DiMaggio&#x27;s Pizza &amp; Burgers

Subpar "italian" food, the main thing they have going for them is they're open late. Husband and I…read moreordered food to go because we got into town late and needed food before settling in. Lasagna was good, but it came with a very underwhelming side salad. It was majority lettuce and two tomato chunks and a pepperoncini. Husband's sandwich came with no condiments at all. No mayo, mustard, etc? Wasn't even offered it at the check out or when the food came out so I assumed they make sandwiches as is or they put it in the to go bag. I didn't really know what the ingredients were in the dishes because their menu at the check out counter doesn't fully describe things. Of course we don't discover there were no condiments til we are home so he ate a dry sandwich. Unfortunately we only opted to come here out of desperation and it was disappointing. It was also confusing because we get here thinking we can sit in but we were never offered that and the chairs were all up. We came well before the posted closing hours, so all they said was "we'll bring it out to your car". Kind of a weird vibe.

Roma has some decent pizza. I am from Chicago so my standards are pretty high ( pizza snob). We…read morehave ordered Roma more than a few times when we have guests & they are always pleased. The sauce is a ' lil sweet and crust is thin but could be thinner & crispier. Definitely recommend giving it a try. It is take out only so you can enjoy at home.

12inch Deep Dish

See all

Large pepperoni pizza

Pour House

2.2(6 reviews)

4.3 mi

Called the Pour House, but the bartender can't pour drinks??…read more Ordered a whiskey shot with a coke back. I had to explain what a coke back was. Even after I explained it was chaser for the shot, he still didn't get it. Brought me a full sized coke. The whiskey shot came in a cocktail glass with ice. I guess maybe they don't have shot glasses....at a bar...?? Also ordered a whiskey ginger ale and it seemed this was the first he'd ever heard of ginger ale. Really weird experience.

The pour house is a no frills, take no prisoner, wonderful spot. The atmosphere is pretty old…read moreschool and it is definitely frequented by regulars who may have been going there since forever. Every time I've gone there I've left smiling - great spot ! Laura is a fantastic hostess and bartender

See all

Storefront

Saylor's Main Street Pizzeria

3.8(33 reviews)

6.3 mi

Saylor's Main St Pizza deserves its own spot on the Pizza Hall of Fame (yes, that should be a real…read morething). I placed a large order--like, "feeding a small army" large--and they didn't blink. No panic. No delay. Just perfectly cheesy, crispy-edged, saucy goodness, delivered with the confidence of a team that knows they're elite. Every pizza came out hot and fresh, like it had just done a runway walk out of the oven. The crust had that perfect crunch-meets-chew ratio, the toppings were generous, and not a single slice was left behind. Even the pineapple-on-pizza skeptics were converted. Miracles were witnessed. I don't know who's running the kitchen back there, but I suspect it's a team of culinary ninjas trained in mozzarella warfare. Respect. Saylor's: 10/10, would abandon all future diets for you again.

You want the most bang for your buck? Sick of the hut?…read more This place is for you, get the family special and eat like a king for the whole day. The prices are very reasonable when compared to other places.

See all

Pizza Hut

2.7(23 reviews)

4.3 mi

We live dangerously close to this location & not sad about it! It is nice because we can phone…read moreahead & pick up pizzas for our guests that helps us maximize our time on the lake! They do have a dining room if you want to make it a night out but I do not think they have alcohol. Plenty of parking & staff is always friendly & service is quick. Definitely give this Pizza Hut a try the pizza is oh so yummy ( you can even get a personal pizza so great for lunch)!

Friendly fast service and of course Pizza Hut has decent pizza. Clean large dining area.read more

See all

Arclight Brewing

4.2(84 reviews)

6.3 mi

You get the feeling while there that the staff just kinda gave up on being in business…read more Don't rotate beers and the beer offerings keep dropping, like they are just selling off inventory. Place had a lot going for it at one time but it's just withering away now.

First Bring Your Own Food…read more Service was good - sociable Cute place for Good Brews Pretty cool board games and foosball table

Beer

See all

Beer Flight

Casey's

3.6(13 reviews)

6.5 mi

All but four punps were out of order, the pump I chose didnt end up working and I had to get gas…read moreacross the street. The only reason I stopped was to get some pizza and take a break, I was really disappointed that the bathroom was gross and there was no pizza made, at 630pm, on a Saturday. I've been to Casey's all over the US and normally they are an amazing experience. This one was an outlier, do better.

I am excited for Casey's in Hartford. The staff is friendly and the price of gas is generally lower…read morethan other area gas stations. I had to feed a bunch of high schoolers and placed an order for 14 pizzas and everything was ready, hot, and well received.

Doughnuts

See all

Waterfront

2.7(85 reviews)

5.3 mi

Great waterfront seating, beautiful view of the lake and boaters/swimmers…read more We were thirsty so asked for some ice water. The glasses and silverware were already on the tables, so the waiter brought a very large necked blue wine bottle full of water so we could serve ourselves - nice touch. We both ordered the Whitefish sandwich, it came with a large portion of very lightly breaded fish, crusted roll (maybe sourdough?), lettuce and tomato with tartar sauce on the side. I usually avoid the Tarter sauce unless the fish is not good - and it was very good. Sandwich came with potato chips. We also ordered their side waffle fries, extra crispy; which were good too. We split an awesome slice of German Chocolate cake w/ the most excellent coconut and nut frosting! The waiter was excellent, friendly and helpful. We had the pleasure of meeting the Chef and had great conversations, Later we saw him come outside seemingly looking like he was pulling weed, until I realized he was harvesting fresh herbs he was growing, for a customer's dish he was preparing. We will be back

We had a lovely celebration dinner here last night. The crab stuffed mushrooms were fresh, cooked…read moreto order, and had real crab. The Italian items are where they shine. The homemade lasagna and meatballs were clearly made with love, well seasoned, and cooked to perfection. Staff made the night special.

Side Patio

Crandberry Summertime salad

See all

Chocolate chore, ribs, wedge salad

Vineyard 2121

3.4(124 reviews)

5.2 mi

Decent wines, ciders and beers. Ok food. Mediocre live music that was too loud. Geat view! Good…read moreservice. Will go again.

We were driving thru Benton Harbor and saw this cute winery online so we decided to stop in since…read moreit was a rainy afternoon. We were greeted by Jessica who was super nice. We did a flight of reds along with a Caramel Apple cider. We also ordered their whitefish dip (GF). She was so nice she bought my wife crackers and veggies since she's GF and a basket of regular crackers for me. The wines were very good as was the cider. We loved Third Times a Charm which was a red blend. We bought a bottle even tho it was pricey..39.00. They have indoor and outdoor seating as well as live entertainment and food specials on certain nights of the week. Check their website for more details. Whether your a wine enthusiast or just looking for a fun time, Vineyard 2121 is definitely worth a visit...voted Best Local Winery year after year.

Graffiti wall outside restrooms

Flight of red wines

See all

Rain rain go away

Taco Bell

2.2(36 reviews)

6.5 mi

today I got Taco Bell i thought it was gonna be a normal meal but when I checked the second taco…read more It almost has no beef. Bro what the fuck is a taco without any beef

This was a really disappointing experience from start to finish. The place itself was in rough…read moreshape -- the front door wouldn't even close properly, and the tables were noticeably greasy, which made it feel unclean right away. Service was slow, even though there were at least six employees working. It didn't seem organized, and we waited much longer than expected for our food. The drink situation didn't help either. Every soda from the machine was flat, the lemonade was watered down, and the ice dispenser wasn't working at all. On top of all that, the prices were high for the quality and overall experience we received. Nothing about this visit justified the cost. Unfortunately, I won't be coming back anytime soon.

See all

Subway

2.7(19 reviews)

4.3 mi

We were in the area and had originally planned on going to the Watervliet location, but a sign on…read morethe door informed us it is permanently closed and to venture over to Coloma. This location wasn't too far so we decided to follow our Subway loving stomachs to this location. I personally have always liked the way Subway restaurants are decorated and this location is as adorably decorated as the others. Restroom was clean, as was the drink station and the rest of the restaurant. Chips were well organized and everything seemed stocked well except the bacon, which my husband was disappointed they were out of. Both employees that were out front were working quickly and standard quick food service friendly. I got the #23 untoasted with lettuce, onion and banana peppers as well as the vinaigrette dressing. My husband got a chicken breast and steak sandwich with a sauce I cannot recall. We both enjoyed our sandwiches very much. Other than being out of bacon this Subway was a pretty standard Subway stop. If we're in the area and craving a Subway sandwich I would consider coming back.

Just wanted to write this in hopes the manager sees it. I think your toaster is going out, got two…read moresandwiches toasted and only one was toasted and the other was still raw! Great food tho and the employees are awesome but please get a new toaster

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

11 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Jim S.

1

0

19 years ago

Their pizza is outstanding. They keep it simple. One size pizza with any or all toppings. Excellent, sausage and peperoni. Burgers, Meatball and Sausage sandwiches are all excellent. A great place to meet people after a long day on the beach. I have lived in Chicago all my life, I prefer thin crust pizza and this rates up there with the best. The only entertainment is a Juke Box and a local named Big Jack! read more

Ann C.

15

8

7

4 years ago

It is a local, out of the way place. Love their pizzas and a great place to have a cocktail.The bartenders are very generous with their pours! Their food is always delicious! This is a cash or check only - no CC. read more

Ralph M.

247

71

62

10 years ago

We are back again this summer. Denise is running the show as usual and the best. They brought in Saugatuck microbrews this year! Just a great place with awesome pizza read more

Eeesketit 8.

0

1

0

7 years ago

The spegetti was water then my girlfriend, I wanted food not a lake they need to fix this or they will lose service LEARN HOW TO COOK and the fat bartender is so rude read more

Lyn H.

0

10

3

3 years ago

Came down to Michigan to visit my Best Friend. Happened to find it secretly nestled in town....Love it Chicago Style hidden in Coloma Michigan!! read more

Elittlebeth S.

1

76

56

6 years ago

Large veggie pizza was good, filled us up when we were hungry. It was not great. Good for the area.

Derek H.

1

5

30

3 years ago

Yummo pizza. I ate it on the beach with a pretty lady. It paired well with a Michigan beer.

John G.

0

10

0

11 years ago

Food is traditionally great. Usually a long wait time on weekends and holidays.

Jim P.

179

73

234

14 years ago

So good. Just really good, honest, simple pizza.

Kylie R.

8

6

0

9 years ago

One of the best pizzas in MI by far!

Nicholas P.

3

48

6

13 years ago

Decent pizza.

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Coloma, Michigan Restaurants near DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers

BEST of Coloma, Michigan Desserts near DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers

BEST of Coloma, Michigan Breakfast near DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers

BEST of Coloma, Michigan Things to Do near DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers

BEST of Coloma, Michigan Coffee near DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers

BEST of Coloma, Michigan Dinner near DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers

BEST of Coloma, Michigan Burgers near DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers

BEST of Coloma, Michigan Shopping near DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers

BEST of Coloma, Michigan Thrift Stores near DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers

Best of Coloma

Things to do in Coloma

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers also viewed

Gala-T-Inn

3.8

(32 reviews)

Friendly service and excellent food. Generous portions, too. Homemade lasagna is the best. Their…read morepizza rates right up there with Chicago's best.

Went for a pizza. Ordered the gala-t special. Included Italian sausage, pepperoni, bacon, onions&…read moremushrooms. Generous amount of toppings and cheese. Really like their thin crispy crust. Caleb our server, did a great job with service, refilled soda. He was friendly and personable. Great pizza!

Roma Pizza

4.2

(31 reviews)

We have been going to Roma since they opened years & years ago…read more The last couple of times we've ordered the pizza has been very disappointing. There has been barely any sauce on the pizza. I've even sent pictures to the owner (the original owners son showing no sauce). I've tried numerous ways to tell them that you should be able to taste sauce on a pizza. I've had to pay for extra sauce as a topping and even then it's NOT EXTRA it's what it normally was a couple years ago. The mushrooms on it are sparse as is the sausage The pizza last night had a weird taste. We did order pepperoni on half which we normally don't do. The sauce had a strange taste and the whole pizza had a different taste and smell. They've raised prices which I understand but you don't raise prices and not make the pizza as it's been made for years Very disappointing and not a pizza we will have anytime soon again. I know what their pizzas taste like and that pizza was NOT it. After 20+ (possibly close to 30) years of ordering it's sad that Roma is no longer the same.

Tired of having to tell them "cooked pepperoni on top of cheese". Their preference is to put it on…read moreat the end of the baking. Raw pepperoni. They still screw it up more often than get it right. The only pizza place I have ever ordered from that doesn't cook pepperoni . Try to be different some other way.

DiPisa's Pizza

3.9

(42 reviews)

I stopped in for a takeout order on two different occasions. The meatballs and sauce are good. The…read morepoor boy sandwich was just ok. The pizza is good, thick crust around the edges. I don't think that the ranch is homemade but the one they use tastes ok. The pizza sauce is sparse, so I got some extra, and some banana peppers on the side. Service is friendly.

Got the chance to try a few different items from here tonight. We had a work meeting that provided…read moredinner of cheese pizza, pepperoni pizza, salad, and breadsticks. The pizza was hot and delicious as were the breadsticks. I had never gotten pizza here before today but this will most certainly not be the last time because I'd like to introduce my husband to this glorious food. Slices were on the thin side but also long and filling as well. I only needed 2 slices, a small bite of salad and a single breadstick to get full. If you're hungry for pizza while in Stevensville I would highly recommend coming by DiPisa's for some pizza.

Saylor's Main Street Pizzeria

3.8

(33 reviews)

Saylor's Main St Pizza deserves its own spot on the Pizza Hall of Fame (yes, that should be a real…read morething). I placed a large order--like, "feeding a small army" large--and they didn't blink. No panic. No delay. Just perfectly cheesy, crispy-edged, saucy goodness, delivered with the confidence of a team that knows they're elite. Every pizza came out hot and fresh, like it had just done a runway walk out of the oven. The crust had that perfect crunch-meets-chew ratio, the toppings were generous, and not a single slice was left behind. Even the pineapple-on-pizza skeptics were converted. Miracles were witnessed. I don't know who's running the kitchen back there, but I suspect it's a team of culinary ninjas trained in mozzarella warfare. Respect. Saylor's: 10/10, would abandon all future diets for you again.

You want the most bang for your buck? Sick of the hut?…read more This place is for you, get the family special and eat like a king for the whole day. The prices are very reasonable when compared to other places.

Roma Pizza Restaurant of Coloma

3.5

(35 reviews)

Subpar "italian" food, the main thing they have going for them is they're open late. Husband and I…read moreordered food to go because we got into town late and needed food before settling in. Lasagna was good, but it came with a very underwhelming side salad. It was majority lettuce and two tomato chunks and a pepperoncini. Husband's sandwich came with no condiments at all. No mayo, mustard, etc? Wasn't even offered it at the check out or when the food came out so I assumed they make sandwiches as is or they put it in the to go bag. I didn't really know what the ingredients were in the dishes because their menu at the check out counter doesn't fully describe things. Of course we don't discover there were no condiments til we are home so he ate a dry sandwich. Unfortunately we only opted to come here out of desperation and it was disappointing. It was also confusing because we get here thinking we can sit in but we were never offered that and the chairs were all up. We came well before the posted closing hours, so all they said was "we'll bring it out to your car". Kind of a weird vibe.

Roma has some decent pizza. I am from Chicago so my standards are pretty high ( pizza snob). We…read morehave ordered Roma more than a few times when we have guests & they are always pleased. The sauce is a ' lil sweet and crust is thin but could be thinner & crispier. Definitely recommend giving it a try. It is take out only so you can enjoy at home.

Propaganda Pizza

4.3

(45 reviews)

I'm so bummed. First time I came here it was the best quality, because the owner was working. The…read morepizza was perfect, and we couldn't wait to come back. The second time we came here, the owner wasn't in and the girl working had a major attitude because we asked for napkins. The pizza was super greasy and the crust wasn't cut so we had to use a knife. Sigh. I guess go in when the owner is there for the best pizza otherwise lower your expectations, a lot! Pictures are same pizza from first visit and second visit. Will try again but would call first to make sure the owner is on premises.

Mixed feelings for this place. I have celiacs disease so it's a safe and good option. Recently i've…read morebeen running into problems when the younger people are working. They will disable online orders while they're open and say they will be back at whatever time, go back to check and they move it again to a later time and also won't pick up the phone. They answered one time and told me to hang on, and then hung up. I finally got my order. I ordered chicken ranch pizza, no bacon or onions. there were onions. also, i couldn't eat dinner last night and had to waste $30 because the black stuff all on the bottom was so strong and gross!! ... i eat here pretty regularly and this is happening every so often.. very upsetting. please better train your employees. there's a really nice lady with brunette hair who i assume is the owner? i'm not sure. The only time my food is good from here is if she's working.

Barnstormers Pizza & More

4.6

(53 reviews)

We're from Ohio in town to visit our college student. Got pizza and garlic knots and loved all of…read moreit! Very pleasant staff and extremely cool aviation theme! I loved the writing on the pizza box as well! Great experience!

ALL OF IT! The "Control Tower" had all the best ingredients, the staff and Don, the owner, very…read morefriendly, their restaurant is clean as a whistle. If you like aircraft and flying, you'll appreciate the surroundings. Just you try - to sneak out without a cheer and a thank you from the crew.... BETTER PIZZA THAN SILVER BEACH!

Nardo's Pizza

4.2

(40 reviews)

Wow! One of the best vegan pizzas I've ever had. The crust is great with tasty toasty edges. The…read morevegan cheese melts nicely and that vegan pepperoni has a nice slight spice to it that I loved. 10/10 Nardo's rules. Shoutout to the super kind employees. Also the arcade interior is totally awesome and their rockstar mural is fabulous.

Enter the rave basement to find a pizza arcade that is ALMOST kid friendly. The games all work…read morewell, even the pinball. My kids thought they had skee ball but they did not. They definitely need more games to fill in better. Sunday seems like the day to go with your kids, but the party here seems to fizzle out Saturday night. They had one person tending everything. Pizza is fine. Not amazing but it has it's own style. We did not try the pan pizza. The kids got bored quick, they need more crane games and a skee ball line up. 1 of 2 cranes worked, but it did pay out almost every time for $1. Cool place, would come back.

Subs N More

3.6

(85 reviews)