Hot take: Many people have said that the food just isn't worth the price here. I have to say I disagree!! We for sure got our moneys worth. I have also seen comments that it is too loud and that was not our experience at all. We sat at the two person booth on the wall right as you walked in and had no problems. Our waitress, Sarah, was phenomenal. We were celebrating our first night out alone after the birth of our daughter and she made our night very special. I enjoyed the martini and my husband enjoyed their wine list. Our server even had some recommendations based off what we were eating and she hit the nail on the head. Food: The standout- Garlic mashed potatoes and funny enough the homemade butter for the bread steak 10/10 my husband had it cooked medium and it was perfect Veal Parmesan 9/10 great although just a tad overcooked. Green beans 8/10 good flavor a little oily Tiramisu 10/10 Cheesecake 10/10 Skip: the calamari (it's very chewy and left something to be admired) read more

See all

Went back to Delmonico's and it somehow topped my last visit. The steak was unreal, perfect char on the outside, super juicy inside. Bourbon peppercorn sauce paired perfectly, and the truffle butter was incredible. Tried the blackened scallops on our server's recommendation and they were phenomenal. Honestly didn't expect much from the sides, but the twice-baked loaded potato and Brussels sprouts were both spot on. Everything was just done right. Shoutout to our server Erin L. for being super attentive and taking great care of us. Definitely coming back soon. read more

See all

Today My wife and I celebrated our 4th year anniversary. I proposed to her 5 years ago at this restaurant. This is a very nice restaurant and the food is great ! But most!!! I had a conversation with the general manager; Mr.Tim . He was very professional. But he really impressed me because he remembered me from a passed conversation. That was very impressive to me. All in all. The atmosphere , the food and the staff was great. 5 stars for me. Keep up the good work. read more

Wow! Great atmosphere, excellent service and delicious food! We had dinner here last night which was a Friday. We didn't have a reservation but we were seated right away. The lobster bisque was so delicious! Rich and full of flavor. The meatballs were really scrumptious! Very tender and res the best I have had thus far. My husband had the Delmonico with onions and mushrooms. It was cooked a perfect medium rare and absolutely delicious. I had the scallops with cauliflower purée, roasted carrots and apple chutney. We also had the mashed potatoes for him and the twice baked potato for me. The wine was so good we ordered a bottle of the Riesling! We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Had reservations for our Anniversary dinner tonight, service was great the waiter was attentive and helpful with selections, the steak was tender and delicious. The ambience is always great at this location. Always a favorite spot. read more

See all

We celebrated Christmas with dinner at Delmonicos and it did not disappoint. Our server was very attentive and made nice wine recommendations. They had a great wine selection and romantic ambience. The lobster bisque truly is to die for as is the béarnaise. read more

See all

Fine Dining in a 1950s Manhattan Supper Club serving delicious steaks, seafood and Italian classics! Ramazzotti Spritz Lobster Bisque Caesar Salad NY Strip Steak Gulf of Maine Salmon Filet Oscar read more

See all

Dined here last week for my birthday and they did a good job making me feel special! Our server, Erin, was excellent. She was really sweet and easy to chat with and offered to take our picture as a celebratory memento. I ordered the Chilean sea bass and it was well prepared. I realized later that they had forgotten the asparagus that was supposed to accompany it and they brought us an extra birthday dessert as an apology! Great service and tasty food...the mocktails especially blew us away. They were so unique and delicious! The restaurant is pricey, but you get what you pay for. We will be back for sure. Thank you, Delmonico's! read more

See all

Love Delmonico's! Always a solid option, although I have never been here for dinner, their lunch menu never disappoints. Great atmosphere, ok for kids. Can tend to be a very busy business spot at lunchtime. read more

Service was fast even though they're always busy. Drinks are always good and the food is always consistently good. I love the oysters or any of the seafood towers. I always get a ribeye or filet, this time I got the surf and turf and it was 10/10. Will be returning always. read more

Delmonico's Steakhouse - Blue Point Oysters - Steakhouses Near Me - Independence, Ohio

See all

Want the best Filet Oscar in Cleveland? Here's where to get it! Cooked to perfection. Love the warm cozy feel of this place. Service was impressive as were all the staff. read more

Very good restaurant, fair prices, quality food. Happy hour Mon-Fri 3-6, check it out. I travel a ton for work across the US & eat at a lot of good restaurants. This one is up there! The nonsense below par reviews on here really make me wonder the trolls leaving negative reviews. Keep up the fantastic work Delmonico Team. I'll be back soon!! Matti read more

We went over Valentine's Day weekend, and service and ambience was great, but I thought the food was just okay. The slightly bigger steaks allows you to choose a sauce and add extra for a "style", but I don't think the addition of the style is worth it. The Oscar style only came with a few pieces (3) of asparagus and crab meat for $16. If I would have known of the sizing, I would have gotten a side instead. Definitely make a reservation before coming, to guarantee a spot! read more

The good: lovely ambiance and staff attitude. Classic menu and good location. The bad: service time, order accuracy and food preparation. Overall too much money for just good food. The flavors were underwhelming. The preparation was borderline. Our well done steak was raw in the middle and medium steaks could have been more tender. We were compensated for the shortcoming. We waited 20 minutes to have our order Taken but it came out in reasonable Timing. That's all. read more

Visited this week for a business dinner. There were a lot of us in a back room, so your results may vary from mine. Overall, I really enjoyed the evening, the location and the staff. The place outside looked like a strip mall but inside looked like a real deal steakhouse. From the bar back, things looked refined & relaxed. Enjoyed the stay. Since we were a large-ish group, I was there a while and was never uncomfortable. The staff were efficient, good, and light-humored in a grumpy way. It wasn't like they were seriously angry, just as if being put off was part of the schtick. Light-heartedly put off would be the summary. As if everything was a bother and an inconvenience, but maybe not really. After a couple drinks, didn't even notice any more. I started with a Negroni and wanted to hug the bartender. I don't often go with them, I usually like something fruity. But in a steak restaurant with a lot of business friends, I had to act macho and didn't regret it. Negroni's often are made poorly and like scallops, when not done well --- Oof! These were prefect. For an appetizer, salad I decided to go with the lobster bisque. I thought it was a great choice. It was very tasty, a lot of it and a TON of actual protein in it. Lots of nice, delicate chunks of real lobster meat. Well done there. Since I was in a seafood mood in a steak restaurant, I went with the Surf & Turf. I'm a rube, so I ordered the steak portion in medium. For a steak restaurant I was sorely surprised with the meat. I would just give it an OK. I was looking for outstanding, but that just didn't do it. A bit overcooked (even for a medium!) and I almost had the aftertaste of a piece of liver. Not as tasty as I would have wanted. On reflection, I should have gotten some sort of saucy side to cover it. I hate to recommend adding it (I was taught BBQ sauce hides poor brisket), but it is what it is. However, the lobster was really good. It wasn't a large thing. An over sized prawn. But it was tasty and filleted out for you so it was even easier to eat. The asparagus and mashed potatoes with it were par for the course. As a business meal - recommended and would do it again. On my own dime with a date, I would have been far more brutal in the review. read more

See all

Steak was delicious ! Mashed potatoes were delicious ! Green beans were delicious ! No complaints read more

I have spent much more at other steak houses. Delmonico's is far ahead of most in the city. The food is outstanding. The prices are very reasonable. I also have no complaints with the servers. They are all quick and pleasant. The atmosphere is very lovely and welcoming. read more

Steak was very good and the staff was exceptional! It's a very cozy spot with incredible food! From the salad to the steak it was great.

Great ambience here. Not at all noisy or overcrowded. Three of us for my birthday dinner. Hubs and I both ordered filet and daughter had grouper. All cooked perfectly. Service was prompt, attentive but not overly so, and they brought me a slice of cheesecake on the house for my birthday. Altogether a great experience. Well worth the 30 miles it takes to get there. read more

We've wanted to try this place for years, but live on the East side, so haven't made it here until now. It did not disappoint! Our waitress was amazing and we loved that she was honest w her feedback about the menu. I started w the Delmonico salad and it was the best combo of dressing and Parmesan cheese that was sprinkled in. I ordered the 8 oz filet with black and blue cheese topping. She was upfront that it could be salty, and it def was but that's how I like it. Husband ordered the Delmonico ribeye with extra onions and he said it melted in his mouth. We can't wait to make it out that way to go again! read more

Sweetie day booking for my sweetie I heard such good reviews about this steakhouse and wanted to treat my boyfriend. But we where disappointed. We ordered steak and salmon Steak: 2 out of 5 very fatty Salmon: 3.5 out of 5 unevenly cooked Service was friendly but agitated by any extra questions he seemed like he was in a rush but it was practically empty. Ambiance 4 out of 5 very clean and typical steak house but they sat us a at a very small both very intamite for sure but my boyfriend is 250 lbs not the most comfortable. read more

See all

Restaurant is really loud. I could not hear the other guests at my table. Food was good but well overpriced. It's a typical steakhouse approach where they push apps and desserts at high prices. Didn't know the tip was included in the bill so I way over tipped for adequate service. Maybe some people out there think it's "their thing", but I won't return to this restaurant for the above reasons. Missed on the experience. read more

I'm giving this a 5 star because the lobster bisque is the best in Ohio. When I asked they said it is gluten free and I have been eating that everytime I go. If you're going there for a steak and prefer it cooked medium, don't even try it, it will be purple on the inside (every time). They changed the happy hour and made it more pricey which doesn't make me want to go as much. Service is good. read more

Just got take out from this location. Bought two bowls of lobster bisque for $12 each. The amount of soup that was given to us is absolutely obscene and Delmonico's should be embarrassed. read more

This place was ok. I got the steak filet it didn't have much flavor but it was cooked well. Sides were good as well. I would put this as a better option then Texas Roadhouse. Might be over priced because of being around hotels. read more

Delmonico's Steakhouse - Mule, bread - Steakhouses Near Me - Independence, Ohio

The service was outstanding. Mike, our waiter went out of his way to make our experience top notch. The food was excellent, I highly recommend the lobster bisque. We definitely will eat here again when we are in the area. read more

went there last year for New Year's Eve. The food was awesome and service. hoping that they will be open for Christmas Eve. I'm checking into this now.o read more

I had a chance to go to this restaurant recently and 5 stars wasn't enough. The food came out and it was wonderful. The calamari came out and it was a little under done for my taste, the manager came out with a fresh crispy batch and it was amazing. Our server was sensational I had the Chicken Marsala and it was PERFECT! Also had the lobster tail with melted butter, I did add some salt and pepper to both the butter for the bread and the butter, but I guess that personal preference because they were both pretty bland, but other than that, drinks were great, food was great, the outside seating was really nice, when the sun goes down they have this lavender/purple like that creates a really nice ambiance outside. Highly recommended and would go again, but make sure that your pockets are heavy, when the tab comes it's not for the weak lol read more

Myself and two co-workers enjoyed dinner at Delmonico's in Independence to celebrate some recent workplace victories. I ordered the 10oz filet with garlic mashed potatoes and it was delicious. The steak was cooked perfectly and had the right amount of seasonings. The potatoes were good as well but it's hard to mess up mashed potatoes. Both of my co-workers got appetizers (wedge salad and crab bisque soup) and they both enjoyed them. We all had a few mixed drinks from the bar, and they were all good as well. Our waitress was great, one of my co-workers gave her a hard time (playfully) and she gave it right back to him, it was hilarious. Great experience and great food. Definitely pricey but that was expected and you get what you pay for. read more

Delmonico's Steakhouse - 10 oz. Double Cut Filet with garlic mashed potatoes - Steakhouses Near Me - Independence, Ohio

Really enjoyed my meal. I had the 10oz fillet cooked to perfection. Mac and cheese which was ordered by another ended up tasting really good. Service was excellent. I was with coworkers and not picking up the check so not able to experience the menu as I would had I paid. I would definitely come back for another meal. read more

Was at the Independance restaurant for a meeting of a group of people. I'm going to make this quick and to the point...everything about my experience was poor! The service, quality of food, meals that had been put under the 'warming lights' too long...the list goes on. I called and spoke to manager and explained my situation and that my husband and I had spent $200, he said he'd bubble it up to corporate. Well, one week later, still have not heard from anyone!!! Very disappointed in the entire experience! Don't bother wasting your time or your money. Not worth it. Go somewhere else if you want to have a great steak AND great experience! read more

Was in town on a business trip and decided to eat here as it was close to the hotel. I sat in the bar area and the service was very good. Nancy was running the bar and the booths in the bar area and did fantastic and was always there when I needed more wine or bread etc. the food was very good and flavorful. I had a Cesar salad to Start then the 14 oz NY strip cooked medium. My only complaint is the steak was a tad chewy on the inside but the flavor and sear won the show. Mashed potatoes were average. Definitely would recommend this place if you are in the area. They have a great wine selection as well. read more

Delmonico's Steakhouse - NY 14 oz. Prime New York Strip - Steakhouses Near Me - Independence, Ohio

See all

Perfect service and food, Tracy was spot on. We had a meeting today, awesome service, She was always there when we needed her and left us when we needed privacy. The lobster bisque was truly liquid gold. The fish special included shrimp and mussels and was mouth watering. Fresh warm bread with whipped butter, ... yummm...It has been a few months since I had lunch here and I cannot wait for the next opportunity. Of course the wine made the time memorable. read more

We went to Delmonico's for a Holiday/Birthday dinner. Everything was 1st Class, 6 dinner and everybody had a great meal. Jennifer did an excellent job of making sure everything was spot on. Thanks to Delmonico's!!! read more

This place was recommended to us by a friend. The ambiance of the restaurant was good, but a little too dark on the inside. Wait staff was wonderful. Our waiter, Ethan, was attentive. The woman that brought us water was kind, respectful, and prompt. (Wish we remembered her name, but she said she was new there). I appreciate the restaurant splitting some of the dishes I shared with my partner. The salad was refreshing. I loved the taste of the lobster bisque but was disappointed by how little lobster was in the soup. The calamari was not crispy and not that hot when it arrived. The eggplant parmesan did not feel fresh and felt like it was microwaved with cheese on top. We opted out of getting dinner at that point. read more

Delmonico's Steakhouse - Tuscan Delmonicos Salad, Fried Calamari, Lobster Bisque, eggplant Parmesan - Steakhouses Near Me - Independence, Ohio

The food and service were great! I had the steak Christopher and it was awesome. My colleague had the ribeye. Both were cooked to perfection. The ambiance was great for a business meeting. The service was great. The staff were all quite friendly. read more

We recently visited Delmonico's for my 33rd birthday. My husband had been there previously with his dad but I had never been. It's a nice place, felt cozy and perfect evening lighting. My husband basically had an order planned before we sat down. We met Ethan first, he was a serving assistant who promptly got us set up with waters. Then we met Antoine, our server. He was very friendly and nice. My husband loved their gin selection, they had his favorite which he doesn't see in restaurants very often. We got 2 dirty martinis which were great. Bread came quickly and was nice and warm. My husband got the lobster bisque which was the best thing we tried. It was so good, I should have ordered my own. We split the chilled seafood tower, it was good, oysters were tiny but that is a seasonal thing, we know better but seafood is my favorite and it was my bday! Anyways, we also got the Delmonico steak Oscar style, it was okay, my husband enjoyed it, but I don't think it's what I would order next time. Next time I WILL be getting my own bowl of lobster bisque. When we were ending the meal Antoine asked if there was anything else, my husband had to ask for a dessert menu which made me feel bad like maybe he wanted us to go and not stay for dessert so I mentioned forgetting it but my husband said crème brulee was my favorite so I deserved it on my bday and ordered it, it was pretty good. Overall it was a nice dinner, nice place, good service. It's not the whole celebratory vibe but it's a solid dinner w/ good bisque!! read more

I don't normally feel out of place eating out at a restaurant. This one was the exception. Not because of how I was dressed but because of the quality of food. The picture I included does not do it, Justice. Simple and amazing. the flavor, the texture just wow. The downside is the cost. let's just say that a second mortgage on your house might be needed. You can easily drop $125 for just one person. That doesn't include wine. As a foodie, It's worth it. It's definitely a place where wine and food and better things are all wrapped together. read more

Delmonico's Steakhouse - Steak Christi - Steakhouses Near Me - Independence, Ohio

They have a great steak salad that I had at a lunch. Loved it so much came back for a dinner. It is not on the menu for dinner but the staff accommodated me and made me one. But the topper of it all is their manager Sam Scavetta who not only accommodated my salad request but introduced me to Crème Brûlée with a port wine. It was amazing. Thank you Sam! Now the only bummer is I have to go back to Chicago and "jones" Delmonico's until I can have a business trip here again! Thanks! read more

The service was incredibly slow. Everyone finished their first cocktail waiter never came back and checked on us. We finally had to go find someone to give us a refill. During the time we finished two cocktails finally, our meal arrived about 45 minutes later four of us had ordered the grouper it was dry and tough. The manager did come over and offered to take it off the bill, but we really didn't wanna be like that so we picked at it they did offer us free dessert and three of the men did choose to eat dessert. I'm not about being a jerk and sending food back, but if you've got seafood on your menu and it's that expensive, the chef should know how to prepare it. After discussing this with some friends, they also felt that their visits have been very similar, and that the service was very slow and the food was not up to the quality of the price. Not sure I'll give it another chance it's been here since we had been there And it's too bad because it's really very nice place inside. read more