We grabbed a couple pizzas and garlic knots to bring back to our little shore house while on…read morevacation and this place was terrific. Heidi took care of me when I went in to grab the order and she did terrific and was fast, friendly and efficient. The buffalo chicken pizza was amazing, I subbed out blue cheese for ranch and added pepperoncinis and it was REALLY good. My wife opted for a margherita pizza and it was terrific as well, the pesto drizzle added a little pop of flavor. It wouldn't be a trip to NJ without grabbing a piece of plain pie so we also added a last minute slice they warmed up for us and it was my wife's fave. The crust is amazing! The garlic knots were just ok, not a show stopper but I think that's because everything else was so amazing.

Sat there for 15 minutes and NO INE even came over to take our order. The waitress walked by us 6…read moretimes. And several people behind the counter and NOTHING!!!! Won't be returning nor place a take out order either!!!! So disappointed Friday August 7 at 5:45 pm and they weren't even that busy!!!!

I'm fairly certain that I've had pizza from every place in Cape May and Mario's is the best! The…read morecrust/sauce/cheese ratio is right on! Also, the staff is always really helpful and kind! Also, if you ask nicely, they'll make you the best panzerotti ever!! Go to Marc's place and give it a try!!!

Awesome!!!!! I expected average boardwalk pizza.... What a got was some really well made pizza;…read moregreat crispy crust, fresh ingredients on the "works" pizza (see picture) and high quality cheese. My guess is grande cheese, the best of the best .if it's not, I'd be shocked. Anyway, highly recommend!!! ‼

Excellent food and outstanding service. A nice little gem in Rio Grande. Same owners are taking…read moreover the old Nino's sometime in July.

Mangia is in the centrr of a strip mall. I went with my family prior to a day of sightseeing…read more We went just before 1 pm on a Friday in August. There were about 3 other customers. The place has a group of tables near the entrance and six more along the side wall. The woman who took our order was nice. The pizza was good and the price wasn't crazy. We ordered six slices, including a broccoli slice, for under $19. A good choice if you need a quick bite.

great food. great service. Great atmosphere. Highly recommend this hidden jewel in N Cape May.read more

Ordered seafood, pasta, pizza + apps ALL were great!…read more This has become one of our go to who places in the are

I saw this place opened up a few months back and all my friends kept telling me I had to try it so…read moreI figured I would give it a try. I'm glad I did. It's awesome. I go there at least 2-3 times a week now. They have really good wings cooked fresh. They also have daily specials with food that you generally don't get in a pizza shop. I dined in many 5 star restaurants when I lived in New York and some of the daily specials are on par with those expect at a cheap price. Their pizza is also very good and you can't beat it when you catch their $5.99 large 1 topping pie. I highly recommend!

Let tell you something if you're looking for a the greatest pizza in my opinion around the Jersey…read moreShore I might even say the Tri State area. Ever Pizza I have have had is Fn awesome my fav

A solid local pizza place! The meat lovers was our favorite, followed by the Hawaiian and…read morepepperoni. The crust is okay, wish it had a little more bounce/chew to it but nothing to complain about. Orders can be picked up via the walk up window.

A BBQ pizza joint? We had to check it out. We ordered take out and it was ready when they said it…read morewould be. We got a pizza and some BBQ. Pizza was just OK. Sauce was not very flavorful and crust was little too thick for my liking. We also order a BBQ pulled pork platter. The pork was tender and had some flavor but not covered in sauce. The baked beans were dry - like they had sat out all day. The creamed corn was also dry and tasted canned. The corn bread was tender and had a flavor of jalapeños (maybe) but wasn't spicy. We ordered late afternoon during the week so maybe things would be better/fresher tasting during a peak time.

My family and I visit Cape May, NJ annually and always want to try a new place. Looked online for…read moreanything local and found a bbq spot which we were very excited for. All I can say is we were extremely disappointed with the outcome. The photos from online are clearly not the same as what you would get.

I've stopped here during work and a great deal for a slice and a drink…read more Can add toppings to a regular slice. It's the perfect portion for a lunch on the go where I'm not starving all day until dinner. It's small and locally run so have a little patience if you hit it during the lunch rush. He takes phone orders to have it ready if you need. Place is a bit small so be prepared to take it to go. Great place to grab a slice or a whole pie and take it out to the beach at the end of Sunset for a little car side picnic and watch the sunset.

Great unpretentious pizza place in West Cape May on the way to Cape May point. They offer slices…read morethat are reasonably priced. Quality, tasty pizza.

I went to the Boiler room recently, and I had a wonderful experience. Michele was my server. I had…read morean espresso martini and the truffle wedges and a truffle brick oven pizza. Michele was so fun and cool and friendly. The food was great. The atmosphere was really lovely. I would recommend this place for a chill night for drinks and a quick bite. I was very happy with my service. It made all the difference! Thanks!

So cute fun and good! Went out with the girls on a Friday. Live music was fun and the atmosphere…read morewas great. Loved the pizza and salads too

We had the cheese pizza and the veggie lovers pizza. Both tasted great! The veggie lovers pizza was…read moreloaded with veggies and the baking of the crust was great! Service is good.

We went to Italian Affair for lunch on a weekend. It wasn't too busy, service was prompt and very…read morefriendly. There is seating inside, but not traditional waitress service. You order and pay at the counter, then they will bring the food out as it's done. We ordered: 12" cheese pizza, 6 garlic knots, fried calamari, shrimp basket (not popcorn shrimp, large/full sized shrimp and comes with fries), side order of fries, and 3 cans of soda. Our bill was ~$67 before tip. The food was great. The fried calamari had bits of fried wonton in it, which I was sure of at first, but was actually good. The garlic knots were delicious, definitely homemade and freshly made. The pizza was good, one of the better pies in the county. The fried shrimp was the only thing we probably won't get again, but that's only because we aren't big on seafood. It was good. Also, the marinara sauce is delicious. Heavy on the basil, but very good.