10/10 experience! Everyone was incredibly kind and even took the time to answer our questions about…read morestreet parking with the storm coming in. You can tell this place is run by people who genuinely care AND the pizza was fantastic. We ordered the Meat Lovers pizza slices (and honestly would've gone for a whole pizza if we were hungrier). I loved the wonderfully thin, crispy crust and how the toppings were packed with flavor. The restaurant itself is cozy, decorated with Cape May artwork, and has a charming diner-style vibe that feels both local and welcoming. Would recommend to anyone visiting!

This place continues to sell preprocessed food from the secondary flour to the ingredients. They…read morespare no expense to give you the lowest made ingredients. This place uses advertisement to lie about what they are proud about. Ask them for broccoli rare they never have it they don't want you pet you vacation with they tell you to put them on the floor. Not the owners dog though. They are really not a quality pizza shop they pri on vacationers that don't know any better. Only one near the beach is better with quality products used . Don't settle for less eat real food not artificial ingredients with no regards to your health. .

I've stopped here during work and a great deal for a slice and a drink…read more Can add toppings to a regular slice. It's the perfect portion for a lunch on the go where I'm not starving all day until dinner. It's small and locally run so have a little patience if you hit it during the lunch rush. He takes phone orders to have it ready if you need. Place is a bit small so be prepared to take it to go. Great place to grab a slice or a whole pie and take it out to the beach at the end of Sunset for a little car side picnic and watch the sunset.

Good takeout pizza easy ordering process quick ready to pick up time..would get againread more

I went to the Boiler room recently, and I had a wonderful experience. Michele was my server. I had…read morean espresso martini and the truffle wedges and a truffle brick oven pizza. Michele was so fun and cool and friendly. The food was great. The atmosphere was really lovely. I would recommend this place for a chill night for drinks and a quick bite. I was very happy with my service. It made all the difference! Thanks!

i used to like their pizza so we went to tryout the new expanded menu. The cheeseburger is only…read morecooked well. The roll was cold and small. -not very good. A piece of melted cheese and a little bit of lettuce was on it because I didn't want the Mac sauce. The pizza was overcooked and also not good. The service was very bad and it was almost empty. The young men (waiters); were too busy talking with each other to wait on any table. The two tables I could see were also almost ignored. I am local and will never go there again or tell anyone else to go. I don't usually do bad reviews but I don't want others to get ripped off. There are too many good restaurants here. Don't waste your time and money on this one.

Although pricey, Mangia's has really great New York style pizza! I ordered a large pepperoni for my…read morefamily and asked that it be lightly cooked and slightly doughy. I watched the man behind the counter make it, so I know it was fresh. When the pizza came out of the oven, I was able to take it across the street to my family where we enjoyed it by the pool at our hotel. We enjoyed the flavor and the thin crust of the pizza. The dough and sauce were both homemade and delicious. It cost us $22, but I guess it was worth it considering the quality, convenience, and friendly service.

We stopped at Tony's prior to our excursion with the Cape May Whale Watching trip. Don't expect…read moremuch choice for kids unless they want pizza. Our 5 year old daughter wanted pasta (the pasta was going to take 25 minutes). They don't have many kids drinks like chocolate milk, or apple juice. The server was helpful, but not very friendly. Also be aware that the traffic over the bridge is typically backed up and he might need some more time to get to this place (not that I am recommending going out of your way to come here). The food wasgood . I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich and it was made just like I asked. The lettuce and onion were fresh. The french fries were a little overcooked but crisp. My wife ordered pizza and the slices were huge! Very cheesy and well cooked. Tony's is ok if you're looking for something quick and basic.

I had a very large order . This they did deliver for a very short distance. However because my…read moreorder was so large did ask if they had a special or discount for a large order. There reply was we get large orders all the time. We don't give anyone a discount. So the way they stated things I felt was a like my business was not that important. Flavor of our order was disappointing. The pizzas definitely lack flavor. Very disappointing. The subs lacked flavor and value. ( steak subs) now for delivery it was hot and on time. For value and flavor I do not recommend this place at all. I'm going to try my luck at a different place. May I get better taste and more professional answers. I still have large orders coming in the future.

Brody great server, food fresh and true Italian, ambiance warm & cozy. Byob is great.read more

Another amazing dinner at Panicos. The staff are so good and the food is VERY good. I'm currently…read moreobsessed with the gnocchi appetizer. It's the perfect bite of soft pillowy pasta. Sweet and a touch of earthiness with the whipped pesto on top. It can be a bit loud as the kitchen and dining are all in the same room- it's an old church. But it's part of the charm of the place. Ps Most of the time a byob is annoying but here is so excellent at making sure you have an ice bucket asap when you arrive.

I Ordered a large pie. It was very surprising but the Pizza is actually very delicious.read more

Delicious cheese pizza & house salad last night. Staff was friendly. Definitely will order again.read more

Stopped in to the Santucci's in Rio grande today which is owned by the same owners as the wildwood…read morelocation. The new location is also convenient when out running errands off island. For today's order, I opted for the pizza of the month special and it certainly did not disappoint and was made with Pepperoni whipped ricotta basil and mikes hot honey. Congrats to the owners on bringing the same consistency to the menu we know and love at the new location. We will obviously continue to support both the wildwood and Rio grande locations!

I went here for lunch at the Rio Grande location and the pizza was ok. The crust was great but the…read morerest was just ok. I will have to try other slices to see if it can get better

Best place for pizza and entrees and sandwiches, with a great staff and food they go the extra…read moremile. Crunch factor that no other pizza place on the island delivers. Try the eggplant parm its a great meal. All ingredients are freshly made to order. The place will undergo a change soon im told by who cares as long as the food is made fresh to order. 5 stars on quantity and service they are open till 2am all year round. First place on the island to introduce gluten free pizza. Come get the best pizza and food at BLUE MOON PIZZA

Date of Visit: August 1, 2025…read more This was my first stop when I got to Cape May and I wasn't disappointed. And I have to agree with Eddie 9, I checked the reviews and the ones that gave it a bad review must have got on YELP! just for that reason, they only have one review to their name. So sad. While taking a walk-a-bout I came upon this place and it is just across from the beach, great location. I did walk by first then stopped and looked in the window and saw their pizza by the slice selection. Had to go in. As I entered I could tell this was a top notch place. I checked out the line-up and decided on a square slice, don't see that too often in Florida. I got one with pepperoni and because of the size I only had one, perfect. With the thin slices I usually get two. One was enough. This must be the local favorite pizza joint cause after I ordered, it started to fill up. After receiving my slice, nice and hot, I could tell they use quality cheese and sauce. All melted nicely. Oh, after the first bite I was right. And as far as the price, no different than any other place. Next time I come thru this way I will make it a point to stop in again. Peace.

Another restaurant we enjoyed so much that we went twice during our short visit to Cape May (see…read moreprevious review). The prices here are ridiculous; in the best way. We were seriously shocked at them. So dang cheap! Just look at that menu and their "specials" board. Not to mention $2.50 pints of Pabst beer all the time! Cocktails are also very reasonably priced. Me and my husband love buffalo wings. We got an order of them during our first visit. WOW. They were sooo good. SO good. Up there on the some of the "best wings we've ever had" list. We had to go back a second time for another round of those scrumptious wings. We liked the other food we got too but the wings were the highlight!

Beer is cold Good fries…read more Owner was there,Greg, nice Irishman Wings a very good, enjoyed by all 2-piece fish and chips were fantastic Crab corn chowder was great soup de jour French onion soup was delicious Steamers were a perfect bakers dozen Grilled pastrami hit the spot Our waitress, Gina S. was very good