Totally amazing!! I had to order a custom cake for my daughters bday and she was kind enough to accommodate me last minute( a day before). The cake looked amazing and was loved by everyone. It also tasted great. Red velvet with chocolate filling!!!!!! read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - Beautiful last minute (day before) custom cake (miraculous ladybug) was beautiful and was delicious!! I provided the topper and candles. - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

Absolutely phenomenal experience with CUSTOM CAKES NYC! From start to finish, they were a pleasure to work with. Not only were they able to accommodate my specific requests for a custom cake, but the final product exceeded all expectations. read more

So we have worked with this place 4 times. And twice they have been great and twice they have been ok. Our wedding cake was amazing and perfect. It had everything that we wanted in a cake. For my son's baby shower we we're going for a beach theme and that was ok. I guess my expectations were kind of high because of how the wedding cake turned out. Then for my son's 1st bday party I wanted cupcakes with something from the Incredibles. They came up with printed edible sheets on top of the icing. And then recently for my son's 4th bday party we asked for a lightning McQueen Cake. While cartoony we didn't have crazy high expectations and my son loved the toy on top of the cake. Everything that was made for us tasted great. Can't complain about the taste. And price is very reasonable. I just know now that if we something fancy like a wedding cake to definitely come here. read more

The lady who made our cake was so nice and accommodating. Although we did not get the flavors we originally wanted, the cake still turned out tasty and beautiful. Every one in the party said that the cake tastes delicious. We added the topper from amazon. read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - My wedding cake made by Custom Cakes New York - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

At the buzzer, Custom Cakes came through for me, delivering a fun basketball themed cake for my nephews birthday. What I didn't know was that the cake would be delicious!! Even more so, each layer of the cake provided a new experience. The bottom -- chocolate cake. Moist, delicious, well-balanced chocolate cake. The middle -- outrageously good, fresh strawberry shortcake. Fresh sliced strawberries, light custard and a pillowy soft cake made for the most delicious cake. Under the fondant ... a surprise freshly whipped cream. Wow and wow. I was so impressed and have been craving more of this cake since then. Not only was it delicious but the team was so sweet and over-delivered. The pricing was great and they even delivered it 45 minutes away ... at the crack of dawn, and with a smile!!! Can't wait until the next party. I will absolutely order this cake! read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

The choices,are to DROOL for!! You can name,any flavor!! she will bake it! dont know? She creates delicious flavorful delights! She surprised me with a mango flavor cake with Fresh MANGO. It was refreshingly tasty!!My new FAVORITE! Her tres leche and duke leche are out if this world! My 2 out if3 sons love chocolate she blew us,away with the chocolate and Oreos cake.. I could go on!..just go,call and order a cake or 2. * another secret* she makes,healthy EMPANADAS!! They are BAKED not fried.. scrumptious! What are you waiting for! Go order! YU will thank me..especially for the sweet and kind service that you will receive read more

See all

I've used Maria and her staff five times for 5 birthdays and am very satisfied with her work. I had custom cupcakes for my sons birthday every year since his birth and now he's four and I love working with her . She makes custom garbage trucks and miniforce and fire trucks so she can do almost everything . I love Maria and think she's fantastic with what she does . read more

This review is for the custom cake i ordered for my son's baptism. BTW it used to be called Sweet Treats NY and now called Custom Cakes NYC. I initially called her for an appointment and ask if she'll be able to make me a very specific cake design for my 3 tier cake. When we arrived there, she handed us her 3 best seller flavors for us to sample. It was red Velvet, chocolate, and strawberry. It was so good and moist. The strawberry flavor wasn't just a flavor, she was actually using actual sweet strawberries which was to me a great thing to have in my cake. We had a hard time choosing which one to choose. And then we realized hey, why not just have 3 flavors on our 3 tier cake! We told her the day and time we needed the cake. And as agreed she delivered our cake on time. Our guests took pictures with the cake coz it looks beautiful. Not only that, when it was time for our guests to get their slice everybody said it was delicious! Some even asked for seconds. And as a host that made me happy! I highly recommend Maricor to anyone who wants to order customized cake. I actually just ordered another cake from her! read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

I am so amazed how the cake turn out to be exactly how picture it. I am so impressed of her work and I will definitely come back again for another custom cake. Every penny was worth it. She's very nice and pleasant to deal with. She responded on me via text so quickly. Excellent customer service and very professional! read more

Wow amazing is all i gotta say!!!! They did exactly what i wanted and showed in a picture. Loved it so much, it looked absolutely amazing and tasted amazing too! Thank you read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - a wedding cake with sparklers - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

Maricor is amazing! She worked with me last minute and answered any of my inquiries almost instantly. I requested a firefighter helmet for my boyfriends FDNY graduation and it came out as perfectly as I could imagine. I will definitely return to Maricor in the future! read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

All I can say is $363 down the drain. Very unprofessional and poor quality cake. I ordered the cake for a baby shower a week in advance/placed the deposit. The day of the baby shower I was supposed to pick up the cake at 2 PM. I received a call around lunchtime with an excuse saying the cake wouldn't be ready. I said, okay what time do you think it'll be ready? I was told 3, okay that's fine. I got to the bakery at 3 PM and the cake was probably only 25% done. I kept calm, but the baby shower was starting at 4 PM, so I was panicking a little. The lovely Maricor told me to go buy some balloons or something... okay, now I'll blow you up, but I didn't. I would've appreciated a call letting me know the cake wasn't ready. We didn't get the cake until 5 PM. Only one piece of cake was eaten and the rest melted. Thank you. read more

This was the second time we ordered from here within 2 months. It came out gorgeous & tasted amazing as well! Going to be ordering again in October! Thank you Mari! read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - Moneybag cake, Chanel bag cake, Rack of money cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

I ordered this cake for my boyfriends birthday he literally laughed out loud when he opened the box lol. Thank you so much Maria! you put a smile on his face and made our night :) he loved it. read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

Custom Cakes is truly the best creator of cakes in Queens. The owner, Maricor, is so pleasant, efficient and detailed in her creations. Whatever your request is, she will create with artistic quality and a smile. She is the go-to person for my family and friends. I kid you not, I have contacted Maricor two days before an event and she was able to have the cake available for me. Custom Cakes is definitely the place to go for all your cake needs. I'm so blown away by Maricor's creativity, I've attached some of the creations she's done for my family members and myself. read more

See all

Maricor's cakes are absolutely out of this world! It's not too sweet and they are quite delectable! Her foods are awesomely delicious!! I recommend this place to anyone who needs a cake, food, and even cookies. Had the most yummy matcha cake last night at a birthday party. (see picture below) I highly recommend Maricor! read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - Absolutely tasty Matcha birthday cake!! :) - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

These ladies make magic happen! My Goddaughter had a birthday party at a bowling alley and we decided to get a bowling ball cake. This decision was made 2 weeks prior to her party so I had a hard time finding a bakery to accommodate us due to graduation and wedding season. I did lots of calling around before I decided to go with this bakery. Not only were they the most affordable of the few last minute options I had but they were also very customer service friendly. Everyone loved the cake including my Goddaughter!! I will definitely go back whenever I next need a cake. read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

I would highly recommend this company. Maria was easy to work with. She baked two beautiful cakes for me last year. I got many compliments for it. It was very delicious too. It was easy communication thru text with no worries. Thank you Maria. read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - Wedding cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

See all

Very disappointed for a cake that cost $150! Worst part is the taste and the inside of the cake. I've never had a cake that taste like this before therefore cannot explain how it taste like. Just saw chunks of butter like substance and no one can finish their cakes. Will not go back again read more

This is my first time I ordered from this place. I have to say I made the right decision. Not only my cake looked awesome, it tasted delicious. Each & every guest liked the cake & gave me compliments. Thanks Maricor for making my baby shower more special & memorable. All my pics came out so good. I will surely order from u again. read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - My guests loved the cake, awesome job done thanks a lot - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

So, everyone has a story! I called my regular cake place a whole month in advance to get a cake for my sons birthday. The said for some reason that that wasn't enough time, so I had to find some where else. Of course I went to my trust worthy application...Yelp! It had seen really good reviews on the taste of the cake which is very important for me. We got the strawberry custard filling with yellow cake. It was pretty good! The cake wasn't to sweet and the fresh strawberries where perfect for a summer party. The only thing I would say about the cake was the yellow cake was a little dry but that's just me being picky. The price was great, the baker was super friendly and the cake came out great!! read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

I wrote a review for this place a few years ago. I just wanted to update my review and say that it is still as good as it was when I first went there to place my first order. I find most businesses tend to lower their standards with time which is very disappointing. I'm happy to say that Custom Cakes has been consistently excellent and it is so good to know that I can rely on Custom Cakes to deliver a beautifully decorated and delicious cake for special occasions throughout the year. Maricor, the baker, caterer and owner of this business, is a real gem! She bakes her cakes and cooks her food with so much love. You can taste the difference. Her empanadas are my favorite. No one makes empanadas like she does. I highly recommend you give her cakes and food a try. read more

I ordered a 3 tiered snowflake themed cake for my son's first birthday and it came out amazing! Maricor was great at helping me design the cake and she was very accommodating, especially after I made some last minute changes in the days before the party. At first I was nervous about ordering a custom cake but I'm so happy I did! It was the highlight of the party! Everyone was impressed with how beautiful the cake was and even more impressed with how delicious the cake was!! We had two flavors- the vanilla with fresh strawberries and chocolate with Oreo frosting- both were insanely delicious- so good!! Also, the prices are very reasonable. Order from Custom Cakes NYC and you won't be disappointed!! read more

See all

Hello everyone I just had my first son birthday party and I order my cake from here the flavors and the taste and the decoration is spectacular and amazing if you come and Order you cakes from here I promise you will be satisfied!!! :-) read more

I highly recommend Custom Cakes NYC for your customized cakes! The owner Maricor is professional, talented and friendly. I was impressed by her level of expertise. Just by telling her how I wanted my cake designed for a baby shower, Maricor was able to customize exactly what I had in mind. She also has many photos of cakes she previously baked in case you need ideas. I left her shop feeling satisfied and I'm very happy I chose her to bake my cake. Her prices are also reasonable. I plan to be a returning customer and take comfort in knowing that anytime I need a customized cake, I know exactly where to go. -Queen read more

The cake tastes good and the workers are friendly. I got a cake customized with my friend's picture and it looked pretty good. I recommend. read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - Red velvet and cream cheese. Tasted pretty good. The picture was also put nicely - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

I am so glad I found this bakery to do my daughter's mermaid birthday cake. Not only was the cake exactly what I wanted - simple, delicious, good value - working with Maricor was great. read more

The worst ever!! I ordered a NY GIANTS football jersey cake for a party of 15, i showed the picture of what i wanted and i was told it can be done etc......the day of the party (5days later) i came to pick up the cake and it was HORRRRRRIBLE. I cried, i was told that she was too busy and told someone to do it, although i PAID HER TO DO IT. She WAS very apologetic and gave me a refund, as well as the cake. BUT it was too late, what about my party? It was so bad that i had to tell the story 1st, before i bought the cake out......it was the joke of the night, when it was supposed to be the highlight of the night. I WOULD NEVER GO THERE AGAIN!!! see my profile for the actual cake. Looks looks like a child did it. THEY CUT OUT OF THE GIANTS STICKER AND NY STICKER AND PASTED IT ON THE CAKE.....NOTHING LIKE THE PHOTO.....its suppose to be red white and blue....why is it orange?!?!?....‍‍ read more

Ordered a custom cake for my friend who just got his green card (green card cake) which I came to pick up from the East Village. The cake came out amazingly well, the people here could not have been any friendlier, and the price was great. In the NYC area where custom / event cakes can just mean worse quality and more $$$, this place stands out as a gem and I'd highly recommend it! read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - Green Card Cake! - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

Maricor you truly are amazing! I can see the passion and love you have for what you do for a living. You made the cake I described better than I expected or imagined. You are an artist. Not only did the cake and cupcakes look sooo PERFECT, it was so delicious. The cake I ordered was Disney Sofia the First Theme Birthday Cake for my Daughter's Princess Sonia's 4th Birthday Party. It was a 2 tier cake to feed a total of 40 people, top layer was vanilla cake and vanilla creme, and bottom layer was vanilla cake with chocolate creme, and 48 cupcakes, half vanilla and other half was chocolate, half with purple icing on top and other half with pink icing on top. She delivered it all the way to the bronx. Her bakery by the way is what I call a hidden gem, because of the location. But I found my baker for life! Thank you for making my daughter a very happy little princess. read more

See all

Can't say enough good things about Custom Cakes. Due to some last minute issues, I found myself in need of someone to bake a cake for a baby shower that would feed 60-65 people within two weeks. The baby shower was early December, so there were weddings abound AND the holidays were upon us so most of the people I called were too busy. I happened to locate Maricor online and initially we communicated everything via text. I sent her a picture of the design I was thinking of and after a little back and forth, she quoted a price and we set up a time for me to come in and taste the different cakes. Price was reasonable and even though she had a large wedding to do that day, she assured me she could fit it in if I was willing to pick up myself. When I went into the shop to taste the cake, Maricor and I went over the cake design in detail, right down to the last baby bottom ruffle. I was impressed by her attention to detail. Ultimately, cake was completed late night the evening before so it would be ready for pickup first thing the next morning. Maricor was even kind enough to send me a photo of the finished product the evening before since she wouldn't be around the day of when I went to pickup. It was perfect and oh so delicious! Bottom layer was vanilla with strawberries (which, by the way are fresh strawberries) and the top two layers were red velvet. Definitely a winner and served as an amazing centerpiece (that is, before it was devoured...). read more

CUSTOM CAKES NYC - Custom Cakes Near Me - Jamaica, New York

See all

This is my favorite cake place in town. Her customized mango cake, chocolate cakeare Judy ity of this world. She also does amazing Philippino desert. The best custom cake in town!!!! read more

I definitely made the right decision by coming here. Maricor designed a beautiful cake for my baby shower and not only was it visually appealing, it was mind blowingly delicious!!! Vanilla and strawberry filling was my favorite! My guests could not stop complimenting on it. Maricor was very helpful and professional from beginning to end in working with me. She's excellent at what she does and I highly recommend her for your next occasion! read more

See all

If you need a custom cake, this is the place to go! You will get a beautiful cake made with love by the sweet owner, Maricor. She also has an extensive catering menu for your next party or event! My favorites are lumpia, empanadas (they are baked not fried) and macaroni salad with chicken and pineapples! Her specialty is Filipino food! Don't take my word for it, go try it for yourself! read more

Custom Cakes is a hidden gem! Their cakes are scrumptious and to die for! I love the mango cake with fresh fruit (so refreshing) and the chocolate cake (so decadent). Maricor also makes delicious Filipino desserts such as cassava that is so delicious and melts in your mouth. I am planning a party for a relative this month and am sure to order this special cake from Maricor. I know the cake will be made to order and my guests will love it! read more

I tried Maricor's (the owner) empanadas two years ago because a friend brought them over for a New Year's Eve celebration. The minute I took a bite, I knew these empanadas were different. They were baked (not fried), the fillings were full of flavor, and the crust was so delicious -- light and buttery. They were the best empanadas I ever tasted. When I went to Maricor's shop to order the empanadas for an event, I discovered to my delight that she also catered Filipino food and is also an incredible pastry chef. Her food is made with love and even my father who can be very particular about his food raved about her cooking. He even exclaimed that the oxtail stew was cooked "perfectly." Maricor's cakes are not only beautiful, they are so good that you will want to eat every bit of it including the delicious buttercream frosting (that's saying a lot from a health coach who will only eat exceptional sweets). She is a culinary artist and a secret treasure that I feel so lucky to have discovered. I love her cooking and her baking. I highly recommend stopping by and meeting this lovely lady who cooks with so much love and joy. Her food makes people smile. read more

I contacted the owner and had a rush request [5 days] to make a custom Halloween cake for my son's birthday party. I sent the lady a picture of the exact cake that I wanted and asked for a reasonable price, as the cake was small and only needed to feed about 25 people. She dropped the price from $300 to $196 [with tax]. I read her reviews and was expecting the cake to not only taste good, but look great as well, as this was a themed party. The cake looked like absolute shit when I went to pick it up. The design that I sent her, looked NOTHING like the cake I was given. It looked like she just slapped some fondant on there, didn't even smooth it out properly and the pumpkin was not even orange!!!! It wasn't even shaped like a pumpkin, it looked like a deflated ball. It was so POORLY presented I was in shock. If I hadn't paid a deposit, I would have NEVER taken that cake. It was so ugly and not what I was expecting at all. I was HIGHLY disappointed. Why would you take my request knowing that you weren't going to put your all into it? Why not just say no, you're too busy?? I will NEVER order from here again, and won't be sending any business this way. I am truly dissatisfied. read more

Stay AWAY !!!!!! usually don't leave reviews unless I have a horrible experience. This lady that took my order was extremely rude. She sound like she was in her mid or late 30s over the phone. She had the nastiest attitude very hood like. I had my friend call in to order a cake and she gave my friend a quote for $150 for 30 people $5 per person. Then I called AND she's says it's $180 same EXACT cake for 30 people. Then I told her how she gave my friend a better quote then she tried to change up the story and say that she was charging me for the cake topper which was a simple topper of a tiny baby. Then I asked her why she wasn't charging my friend 30 for the cake topper. When she realized she got caught giving me and my friend two different quote for same exact order and cake, she decided to completely ignore me and my calls. How unprofessional! !!! Then my friend called her and the baker lady decided to do it for 150. So when my friend called her back few minutes later, after deciding on the filling for me, the baker lady says she can't take the order anymore because she took an order from some else who apparently paid more for their order. I cannot believe how unprofessional she was to reject our order when we spend 2 days trying to get this cake ordered last minute she decides to not take our order over someone else's order. I am so upset, I had to now go to another bakery thankfully I found one on time before my date. read more