Demi has been getting a lot of hype lately. It was named the Twin Cities restaurant of the year, and talk is swirling of a Michelin star. With that hype comes a hefty price tag: the Whitney menu, the larger of the two options (which I recommend spending a bit extra on, since you are already splurging) will set you back $180 per guest without any drinks. Naturally, that means that diners will (and should) have higher expectations for their evening than eating at, say, a $30 or even a $50 per person restaurant. By many rights, the evening lives up to that hype, with the majority of dishes tasting exceptional, the quality of the food being amazing, and the service mostly being great. However, for $180 per person (plus another $100 to share a wine paring), we expected near perfection from the evening, and with that in mind, Demi fell short. Here's why:
The service: Everyone was super attentive and friendly. The hostess remembered our name from the start and throughout the evening, and the head chef spent time talking to us a few times throughout the night. However, a few of the food presentations were a bit rushed. With this much complexity, we would have appreciated recommendations of *how* to best enjoy each dish in addition to what each dish was, and we only got that about half the time. We also noticed some of the chefs slipping up a bit when giving details to guests around us; they almost seemed a little unsure of themselves (for example, one chef first stated a dish was Chinese in origin, then had to correct themselves to say it was Japanese). All of this was very minor, and didn't take away from the actual taste of the food, but I would have expected better attention to detail from this type of restaurant. Giving everyone a copy of the menu at the end was a nice touch that we appreciated.
The food and drink: The quality of the food here is 95% amazing. Nearly everything we tried made our taste buds go "wow!" The foie gras and quail dishes were particularly great; they are probably two of the best dishes I've ever had. The wine pairing was also good, and while we split one, we thought that the quality and amount of wine was well worth it (one pairing felt like more than enough for two).
However, there were some minor imperfections scattered throughout the evening. These included things like the crust on the cheese being super, super dry (almost like a saltine), the bean sprouts on the beef plate being super bitter - taking a lot away from the dish, and the poor quality of coffee offered at the end (at a place with such attention to detail, I would have expected something akin to what's served at Dogwood or Spyhouse, but Demi's coffee tasted like the batch-brew you would get at a Denny's).
The biggest disappointment, however, was the *quantity* of food. At a restaurant like Demi, I would never have expected so much food that I needed to take leftovers or be "rolled out" of the restaurant. However, based on the price tag, I would have also expected to at least come close to being satiated by the end of the evening. Unfortunately, after consuming everything on the (expanded) menu, I was still legitimately HUNGRY when I left the restaurant; so much so that I needed to cook myself and eat the equivalent of another meal when I arrived home 15 minutes later. While 16 dishes seems like a lot, when you count that 2 were liquids, another 4-5 of the dishes were only 2 or 3 bites, and everything was spread out over nearly 3 hours, it's basically just enough food to hold your hunger where it is when you walk in. I would say that the size of many of the plates, particularly the proteins, need to be increased by quite a bit.
The setting: As for the inside of the restaurant, it was super warm, welcoming, and comfortable. The restroom was clean. We were a bit disappointed with how difficult it was to watch the chefs work: we were expecting the visibility of the chef's counter at Spoon and Stable or other similar restaurants, but diners really only got to watch the final assembly. The lounge area is pleasant enough, and while we didn't try a cocktail, everyone drinking seemed happy: they will make you almost any cocktail you want (they also have Old Forested bourbon, if you are as big of a fan as I am).
All in all, Demi is a nice evening. However, they still have a little ways to go to get to the 99% food quality they should be at, they need to do even more to "bring the diners into the kitchen," and they definitely need to increase the size of many of the dishes. read more