered 1/2 chicken with 2 sides combination meal. The side's was rice and black beans. I was disappointed with the 2 sides. The rice was old and so was the Bean's. It practically smelled! The rice was probably a left over from the day before and the portion was very small. It wasn't even 1 cup full. The only thing fresh about the meal was the chicken. read more

The best chicken in town and no doubt about it....Highly recommendable and the price is very reasonable....Two thumbs up read more

Don Mario - Chicken Shop Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Very disappointing. Chicken was mediocre at best , guacamole was super underseasoned and the service was slow considering we were the only ones there. read more