Cancel

Open app

Search

DiMillo's On The Roll

3.7 (3 reviews)
Closed • 12:00 pm - 6:00 PM

DiMillo's On The Roll Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - DiMillo's On The Roll

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Seafood 2,392 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Eventide Oyster Company - Oysters with kimchi ice and red onion ice

Eventide Oyster Company

4.2(4.5k reviews)
0.2 mi•East Bayside
•$$

Very quick service and informative wait staff! We don't know much about oysters other than the…read morefact that we like to eat them!! When it comes to picking what oysters we want, we have no knowledge. We shared this with the wait staff and gave us a good tasting with variety from a number of places. We especially loved the way they did their mignonette here -- it was like flavored shaped ice (so much easier to spoon a chunk of that onto our oysters!). Oysters were so meaty & delicious. We also got a soup which was okay - nothing that overly impressed me, but was nonetheless delicious. We also got a lobster roll which was tasty. Both these 2 dishes were quite small given the price point though. We arrived early as we didn't have a reservation and walked around until Opening to ensure we could get a spot, and to our disbelief, they were already busy! Even with high traffic for just opening for the day, they seated us immediately which was great. We're from out of town and cannot wait to return when we visit Portland again. This will be a staple for us for sure!

Long wait in line to leave your name to get on the waitlist... for getting a table. But it's worth…read morethe wait as there's some cute shops nearby around downtown. The staff there were super friendly and welcoming despite being busy! Ordered New England clam chowder and swordfish belly fish off the special menu of the week... loved the twist of what New England Clam Chowder is... it's thin compared to most chowder soup although full of flavors including seaweed which was very surprising and pleasing for taste bud! Of course it came with crackers. Swordfish belly was seared to its perfection and basically melts off in your mouth. Sided with vegetables and pureed root which was a nice compliment to fish. No complaint at all! I'd love to order second of everything!

Photos
Eventide Oyster Company - Interior

Interior

Eventide Oyster Company - Eventide Brown Butter Lobster Roll ($22)

Eventide Brown Butter Lobster Roll ($22)

Eventide Oyster Company - Maine Halibut Collar ($32) Mole Negro, Curtido & Tortillas

See all

Maine Halibut Collar ($32) Mole Negro, Curtido & Tortillas

The Highroller Lobster - The HighRoller (captured by @a.bite.of.life)

The Highroller Lobster

4.3(2.4k reviews)
0.3 mi•Old Port
•$$
Locally owned & operated
Outdoor seating

Some of the best lobster I've had in Portland. It's a very chill, retro vibe, and though seating…read moremay take a while on busy nights, you can also order takeout (and merch) from the left-side area. The restaurant is larger than it looks since there's a second seating area too. I'd recommend the Flight of mini lobster rolls (3x 2oz lobster rolls), which can be chilled or warmed. Prices are fair, at about $20 a lobster roll. Their ghee butter add another level to their lobster rolls and they don't skimp on meat! Definitely try out the Highroller and maybe get some of their iconic merch.

On our last day in Portland, my wife and I stopped here for lobster rolls. Getting lobster rolls…read morewas a must during our trip, and I read enough great reviews that we agreed to stop here. Plus, my wife had been here in the past and loved it. We came on a Monday afternoon and were surprised to hear there was a wait to be seated, but understandable since it's a bit of a tourist destination. We were told to expect a 20 minute wait, but since it was only 2 of us they were able to seat us only a few minutes later at the counter. We didn't even look through the rest of the menu. We knew what we came for and what we wanted: lobster rolls. The only hard decision we had to make was what sauces we wanted. I ended up going with the garlic mayo, while she opted for the charred pineapple mayo and the mango habañero mayo. We both chose to have ours warmed rather than cold. Unsurprisingly, they were delicious. The mango habañero mayo was hotter than my wife expected, but she still enjoyed her selection. Ultimately, not much to complain about. It's a little pricey but that's to be expected for lobster. Cool vibe inside, quality food, clean. If we had to wait longer than we did, I may be singing a different tune, but our experience was great. If you're in the area and the wait's not ridiculous, give it a try.

Photos
The Highroller Lobster - SO GOOD. Lobster tasted so fresh and tender. Bread was hefty and a great compliment. (Lobster Roll)

SO GOOD. Lobster tasted so fresh and tender. Bread was hefty and a great compliment. (Lobster Roll)

The Highroller Lobster
The Highroller Lobster - Lobster Cheese Crisp Taco, Lobster Roll

See all

Lobster Cheese Crisp Taco, Lobster Roll

Dry Dock

Dry Dock

4.3(98 reviews)
0.1 mi•Old Port

The husband and I dined at Dry Dock during our trip to Portland over Labor Day weekend. There was a…read moreline waiting for tables even though it was only 5:30pm on a Saturday - this place is popular. And for good reason! The food was insanely delicious!! We snagged an open spot at the bar and was immediately greeted by the one-and-only, Eddie. He was fun, kind, attentive and entertaining. We started with the caesar salad, which was good and had a nice lemony finish. I ordered the baked haddock and the hubs ordered the blackened fish sandwich. The sandwich was good but the baked haddock was a clear winner (not that it was a competition!) The baked haddock had a panko crust and smothered in a tomato wine sauce over puréed potatoes. To. Die. For! My husband isn't a huge fish lover and he basically stole my plate. He loved it - and so did I! Highly recommend. Overall, if you're in Portland, make it a point to dine at Dry Dock. P.S. don't let the wait time deter you. This place is big and they were sitting people quickly. And if you have a chance, grab a seat at the bar with Eddie. He's good people!

We stopped by for a drink and enjoyed our time at the bar. This was our last stop in Portland…read morebefore heading home, so we used it to take a beat and chat about our day. Staff was kind and it wasn't busy, but it was also around 4:30ish on a Friday, so probably right between rush times. The food smelled great! We wanted to eat but had dinner plans elsewhere. Great views of the water if you're upstairs, and spacious seating downstairs. Lovely wine and drink menu, and it's very clean.

Photos
Dry Dock
Dry Dock
Dry Dock

See all

SoPo Seafood Market & Raw Bar - Wolfe River raw oysters

SoPo Seafood Market & Raw Bar

4.7(122 reviews)
1.4 mi
•$$

Hands down one of the best seafood spots in Portland, especially for the price!…read more My husband and I are big seafood lovers, so we had to stop here during our trip. We started with the fish chowder since they didn't have clam chowder. This was probably the only dish that felt average to me, although my husband really enjoyed it. Everything else was a completely different story. The raw seafood was so fresh. We tried the oysters, clams, scallops, and spoons, and every bite tasted clean, fresh, and high quality. The prices were also surprisingly reasonable compared to a lot of other places serving similar seafood. For our entrees, we both went with the hot butter lobster roll. It was classic, simple, and exactly what I expected a good lobster roll to taste like. For the price, I definitely think it was worth it. The restaurant has a casual, laid back ambiance, which fits perfectly with the no frills seafood experience. It's a great spot if you're looking for something relaxed rather than fancy. Service was attentive, friendly, and overall great. If you're in Portland and craving seafood without wanting to spend a fortune, I highly recommend giving this place a try!

OMG Great Seafood…read more Some of the best oysters. Had 5 different oysters all anywhere they come from. Awesome had raw scallops good but not as good as the oysters, My niece Liv had a sampler platter with Tuna & caviar etc... Full bar. I had a mocktail Great waitress my bad I forgot her name & Alex the shucker was also awesome. There a combination restaurant & market very busy place great for people watching. Go there now

Photos
SoPo Seafood Market & Raw Bar - Bar seating

Bar seating

SoPo Seafood Market & Raw Bar
SoPo Seafood Market & Raw Bar - Deli counter menu

See all

Deli counter menu

The Shop - bloody mary (already ate the oyster, oops)

The Shop

4.6(267 reviews)
0.8 mi•East End
•$$

This place came recommended by multiple people, and now that I've been, I can really see why this…read moreis a must-visit in Portland. Once you are seated, you're handed a paper menu on which you mark your selections, then bring that marked-up menu to the counter, where you order and get a number. Food is brought up to you, and you can order subsequent rounds of food by crossing out previous orders and marking up the menu anew. I would highly recommend multiple rounds of oysters -- the first to try one of each and figure out which varieties you prefer, the second to get more of the ones you like, and the last to go all in on your favorite. They've got a varied selection that will suit various tastes, whether you favor a large creamy oyster, a small briny guy, or somewhere in between. All from Maine, which made me feel better about having oysters in a non-ber month. The oysters here are top notch, and the shuckers are, too. Not a single speck of shell in there! I love oysters, and this was my paradise. The non oyster items are also worth trying, so if you have a friend who isn't into oysters, there's something here for them, too. The smoked fish dip and french onion dip are awesome, and the chips they get from another local producer are fantastic. Whether you're a beer lover, a wine person, or a cocktailer, they've got something for you here. Any of those could be the perfect company for your favorite oyster, or you could go for their cucumber mint lemonade slushy, which is insanely refreshing and a great palate cleanser between oysters. Service is efficient, welcoming, and friendly. I think anyone from an oyster novice to an aficionado would feel right at home here. If I didn't live on the opposite side of the country, I'd be here all the time. Unfortunately for me, I'm relegated to pining for these oysters from a distance. If you live nearby, take advantage of your proximity and eat some oysters for me.

This place was a great spot for some fresh oysters. They had a decent sized lot and an open space…read morein the restaurant. The host let you pick where to sit, they had a lot of long tables but you can spread out so you're not sitting directly next to someone. They give you paper menus so you just check out anything you want and order at the counter. Drinks are presented by the front, they did have happy hour for certain items but I'm not sure if the blackboard already presented any happy hour prices or if it was just like $2 off. I would say the oysters were definitely worth it if you like eating them. Note that the sauces are extra and they don't give you that much. You check them off on the menu and there is a charge so if you're just getting to get, keep that in mind. Our favorite were the sweeter ones and they are pretty quick with shucking and bringing them to you after you order. We also ordered Smoked Fish Spread which I would recommend. It was nice to have a little dip to eat with though I wish there was more pickled onion. We also got the Elote Hotdog which was quite small for like $10 I wouldn't recommend that, I would say stick to the classic menu. The drinks were okay. The Bloody Mary tasted like straight V8 and was in a pretty big cup too so couldn't really taste the vodka. We also got a gin drink that was a little bitter but I think that was due to the fruit. Overall a decent place to stop for oysters. The fish spread was also nice but if you want other items I would say try a different place.

Photos
The Shop - Oyster shooter

Oyster shooter

The Shop - Exterior

Exterior

The Shop - From the street- plenty of parking

See all

From the street- plenty of parking

DiMillo's On The Roll - seafood - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...