Love this pizza most in southwest Michigan. Have enjoyed it regularly since 1978. Still live in the neighborhood! read more

Food was very good for the location. It wasn't what I was expecting but is closer to me than Hartford so thought we'd try it. The pizza was the best but I don't get a picture. I'd get the pizza if you go and skip the bread and pasta. Service was fast and friendly and it was clean and semi warm in there (went during winter) Will return when I'm craving pizza again! read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Cheese garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

See all

They do make a great speciality large pizza. Just ordered one. Yummy. Added black olives.

Nancy (our server) was AMAZING! Every booth was full, every table was full and the bar stools were all full and she handled it all flawlessly!! They'd have to hire 3 people to replace this woman. The kitchen staff is great also. We had a side salad - large portion and fresh and crisp. We had a large pizza with sausage & mushrooms over all and pepperoni on just half. It was hot out of the oven and EXCELLANT as always. It is always clean inside. Will DEFINATELY return it's one of our regular stops. I have to say without Nancy there it's not the same. read more

See all

So every time I ride by this place it was busy so I finally decided to give it a try. Jody was our server and she saved the day!!! She was a great server she never let the drinks get empty and served that food fresh and hot the pizza was great the meatball plate was fabulous and the grilled mushrooms were the bomb!!!! Loved everything about the food will be back!!! read more

I can't tell you how many times we've driven by this place over the years, but we finally decided to give it a try and order carry out. We ordered the meatballs, a 14" pizza and a burger. All were very good! If you aren't used to these small restaurants in the area, just know that this place is cash only like many others - so don't be surprised by that. Also, they don't have fries on the menu, but that wasn't a deal breaker. They do offer bagged chips as a side option with the burger. read more

The best pizza anywhere - hands down. You cannot beat this pizza (and I don't care what they say in NY).

Best pizza!! Very family oriented and the food is fantastic!! I would highly recommend this to family's all around!!

Always fast to the table (or barstool) with friendly service! 3 different ways to have your pie ( we usually go thin but the deep is great also! If you need (or just NEED) an appetizer don't miss the meatball plate or antipasto. The beer is always cold and full bar is available. We have friends when in town that don't need to have arms twisted to go there again and again! read more

Consistently Good food, good service, even good wine! Great family place! Love the new look.

As an out of towner passing through, I did not have a good dining experience here. The service was not great. The food was incredibly bland and way overpriced (16$) for a greasy, small sized cheese pizza. I can only describe the ambiance/ vibes as unfriendly/ unwelcoming. We basically were ignored by the waitress the entire night but it seemed like the town locals got lots of attention. It took about 7 minutes after being seated to even get menus. The confusing mix of one-sided political news and game shows on the TVs did not help the strange vibes. Also- note they only take cash, with a hefty ATM fee (that doesn't take Amex either). Overall, I'd skip and go to little Caesar's. read more

First I would like to say we always love the pizza at DiMaggio's but tonight I would like to let you know that our server was AWESOME. Christina was EXCELLENT! She went above and beyond to make us feel special. We will be returing to your place and hopefully we will get Christina again. read more

Its a Great stop! Great pizza and good service. I Wish they had a 16in pizza. Good news there's PACMAN in the corner.

Everything we needed on our road trip the the Michigan Gambler 500. Burger was excellent. Best burger I had in years. Didn't have the pizza but it looked and smelled amazing. read more

DiMaggio's pizza and burgers is well known for their food. Cocktails are reasonably priced Pizza is best in the area. I always order double sausage pizza with mushrooms and onions. All the waitresses are nice and cordial . Everything on the menu is good I personally like the Italian beef sandwich and the meatball sandwich You won't be disappointed if you come here to eat. I recommend this establishment read more

The pictures look great. When we picked our pizzas up, they looked even better. The flavor? Well, the crust was really good. The toppings were superb. The pizza sauce is the problem. No flavor. Oh so close to having a killer pizza. Unfortunately it missed the mark. read more

Terrific. Years of great food and service. A family favorite for my kids and grandkids.

Pizza was ok, drink order was wrong, the service was slow but at least I got to eat my pizza off of a paper plate....

My go-to place for good pizza in SW Michigan! I've been going to DiMaggio's my whole life and I'm now 67! While the pizza isn't quite the same as it used to be years ago, it's still the best pizza available in all of SW Michigan. I drive from 50 miles away just to have their pizza! They use ample cheese, nice crunchy crust, good sausage, just overall delicious as evidenced by the pictures attached to this review. read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Small (12") sausage, mushroom, onion, pepper pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

See all

Tried to place an order for pick up and guy was rude and hung up on me right away. I'm sure it's good food but wouldn't know since I couldn't place an order. read more

The food is not good and honestly the staff is very very unfriendly. We actually weren't sure if it was part of the deal like an Ed Debevic's where they purposely treat you rudely. We live in the neighborhood and pop in now and again just for a beer or two. They treat you like you are bothering them by sitting at the bar. Very disappointing because it's the only place around us, but we won't be going there again. We have given them more than enough chances. read more

Best around for 30+ years. Usually get take out, but dining in can be a fun experience too.

They close whenever they decide to. They don't honor their own hours. They were rude and aggressive about not serving, serval, cars of people who were turned away an hour before they closed. They claimed the kitchen closes a half hour before they do but it was barely 9:15 when they supposedly close at 10:00. Can't even judge them on their food because they wouldn't let us have any...super disappointing. read more

If you want a great pizza this is where to go. Then add the local part lol. It's just a great pie. It has a nice crunch. Enough sauce and toppings.. If you live in a 25 mile radius this is a must. If you're going to St Joes or South Haven being a tourist and wanna switch gears. Go here. Hometown family feel. Relaxed dining. Booths and tables. A nice bar. A few tvs on local stations. Expect a lil wait on a weekend evening, get a lil appetizer. Friday night was an hour for 2 large pies. Got an app. A few beers and PIZZA. Staff was nice. Prompt. Easygoing read more

See all

The fact that they don't take credit card, started to bother me the next few times I went there. Customers have to use the atm in their restaurant, and the atm charges a lot ($3.50), which of course goes to DiMaggio's... I asked for marinara sauce and they asked for $2.50 for a tiny amount of sauce. On top of all that, they're rude... read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

See all

Cash or check only. An ATM was available. Sunday eve: The restaurant was busy, but I was able to get a table. It seemed short-staffed. I ordered an appetizer, and the vegetarian pizza was good. The ambiance was loud, and some diners were obnoxiously vulgar, even in the presence of children with parents. It's not a place for a family with children--even on Sundays. read more

Ordered a large Special Pizza with double sausage for carry out, was delicious! Crust was very nice, and perfect amount of cheese. read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Tasty Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

I enjoyed my last two meals here at DiMaggio's. We had 3 takeout pizzas in mid July. They were enjoyed by all ages 77 to nine. We dined in on the last Sunday in August and although they were quite busy our food came in a reasonable time and was hot and tasty. read more

I can usually find good in most places but this was hard. The pizza is just ok. No real creativity in their offerings. Thin crust but you have a choice of thick if you add 20 minutes to your order. Our thin crust pizza took 90 minutes so beware. There is no indication if you're to be seated or if some one will do that for you so we saw customers get yelled at by the wait staff for jumping the line. They only take cash and checks so be prepared. They do offer an ATM. It looked like they had a bar but our waitress was so surly and rude we just stuck with water. After 75 minutes we asked about our pizza and we're told she had no idea and was too busy to check. The final negative is they use cheap paper plates for dinner plates. The interior was clean and bright after a fire a year or two ago but it's like putting lipstick on a pig... it's still a pig. read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - The special pizza with added pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

See all

Tho the pizza is not bad here but definitely not worth the attitude from the elderly skinny blonde with short hair and glasses, she closed half of the seating area in restaurant and told my family of 4 that there are no tables right now and will be bid of a wait, I saw a couple getting ready to leave a booth and the waitress yelled from the bar to me that table is taken when the couple leave and that there will a bit of a wait she repeated to us, so we left and went to VILLA NOVA IN NEW BUFFALO where they some awesome pizza and great service which will now be my go to when in the area. read more

I was so excited to take my friend there for a pizza;as she's never been there. We ordered a veggie pizza. Never asked for a thin crust. When it came out I was shocked to see that more than half the edge was burnt and there was barely any sauce on it. Let's just say I've eaten better frozen pizzas I did complain to our server and she did only charge me for the cheese pizza. Such a disappointment. Definitely was a huge disappointment. read more

I wish I could give it 3.5 stars. Went last night with my dad and son. My son had the spaghetti with meat sauce; he said it was okay but, he wouldn't have it again...that being said he ate all of it. My dad and I ordered a large thin crust pepperoni and extra cheese pizza. It looked absolutely delicious but, didn't have much flavor. I'm not sure if it's because it had so much cheese that that drowned out the sauce or if the sauce was under seasoned. Service was good. It's cash or check only. They do have an ATM. read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Spaghetti and Meat Sauce - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

This place was really cool. Sadly it burnt up and was remodeled in 2019 so it was a clash of tradition with modern interior. This would be a great place to belly up to the bar and enjoy some food. We had the pizza to go. All were great. Wish I would have known they have 3 thicknesses of crust. If you don't ask you'll get the standard but they have a thin and thick. I imagine the thin crust with mushroom is amazing! read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

See all

Honestly one of the worst pizzas I've ever had ... it's like they tried to reinvent the wheel and cut the pizza into thin strips like cheesy bread... can't hold the pizza right .. like trying to hold a lasagna noodle if it was the crust ... flavorless .. can't remember the last time I put salt on my pizza oh and the place also could use a visit from an exterminator.. bugs all over the inside windows jumping on your table ..And the Ranch Dressing blows read more

Pluses: Fast service; easily accessible in the Hagar Park area. Negatives: Salad was shredded lettuce and a pale tomato; pizza crusts were cardboard quality. Conclusion: skip this place if you are craving good pizza. DiMaggios are lucky they have a captive audience in the area. read more

Highly recommend this being a stop for anyone looking for some good pizza. The crust was crisp and not too thick. They have an option for thicker or thinner crust. I would recommend going with the regular crust. The toppings were fresh and the sausage was amazing. The pizza sauce had a nice flavor as well. If you like Chicago style pizza, I would recommend stopping at this gem off the beaten path. We got the 18" which ran us $20.99 after taxes. It's a bit pricey but was well worth it. Additionally, the staff was very friendly and on the ball. She was the primary person working up front and handling all the ordering, serving, payments and bar. read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Seating and bar area. - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

See all

Great pizza and atmosphere. Service was top notch. Would definitely return next time in the area!

While spending the week at Paw Paw Lake we had a taste for a pizza night. After going back and forth on several choices nearby we settled on DiMaggio's (based on others' reviews) and were not disappointed! They have delicious pizza and the staff is welcoming and friendly. We're from Chicago and I absolutely love New York style pizza, so I'm on good authority to say that DiMaggio's pies are top-notch. We were feeding 10 people (4 adults, 2 seniors, 4 kids) so we went with 2 large and 2 small with a side of Garlic Bread w/ cheese. We picked up and brought it back to the house and it was still hot-and-ready to eat. They cut their pizzas into squares, which is fine (triangles are better...), and they do a good job of loading up on the toppings. Not to mention the taste of the sauce... it really makes or breaks a pizza and here it made it. A big thanks to DiMaggio's staff for serving up the good stuff with a smile and also a nod to Yelpers - we wouldn't have found this spot if it weren't for your reviews. If you're vacationing in the area, or you're a local, don't pass this place by, it's great! read more

Very friendly staff. Service was good. Food was delicious Atmosphere was nice. Special orders were no problem read more

Stopped on Saturday night late. Waitress was pleasant and pizza was very good. Thin crust & plenty of toppings.