All the employees were pleasant and helpful. My family and I didn't like the flavor of the pizza…read more The cheese pizza was the most palatable. It could just be that we are new to NC and where we're from we were used to something different. We ordered some assorted slices as well and 2 of 4 were burnt on the bottom. Edit: I know it's a far stretch here, but have you considered that fact that Yelp asks days later if you'd still like to leave a review so I thought why not..now I have the owner scratching his head and finding it suspicious that someone could possibly have not been thrilled by his pizza. It was a review from a day you were very much open, Friday. I still think that any and everyone should give it a try if they are so inclined. I'm also thrilled that so many people have enjoyed it. As a business owner, your immediate response to a review should not be to attack the reviewer. This interaction has left a much worse taste in my mouth than the burnt pizza.

As a native New Yorker from THE Island this place is spot on!!!…read moreGreat authentic pizza, REALLY!

The first time I went l had the pizza it was awesome. The second time I ordered a calzone with…read morethree selections they didn't have the selections I was really disappointed.

The best sauce this side of the bridge! So glad We found it and look forward to frequenting this…read moreamazing establishment. Being from the northeast, I am thrilled to have found this place.

I come from a state that's notorious for pizza. This must be one of my favorite pies by far. It was…read moreso fresh and so cheesy. It was warm and it took a few minutes to get to. It was really cheap. There was also a drive through. Definitely worth your money!

I ordered delivery from Wheelz last night and it was so good. When my order was on its way they…read moresent a link out to track the driver. This was helpful since I'm staying at a motel so I knew exactly when to go downstairs to get the food. I really enjoyed the pizza, cheesy bread and cookies! Will definitely order again next time I am at the beach.

I've ordered from Cugino Forno twice now and both times have been great. The pizza is delicious,…read moreand the salads are fresh and flavorful--I usually get the blueberry salad, but even the one I got by accident was just as good! There was a mix-up with DoorDash picking up the wrong order, but when I called, the manager handled it immediately. He was kind, apologetic, and truly cared about making it right. That level of service really stood out and turned a Mix-Up Into a 5-Star Experience Mistakes happen, but they went above and beyond. I'll definitely be ordering again!

You no longer have to travel to Brooklyn to get authentic NYC style pizza. It's right here in ILM…read more Friendly staff and outrageously great pizza (yes, and salad too).

I'm a local in HB . born and raised, I also run a restaurant for a living, with that said... I…read moreCANNOT SAY ENOUGH AMAZING things about sorellas!!! I dont eat out hardly ever...UNLESS its here!!! I frequent this establishment more than I'd like to admit, and as an AGM of a restaurant, I have to say, the food is absolutely perfect, the staff is friendly, they work as a genuine team and truly do their best to make you feel at home and have a wonderful dinner experience! Shout out to hailey for absolutely rocking! And also Ms martha... she's the sweetest, cutest hostess ever! Dont miss a trip here if visiting holden beach!

My wife and I live in the Holden beach area and this restaurant was on our list of places to try…read more We both totally surprised. The baked ziti was so large we took some home I had the Stromboli which totally delicious and had everything in it that any meat lover would want, We will be going back and this time we will leave room for dessert.

The food and service is fantastic!! They are fast in completing our orders, and it's our go to for…read morea pizza night. We love Fat Daddy's!

Seriously best pizza around and they have a GF! Wish GF was…read morea large but we make it work. Finally becoming "regulars", always place an order and then we just get there in time to just sit and eat and enjoy! They only have beers for the alcohol menu. Bring quarters for the kiddos!

From ordering over the phone with Sheryl, to picking up the food, and enjoying our dinner,…read moreeverything was great! The food was delicious and was exactly what we were looking for in a takeout pizza place. If you are in Emerald Isle, this is your spot for takeout pizza.

Mediocre pizza. Didn't try anything else. I read good things about the place, but that wasn't my…read moreopinion.

Enjoyed the pizza! Good service. Convenient location. Will certainly try their carry out again.read more

We just moved here 3 months ago. This was the first place we ordered pizza at. Very friendly…read moreworkers and owners. We had a meat pizza. It was great. Very lots of things on the walls to keep you entertained while waiting.

Meh.... Can't say anything really stood out except that there were barely any mushrooms in the…read moremushroom pizza. Meat pizza was pretty good.

Best Pizza!! I was a New Yorker and have tried a few others in the areas, they do not compare to…read morethe taste and quality of your pizza. Just as good if not better then NY Nice job!! Peter

Needed food after a late flight. Most places closed, this was open at 930pm (though they threw in…read morethe towel right after we got our order.) Small, a few tables, mainly carryout. They were out of a lot since it was late on a nice Saturday. But we got plenty: cheesy bread for K, pepp for Sweetie, meat for me (the "landlubber" or something.) They were out of sausage so my meats were pepp and meatballs. All pizzas were good. (The cheesy bread is pretty much a cheese pizza.) Surprisingly good for "what's open late at the beach off season" pizza. Good crust, good cheese, good toppings. We had plenty left over to share the next day at a gathering, and it reheated well. Service was great. Easy to find. Small parking lot. Decent prices. I would definitely come back.

Great bar pie! Very fast service not much seating definitely a take out type of placeread more