We were in the neighborhood.... Honest. We were a bit hungry, too. DeFazio's, one of the region's premiere pizza parlors was only a few blocks away. I haven't been to this original location on 4th St. in Troy for a few years. The family operation is nearly 100 years old. Remarkably, it's very much as I remember it. A tiny place with three tables. Some of the seating looks like repurposed church pews. The youthful staff, friendly as always. They were running into some delays as orders came pouring in just before dinnertime. They'd have to check to see if they could fit our order for a big pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and peppers. They squeezed us in! Since the wait would be between 20-30 minutes we kept ourselves busy by checking out the desserts in the self serve refrigerator. I picked out a slice of "hangover" (alcohol) cake and I devoured it before our meal arrived. It was so delicious and naughty fun to eat our dessert before the meal. The pizza was fantastic when it arrived. I prefer crisp crusts-- this one was not-- but it was awesome just the same. My friend and I were so hungry that we consumed half of the pie before I realized that we hadn't photographed our delicious pizza. The remaining half was boxed and taken home to be enjoyed for a couple more days. The staff was so ready. They came to our table with the box and we settled up our bill. A lot to be said for tradition and quality. I've also visited DeFazio's in Albany, but I have yet to visit the relatively new restaurant up the block. Thanks, DeFazio's, for another great meal. read more

DeFazio's - Hangover cake minus one bite. - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

See all

Family business, neighborhood ambiance, fabulous pizza, fresh ingredients, and the most authentic pizza I've had! Great sizes, reasonable prices, and absolutely amazing! read more

DeFazio's - Italian Hangover Cake - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

See all

Food was amazing the service was not. Waitress brought water and then first round of drinks; did not ask AT ALL if we wanted another round. One picture of water for the table .. for the evening. Maybe she was having an off night. I don't think we will go back Would rather order to go - read more

What an authentic place to get great pizza. Really small - not a lot of space to sit. But service is quick and pizza is delicious. I had heard about this place from colleagues and reviews. It didn't disappoint. read more

DeFazio's - Mozzarella pizza with balsamic drizzle - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

We ordered two pies! The pizzas were perfect! The crust was doughy and firm! It is a combination of NY style pizza and Napoli, Italy! It is so good! The crust is soft doughy! 2nd time here and they never disappoint! Pizza was ready in 10 minutes! The place has 6 person table, and two bootj read more

See all

I have to admit that I was inspired to come here by the Dave Portnoy review, and it was definitely worth the drive. I ordered a fresh mozzarella pizza. The crust was crispy and left flour on my hands, as good crust should. The sauce was smooth perfection. The cheese slid right off of the pizza, but was delicious. The service was good, I received the pizza at a normal time. My only problem with the ambience was the size of the restaurant and the amount of seating. Overall, Defazio's Pizzeria was amazing, and I'm giving it 5 stars. read more

DeFazio's - The pizza that I ordered. - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

I am unfamiliar with the Troy area, however I will travel when I'm told by many what a gem this establishment is. It is family owned and generational. My only mistake in my haste was not calling in or going online to place my order in advance. No matter, as I am happy to wait for delicious wood fire pizza made to order any day of the week. On this visit, I stopped in their local neighborhood just to try a large regular pie as well as a Fra Diavlo pie. Well, needless to say I was loving their cheese pie which was so simplistic yet made with wholesome ingredients and homemade sauce. Their Fra Diavlo had homemade Italian sausage, hot chopped peppers, cheese and sauce and was wow! I look forward to trying their pesto pie and eggplant Florentine pizza on my next drive over. In this instance, I really wish I had a second stomach hmm hmm.... This cozy yet quaint pizzeria has so much to offer. They have pizza and pasta and many other house made items. I can't wait to try more! read more

See all

I came here for a lunch meeting. My client raved to me about the pizza here. Now honestly I hate rave reviews because then I expect something that maybe is just not the same thing someone else would expect. This place is definitely a Dive. It's a little hole in the wall place that appears to be family owned and operated in not a great part of town. The girls at the counter were cute and you can smell the wood fired pizza oven from outside. It's awful inside, unclean and unkept. The one person bathroom (closet conversion) didn't have a working light. You have to use the bathroom and find the soap and wash your hands in the pitch black. The pizza was decent, though it lacked seasoning. I was particularly impressed by the fresh sliced mushrooms. Most pizza places serve you water logged grossness from a can. Honestly guys lets have some respect for yourselves and your customers and renovate. I know a guy read more

See all

Best Pizza I have tried. Authentic Italian food. The signature cake is amazing. The service is pretty good.

This is great pizza. I've had it from the shop in Troy, the pop up in Albany and both places have been great. Many types to choose from and all delicious. Staff is wonderful as well. read more

The pizza, the sauce, the sausage....the hangover cake-omg so Delicious!! Had me googling Italian hangover cake and how to make it. If you're in the area-check them out! read more

On my way back from snowboarding I always try to make a pit stop to grab some grub and so I had to pull up to DeFazio's Pizza! Let me tell you.. Their Pizza is so delicious. Seriously.. I'm from NYC and I know good Pizza and I'm telling you this Pizza is off the hook! I ordered the 12" which was perfect for 2 people. Cheese to sauce ratio is perfect. Not too cheesy or too saucy.. The crust is nice with a little crispness.. All together you can't go wrong. The service was great. I mean it's a Pizza shop yall. You just sit down and order. The staff was very nice and accommodating though. As far as ambience, it's a small Pizza shop. Not many patrons other than the staff who works there. No loud music. Just a nice cool spot with some tables to sit and eat at. Yeah.. Sonic you find yourself out in the Troy area and you want some slamming Pizza this is your spot! You can thanks me later. Have a great one yall! read more

DeFazio's - 12" Cheese Pizza So delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

See all

No pizza by the slice! Food was good, pizza was artisan personal type brick oven. No crunch but the crust was good, toppings were decent overall. Tomatoes on top the arugula prosciutto wasn't my favorite. Service was a little slow and had some problems handling the 4 ppl I was with. Ambiance was weird, not inviting, had a weird smell, and pretty dark. Overall all 6/10. read more

DeFazio's - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

See all

Still remains my favorite in the Cap District. We wanted to try the new spot just down the street but it's only open for dinner hours so we were glad the original place still had indoor dining. We ordered sausage for there and lobster ravioli to go, pizza as usual was great and the LR was really good and huge raviolis. read more

DeFazio's - Sausage pizza... so damn good! - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

Ordered a pizza for pick up and very disappointed... it was flat and tasted like cardboard. Reviews were really good so was super surprised. Will give another chance, but for dining only. Will not order for delivery or pick up again. read more

Stopped while at the farmer's market for a slice of breakfast pizza. Loved that they had the option to pay through Paypal, because I forgot my wallet in the car. The slices are big. They have convection ovens to heat up your pie if you want to eat it immediately. I got the spinach and cheese. Didn't realize there was an egg on it (hence the breakfast pizza) so that was a nice surprise. Fresh and tasty! read more

I'm a Manhattan kid born and raised (E 120th & Paladino Ave & Greenwich Village) so I've eaten thousands of New York slices and believe me I know and love pizza Plus David Portnoy brought me here lol. DeFazio's is absolutely amazing I ordered the 16' sausage pizza and it was an absolute beauty and was pretty big. The sausage was perfect, the sauce was delicious, the crust was good and for $21 I couldn't have had a better lunch. The staff was unexpectedly diverse (Very refreshing to see) and the shop itself had a very old school vibe to it. I'll definitely be visiting again! read more

DeFazio's - Fabulous looking pizza pie - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

Absolutely delicious pizza! Very small interior but the service was good. This place is always so busy, this is the first time I've gone and it's not insanely busy. read more

DeFazio's - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

Just come... come to this spot and have the cake. Have the cake and a pizza and a cannoli. But do not leave without having the cake. Pizza was phenomenal, cannolis were great.... The cake was god tier. read more

DeFazio's - Chicken Parmesan Ricotta Pizza and Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

Amazing product, always high quality. Service was fast and friendly. The building and interior design is beautiful! I loved it so much, I booked my rehearsal dinner here. Give it a try! You'll love it. read more

Unbelievable pizza! Fresh homemade ingredients, great service! Rocco came out and talked to us about the history of the family and restaurant. Was like we knew him for 30 years...loved the experience! read more

See all

This is everything a pizza should be from sauce, cheese and a surprisingly different non traditional all purpose bread flour crust. DeFazios delivers an "Old World Pizzeria" experience; making their sausage and all pizza ingredients in house. Dave Portnoys 8.2 pizza review and rating is extremely high if you follow Dave's Reviews. His recent review prolly has elevated the pizzeria into a national trajectory which already was in a local ascension in the greater Albeny area. My wife and I were blown away as DeFazios pizza is something you don't want to miss. Make no mistake, you should make a reservation as there is very limited interior dining space. Also, make sure you call or order online to get in the queue as there is always a wait. Enjoy..!!! read more

It had been probably 30 years since I had been to DeFazio's. It was as good as I remember it. And that means it was absolutely fantastic. You will not have better pizza. You can buy dough balls. You can shop in their mini store. But, always, get the pizza. Don't forget about the little garden area out back. My highest recommendation! read more

See all

I had been wanting to try this place for a number of weeks but my schedule and their schedule just didn't match for being able to get a reservation. However, tonight I had the opportunity with my daughter to go out to dinner and called to make a reservation I made it for 430 because they told me that they were really booked up later. Looking forward to a nice relaxing dinner. We went at 4:30 on entering the restaurant. the ambience was beautiful, but I could tell that it was a loud room with just a few people at that time that were there The waitress offered us a variety of waters of which both of us were looking forward to a cocktail ice cold and relaxing. I ordered a Manhattan and my daughter ordered a martini. When we got the drinks, they were served in goblet glasses just about a half a drink each and we were very disappointed as in a regular Italian or any restaurant the drink would've been twice the size for the price that was charged, but we took it for granted that maybe the dinner would be better We ordered. She ordered little neck clams with a white cream sauce on fettuccine and I ordered the fettuccine with a homemade Italian meatballs and marinara sauce When our dinners came my daughter got four little neck clams in a cream sauce with very little chopped up clams I received a dish of fettuccine with four tiny meatballs, Their homemade pork and beef. I must say that the meatballs were very tasty, but very small. We decided to go all the way since we were so disappointed with our experience and at this point we ordered a dessert which was a saving grace as my daughter loves cheesecake and they had this homemade cheesecake that was absolutely delicious. Found that the drink prices were very high for the drink the meal prices were out of proportion to the quantity of the meal that you got Service was average for the menu price, but the servers were very friendly. I have been in a food beverage business for over 50 years also a consultant I found this not to be a pleasant experience. Something that we waited for to relax and enjoy. Turned out to be a costly mistake . read more

Customer service asked for cash in the market, but apparently the pizza side takes debit cards while I went to get cash. My pizza got cold do yourselves a favor and have one policy good for both places and then educate your clients. pizza with cold crust was burned. Not a great experience. I would go somewhere else. read more

Ordered DeFazio's for a pick up today. You have to order early, sometimes the day before. So called first thing for a 4pm pick up. The girl takes the order but doesn't ask my name, so I asked if she needed my name for the order and she said "oh yeah." Didn't think much of it at the time. I drive all the way out there to pick up all the food and get told "no we don't have your order." And they just stand there and stare at me like I am in the wrong. No apology, no "give us some time we will get it done for you." NOTHING! They offered no remorse, no "let's make this right." It was the worst customer service I have ever experienced. read more

DeFazio's is the best spot in town! Nothing else has to be said! I love the food, I'm obsessed with the staff and owners! I'm not surprised at all these amazing reviews, it's worth it and well deserved! read more

We enjoyed our dinner at the Fazio's. It was clean, staff was attentive and prices were not too bad. Our dishes were very good portions were fair. We enjoyed our experience. read more

Awesome hidden gem in Troy. The staff was extremely friendly and the pizza came out piping hot. We ordered a large cheese with their speciality garlic and herb dough. The flavor in the pizza was awesome (and I like how they sprinkle herbs over it once it comes out of the oven), but not sure the specialty dough was worth the extra up-charge. I like my pizzas a little crisper - this pizza had a little flop to it, but I would definitely come back to try another one of their specialty pies. Worth the hype and detour when you're upstate. read more

DeFazio's - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

Food was terrific... large cheese and a white clam ... got the hangover cake also ... bomb ass shit read more

DeFazio's - White clam - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

See all

Dave Portnoy made me do it. Defazio's 100% lives up to the hype! Ordered online the morning of at 10am and it was ready for pickup at 6:30pm - make sure to order in advance! They really do sell out. Ordered the following: Large cheese pizza with meatballs & sausage - red sauce and meatballs tasted so fresh and had great flavor. Meatballs are cut thin and sausage crumbled - so good! Small spinach and mushrooms - this pizza ended up being my favorite! The seasonings they used to sauté the mushrooms and spinach were garlicky and delicious and they give you a great amount of the veggies Small white clam pizza - was super intrigued and had to try! If you're a big seafood fan you have to order. Packs a lot of flavor. Mini cannolis - fill them for you right then and there! Authentic and fresh! The pizza bread dough was light and airy and cooked to perfection. Can't wait to try more items on their menu! 10/10 would recommend DeFazio's. read more

See all

I honestly don't know where to begin. First off, we're from Los Angeles and took a red-eye flight to fly into Newark. The first thing we wanted to do was drive 2.5 hours to get to DeFazio's! Yes, we came on behalf of Dave Portnoy's recommendation. And it did not disappoint! This really was one of my most memorable restaurant experiences. - Pizza was INCREDIBLE - Hangover Cake was out of the world!! So moist perfectly throughout the entire thing. - We were eating outside and came Rocco popping out to ask how it was. We were the only ones so we got to talk to him for a while and it was such a nice conversation. So funny and cool. He was even so nice to invite us in and give us a tour of the store and recommended the Italian Hangover. - Even got to meet Rocco's son and he was chill as well. Overall, yes. Just go here and experience how great it is. I can't get over it. It's now a must-go place for us every time we're in the east coast now. Grazie, Rocco and DeFazio's team!!!! You've made my trip that much better read more

See all

We stopped by on a Friday around 3 to order pizzas and we were told the next available pizza would be around 7/8 pm! Our schedule was not that flexible so we ended up leaving. While in the car, we saw that there was an option to order ahead for pick up so we scheduled a pickup for Saturday around noon. I was very excited to see that there were vegan pizza options since I am lactose intolerant. I ordered the Vegan Margarite Pizza which has Vegan Mozzarella, Tomato Sauce, Fresh Basil, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Homemade Vegan Parm Cheese and OMG it was the best vegan pizza I've ever had. I was nervous that I accidentally ate a pizza with real cheese since it was so good. The crust was cooked perfectly and the sauce was delicious. Wish I lived closer so I could try other vegan pies! My bf ordered a cheese pizza and the Italian hangover cake (thanks for the recommendation Portnoy) and absolutely loved it! Next time I'm visiting RPI, I'll have to visit again read more

DeFazio's - Vegan Margarite Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

First time here a DeFazios Troy. Went in at 1:00 ordered for a 6 PM pickup. Pizza was ready, hot, and good to go. Walked it home and dove in. My wife and I loved it. Great crust, sauce , cheese. Fresh mushrooms and sausage. The girls at the counter were friendly and efficient. We will definitely order again, maybe this Monday! read more

Authentic Italian you got it! Homemade pastas, traditional parmesan dishes, huge and i do mean huge portions! The salads can be split 3-4 people! The Arugula salad was a mountain on a plate refreshing but not over powered by the lemon dressing. Pizzas are amazing the Vinny personal favorite,-Eggplant parm could feed a small army i kid you not Service very friendly and personable- Taylor, Maggie,Jess- thank you for your personal attention par excellence! Apple cider spritz very "Fally" and not to be missed. The wine portfolio was fabulous and heavily weighted with wonderfully unique Italian varietals- remember peeps Italian wines are meant to be paired with food to compliment both the wine and food - so grab that bottle and let it decant and warm up during salad, soup and appetizers and don't try to drink it before the food comes- I promise you will thank me later! Personal favs- Nobile di Montepulciano (Sangiovese from Tuscany) and the Toscano Rossa (petit verdot/cab blend) for more rich dishes Ambiance was bustling- sat in bar at high top one night, in dining area the next- i like the vibe of the high top better and the energy around the bar. This restaurant is actually 216 4th street and reservations are a must! We dined 2 nites outta 3 while in town for RPI parents weekend! Mangia mangia, salut, and molto bene! (Our only disappointment was missing meeting and chatting up the Sommelier both nights) read more

Saw Dave Portnoy's glowing review last year online not knowing the location. While visiting family in the area his review popped up again on my IG feed and only then did I realize DeFazio's was less than 20 minutes away in Troy. The pizza was delicious but it was the Italian Hangover cake I had my stomach set on and to say it didn't disappoint is an understatement. It was absurdly delicious and surprisingly complex in flavor. I got a second slice for my family and they all agreed. Absolutely stop by if you're in the area. read more

DeFazio's - Pizza Near Me - Troy, New York

Delicious food and pasta. Hangover cake is amazing recommend getting a slice every time read more

Hands down the best quality pizza in the Troy area ....The place is located in South Troy in a kind of hidden spot but worth the hunt. The people there are accommodating and nice...Their other menu items are great as well..Highly recommended! read more

Read the pizza reviews of the local Albany-Schenectady-Troy lot...then read the reviews from the NJ-Long Island-Connecticut folks. Who would you trust? Exactly...this is 6.5/10 pizza where I grew up. I'm being kind...doughy crusts and flop from the slice maybe ok in the "Good for Albany" world...but south of Westchester......I don't need to answer that. The red saucy Eyetalian pasta dishes are solid (classic Jersey worthy stuff)....not over the top memorable but I'm not driving 30 miles to Troy NY to visit this place...I'll save the gas for New Haven CT. read more

Was told wait would be "one hour" ended up waiting over 2 hours for pizza... was less then 10" in diameter... they need to change their system. Unbelievable. read more