Made a stop at the Pin Ball Garage for some midday fun and noticed someone eating potato skins, my favorite, and realized where they got them from since the Pinball Garage doesn't have a kitchen. I quickly proceeded to All8Up Pizza, beside the Pinball Garage. I ordered 4 potato skins. They have a choice of 2 or 4. I thought that was odd to only have those choices but once I received my order, I quickly realized why. Their skins are oversized. I had never seen potato skins that large. I could only eat 2. You can choose between standard bacon or chicken on top. I opted for the traditional bacon and it did not disappoint. What a delight. My son ordered a small sausage pizza that came out piping hot and fresh. He said it was delish and would order again. If you're wanting to ditch the big chain pizza shops and go local, All8Up is sure to quench your pizza hunger. read more

See all

Stopped in today because I knew I could get just a slice and it worked out perfectly. Of the choices I had one slice of their all meat pizza and it hit the spot. Not only was the pizza delicious but the sauce was enough to taste it and the cheese had a great pull. The meat which I believe was pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon was a perfect blend. I decided to dine in and service was excellent. If you are Looking for a quick lunch and an awesome meal stop into all8up and you will be pleased. read more

All8up Pizza - The all meat slice on the lunch menu. - Italian Near Me - Hamilton, Ohio

Add bar b q sauce. The sandwich was VERY DRY and the brisket was dry ans pulled pork was hard....so disappointed

The pizza was GREAT!!! We got 2 pizza's for dinner. Mine was gluten free and it was awesome! The crust was good and the amount of topping a cheese were great. My wife said her pizza was good too. You need to get their pizza it is good!!! read more

All8up Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hamilton, Ohio

The food for me was really good, but my wife's was overcooked for the same basic dish. Her noodles were hard and the cheese was over crusted. And what the heck is up with the cheap plastic forks that bend when attacking the cheese or meatballs? At least splurge for harder plastic forks. We like their food and usually get it through Pinball Garage, but that's not open for lunch on Tuesdays so went to the source. This is the first time my wife complained. She usually loves the spaghetti and meatballs. I got the Alfredo and am happy except for the forks. Also tea, I prefer home brewed unsweet tea instead of acid infested bottled tea. read more

I tried it for the 1st time and absolutely loved the pizza! I got a personal size with extra sauce, cheese, and jalapenos. The crust, sauce, and peppers were all good quality and I thoroughly enjoyed my lunch. Price point was fair too. If you all keep up the quality and don't cut look for short cuts you'll continue to do very well! I definitely plan on being back next time I'm in Hamilton. read more

All8up Pizza - Absolutely delicious personal pizza, i loved it! - Italian Near Me - Hamilton, Ohio

Looked forward to this pizza for months ordered it had it delivered at MBW and honestly, it was dry and terrible lacked ingredients. Last summer and previously best pizza. Hopefully just a fluke. Should have sent it back. So disappointed and pizza was not cheap read more

Wonderful service and fresh food. I'd definitely give this a chance to try the many dishes offered. Prices were reasonable with the quality,quantity served. They also have great hoagie options read more

All8up Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hamilton, Ohio

On April 12,2025 I finally made it to try their pizza and it was amazing . We tried the cheese, a hot honey Hawaiian and my favorite the meat lovers with extra cheese ( and the cheese was amazing like we got in the 80's and 90's) even with all the cheese my crust was delicious and not doughy at all. I can say it is by far my new favorite pizza place by far. I would have posted pics but the pizzas were eaten in record time by the 6 of us The toppings are definitely great quality read more

All8up is a great place to eat at. Their calzones, pizzas, steak sandwiches, salads are all so good! Honestly anything you order will be good and exactly how you ordered it. They have a nice dining room and also provide pick up and delivery. They also do so much for the community of Hamilton and it's great to support a business like this. read more

Good little pizza place that is in operation with the Pinball Garage. Pizza was certainly good. I would get this again. read more

All8up Pizza - Calzones - Italian Near Me - Hamilton, Ohio

See all

This was super low key, pizza was tasty, I'd give it a 7/10. The potato skins were 11/10. Prices were affordable and service was quick. On a bonus note I enjoyed that they were playing Christian Music in the restaurant. read more

See all

I really don't know why people love this place. Food was mediocre at best. Service was so slow on a Friday night. We waited an hour for our food. I hope they make it but I'm doubtful. read more

Wonderful service even better pizza Had a good time had the chicken pizza was very yummy would recommend and that's saying something because I'm picky read more

Happy Pi Day!!! I wanted to go someplace I'd never been before to celebrate Pi Day. All8up was a great choice!!! (Pat Pat Pat) It's a small location uptown Hamilton, a hidden gem! The staff was fantastic. Very nice and attentive. We ordered a little of everything. Of course a pizza; a small meat (pepperoni, sausage, and bacon) pizza. It was perfectly cooked. Crispy dough, just enough cheese. Fantastic! The waitress told us they are known for their calzones so we got a Italian chicken, mushroom, and tomato. That was wonderful too. Just the right amount of dough to filling ratio. Their side salad was yummy too and they give you the perfect amount of dressing for the size of salad. We ordered garlic bread with cheese and yum!!!! Their food is absolutely amazing. They know how to do pizza and calzones! I will be back!!! read more

See all

Perhaps the best pizza in town and top 2 in all of Butler County and I will fight someone on that. The service is amazing and the people that run it are sharp business folks that k ow how to get to their target demographic. The Hamilton mementos and the advertising of other local businesses is a nice touch, i other words, the ambiance is flawless. read more

Love this place salads, sandwiches are yummy. We order often. Nice looking cal place. read more

All8up Pizza - a slice of pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - Hamilton, Ohio

See all

Ordered a salad and large pep with banana peppers. Crust slightly burnt on bottom (perfect). Really good.

ordered delivery over 90.00 worth for delivery. delivery scheduled for 5:30. 6:10 still no food. call. get blown off the did not care at all sorry i left a 20$ tip. will not call them again after ordering 100$ worth of food for weeks. read more

We like all 8 up, and we've been eating there before it changed hands. We usually go through the pinball garage, so I can speak to the service. I've seen the inside of the building and the ambiance is much nicer than it used to be. I like to get the calzone; they are very yummy. My son gets a cheese pizza. read more

Great Pizza and hoagies! I he been trying every local owned pizza joints around Hamilton an this one is very good.

This is a great local pizza shop.if you've never had all 8 up I heavily suggest trying it. (you can also play classic pinball and order all 8 up next door at pinball garage) read more

Pizza is very good. Service was great. Dining area is adequate. Street parking only in a downtown area, but usually not an issue at night. I will visit again! read more

This place will take you back to a simpler (and better) time! The intimate diner experience and personal attention of a locally-owned mom & pop shop is hard to find in a time of fast food, corporate franchises and prepackaged meals. The menu is simple, the food is handmade and the speed of delivery is surprisingly fast for the top quality. Eat in, carry out or delivery-you'll get the same experience! Well done, Kat & crew! Definitely recommend. read more

All8up Pizza - The Bothast-Revalee crew - Italian Near Me - Hamilton, Ohio

See all

I'll spare you the white girl blog post. Better than all the other local joints... Karens, Milillos, Richards and Cassanos. Only real competition is Pizza Chef and Gina's, but I'd put this one above in overall flavor. read more

All8up Pizza - Pepp, onion, bacon, mushroom - Italian Near Me - Hamilton, Ohio

Really good garlic breadsticks and pizza is honestly like 4/5 just because it could use a tinyyy bit more spice in the sauce. Would like to see fountain drinks also just because drinking from a can is really bad for your teeth. It washes over your whole mouth vs a straw.(my dentist told me this) read more

Color me impressed! I'm a sad excuse for an American, as I'm not someone that would list pizza as my favorite food. Don't get me wrong, it's delicious, it's just that I can easily go without. But every now and then I get a hankering and that's been difficult since I decided to go vegan for ethical and health reasons a year ago. I love to support local businesses, but Hamilton is late to the vegan train and I don't really have options here, leaving me to make a drive to Cincinnati for some real tasty cruelty-free grub. Tonight, I had the rare "EAT PIZZA IMMEDIATELY" voice in my head, so I just looked up the menu for ALL8UP. Wonder if I could just do a pizza sans cheese and butter? I contacted them about their dough and - sure enough - it was free of any dairy. Ace! I ended up ordering a large pizza, no cheese, no butter on the crust and then selected my toppings: banana pepper, mushroom, spinach and onion. About 40 minutes later, the pizza was in my possession and I was truly struck by the flavor. Holy Toledo! IT WAS DELICIOUS! Without cheese, the striking savory flavor of the pizza sauce really comes through and is much, much more enjoyable. The toppings tasted fresh and the spinach was baked just perfectly. The crust was soft in the middle with a wonderful crunch around the outside. My boyfriend and I polished off the entire thing and raved about how absolutely amazing it was. For anyone wanting to try something totally new, try a pizza without cheese, it completely changes the game. I'll be back to ALL8UP - no question. read more

All8up Pizza - The pizza in question. - Italian Near Me - Hamilton, Ohio

Excellent pizza we had 2 large pies absolutely loaded with fresh toppings. Free delivery is a nice bonus if you live in Hamilton. Prices were very reasonable also read more

Got a large cheese and mushroom pizza and there was nothing special about it. It was greasy and the sauce was bland. It did had plenty of cheese. Maybe they had an off night or my expectations were too high based on the reviews. Either way, very average pizza. read more

hubby just ran in to grab us a slice of pepperoni pizza each. it was $3 per slice. the pizza is the only thing we've tried. to both of us we thought it tasted exactly like frozen pizza. it reminded me of the pizzas called mama rosa's i believe they were called? we used to get from the store growing up. i can't speak as to how the other items taste but the pizza was not favored by us in the least. still willing to give other items a try though. read more

We stumbled across this pizza place and it was amazing! I ordered a pepperoni, bacon and banana pepper calzone. It was perfectly baked and tasted homemade! I will definitely be back! read more

Love this place! Great service, great food and the prices can't be beat. Added bonus, it is owned by a local family!

Always good neighborhood pizza and calzones eat here every time in Hamilton. Will be back again.

Are there for the first time,had a Calzone,very very good. The crust was excellent ,pepperoni very tasty. I will say this was the best Calzone. I cannot attest to the decor since we couldn't go inside but I can say the food is delicious. My husband stated,"We will be going back." read more

Ordered for first time today. I was pleasantly surprised they delivered and found address which was surprising because no other place can. Food was delicious and very well priced. New customer for life. 100% A+++ read more

Our last night in Hamilton. The five of us wanted to get something near our Marriott. This place had great reviews. They did not disappoint. The place is not fancy. It's all about the food here. Among us, we ordered pizzas, calzones, salads and cheesy bread. All were exceptional. Generous toppings. I've never had a more complete and filling 9" pizza in my life. I don't think they could have put more cheese on it. I started with a small house salad and it was fantastic. Maybe the best Italian antipasto salad I've ever had. Service was really friendly. Treated us like family. Only drawback is the lack of alcohol in any form. read more

Great family business. Italian sub is outstanding! Generous toppings on pizza; meatballs are delicious! Definitely recommend.

Lots of pizza choices around town, so broke from the usual suspects and was presently surprised. I ordered a variety for takeout. Pizza, calzone, Chicken hoagie and a salad. All were still fresh when I arrived home. Chicken on the hoagie was a seasoned grilled breast fillet and it was good. read more

I thought there pizza was gross, when we walked in they were not pleasant at all, the pizza was pricey. We ordered 3 large pizzas and they didn't taste all that great, I don't think anything's made from scratch the tomato sauce was bland. When this place originally opened we ordered from there it was pretty good, we went back years later completely different. read more

Never heard of the place until searching the internet for a quick bit of delivery. I ordered two hoagies, antipasto salad and garlic bread came to about $20. all of those items arrived to my house at proper temps. Chilled crisp lettuce and warm hoagies I hate when I get delivered warm salad or cold pizza. Everything was better than expected and delivery was free!!!! Plus my food arrived before the quoted time they gave. Lady who took my order over the phone was pleasant and delivery driver was kind. I will definitely be ordering again soon and trying out more menu items. read more