I purchased a Groupon for the small family pizza package, which was a great value. Jonathon took my order and also made my pizza, I've got to say this guy is a great asset for Cousins Vinny's, he was totally professional and made one of the best pizzas I can remember having from Cousins Vinny's, kudos to Jonathon, GOOD JOB Cousin Vinny. T. Smith read more

Me and my boyfriend ordered them at like 3am one day because we were hungry and didn't feel like cooking. We were surprised they were open and hoping for some good pizza. But when we got it we were high key disappointed the pizza was just very dry and bland no cheese pull, barely any beef lol. Wouldn't get again read more

Cousin Vinny's Pizza - Cheese and ground beef pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Ohio

See all

Arrived ten minutes early to the estimated arrival time. Pizza was already dried out under the heat lamp. I don't know if they put sauce on the thing. And in all seriousness, I could not tell the difference between the cardboard box and crust. Threw it away made a sandwich. Lots of better pizza options. read more

Ordered pizza and it was really good. My only complaint was the delivery driver. I left a 9$ tip which was well above the normal. He insisted on talking about how he needed gas money and needing help and made me feel very uncomfortable. I didn't have cash so I tipped bigger on my card. Hope all is well. read more

Great food for cheap college kids but maybe not for families. I have had many of the pizzas and even the chicken Alfredo and all of it has been great. It tastes best after a few drinks of course. Mr. Cousin vinney even delivers to houses sometimes which makes it feel special. I would recommend this place highly. I also heard the wings are tasty read more

worst pizza I've had nothing good about it. my dog won't even eat this stuff. called and was told I don't know what to tell ya and I could have a credit for half what my order was. well no thank you please keep that. read more

Cousin Vinny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Ohio

IF UR GONNA READ ANY, READ THIS ONE!!!! I doordash, and I was in here the other day and not a SINGLE person was wearing gloves while handling or making the food, nor was ANY of the employees wearing hair masks and they were all men, especially with facial hair when I was in there that night. Never saw anyone wash their hands after handling money or their PHONES. the same thing they scroll on while on the toilet! Then touched the food! They took forever to get me my orders and was very rude overall. read more

Loved the food at first. Now they can't cook a pizza shouldn't be that hard. Won't come back to this establishment again

horrible service couldn't give me exact change and told me that they would bring it but didn't so i called again and ask them to bring it again sad moments read more

One star is one too many. The ONLY reasons to ever give your money to this garbage establishment are because it's open late, and you're starving. (It's late hours are its single redeeming feature, and, I imagine, the ONLY reason they're still in business.) And, upon serious reconsideration, you're far better off starving. I've given it more than enough chances. Food is always half-cooked, un-cut, soggy and disgusting. I've also dealt with the management in the past. They are rude and could not possibly care less about your experience or their product. And I mean, seriously, you have to actively try to mess up a pizza, which they consistently do. However, you can only call what they make "pizza" in the loosest possible sense. Don't waste your money on this inedible trash. You will regret it. read more

Best pizza in town. This is my go to every Saturday. Maria is always pleasant and upbeat. Even when I have found her working alone trying to keep up on orders she greets me by name with a smile. read more

Got delivery. Tracked the order. Even if it wasn't cold, it still tasted like corrugated with pizza sauce. Just a more expensive Little Caesars. read more

Great pizza, great price: $7.49 for a medium pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom. Hot and ready when they said it would be. Nice staff.

Always excellent pizza and ranch dressing to die for! This is a regular go-to for our family!

We googled cousin Vinny's and clicked on the link that said to order. Placed our order that took us through yelp, went in to pick it up and they said they didn't have our order. They said they couldn't take our order in person because they'd be "stealing" a customer from yelp and if we wanted our money back we'd have to contact yelp. We weren't able to get our food or place a new order. Completely unacceptable and poor service and this was our first try with cousin Vinny's. Will not be returning. read more

Bad ass pizza for a 3 am delivery! Everyone says they can't find no workers? Everyone closing early? Or closing all together? These people be popping out pizzas all night long? Just had a Meaty Hawaiian delivered at 0230 with a smile. read more

THE SLOWESTTTTTTTTTTT cousin vinny's of all time. if you want your pizza 3 hours after you order it then this might be the perfect place for you!!! dont forgot the COLD and SOGGY pizza you get after waiting almost 3 hours :))))))) this cousin vinny's is 10 minutes away from my house and they still manage to take a lifetime to get here. they also gave us the wrong drinks, and they were watered down. if i was able to rate this place 0 stars: I WOULD. i don't know why i continue to order their pizza even after i receive it super late all the time. by the time it gets here it isn't even worth what i'm supposed to pay. this cousin vinny's is the WORST and would 0/10 recommend!! read more

We've been enjoying their pizza and sandwiches for some time. Sometimes 2-3 times a week with all of our competing work schedules. But, over time I am watching the quality slide. Tonight we ordered an Italian sandwich along with our pizzas, as we have done several times. When I opened it I was astonished to find two paper thin slices of meat covered in vegetables. When I first discovered Vinny's about a year ago the Italian sandwich was solid, and I didn't have to look for the meat. Quite disappointed. Not sure if its local management or a franchise wide issue. We're hoping it was just a bad day. read more

Best pizza place!!! we never have a problem with them. food is always hot when u get ur food and the employees has the best customer service that u can ask for!!!! read more

Honestly, worst customer experience. I ordered a cheese pizza through DoorDash (yes, I am aware they are a separate company) and Cousin Vinny's Pizza made me the wrong pizza. I contacted Cousin Vinny's immediately and asked if I could just get a cheese pizza later on in the week for the wrong pizza. I was told this was a DoorDash issue. It's not. It's a Cousin Vinny's Pizza issue for not paying attention to detail of the simple cheese pizza order. I was then told I had to save the pizza and bring it back later to get a new one. The manager was not apologetic at all. I order from this company at least once a week and my work does as well. This is ridiculous and a lack of strong management. read more

The absolute best cheap pizza around! We prefer their cheese...not a big fan of the pepperoni they use and we usually get extra sauce. The bread sticks are great, too. read more

Cousin Vinny may not know what a "yute" is - but he makes a great pizza. If you are looking to try something new - give him a holler! Right now it's $5 for large 1-topping pizzas on Tuesdays - great time to give him a chance. You'll love it! read more

Amazing pizza and great customer service! My go to for pizza. The wings are really good too.

It's no wonder why 24% of their online reviews are 1 stars!!! Wish I could give 0 stars but by default I have to give at least 1 star. Absolutely terrible. Waited for 2 Almost 3 hours hours for my pizza to even be on the way although said my order would arrive in 50 minutes. Had a 60 dollar order and was told store manager was doing a "pee-on's" job in reference to being a delivery driver, by Mike whom he stated he was in charge at the time. Kept asking what HE could do every time told him I wanted to speak to a store manager. Was told on 3 different occasions the store manager would reach out to me to settle the issue as for when my pizza arrived it was completely ruined and COLD. Was told the box states there are no refunds but the box says "cash refunds" and does not specify no refund all in all only that there would not be any "cash" refunds. It's been a week and still no call or even an email. Will NEVER order from them again and highly suggest others beware of this so called "great priced pizza". Very sub par and will NEVER do business again. I hope someone higher up see's this and sees the type of business the Middletown Ohio Store is conducting. read more

Called ...guys talking order asking over and over the same question I repeated he heard and said I sounded far away but heard everything I said then hung up on me..out of town never use them again read more

Visiting from out of town and taking a chance I ordered 3 large pizzas for a family get together I must state the pizzas were excellent; the price was great and service was very friendly. I definitely would recommend this pizza store! read more

Not only is Cousin Vinny's Pizza a really great price, along with the super late night deliveries, I crave their pizza and it's amazing taste. For such s low price, the quality and flavor blows my mind. Cousin Vinny's delivers the satisfactory every time. Plus you get free cups with your meal. I have a collection. read more

Great selection of pizza. Open late and super friendly when I went to pick up. Would eat that food again.