Piro's Pizza

Sitting at the counter in Sam's and watching the magic happen was an awesome experience, and the…read morepizza hit all the right notes. It had no flop and a crispy undercarriage, a slightly sweet sauce, and good flavors with a strong sauce to cheese to crust ratio. Excellent for boardwalk pizza - so much so that if I walked into this place on the streets of NYC for a regular slice, I wouldn't be disappointed.

Really great boardwalk pizza. I ordered two plain slices from the takeout counter and they came out…read morehot and crispy. The place has a lot of turnover, so the pies that were already made sitting out were still very fresh out of the oven.

Dough is undercooked

See all

A & LP Foods

3.6(146 reviews)

1.2 mi

The cheesesteak was very good. I would definitely get it again. The Italian was pedestrian. I guess…read moreas a reason does no description of the ingredients. It's ham, salami, provolone, and some cousin of bologna with specks of black pepper, super bland and unforgettable. The chicken tenders were basic Cisco frozen the fries were also but they were a solid portion and Family favorite so I would get french fries again as well I'll stick to cheesesteaks. The roast pork with broccoli Rob did look quite tasty. On a sidenote, I walked in and there's no one there but there's five people behind the counter chatting. You can tell the three workers were busy working. God forbid one of the two owners look up or glance and acknowledge and say hello. Someone will be with you in a moment. A & LP? Only if I can buy a vowel and choose what to order.

OK figured I'd try this place out. Big sign out front. Pizza steaks and hoagies waited in about a…read more10 minute line to get to the counter to be told oh we don't make pizza until 4 PM WTF another place checked off the list.

Cheesesteak

See all

Roast Pork Italian. Was just ok this time. Pork had no flavor.

Poppi's Brick Oven Pizza

3.9(590 reviews)

0.3 mi

The food is incredible, from the italianos to the neapolitano pizza. A memorable taste of Italy in…read morea quaint New Jersey seaside town. The Caesar salad was the magnum opus to this Italian seaside dining melody.

Another great dinner here outside! We brought our dog and they were beyond accommodating…read more We started out with the lasagna mozzarella bites, which were crunchy delicious with a fabulous marinara. For entrées, we got a meatball wedge and the Bronzino entrée. The fish was outstanding! The meatballs were also just as delicious. Our waitress was a dream and took lots of pictures of us with our dog! All in all a fabulous experience with delicious food.

12" Meatball pizza

See all

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza - Wildwood, NJ

3.7(75 reviews)

0.7 mi

Never again! I…read moreshould have been tipped off to what fortune awaited us when there was not one other customer in the place at twelve noon, on a Saturday, in the summer. Ordered a dozen garlic Parmesan wings, two personal "pizzas", one regular & the other white. Let's start with the wings. Absolutely no flavor, which will be a recurring theme. All they did was sprinkle Parmesan cheese on the wings. To be fair, they were crispy, but again, the breading tasted like cooking oil. Drowning the wing in ranch dressing was the only way to make it palatable. Twenty five minutes later the "pizzas" arrived. The white pie was barely edible. Literally just burnt mozzarella cheese on a thin, hard, favor-less crust. Maybe the garlic & spice delivery truck didn't come this week? Their regular pie definitely was an improvement over the white, but nothing to write home about. No joke, you can make a better tasting pizza at home using only three items from Costco...stone flat bread, mozzarella cheese, & Mama Rao's sauce. I will acknowledge that the place was clean & the young lady working the counter was attentive. They also do have free refills on fountain drinks, so there's that. Overall, the fact that this place is a franchise boggles my mind. Like, how to did someone get hoodwinked into thinking this was a wise long term investment opportunity? I wish this place luck, but let's be honest, it won't be here the next time I am in Wildwood.

I went here for lunch at the Rio Grande location and the pizza was ok. The crust was great but the…read morerest was just ok. I will have to try other slices to see if it can get better

Plain cheese pizza

Antipasto Board

See all

Steak’em Up

3.9(46 reviews)

1.2 mi

When I went here the third time I had their pepperoni pizza and it was very good I would highly…read morerecommend anyone who hasn't been there before to try out their pizza. I am giving them a 10 out of 10 their service and ambiance is good.

Only came here because Dave Portnoy's review was so funny, but I wish I had never watched it. $3+…read moreto take two bites out of a slice and throw it out because it was so bad was a bit of a disappointment - if this really did win best pizza on the boardwalk for three years like the sign out front says, I really wonder who the judges were. There was no flop, and a solid undercarriage by looks, but there was just a heap of undercooked cheese on the slice and a bland flavor - with the sauce and cheese contributing nothing in the way of taste. Reminded me of a Sbarro's - the type of pizza you settle for in a midwestern airport but not what you expect in the tri-state area.

Amazing food you must try it. #50dollartech

Small dish coffee ice cream with whipped cream and cherries

See all

Cheesesteak Sandwich

Mack's Pizza

3.7(412 reviews)

0.4 mi

Great boardwalk pizza located on the boardwalk in Wildwood. It's been here forever and we have…read morebeen here numerous times. They have friendly and great service. They are always very nice. Have had both the white pizza and the regular pie which we always order with extra cheese. Either after a long walk on the boardwalk or stopping in here after the beach it always hits the spot. One of the better views in New Jersey while eating a slice too. Will always be back when on vacation.

Located on the busy Wildwood boardwalk, this place seemed very popular, big crowd around it and…read moreoperates cash only (which was annoying but there was an ATM near by). We decided to get a whole pie with half white garlic chicken and half buffalo red chicken. For pizza on a boardwalk and hungry/tired people, the pizza hit the place but otherwise probably would've given it 3 stars. They do make the pizza right in front of you in a big brick oven- which is great to have fresh pizza. Super busy and lively ambiance, nothing short of what you'd expect for a place in such a busy boardwalk.

The chefs hard at work

Sausage pizza. This is the OG slice here. Get this one for sure. FYI - cash only & they do deliver

See all

The chefs

xo pizza

4.3(18 reviews)

1.0 mi

We stopped into XO Pizza while trying a bunch of different pizza places in Wildwood. XO was the…read morewinner by far. We tried a grandma slice, a Margherita slice, and a white slice. All were great and super flavorful, and they certainly don't skimp on the cheese! We ended up getting a pie to go as well. Will definitely be back!

Had bbq chicken slice. It was just ok. Felt like it could have been cooked a bit more. My friend…read moregot a grandma's slice and said it was really good. Also had mozzarella sticks. They were ok. Decent boardwalk food.

See all

Carini Pizza & Italian Restaurant

3.2(242 reviews)

2.7 mi

Absolutely , positively the best linguine with white clam sauce anywhere including Italy which I…read morehave visited 9 times.

This is a fantastic restaurant perfect place for a big group. We were craving prime rib and they…read moredelivered their Thursday night. Special was perfect. My husband ordered a seafood broil, and I think it was probably the best one we ever had. Portions are large!

Hot roast beef with provolone - incredible sandwich

Menu from 9/8/25

See all

Menu from 9/8/25

Dolce Italia

2.8(64 reviews)

1.8 mi

Love the calzone best on the island h and cheese - Pizza is good tooo so are family mealsread more

Great service Great Food. Grandma pie spectacular. Deserts are amazing. We will be pack to try…read morethe Italian dinners

Cut off the end since it was so hot and I couldn't wait....lol

Underdone crust, only the ends are done.

See all

Buffalo Chix slice

Russo's Market

4.4(247 reviews)

1.6 mi

Everything is great here! The service is amazing! The food absolutely amazing! This is our go to…read moremarket when we are on vacation!

Cash only! I've had good cheesesteaks from here but the wraps left more to be desired. Pretty…read morebland. The chicken italiano wrap was drenched in oil/juices, making it basically inedible.

Half of a small cheesesteak with long hots.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Justin C.

300

8 years ago

Decided to stop in for a typical plain pie. What I got was a subpar pizza with terrible sauce. The place looked like they have clan meetings inside with overly political messages on the wall. These guys seem like real conservative snowflakes with terrible food. If you're looking for a safe space to talk about police brutality this is your spot. read more

Corey H.

2 years ago

Pizza used to be great not so much anymore. Don't know why I have to put 85 characters

Piro's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Piro's Pizza also viewed

Sam's Pizza Palace

3.8

(390 reviews)

Mack's Pizza

3.7

(412 reviews)

Romans Pizza House - N Cape May

3.7

(124 reviews)

I was really in the mood for Pizza and they did not disappoint. We got the Mamas which I did not…read morethink I would like but it was Excellent but everyone else wanted it. It had FRESH basil leaves, and the outer crust were crispy. We got 2 regulars as well. It was a thinner crust, but not too thin, and the sauce was nice not too sweet. Order was ready within 20 minutes as promised. Would definitely go again.

We grabbed a couple pizzas and garlic knots to bring back to our little shore house while on…read morevacation and this place was terrific. Heidi took care of me when I went in to grab the order and she did terrific and was fast, friendly and efficient. The buffalo chicken pizza was amazing, I subbed out blue cheese for ranch and added pepperoncinis and it was REALLY good. My wife opted for a margherita pizza and it was terrific as well, the pesto drizzle added a little pop of flavor. It wouldn't be a trip to NJ without grabbing a piece of plain pie so we also added a last minute slice they warmed up for us and it was my wife's fave. The crust is amazing! The garlic knots were just ok, not a show stopper but I think that's because everything else was so amazing.

Cappy's Seaside Pizza & Steaks

3.1

(70 reviews)

Owners very polite, attentive and respectful...... Good ambiance, place clean and great prices too…read more Best pizza I've had in years..... thank you for you hospitality and service.

We Love their Cheese Steak Hoagies! Made to order and heavy due to the amount of steak! All other…read moreingredients are fresh and delicious.

Blue Moon Pizza

3.2

(123 reviews)

This place is the best around Cape may, Cape may county and surrounding area's. Come try it ive…read morebeen all over the jersey shore and food this place don't skimp on the toppings art all. Every month for 14 years has ingredients are not from a frozen bag and his entrees are like being on Italy! Gis experience speaks for itself. True cooking done here not artificial fillers are make believe parmasian cheese or mixed provolone cheese with mozzarella cheese in his pizza pies. Taste the goodness and crunch no one has this only imitated. Let this place show you what real pizza and entrees taste like 425 ocean Ave Cape may. Open till 3am yes 3am winter is 1am or later they will never send you away like others do. Everyone is treated. Like family. Taste it for yourself and don't hangout in your basement and talk about the place , go try his many options to choose from including many African entrees upon request. Get your beach delivered pie as well come see the food. The prices. Experience the flavors here you are like family INCLUDING FIDO!!! ... , No B.S here only great food. .did I mention hot coffee and tea ? Ice cream as well. Be honest get the food with no artificial anything....BLUE MOON PIZZA.

We have gone to this place for the second year in a row on our annual family trip to cape May. The…read morepizza and fries are both pretty good. The kids working here are hardworking and nice kids.

Mario's Pizza and Italian Eatery

4.1

(252 reviews)

I'm fairly certain that I've had pizza from every place in Cape May and Mario's is the best! The…read morecrust/sauce/cheese ratio is right on! Also, the staff is always really helpful and kind! Also, if you ask nicely, they'll make you the best panzerotti ever!! Go to Marc's place and give it a try!!!

10/10 experience! Everyone was incredibly kind and even took the time to answer our questions about…read morestreet parking with the storm coming in. You can tell this place is run by people who genuinely care AND the pizza was fantastic. We ordered the Meat Lovers pizza slices (and honestly would've gone for a whole pizza if we were hungrier). I loved the wonderfully thin, crispy crust and how the toppings were packed with flavor. The restaurant itself is cozy, decorated with Cape May artwork, and has a charming diner-style vibe that feels both local and welcoming. Would recommend to anyone visiting!

Poppi's Brick Oven Pizza

3.9

(590 reviews)

Del Pizza

5.0

(1 review)

I saw this place opened up a few months back and all my friends kept telling me I had to try it so…read moreI figured I would give it a try. I'm glad I did. It's awesome. I go there at least 2-3 times a week now. They have really good wings cooked fresh. They also have daily specials with food that you generally don't get in a pizza shop. I dined in many 5 star restaurants when I lived in New York and some of the daily specials are on par with those expect at a cheap price. Their pizza is also very good and you can't beat it when you catch their $5.99 large 1 topping pie. I highly recommend!

Italiano Pizza

3.5

(6 reviews)

There was Outstanding Customer Service, the Food was Great, and the View was Great! I definitely…read morewould return again.

We ordered from Italiano because one of the employees was handing out menus on the beach during the…read moreday saying they deliver to the beach, so we figured we'd give it a shot. And I do think this place is worth a try, if you're looking for some easy, simple beach food. Here's what we got: Gyro: VERY good... they use the chunks of meat rather than slices, which I really like Italian subs: both people who got these were very happy Cheesesteak: just your average cheesesteak, was good Chicken quesadilla: this was the one that wasn't good, so I would recommend avoiding it. It was just breaded chicken fingers and american cheese (ugh) in the tortilla. And they forgot to include the salsa. French fries: good fries, they actually arrived still crispy, always a plus A tip: when we ordered (6 p.m. on a Tuesday) they said estimated delivery was in 30 minutes, but it was actually a little over an hour. So take that into account when you order. If you're ordering to the beach, make sure to ask for napkins. They did include plastic ware. Delivery guy and guy who took the order were both very nice.

Uncle's Pizza

5.0

(1 review)