Yay! I finally got to visit one of their stores. It's been a while since I last had a sample at one of the Yelp events I attended back in 2024 for World Mental Health Day. At first glance, the store is very bright, and the menu is pretty self-explanatory. A staff member greeted us right away, was eager to assist, and explained how everything worked. I ordered the salted caramel crunch and one of the mint specialties. When we arrived, there was only one couple ahead of us they ordered through the kiosk, while we placed our order with the associate. The ice cream-making process is so cool. it's a show all on its own. If you have kids, this is definitely a fun treat. The business looked well-kept and clean. I would recommend having another team member assisting with orders, though. During our visit, there was only one employee helping more than 15 people while we enjoyed our ice cream not to mention the mobile orders coming in and since it does take a minute to craft each order i think this would help customer satisfaction. they could us the help! parking is a breeze! read more

See all

Creamistry was just okay. For the price and the amount of time it takes to make the ice cream, I expected a lot more. The whole liquid nitrogen process feels more like a gimmick than anything else, and unfortunately it doesn't make up for what was pretty mid ice cream. We also tried the churros. They were a little tough, but the flavor was decent enough. The highlight of the experience was definitely the customer service. The staff was friendly, pleasant, and helpful throughout our visit. Great service, but the product itself didn't quite live up to the hype. read more

See all

Best Ice Cream shop i've been too. It was my first time going there, and Robyn was very helpful and had great customer service. I will definitely be coming again :)!!!! read more

Great experience and ice cream was awesome !!! The dry ice effect and the service was great too read more

Creamistry - This was some of the best ice cream I've tasted! Very creamy and the experience of the dry ice effect was awesome - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

Ssooooo I don't understand all the negative feedback for this place we had a great experience!! The place is a very unique ice cream experience Our creamistry creator was very nice he's in my pic but he was informative and friendly answered all of our questions about the process This place is small like a lot of your ice cream parlors these days but its ice cream ppl not a 5 course meal so I didn't mind The process is a unique one so it's not a scoop and go type of place so if THATS what your looking for... don't come ... But if you're interested in a unique experience to make your kids be in awe of science then DO go ! The ice cream was a very smooth texture unlike any store bought or scoop and go I've been it was worth the little wait and I'd definitely go back ! read more

Creamistry - How your ice cream is made - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

See all

Worker said it wasn't our order 15 minutes later had to ask her shins just for her to say it was when it was half melted. Would've just gotten stater bros pint ice creams read more

I havnt been here for a minute and can I say I absolutely love the icecream here. The service from the young man was awesome and he was so friendly. The place is clean and well organized which I love. Ill be back. read more

Creamistry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

See all

Ice cream was tastey. I like that you can choose the different dairy options based ok your dietary needs. Serviced lacked a bit. Need a little friendlier staff and the place is a little small on the inside. read more

Week late but forgot to mention. Situation was made right. They made a simple mistake but corrected and was amazingly surprised. Great taste as ever. Definitely coming back again. read more

See all

First time here and I asked for the matcha ice cream. It took 10-15 minutes for them to make it and it didn't taste like matcha. It didn't have much of a flavor. The person behind the register let me choose a different flavor so I went with Milk Coffee. It tasted better but not worth $7 and definitely not worth waiting another 10 minutes for some ice cream. I've been to other nitrogen ice cream shops and those didn't take as long and had better quality ingredients. read more

Creamistry - Matcha Dairy Based ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

Holt cow--WOW! I am NOT a fan of ice cream but this place has me converted! We came here by happy accident when the Krispy Kreme in the same shopping center wasn't open! Like closed for a few days?? So we tried Creamistry for the churros but once we got inside my daughter decided to get the Nutella flavored ice cream with gummy worms. Should've added some crushed oreos and called it a Cup of Dirt. But my daughter didn't want the rest. She ate about half. I am trying to be good because I am on a diet but she handed it to me so it wouldn't drip in the car. I couldn't help it. And. Took. One. Bite. That's all it took to have a life-changing experience with ice cream. I ate almost all of the rest of it. Called my husband who was at our house when we were about a mile away. Told him to come meet me downstairs because he had to try this ice cream. He was like really? Just got changed over and showered. I'm upstairs relaxing. I said yes. Do it. He balks when l give him the ice cream because there are only maybe 2 bites left. I said be grateful I left you ANY!! He sulked away while I went back outside to get the kids out of the car. Don't worry. It was running and they had the ac. We also live in a super safe neighborhood at the end of the cul-de-sac. Lol. But he actually came back outside while I was still getting the kids out JUST to tell me how amazingly delicious the ice cream was!! I don't even like Nutella! Or ice cream for that matter. But this is sinfully other-worldly. I cannot even begin to explain how creamy and dreamy the texture is. I also thought there was a location in San Diego or south OC. There isn't! Idk how l got so lucky to be able to accidentally happen upon this place but the food gods were smiling down on me that day. We will be making sure to bring all our out of town guests here to try it! So excited it's so close to us. Now to see if they'd do a Yelp event here for it to get more traction! I don't want this place leaving. It's such a wonderful addition to our area! read more

We stopped by Creamistry and had a great experience! I ordered the mango sorbet, and it was absolutely delicious refreshing, flavorful, and perfect for a warm day. read more

The first time we went to Creamistry, we had the best (nitro) milkshake we'd ever had--probably because the owner was there working. It was busy and took a very long wait (30-40 min probably) but it was delicious. We went the other day and it was very underwhelming. There were three girls working and the place was a disgusting mess. All the tables were gross that we didn't even want to sit. We'd ordered two nitro milkshakes and they talked about how they messed one of them up by forgetting to add in cookies and they talked about it in front of us like we weren't there. The girl broke up cookies and put them in the already done shake and one of the girls advised her it might not stay mixed probably because of how it was added in but they continued to give it to us rather than remake it properly. After we had our drinks, they did not taste any different than a standard milkshake. It was still good, but for an overpriced shake for the "nitro" effect, we'd expected it to taste as amazing as that first time. It was a massive disappointing experience from the time we walked into the door to leaving the place. We'll probably be going elsewhere for our ice cream, but hope this place will begin to treat their environment, product, and customers better. read more

Excellent customer service and the best ice cream. I love the Cap'n Crunch ice cream and the ice cream is amazing because it doesn't melt too fast and the cereal pieces stay crunchy. They're also generous with their toppings. I go out of my way to go here from Temecula! read more

Creamistry - Custom large Cap'n Crunch ice cream with generous sea salt caramel drizzle! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

Went to Creamistry for a sweet creamy snack and they did not disappoint! Raad was awesome and provided excellent customer service. Our NitroShake and filled churros were delish!! We will definitely be back! read more

First time here and had a great experience. Friendly staff, and very tasty ice cream! We ordered the unicorn one, strawberry bond, and elemint - all of which hit the spot! Chloe was very helpful with helping us order and made my husband's Elemint extra special for his birthday. Will definitely come back again. read more

Love this place now!! Experience was terrible with the previous owners, but the new owners seem to have cleaned this place up and gotten new great staff. Robyn is freakin' awesome. Love going there when she's there. Love the flavors and that it's hand made to order. Makes me feel fancy. ‍ Worth the wait! read more

2 stars because the employee was nice. Unfortunately I threw the ice cream away in front of the store because the employee was texting on her phone with her gloves on and proceeded to use those same gloved hands to crush up Oreos and waffle pieces to sprinkle over our ice cream. Extremely unsanitary. Didn't say anything because my daughter terrified of confrontation and conflict. read more

We went in for literally two scoops of ice cream in a cup, and it took 30 minutes. When we asked them at the 20 minute mark how much longer, they said 10 minutes, so we waited for 10. Still nothing. Asked for our money back and the girl we talked to made it seem like it was a big deal to get our money back for it. Crazy that it took so long for two scoops. My baby didn't even like the ice cream. read more

Went back today and got the cookie monster. Still delicious and I love seeing the nitrogen come out. Definitely worth the wait

I go here whenever I'm in the area, which unfortunately is rare. I don't want it to ever close down. It's literally the last creamistry in my area, and that's saying something cuz home is 2 hours away This is my favorite place to get Thai tea ice cream. The service is great. Hope this place lasts a long time. read more

Creamistry - Thai tea ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

I've been wanting to try this place for a few years now and finally went today-- what a mistake. We had some questions and the owner was extremely rude to us and treated us as though we were the most stupid humans to exist. When my wife asked what the difference was between the Large size and the Shake he said " the large is large and the shake is a shake". When asked to substitute one of the toppings he said no it wasn't possible because it was already mixed in, to then watch him sprinkle the sprinkles on top (not mixed in). The icecream itself did look good and appetizing, but the flavor of toppings were all stale. The marshmallows in mine could have cracked a tooth with how old they were. Absolutely disgusting. I'll never be back and I honestly hope this place closes so we can get something better. read more

Creamistry - Owners & menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

See all

The girl had me order from the kiosk because she was by herself and I didn't realize that I couldn't pick two flavors (half and half). I let her know that I didn't know that and she wouldn't remake the ice cream with the flavors I really wanted... I had never been to Creamistry before and it sort of ruined my experience. read more

Great spot for ice cream! The flavors were really good, fresh, creamy, and exactly what you want when you're craving something sweet. What stood out just as much was the customer service. The staff was friendly, patient, and made the whole experience even better. Definitely a place I'll be coming back to. read more

Loved my visit to Creamistry! The ice cream was delicious and made exactly how I wanted, with tons of great mix-in options. Huge shoutout to Raad -- he was incredibly nice, patient, and genuinely helpful, which made the experience even better. Great service and great dessert, I'll definitely be back! read more

Creamistry - Two milkshake drinks - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

Waited over 50 minutes for two ice creams. They were "short staffed" but kept filling UBER EATS orders pushing the orders in store back. The employees were nice but offered nothing for the extreme delay. read more

my first time I visited this ice cream shop and was extremely disappointed. The service was terrible; the OWNER / worker was incredibly rude and seemed bothered to even assist me. The ice cream itself was mediocre at best, and the overall atmosphere was unwelcoming...... I will not be returning and would advise others to avoid this place. There are better ice cream shops than this one ! read more

Best ice cream I've had creamy, fresh, and always hits the spot . Chloe makes the experience even better so friendly and welcoming!

Great service! Everyone should definitely try this, changes the ice cream game for me!

Wow, not coming back here again. Took 45 min for one over priced ice cream. Good flavor just not worth the wait.

This was my first time having creamistry.... It is so creamy and flavorful. It's ver sweet, but that's expected. My experience was so great the ice cream took a very long time bc it was SO busy Saturday night. But the workers were so kind still and very intentional about their work. Thank you will be back!!! read more

AMAZING customer service, there was a little issue with the nitrogen but the owners gave me a free ice cream on the house for the inconvinence. the ice cream itself is also absolutely delicious, this is one of my favorite shops to get matcha ice cream at. read more

They recently changed ownership and I honestly couldn't be happier with the way things have gone. I feel like the treat is/customers on a more personal/friendly note than most places. Great energy/ambiance! Great customer service! Love the communication and patience when asking questions about certain products! Love the ice cream here! read more

No greeting, no acknowledgment - I should have known right then and there to walk right out the door. Figured I would give it a try. Thought it was weird they were selling boba there, too. Ambiance is of misery and people who clearly hate their job and people. Similar to a cold hospital waiting room. There was no rating displayed on the window (noticed on the way out) Lady was coughing into her arm while she was making my ice cream. Hand written signs everywhere. TVs not in use, I'm assuming because they're too cheap to use the extra electricity. A giant nitrogen tank blocking the restrooms for their customers. Daughter hated her ice cream. She was visibly upset, no offer to replace it. My ice cream (coffee) was a 2/5. No flavor, crap consistency and super dense. Probably the worst ice cream I've had. Cookie Monster was mediocre. Overall experience was so inspiring just had to awake from the dead on Yelp just to tell people - DO NOT DO IT. for the love of God, go anywhere else. I am so salty right now, as I feel like I got ripped off. It was so expensive. I don't see this establishment being open for much longer. read more

Very nice people serving you here. And the drink (Peach Fruit Tea w/ Boba) is delicious. The place is very clean and has room for seating at least 6 people. They also serve ice cream cakes and waffles ice cream. Next time we're doing the waffles ice cream. read more

See all

I'll add a photo the next time I come. My husband and I stopped here on a toasty Menifee summer day. I see where people can say they were not overly excited with their custom service, however, I came here for ice cream and not hellos. With that being said, the service is fine but the ice cream is delicious! It is made to order so expect a little wait but no one needs to smile at me for my order to be correct, well priced and delicious! So smooth and fresh you can taste and feel the difference. We will go back and we did love this ice cream. Inside is a small waiting area to keep cool, but it's more of an order and take situation. read more

If you want some liquid nitrogen ice cream that takes forever to make and it tough as heck to scoop out but tastes delicious with terrible service, this is the place for you. Making the ice cream takes a long time, forewarned whenever you head in. It was tasty, but the ice cream is so cold that it's very difficult to scoop out. And because it is so cold it won't ease up anytime soon .....Maybe try the shakes. But that might be worse trying to drink anything out of a super cold shake overall. Also the owner is stone cold response wise, when you enter and hear him say we'll be with you whenever we can. Sets a great tone for this place. I would avoid this place unless you are willing to wait for it, between them being slow at processing and the ice cream taking a while to make. read more

Creamistry - Sea Salt Caramel Crunch - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California

Awesome service and great cream!! Love the dry freeze, fun to watch! Dude at the counter was hella nice 10/10

I really, really don't want to write this Review. I agree it's an agonizingly long process to make their Nitro infused ice cream. Long! I agree with most Yelp'ers about the staff being less than friendly. I recognize it's a family run business trying very hard. Yes, when you finally get the finished ice cream dish, it tastes good. But getting there. Grrrr read more

See all

Every time I come I get the birthday cake ice cream and it's always delicious!! I hope this location stays open! :) read more

Creamistry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menifee, California