I'm old and have been grabbing slices at Mack's since I was 11. That was a loooooong time ago but what hasn't changed is the quality of their food. Don't believe me, I was there on a random Friday night well after Labor Day and they were packed. One of the things I also like is that they haven't updated it much. Brings me back to those days all those years ago when I could barely climb up one of their counter stools and fork over my 35 cents for a slice (45 for pepperoni). Worth noting is that notoriously famous Franconi's, their neighbor that boasts nazi stickers on their refrigerator, was empty. Not sure if it was a result of their food or their politics but I doubt they'll be back next year. Can't say the same about Mack's who's 50+ year tenure on the Wildwood boardwalk is thriving and delicious. Thanks for the memories (& the pizza). read more

Mack's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

Our favorite pizza for decades in Wildwood! I've been coming here since I was 5 years old. Now my family comes here with me on vacation. Mack's is our favorite. Some prefer other establishments, but for the nostalgia of our childhoods, and delicious pizza, Mack's is a must when in Wildwood! read more

See all

We can't miss a slice of pizza at Mack's on the boardwalk NJ !!! Family tradition and always a stop for a slice !! read more

See all

Highly debated and sensitive topic for some BUT, in my opinion, Mack's is the best boardwalk pizza in the game. Perfect thin crust gives you that boardwalk bite, sauce is balanced, plenty of cheese, and the toppings taste fresh. They stay busy but staff and the cooks keep things flowing quickly. Cash only - don't forget that part. This photo legit tasted like summer at the Jersey shore. If you know, you know. read more

Mack's Pizza - White with broccoli on the bottom. Sausage and red up top. - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

favorite pizza in Wildwood NJ since 1953 on the boardwalk watched a pie being made cheese, then sauce, then more cheese pushing close to the elusive orange slice i love this style, excellent couple of slices & a coke whole pie to share service is prompt, ambiance is great It's the beach !!! enjoy read more

Mack's Pizza - exterior - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

See all

Mack's is probably the best pizza you'll find on the Wildwood boardwalk. We enjoyed it (and that's saying something coming from a born and bred New Yorker)! I appreciated the thin crust, the size, and the taste of the pizzas. We tried a few different ones: plain, sausage, and pepperoni and they were all good. This spot delivers which is super helpful for a big family on vacation in Wildwood looking for a quick dinner. read more

This pizza was amazing. But, don't expect any frills or extras. Our party sat outside on the patio and we had plenty of space. We ordered two pizzas, a broccoli and garlic for the adults, and the kids split a 50/50 pepperoni and cheese. There were no leftovers. For me, the cheese was what really stood out. So good. Cash only, and all soft drinks are served in bottles. read more

Mmmmmmm .Great boardwalk pizza. Came back three times during two days. Highly recommend. read more

Absolutely the best pizza on the boardwalk! Can't beat by the service and taste! Was recommended by my friend Renda the Italian Stallion Will be coming here more often read more

The Three-Slice Challenge is a recent family tradition that continues to this day. On our first leg of the challenge, we stopped at Mack's Pizza for a delicious plain slice. Freshly made, it was a little doughy, a little cheesy, and had sweet tasting tomato sauce. I liked it more than my kids. It reminded me of a good shore slice. Some say it's the best slice of pizza you can get in Wildwood. At $9 for three slices, it was a good deal. Four stars overall for our experience. On our second leg of the challenge, we went to Sam's Pizza Palace, my kids' favorite. Even though our slices were not fresh out of the oven, they were crispier, had a little more cheese, and had a sauce that was not so sweet but tasted more like the tanginess of tomato paste. I'll have to admit I like this slice better. At $8.25 for three slices, it was a great deal. Five stars overall for our experience. On our third leg of the challenge, we went to Sorrento's II. The slices were larger, more doughy, more cheesy, and with a similar taste profile to Sam's... but we didn't like it. Bigger is not always better. My kids got bbq chicken slices. One liked it. The other said the chicken tasted old. At a whopping $18 for three slices, it was a terrible deal. Two stars overall for our experience. read more

Mack's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

Came back yesterday, the black olive pizza was excellent. And we got a large plain as well. My kids ate the whole slice which they usually don't do. And they gave it a double thumbs up. Very busy place but service was fast read more

Great experience. The staff there made the experience for me. Pizza (boardwalk style) was good. They (locals) say it's #1 on the boardwalk so I had to try and I was happy I did. But the staff were so great. Made me feel connected to the boardwalk and them. Definitely try if you're looking for pizza. read more

See all

I went here last year and they forgot my drink and they gave me a headache when I walked in the shop. The Pizza sause comes out of a big moldy tube. Who knows what is in that tube! I DO NOT RECOMMEND read more

Mack's Pizza is an iconic boardwalk institution and a great place to grab a slice of pizza or two while enjoying the Jersey Shore. The staff was friendly enough and the overall ambiance was what you would expect from a Jersey Shore pizzeria. For many, Mack's Pizza is a part of the total experience of a visit to Wildwood, New Jersey. It is a part of many great memories and a place that I look forward to whenever life brings me to Wildwood, New Jersey. read more

There is a reason they've been in business for like 50 yrs. Best damn boardwalk pizza hands down. It is the thin brick oven pizza and you can get any variety-broccoli, buffalo chicken, mushroom, etc... read more

I was a devoted Mack's Pizza fan. I have been eating them since I was 13, and I'm 67 now. When we arrived on 8/31/24 we had a pie delivered to my hotel. I tried to order 9/8 and was told they don't deliver to my hotel in the crest. Very disappointed. read more

Mack's Pizza - Pizza that was delivered to my hotel - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

See all

Having never been to Wildwood, our friends introduced us to Mack's pizza. I pondered where this pizza has been my entire life. We were forewarned that this pizza was "good", we were not told this pizza is "excellent". We ordered a pepperoni pizza ($26) and I ate 4 slices and called it a night! They only take cash, which was my only "complaint". read more

Yeast smell and aftertaste in the dough Sauce was mediocre. Not a good Boardwalk pie. read more

CASH ONLY- Pay once food is brought out. Delicious jersey pizza, located on the boardwalk. A MUST while at the shore. read more

Mack's Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

Mack's Pizza is the greatest pizza in Wildwood I have been coming here for 50 years. There is no way I would ever eat another Pizza on this the Boardwalk it would be sacrilegious. Even the woman working the counter makes the experience worth coming to, she literally kicks ass and gets the line moving. When I was 17 to 20 I worked my summer job on the boardwalk and had Mack's at least 4 times a a week. So if in Wildwood go to Mack's for experience of Wildwood past and future read more

Really like Mack's pizza but this location is poorly managed. Sat in the seating area and watched worked eat pizza and talk while paying no attention to the dining area. People came on 5 minutes after us and when they finally decided to work, they waited on them first. We walked out. Management - wake up!! read more

My love for Mack's Pizza started a long time ago, like 46 years ago long! Is it because of the taste of the cheese, the thin crust, the sauce, or is it because Mack's Pizza brings back great memories from many summers? Today, the Pizza was perfect as usual. Yes there is a great Pizza debate here in The Wildwoods but for me and my family Mack's is our choice. I'm happy to say the my 3 kids, ages 15, 13, and 11 have been fully indoctrinated and are faithful fans of Mack's Pizza. So we said hello to long-time Mack's employees Barbara and Pete today and we know we will be seeing them many more times before the Summer of 2022 is over. Oh, SORRY ate the slice before I remembered to take a pic! read more

See all

One of the worst pizza's I've ever had. The pizza was really greasy and the crust was rock solid. The only this good about this place was the service. 1.3/10 wouldn't recommend. ( instead go to Sam's pizza ) read more

Best. Pizza. On. The. Boardwalk. No contest. All others pizza shops pale in comparison. Quick, efficient service. read more

Mack's Pizza - Extra sauce/ well done... best way to eat it - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

our tradition when we go to the beach. nice decent size slices. we will continue to go there until the pizza is no longer good. just being honest read more

Best pizza !! We love it! Great service! We go there from Delaware for their delicious pizza!

Love the melted cheese that just covers every part of the pizza all the way to the crust. It's one of these perfectly balanced cheese to sauce ratio where it just soupy and delicious. The sauce isn't as sweet as Sam's and maybe it's light on the sauce? Otherwise still damn good. read more

My husband and I had a great dinner at Mack's one night on the boardwalk. They have outdoor seating on a deck in the back which was really nice. The pizza we got was half sausage and half with peppers and sausage. It was so good. They only have pizza and you can mix and match any toppings. It's the same large size. You can also order by the slice. Pricing was decent for the location and quality. read more

See all

Mack's is Wildwoods best pizza and has been forever. The sauce, the cheese, and definitely the same layout as always.

Employees are unfriendly and cold. I get the impression it's kind of a cultural thing as they are all foreigners but still you're in America. Get with the program. Be hospitable. Also, our waitress was very slow. I went in to get a soda bc she was nowhere to be found and the guy upfront very coldly was like, "what do you need?" As he just mean mugged me. I'm like a soda. Not sure where our waitress went. He then got her and she got me a soda but then wouldn't hand it to me until I got back to my table. It was all very bizarre. I won't go back but not like they care. They lucked out being on the boardwalk so they don't have to worry about poor service. There will always be demand! read more

Disgusting & oily . Drips down your hands & the crust looks weird & unappealing . Sams is better .

My family and I go here every year when we visit Wildwood for vacation. Sometimes we even get it multiple times in that week. We love their cheese and sausage pizza. read more

When i went there 2 year ago, i ordered a drink and a slice of cheese pizza. The pizza was so so greasy that my hand was drenched in oil, the pizza was falling apart, and after 2 years, i still have not gotten my drink. I also cannot stand how the pizza sause comes out of a TUBE! that tube must be so moldy and rancid. I would NEVER go there again. Would NOT recommend. read more

We actually ate here twice. Today we just ordered a full-size pizza half pepperoni half cheese service was quick. And to me their pizza is not greasy at all we are very satisfied we will come back again. read more

Mack's is a Boardwalk staple and a shore must! I live in Florida now, but I always make it a point to get to the shore during the summer and visit my favorite pizza spot in the world! I've been coming here since I was a baby, so I guess you could say 1994 haha. The pizza continues to be as good as it I can remember when I was a kid! read more

See all

While my wife and I were visiting New Jersey and different board walks and things around the pier. We decided to try Max pizza. It was pretty good typical boardwalk pizza for anybody that's had that knows what I'm talking about but not bad three seems to be a reasonable score for it read more

Mack's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

See all

Always the best and no other option. Delivery was quick and easy. A must on any Wildwood trip! read more

Mack's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wildwood, New Jersey

See all

This is good but not great pizza - my wife swears by this place, she swears a lot in general, but I think this place is a tad overrated. The crust is thin, even for thin crust pizza, which makes it nice and crispy but some may not like it. The sauce is good but nothing otherworldly as some might have you believe. They have a reasonable size dining area, and a small outdoor seating area out back. The staff are friendly for the most part. The prices are standard for the boardwalk, the most noteworthy thing is that fountain sodas are $2, which is half what it is at many other pizza places. We have ordered delivery as well, again my wife swears by this place, but the delivery can take for-eva. So like order it now if you want it next Thursday. I low key complain/eye roll/leave the toilet seat up passive aggressive when we order delivery from there. Not saying that works out for me, just sayin read more

Best pizza around ! A must stop when you're in wildwood !! Love the birch beer on tap too .

Best boardwalk pizza in North Wildwood! It's my first stop when I get to the shore - and it never disappoints!