We came on a Monday evening for some ice cream and decided on Cremistry off of Haun. There was a big group ahead of us, but we went and placed our order. Lol and I think they had some issue with the registers. They only accepted cash, no card. And considering no one carries cash anymore let alone for a premium priced ice cream, it was pretty surprising to see that sign posted on their front door. We ordered a cookie monster and a cookie butter with cookie dough mixed in. It did take a while for them to get to our order since each ice cream had to be made to order. And when we received our ice cream, all the seats were taken by the group ahead of us lol so limited seating inside.. BUT there are benches and other tables and chair outside so we enjoyed our ice creams there. The flavors and the creamy-ness of ice cream were there. You do have to wait after you order and there are limited seatings even though there are plenty of parking spaces in the plaza. The price is premium and thr customer service wasn't terrible but it wasn't great either. Hopefully they'll fix that register soon! read more

See all

My first time here and wow! Such good ice cream! Met the new owners and they were very nice and the ice cream was so smooth and tasted great, they don't skimp on the toppings either! Will definitely go again! read more

It smells fantastic as you walk in. Clean and so many options! You can get a cake to go and they have non dairy options! Good service, moving pretty quick! read more

Creamistry - Making the ice cream magic! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

Bad customer service. The guy was so hatefully, no welcome greeting at all and ice cream is over priced. Ugh.. should have just gone to monster snow. I do not recommend coming here. I won't be coming here again. read more

The shop smelled like an Asian restaurant. No air conditioning. Didn't even order! Just disgusting. Walked out!

The store was empty. We placed our order. A family with 2 young children came in. One of the kids cried and said ewwww not this one and they walked out. That should have been a warning to us.... The food was old. I ordered a smore. It says toasted marshmallows but they were not. They're were disgusting and hard with NO toasting. The gram crackers were even more stale. My husband ordered the mangonada and it too had stale takies. We threw them away and will not be back. read more

Worst customer service iv ever experienced. Trash customer service & trash items. I asked to get a remake after realizing item had something my kid was allergic to. They said they would remake it but instead they tried to pick out the ingredient with fingers (without gloves) and serve it then had the audacity to be rude and disrespectful when we called them out about it after they promised to remake it from scratch. The worker Vu had a terrible attitude and no regard of customer service, was high tempered & verbally assaulted us. I wouldn't recommend this place or ever come back. 0 stars read more

Ice cream was good but the older man has horrible customer service! He needs to treat people better or not work there. read more

Creamistry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

This location is a must stop for my family when we are visiting my sister. We have always had great customer service and smooth ice cream. Yes, it is pricey but worth it for us. Since we aren't frequent visitors back home, we do tend to stop by often during our vacation. The store is small but clean. My favorite flavor is the dairy base with Nutella. You can't go wrong if you're a Nutella fan! read more

0 stars if allowed. By far the worst experience in any creamistry. The workers appear to be the owners. Bad day? I am sorry, I am done wasting anymore of my time writing about this place. Good luck if you want to see for yourself. Hopefully it is better than what I experience. No recollection of the ice cream over the grumpiness of what looked like the husband and wife duo working the shop. Ambiance ruined! Will not be stepping foot in this place again. read more

You can experience liquid nitrogen ice-cream making which is cool. Tastes good, would recommend to try once! Flavors are great. Great service, People are very helpful. Kids would love it. A little expensive but you get what you pay for. read more

Creamistry - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

I went today, for the 1st time my grandchildren wanted ice cream from here which they come often I ordered the Strawberry and cream cheese cake for my Son-in-laws Birthday as a surprise because my daughter says is his favorite! We sang Happy Birthday to him and cut his cake! And he says: "Is it just me my cake is burnt?!!!"... And yes, it sure was! How embarrassing! However, our ice cream with the children purchased there was excellent read more

Creamistry - Strawberry Cheesecake cake very burnt and a tad-bit dry! Ice cream was great! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

We tried this place for the first time and it was the best ice cream hands down that I've ever had! So creamy and delicious! And watching them make it was a fun treat for the kids and adults. If you have had this you should get some now before I eat it all! Another trip: chaos, teenagers without a clue how to work together, except for the two flirting with each other constantly slowing down the line with a store full of customers. If I were the owner the would both be terminated. read more

Creamistry - These two flirted constantly slowing down the line. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

I don't think the workers like to talk, and the ice cream wasn't good nor presentable

Not the best ice cream I've ever had. The prices are so expensive & it's because it's for liquid nitrogen. The customer service was horrible. No hi , hello, welcome in , what can I get for you . Just a stare down. read more

Came here for the first time to get a cake for my son...cake was delicious...whole family loved it and cake was perfect and looked perfect...5 stars for the cake but 3 stars for customer service...when me and my wife came in i had a question for the young girl working the counter...i asked her what flavor the cake was and if it was peanut free...i asked the girl 3 times and i swear it was uncomfortable because she just stared at me and my wife and just doesnt know anything ...their was another family in there and they were so friendly they even tried to help and answer the question for me...the husband even looked up at the menu and told me i feel thats it...thank you for the couple for the help and shame on the young girl working there...she didnt know what she was doing...and i think it was the owner A guy behind counter wasnt to friendly either...my advice is nice to customers...cake is good but overall customer service needs some help... read more

Went here on a whim and 100% do NOT regret it. This is the best Ice cream I've ever had in my life. So surprised it's dead, we've been the only foot traffic for about 25 minutes now. Love. We ordered the speculoos overload and omg this is the creamiest I've cream I've ever had. Hands down my new absolute favorite ice cream shop. So good I couldn't even wait to get a picture first TO DIE FOR !! read more

Creamistry - Speculoos overload - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

Slow service. Flavor is off. Feels like the ingredients should taste more refined like half and half, whipped creàm this taste like whole milk. They will only give you a spoon if you ask for one they are in such a rush. My recommendation is to NOT try this place. I know what nitrogen ice cream is supposed to taste like...rich, cream flavor on your palette this is just trashy. Thumbs down. read more

Missing a topping on my ice cream. Didn't realize until I got home and called to verify if they ran out or to at least be credited the cost of the topping for a future visit. I believe it was the owner who I spoke to which basically denied it and rather than work out some resolution, simply hung up on me. Will no longer support a business who isn't willing to address an issue that is so small and could have been easily resolved. My suggestion to the owner, check your cameras if you feel so strongly before discrediting a customer. Will never come back after that. read more

I enjoy their rewards program and these delectable and creamy ice cream creations very much. They always have accommodated my requests. Love the variety and options. My favorite base is the cream, and I never count the calories here. It just seems futile ;). read more

See all

I was wary of trying this location since the bad reviews were making me nervous but when I stood in line to order, I saw that an older Indian man would go around wiping the counters every so often after the ice cream is made. Yes, they can't wipe it down after every ice cream spots land on the counter, but I appreciated the effort. He even squeegeed the back counter and there was a running water basin area to wash the dirty ice cream scoops, so I'm not sure why everyone was complaining it was dirty. The tables are limited and yes, customers can be jerks and leave a huge mess on the tables, but when it wasn't so busy after a bit, the man came around to wipe down the tables, so again, people need to stop nitpicking that there's not someone wiping down everything every second. I got the dolenado and it was really good, it reminded me of the dole whips in a way. I was also comfortable ordering my kids ice cream with the organic cream. There's 3 bases, the premium, the organic and the vegan/sorbet base and that was what I got. This place is a bit pricey but it's pricey for the show and all Creamistry places are priced the same. If you can't afford it, don't bother coming and then complain about it later. Service was great, everyone was nice and my girls were greeted often when they stood there waiting for their ice cream. They said "thank you" as you're leaving and "welcome" when you walk in so I think they're doing a good job as far as being a grand opening. read more

See all

First time here. We really appreciated the dairy alternatives. I chose coconut, my wife chose cashew. The coconut base really accentuated the chocolate, like a Mounds bar. The ice cream itself has a very thick texture. Very friendly staff. We'll be back. read more

Creamistry - The nitrogen process. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

The owner is rude! They throw the ice cream on the counter. No common courtesy.

My boyfriend loves this place, I'm not as big of a fan. Cons: It always takes at least 20-35+ minutes to get an order, the staff are not very friendly and the man who appears to be the owner always acts very inconvenienced to help, the ice cream has a somewhat slimy texture (like Nutella) and it's expensive. Around ten dollars for the creations. Pros: it's a unique novelty experience, it's made right in front of you, lots of flavors and toppings to choose from, and they have lots of dairy free options. read more

Love creamistry. I love the super creamy texture of the fresh ice cream and the multitude of flavor options available. So glad one is still around-I go out of my way to stop by when craving ice cream. Nice staff, quick service. Definitely my favorite ice cream place. read more

Overall great service! Promptly greeted and welcomed. Not sure if it was a bad batch of boba but, the tapioca pearls seemed to be underdone and chewy. read more

First time trying Creamistry at the Menifee location. The ice cream was delicious and customer service was great.

I absolutely loved this stuff, I had the cookie monster signature flavor and it was amazing. They make the ice cream to order right in front of you! It's so awesome. read more

Creamistry - Creamistry ice cream machine! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

The best ice cream I have ever had! I live an hour away and every time I go I always stock up on ice cream!! It's so nice and creamy. The customer service is great! Looking forward to another hour drive! Definitely recommend!!!! read more

Creamistry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

Was in the neighborhood, decided to stop by and get Boba, all closest six dollars you got a small cup, which was just OK. I've had better Boba. read more

Creamistry - Sugar boba - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

The ice cream here is so good... best ever! The service is top notch. Danny is awesome always polite and engaging. read more

Creamistry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

I walked in the other day , first time wasn't greeted and I had to wait over 10 min to place my order for it to not even be worth it , it was the owner as well you'd think he'd have some customer service read more

Leslie is the woMan! Most businesses won't serve customers the very last minute before closing but I was really craving a banana nitro shake and she had no problem helping us out! Took our order for four items and provided too customer service! Thank you leslie! read more

Creamistry - Banana Nitro Milkshake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

Imagine complaining about ice cream and when employees not talking to you because they have to work. Just so many ungrateful people!

Best customer service around....which is hard to find. I ordered one of their newest sweet treats and was pretty impressed. The price is right and the employees were very engaging. I will definitely be returning in the near future. Thanks Creamistry!!!! Okay...so fast forward to 7/25/18... my experience was nothing less than a royal disaster. For an establishment that sells two servings of ice cream for $20...the OWNER and staff should be a bit more friendly. I asked if they could split my very large ice cream treat into two cups and the OWNER lied to me and said that the general manager does not allow this. I guess he forgot that I am a fellow restaurant owner in the area and we've chatted in the past about his struggling business in Menifee. The girl made my ice cream wrong for my kids and became angry at me and snatched it back when they began to cry because it wasn't made correctly. Please go somewhere else if you are looking for a sweet treat. The place was dirty, nasty and so were there attitudes! 7/20/20 Update - this place is now under new ownership and the service is 1000 times better. You can feel the positive energy upon entering...keep up the great work! As a restaurant owner, I truly appreciate this, especially during these tough times. We will be back! read more

It's ver dirty inside , ice cream does not taste the same either, taste weird and fake. Don't waste your time or money here.

I stopped on here thinking it was a frozen yogurt shop. I looked at the menu and was reluctant, but finally settled on a shake. It appeared that they actually made my ice cream on the spot and then took my fresh ice cream and turned it into a shake. At $8.50 it was pricey, but once I started drinking it - it was easily worth $8.50, if not more. I am going to treat myself to one every week from this point on. Easily best shakes in the area. read more

Omgggg I love this place! I ordered a scoop of the Cinnamon Toast Crunch and taro ice cream. My sister recommends getting the chocolate ice cream with brownie bites mixed in. Here's a picture of our order. read more

Creamistry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

See all

Love Creamisty! I was able to create my own ice cream and choose the flavors I wanted. I love banana ice cream and it's hard to find it so I was so glad they had it here, I made a Banana ice cream with walnuts, brownies, caramel, and fudge. It was so delicious the process does take a little long to make but I didn't mind it. The service was great as well, Will definitely be coming back ! read more

Creamistry - Create your own - Banana walnut flavor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

See all

This is the best ice cream ever, I crave it at least one a week. I get the regular with captain crunch.