Was very surprised that the pizza we ordered wasn't that great being this business is in Cape May. I didn't hate it, but you can tell the ingredient used are on the cheaper end of quality I feel middle of the road so the reason for 3 stars. The service was fine, but the electric wiring being exposed and being used for refrigerator case being plugged into it in the open on electric strip is dangerous. I think they could do better with the presentation of their place and with ingredients just saying. read more

Went here after a beach day, the inside near the bathroom was kind of gross but I looked past that. Ordered an XL cheese for over 20 bucks which is kind of insane. Didn't leave a tip because why would I when it was that much already. Then me and my cousin got stomach aches around the same time after eating there. Who knows, maybe they tainted it after the bad tip. Anyways, don't go here. read more

The food was not good. This pizza would be ok in Alabama but in N.J. The standard is higher. Would not recommend this pizza

We were hoping for the perfect slice of plain cheese pizza and a fountain coca-cola. We got that along with a pleasant experience. The place was clean, the servers were gracious and friendly and we look forward to grabbing another slice here sometime soon. It really was delicious. Crispy carriage and a thin soft interior. The crust was amazing, a nicely balanced tomato sauce and the cheese had a nice pull. It really was outstanding. read more

Recently ordered a extra large cheese pizza to go. Tasted good and properly baked. Service was good and friendly. Restaurant seating was small in area, but clean and well maintained Will definitely make this my go to pizza place in Cape May. read more

Don't get all the bad ratings. the pizza was very good. service was good. the place was clean. The bathroom didn't have any toilet paper but that was not a big deal!! read more

Truly delicious pizza! We ordered delivery from here on a Saturday night through the Slice app. At first I was disappointed because the delivery estimate after I submitted the order seemed very long, but the pizzas ended up arriving in a normal time frame for pizza delivery (maybe about 45min). We ordered a pepperoni pizza, cheese pizza, sausage/peppers/onion pizza, and buffalo chicken pizza. All were excellent, but the buffalo chicken pizza was much spicier than we expected. Pizza arrived hot, delivery driver was great. I will definitely order pizza from here again next time I'm in Cape May. read more

This place takes the cake . The extra cheese thin crusted 16" pizza ordered was nothing like it. I got instead a large crusted lesser cheese pizza that wasn't worth the 22dollars . The delivery driver was curious but when I called to complain I was told by the owner obviously he was in business for 25 years and after the B.S he didn't address anything about the pizza and why it looked the way it did. Stay far away from this place. You get ripped off from the cost and hardly any sauce don't bother asking for extra cheese they owner know how to cheat you don't to order a thing from him at all . The price speaks for itself. The pizza should belong in a super market in the cardboard box it belongs in. "Del Giourno anyone? Better off to man's it or buy the pizza at the market of your choice. Never again for BROTHER'S PIZZA THIS PLACE ID MINUS 20 IN FLAVOR TASTE AND OWNER ATTITUDE .. read more

Place was busy but service was bad and did not seem like they could prioritize. I will not return. Do not recommend.

The pizza was not good at all to be honest and the owner is very unprofessional. Also keep in mind that if you buy a 2 liter soda at their business you cannot dine in, which makes things worse if you're not from the area. I have been here a couple of times, but after my experience yesterday I will not return to this business with my kids from my job or with anyone at all. I hope that the owner is able to change his approach and be kinder with future customers so he doesn't lose out on money. read more

Best pizza!! Friendly people. We have pizza right down t he street and drive the extra to get Brothers!!

Husband is very fussy when it comes to pizza. We like thin crispy crust. Brother's delivered both. Right amount of pepperoni which did not make the pizza greasy. Pickup was ready when they said it would be. Fair pricing for this day and age. Next on list will be a cheesesteak sub with all the fixings. read more

We ordered Brothers when we stayed in Cape May and it was great! We wanted a place that delivered after a long day of traveling and Brothers brought the food right to our condo door. Food was so good and hot when it arrived. The staff was very friendly! I would highly recommend Brothers if you're a looking for some delicious food to be delivered when you're having a night in at the beach. read more

Don't believe the negative reviews. They are obviously from obese, demanding suburbanites who wouldn't know linguine and clams if it kicked them in the Tesla. What healthy human complains about not enough blue cheese? Maybe not eat blue cheese because it is f*cking disgusting and stinks. Down here from Philly today. 55F and raining. What a day to come down. Grabbed some Cape May Brewing offerings. Kinda reminds me of the weather. Not great. But Brother's Pizza? A spot of sunshine for this gray weekend. Been coming down to Cape May for most of my 46 years. Aside from the Jersey drivers, which I get far too much of in the city, I always enjoy it. Never tried Brother's. But I am glad I did. It's not greasy. Maybe that doesn't seem like a huge compliment. I guess the reader who thinks that doesn't eat much pizza. This wasn't traditional, perhaps, but the veggie pizza has crisp, fresh broccoli and obviously fresh sliced tomatoes and onions. Not drowned in red gravy to cover the crap quality either. Just good pizza. And a chill driver to bring it. The salad sucks but it's a pizza joint. I'm not gonna bang them for it. read more

We ordered a big order of pizzas on our first night of vacation. They were done quickly and everything was right! We even ordered some gluten free pizzas and they came with their own special pizza cutters! We were so impressed with the extra thought for our gluten free family members! read more

Brother's Pizza II Cape May - a red handled pizza cutter - Pizza Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

The food was okay wasn't all that, despite the food the service was okay till they told us there's a no dining in with 2 liter soda. Told us we had to buy the individual drinks instead, So we walked out and decided to eat outside. Worker came out rudely telling us we had to leave, So we proceeded to our vehicle. As we were in the car after 10 minutes of eating, they came up to us claiming we did not pay for our food. When we had the receipt to the transaction in our possession, Therefore how could've one not paid for the food if one has the receipt? Then proceeds and tells us, that they'll refund us for the pizza that we supposedly did not pay for. Straight ignoring that fact, that we were just trying to enjoy our food and time. Which by the way we weren't even from the area, which made the whole scenario more negative in one's aspect. Then proceeds and tells us that the police we'll be called if one did not go back inside and pay. Then continues to be disruptive to us while we were eating. Then try's to block us from leaving the site as if we were trying to leave, while banging on the back windshield harshly, leaving prints when the vehicle was stationed not even moving. Therefore to be said, due to their negative service. I do not recommend this place to the Public at all. read more

Wow. The staff was incredibly rude. I also asked for mozzarella on my hoagie and never got it. Who serves a sausage hoagie with only over cooked sausage and a few peppers? The pizza was not good. Every booth was covered in crumbs and there were tons of bugs. Just an awful experience all around. 0/10 would recommend. How has this place been in business for so long?! read more

Stop all the time over summer and winter. Good food and always nice people. Love the Buffalo chicken pizza. Cheese Steaks are always great as well. read more

We have ordered various items and dishes from Brothers II over quite a few years. Whether we pick it up or have it delivered, they always have a food prepared in reasonable amount of time and it's always delicious. read more

While the pizza from this place was pretty good, they're seemingly incompetent. We were visiting Cape May for the week and were at the beach that is at the end of the street directly adjacent to this place. (It is about 4 blocks). On our way past the shop we stopped in to ask they if they will deliver to the beach, to which they said yes. We ordered a couple of hours later and were told 45 minutes. After about 35 minutes or so we walked up to the bath house/snack shack deck which is between the street and the beach. We stood there for 15 minutes or so before we got a call from the pizza shop. Whomever called us from the shop was agitated and told me that his guy tried to deliver the pizza and we weren't there and that he tried to call us and we didn't answer. I told him we had been standing there for 15 minutes or more and nobody came by with pizza. He sent the guy back. This time we went and stood in the street because apparently the guy couldn't be bothered to cross the street and walk up onto the deck. You would think it is common for them to deliver to the beach given how close they are. Then the delivery guy tells me that the shop wrote our phone number down incorrectly so the number he had wasn't even the right one when he tried to call. (He had tried to write a 9 that I guess looked like a 4 so the delivery guy couldn't read it but the guy at the shop must have recognized his own writing and got it right when he called me all annoyed) read more

Excellent food and great people! Very good fried Panzeroti, cheese steaks and wings!

Delicious pizza a bit off the beaten path! And plenty of parking, which is nice. A few friends and I were grabbing pizza on our way home from Cape May and didn't feel like searching for parking. We were able to find this little gem a bit inland. The pizza was perfect and tasted just like the boardwalk pizza we all know and love. The guy working was very sweet and personable. And it is located right next to an ice cream parlor which is the ultimate in convenience. Highly recommended! read more

I was beyond impressed... from my phone call days prior to needing 8 pizzas for my granddaughters 4th birthday party, my special request for the #4 in black olives( turned out really awesome) the pizzas in itself were delicious, all party guests raved how good, it was delivered to the minute of my requested time, the delivery people went out of there way walking around an entire skating rink to our corner spot and was super friendly and even took the time to show me my order to assure I was satisfied and finally the price, on point and actually a value considering I had toppings and a special order!!!! I definitely will be back and if anyone is having a rollerskating party in cape may I highly recommend brothers pizza for a worry free easy delicious choice as it was for me!! read more

Brother's Pizza II Cape May - Brother's Pizza II making pizza and smiles! - Pizza Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

A nice little Italian pizzeria and diner in the midst of more expensive Italian restaurants nearby. After dining at fancy restaurants the past few days in Cape May, our family felt like something simple as we returned from visiting the lighthouse and watching the sunset. This little joint is actually pretty good especially their Italian entrees. The best part was the friendly service by the waitress who was so happy to welcome us. read more

See all

Decent pizza. The pizza arrived on time. Pepperoni was good. Bacon had very little bacon on it. The crust wasn't great. read more

Oh you thought there was a Three Brothers in Jersey? Nope, this place is called Brothers 2. Who ripped off whom? Well I haven't heard of any other Brothers 2. Anyway, since Louie's Pizza has been under new management for several years now, we have yet to find a new favorite pizza place in Cape May. I'd say so far, Brothers 2 is one of the best options around town. Tried the white pizza this time with broccoli, tomatoes, and ricotta cheese toppings. Pretty good stuff. It's located in West Cape May so it may be a bit more of a hike, depending upon where you are. It's right across the street from the 7-11. read more

Good stuff, although I like my slices thin and crispy, NY style! Prices are good. Place is clean. read more

We always come here at least once when visiting cape may each year . We live in Philadelpahia, home of pizzerias but we always say we wish there was a Brothers II in our area. consistently good pizza and friendly staff. read more

My friend and I stopped here on our way to the beach in Cape May on Saturday. The pizza looked pretty good so we got 2 plain slices. It was a little on the thick side for my liking but decent. What I really want to emphasize is how dirty this place is. There were flies everywhere, the floor looked like it hadn't been cleaned since last Summer, the tables were dirty, the napkin holders had caked on grime on the top of them, the vents on the bottom of the drink refrigerators had such a thick dust/dirt coating that I could see it from 10 feet away. This place is disgustingly filthy! I would never eat here again for fear I'd get food poisoning from the unsanitary conditions. Eat here at your own risk! read more

Hole in the wall typical carry out pizza parlor with a couple of booths inside. It was late (about a half hour before they closed) and the cooks were more than happy to accommodate us - we told them about our nightmare experience at Bella Vida Cafe (see review) and they promised us a great meal. The eggplant parm, pasta with sausage & peppers and chicken parm were all delicious, hot and fresh. Good bread too. Though they wouldn't allow us to drink our wine, the meal was worth it. Thank you for saving us Brothers Pizza! read more

Cheesesteaks! Best in Cape May. Staff was friendly and prompt. Maybe it's expensive but given the area we expect to pay a little more. read more

Brother's Pizza II Cape May - Pizza Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

I'm not a real picky person but I had trouble eating the pizza a bought there. I've had frozen pizza from the super market that tasted better. The crust was thin and tasteless. Cracked like a pretzel when you tried to fold a slice. The sauce was not any better. Don't know about anything else there, only got a pie but if it's anything like the pie I would plan on being disappointed. Gave it two stars because I feel bad giving small business a bad review. Maybe they will improve if they read some bad reviews. read more

Worst wrap I have ever had. It was 4 inches long and and two inches in diameter. Nothing on it but chicken. Total waste of money for an 8.00 wrap! read more

Driving by only place open. Owner was rude and food was mediocre. I would not go back

After walking by this spot and eyeing the white pizza in the window day in and day out we decided to order it on our last night in Cape May. We ordered two 14" pies for pickup last night; one white pizza and the other pepperoni. First and foremost the woman who answered the phone to place our order was very helpful and patient as I was gathering my thoughts to order. The pizza was delicious, we were super skeptical about finding good pizza in Cape May but it was very tasty. The perfect sauce to cheese ratio on the pepperoni and the white pizza was fantastic with a little bit of crushed red pepper added. The crust was phenomenal and the dough was subtly salty which was perfect. We will certainly order again our next time in Cape May. read more

Lunch sandwiches were ok. Tried dinner tonight-- terrible. Chicken wings had very little flavor and not enough blue cheese. Don't order linguine and clams- no parmesan, no salt, no flavor. Chicken Cesar salad also dry and flavorless. read more

Had a pizza cheese stake last night 12/19/2020 and it was one of the best I've ever had in Cape May. Keep up the great job! John C.

Came in for a quick & late dinner around 9 & our waitress was super friendly and accommodating. She made sure we got everything we needed and checked back multiple times to see if we needed anything else. The food was very good as well. We ordered pizza, a cheesesteak wrap, a club ham sandwich, and a house salad. Everything was fresh and tasty :) Will definitely come back if in need of a late night quick eat! read more

We found the pizza to be dry. It contained little sauce and didn't seem to have any cheese. We are used to a better pizza. Furthermore, the extras we ordered all seemed to be dumped in one spot, rather than being distributed evenly around the entire pizza. Since their main clientele are tourists, the place apparently doesn't care about the quality. read more

To the person who said that Brothers ll in West Cape May has burned down...that's a COMPLETE LIE! They are still open and have never had any such issue. They are excited for the summer season to begin!! Still doing a great job everyone! read more