Really good real Ice Cream! Friendly polite staff, very…read morequick! Wonder place to sit enjoy ice Cream!

Ice Cream is my favorite in Columbus. Better than Jeni's in my opinion. Worth the two block walk…read morefrom High Street. IC Sandwiches are the bomb!

This place is fabulous! I found this gem on Instagram and immediately saw their posts of elote and…read moreI had to come here. I was pleasantly surprised to find out this place is an ice cream shop! So many different, unique flavors (and free samples). I tried the queso ice cream which was definitely different than I thought & the girl working the counter had me try her favorite- the blueberry cream cheese which was great! I had that, and of course, elote. The elote was the best I have had in the Columbus area! If you're in or around Whitehall, this is the place to stop at! I will definitely be back.

I finally had the chance to visit your shop today with my children, and we really enjoyed the…read moreexperience. The drive from Reynoldsburg was short, and parking was very convenient. We loved the aesthetic and the extensive variety of snacks and treats available, from the walking tacos to the different popsicles and ice cream flavors. My kids enjoyed their gummy bear and cotton candy ice cream, and I really liked the Snickers flavor. It was great to find a place with such a nice selection of Mexican treats at a reasonable price. We look forward to stopping by again soon.

This is a great place! The custard is amazing, they have a lot of options of what to eat. One of…read morethere workers, I think named "Cailyn" is the best at making Lion Sundaes. I just love to eat here especially after like a sports game or something.

Ice crystals in my chocolate ice cream cone at 1:15 this past Wednesday left me very disappointed…read more Actually, this was the second time here that this happened. The first time I ate the cone but regretted it afterwards thinking it was a waste of calories. This time I went back to the site- with cone in hand-and told them I wanted a refund due to the poor quality of the custard. I received a complementary free ice cream card instead of a refund which I was ok with. Honestly, when you pay over $4 for a small cone, it better be perfection. Also, there are several other ice cream locations in that vicinity so Whit's needs to get it together or people will go elsewhere.

When my son's girlfriend offered to take my wife and I out for PRE-dinner dessert, I was eager to…read morecheck out this new "hot spot" they had discovered. Especially since they had already visited this place four times in the same calendar week, besides, it HAD to be good if they were content with introducing me to it BEFORE I tore into my slow-cooking pot of chili. The first thing I noticed upon entry was a gentleman (the co-owner who introduced himself as Doc West [cool name]) who opened the door for our party of four, welcoming us with a huge smile. He expressed a genuine appreciation for our visit, making me feel like one of the five golden ticket winners upon their initial entrance to Willy Wonka's Chocolate Factory. Chocolate Factory is definitely a good comparison because the brightness in colors all revolving around the pink base felt like I had exited through a portal and into another world. Bright neon signs, oversized games like Connect Four and Jenga, throwback penny candy, beautifully colorful and tantalizing portraits, and wonderful music. Inside, he introduced me to Page Bridges, the other owner whose smile was even larger. These two, in conjunction with their happy employees, all gave me wonderful vibes before I'd even seen the product. (If the name of the establishment sounds familiar, they were formerly located at Eastland Mall - but the show must, and does, go on...) I looked over the menu. Decisions, decisions. Sundaes and ice cream. Should I get one, two, or THREE scoops? Nope. Root Beer floats! *Hums silently and happily like Homer Simpson* Cobbler! Donuts! Hotdogs! Oreo Shack! Slushies! I immediately understood why my son and his girlfriend made so many visits. Everyone in our party ordered something different, but since I didn't try anyone else's items, it wouldn't be fair to comment on them. Suffice it to say that all were completely satisfied with their selections (my apologies for not remembering to at least photograph any of them). I decided to keep it simple and order a vanilla shake. If you know me, I stick with the basics (like sausage and pepperoni at pizzerias) to establish a good benchmark for comparison to other businesses of a similar nature. When I told him my favorite flavors, he suggested that I try mixing it with a banana to enhance the experience without deviating from the desire to taste the root flavor. I was eager to order a large shake but hadn't forgotten that my pot of chili was waiting patiently for me at home. Let me tell you folks, that shake was incredible! The ice cream was deep and rich, while the banana accentuated it perfectly. Part of me regretted not including another flavor, while the rest of me was happy to have stayed in my lane, as this combination reminded me of the shake/malt shop I grew up around in the 70s/80s in East Chicago. The banana was blended perfectly, minimizing the chunks that can often be a bit of a nuisance when sipping through a straw. Then again, the straw was larger in diameter than the traditional ones, so that would not have been a problem anyway. But it wouldn't have mattered because as the sign said on their wall, "Ice Cream Solves Everything!" And that aftertaste, dude. Suffice it to say I'm hooked and will most definitely be returning. Make it your business to get out there to try this place out and, as always, tell 'em Kenny sent ya! Curse me for only ordering a medium...

If you want to hang out with friends and grab some sweet treats Kai's Sugar Shack is the place to…read morego. The shop is family operated and everyone is super nice. It is really cute and they have a plenty of places to take cute pictures. I don't know to many places that you can get a flight of ice cream. I wish I had taken a picture of that. I was excited to see some of my favorite old school candies. Plenty of sweet treats to choose from, you can't go wrong. they also have other food items that you can buy. If you want to hangout for a while there is plenty of board games.

The quick service Mexican Ice Cream shop has a lot of flavors to choose from. For regular ice cream…read moreflavors the pistachio was a smooth and creamy treat. The Oreo frappe was a fancier treat that wowed with the presentation. We were fortunate to get there at a good time as the small shop seems to have an u ending stream of visitors.

Love the concept of Orange leaf! Self serve fro-yo. You select a cup size and select flavor(s) to…read moreyour liking. There are an abundant number of flavors to choose from. You're also able to request a sample for any of the flavors since there are so many different types. For certain flavors, you can also "twist" them together- ex. swirl chocolate and vanilla. Great idea! The toppings selection is also vast. There are fruit toppings as well as candy toppings- so there is something for everyone! Payment is based solely upon weight of your cup- toppings and fro-yo both. Typically, I find myself spending around $6 for a decent sized amount. I once loaded the large cup full to the top and the total was around $9/$10. You can take your cup to go or hang out with friends at their unique orange seats. They even have outdoor seating. Great idea for post-movie treat since the movie theater is located right across the parking lot. Staff is awesome, talkative and friendly. I have no complaints!

We've been to other Orange Leafs and they are fun, especially for kids. A nice cool treat that you…read morecan essentially build yourself. This one is tiny, as they all are. Clean. Super friendly service. I was looking for a root beer float thing I had heard about, and they weren't sure, but they said it is a "fizz cup." And they did have one on display, and some signs promoting it, so yeah, I'm sure that's what I heard about. They essentially screw a bowl on top of a bottle of root beer, A&W in this case, and fill it with your choice of yogurt. Then you squeeze the bottle, the root beer comes up, and you flood the yogurt. Mix and enjoy. Definitely leave the lid on when you are squeezing, because it spouts like a whale or volcano. Their spoon is awkwardly shaped for the little bowl; one or the other has to change size and shape. It made a nice little float. It was fun. It was awkward. It was potentially messy, especially for kids. It is definitely not something to drink in the car, as I'd hope to do. I don't think I'll get it again, just make a float at home, but it was unique.

We started at the German Village Jeni's. I really did not grasp that this Jeni's is just a window…read morein a wall next to a sandwich shop. We attempted to go to this location, but despite all advertised information it was closed. We ended up at the Graeters in Bexley which was large, open, provided a bathroom, and had a lovely spacious patio tucked behind the shop. The Midnight Snack flavor was excellent. I like ice cream with lots of chunks of chocolate etc... All 6 humans and the dog were happy.

Ahhh, NOSTALGIA…read more Everyone's favourite ice-cream....well, definitely not everyone but for a number of people in Columbus or Cincinnati, Ohio. Graeter's Ice-Cream was started in Cincinnati but I grew up going to Graeter's in Columbus, Ohio. I always enjoy coming back to Graeter's whenever I visit Columbus because there isn't one close by to where I live in Cleveland. ICE-CREAMS AND MALTS -- I love getting the toffee chip ice-cream which is my favourite one to get. I also love getting their Malt drinks which is ice-cream melted down with milk (I believe milk). Everything is fresh and homemade or made in-house. You can get ice-cream on a cone or in a cup. You can also buy one of their to-go ice-cream containers. TIP -- Get their loyalty card. I think after 10 punches you get a free ice-cream. TIP 2 -- Big grocery stores now sell Graeter's Ice-Cream pints (small containers) in the freezer aisle. This location in Bexley is my go-to location because I've come here for years and customer service is always friendly and attentive. Now that I've written this review, I want some Graeter's Ice-Cream. YUM, YUM, YUM!!! **** GOAL of 150 reviews in 2024 - 53/150 total reviews in 2024 - 703 total overall Yelp reviews - Reviewed on 5 July 2024

I love Graeter's and had to come try their new flavor - Flying Pig Tracks, vanilla with peanut…read morebutter cups and fudge swirls. It was good but wasn't as fudge-y as I had anticipated. Still a good treat after dinner. This location was super clean, workers were good and fast and great at multi-tasking. It's a warm spring day so the drive thru was pretty busy but I was able to get served in a timely manner.

Ice cream cake we ordered awesome. Picked it up tonight and realized a 20% tip was added to this…read moreorder. Why am I tipping on an online order? Who am I tipping, the young man who provided service wandered around the store looking for this order for three minutes. Am I tipping him for not looking in the cooler he was standing next to when he asked me what I wanted? $39.99 for the product and 20% tip with no prompt or notice of a tip.

I don't have a Rita's anywhere near my home and when I realized I was going to be close to this one…read moreduring an afternoon trip to Gahanna, I made sure to stop and get a treat to satisfy the craving I've had since the temps reached the mid 80's in May. The parking lot was empty when I arrived, and damn well near full when I left. I absolutely love the texture complexity of the slushy slush and the creamy custard. I always get vanilla but tend to mix it up a bit with the slush part. This time I got watermelon with sprinkles on top. The service was friendly and quick and I enjoyed it from my car in total silence. That's how happy I was at that moment. If you've never been, do yourself a favor and go this summer. You'll be happy you did!

Rita's, my wife loves the black cherry Italian ice, waaaaayyy tooo much! But it also gets me out…read moreof the house to get one of your custards. Service at this one was outstanding and I really like the ease to get on and off the highway.

While I appreciated the excellent location and service, I must admit that I was not particularly…read moreimpressed with the ice cream, though this is simply my personal preference.

Stopped by to pick up ice cream for home. I purchased a half gallon of Blackberry Cheese Cake. It…read moreis absolutely delicious!!! Soooo good!!! I ordered online for in store pickup. Staff was friendly & store was clean.