The Mexican burger was absolutely delicious, avocados, peppers, grilled onions, tons of flavor!…read moreEach dish is served with a few pieces of fruit as well. The service was prompt and friendly, just enough seating inside for lunch hour on a weekend. They are closed for dinner hours on Saturdays so keep it in mind. I would gladly come back here again when I'm out on the island and try some of the other dishes. They also advertise several specials like Taco Tuesdays and drink specials throughout the week which really make a it a great value for the price! I personally liked the vintage stye airstream diner vibe interior.

I came here with high hopes & expectations,especially since all I kept seeing was great…read morereviews,however I was pretty dissatisfied with food and service. The food looked appetizing but it turned out to be lacking in flavor. It was unfortunate since I really wanted to find a place reminiscent to home cooked meals We went on a weekend and the wait was about 30 mins, space is small or overcrowded. We sat in a table where we constantly had to move around to make space for staff to get through and our waiter seemed annoyed throughout the experience. Overall the food was not what I expected nor was the service.

First time there a year ago and the food was fantastic... Not sure if the chef changed but they got…read morereally created with certain items and it was a bit lack luster sadly. Orders a chorizo and eggs dish and the chorizo was made it's this sloppy hash like things that tasted nothing like any chorizo I ever had. Staff is still friendly and the space is still adorable but just stick to the regular solid breakfast menu items that are not messed with on the menu.

Came here for breakfast on a Thursday. The waitress was friendly. The restaurant wasn't too busy…read more The food did take a while to come out. I had eggs with corn beef hash. It was good. Very standard. Hubby got a skillet. The flank steak was seasoned very well. We wish it was cut up into slightly smaller size. He wished his egg was a little more under cooked. By the time he got his dish the yolk was no longer runny. Overall the meal was good and we would come back if we were in the area.

Just moved from Queens to Middle Island. ​I ordered the appetizer of "6 Chicken Wings with French…read moreFries" for $11.75. I don't think you are getting 6 wings; it looks like they took only two chicken wings and cut them into three pieces each to make up the count. ​This portion size, combined with the nearly twelve dollar price tag, is shocking. It certainly gives the impression that Middle Island is catering to very rich people! The value here is incredibly poor compared to what I'm used to. ​I expected better for the price.

Best Cheese wontons ! They have Bourbon chicken... something…read moredifferent ... all other dishes I've had have been good. Not crazy about the boneless ribs.

Great local diner, does basics well and the specials are well special!…read moreHad a lox Benedict special and hungry man. It could have fed 3 or 4 people. Get their grits, it's very good. Pancakes are tasty too.

Decided to stop here while in the area who doesn't love a good diner. I had my father-in-law, his…read morebrother and sister in law, and my son with us. Interior was bright and decorated w pics of Greece small space but they made good use w tables and booths. No one was on top of each other and the waitstaff could move easily around. Our waitress was considerate of w us considering the menu being in the larger size and lots of different choices it took us time to decide what to eat. My fil had a western omelet w home fries He liked the portion and said it tasted great. He loved that you had jellies for the extra toast on the table w a variety of choices. My son had your egg burger and like the way the egg and burger came out just like ordered medium well. He liked the fries too. They were crispy and hot. My aunt and uncle both ordered the BLT w mayo on the side. They like that the waitress asked. The said the sandwich tasted good and the bread was toasted well. I had a special. A panini of grilled chicken spinach roasted pepper and fresh mozzarella. I like the flavors the spinach was steam great and they had a good portion size. Most places I've had spinach on a sandwich it not enough for each bite not this one was. My only critique in the negative was that the bread used became soggy when I was taking a break to eat they well done delicious fries. I shared w others who also liked them. My lunch came w soup although she first brought me lemon rice soup. I corrected her by saying is this the lentil she took it back and I watched her pore it back into the soup container. And although that's not something I would do and I know I didn't touch it but that should not have been done in my eyes. The lentil did come out and it was delicious lentil not over cooked broth had good flavor. Only other mistake was my drink I ordered a Diet Coke and I believe the first one was a mix of diet and ice tea once I let our waitress know she fixed the order. My son pointed out that they only have another drink for serving for free. I also tried the water which was as good, and if you've read other of my reviews I am a water snob so this one passed with flying colors.

I love coming here with my family for brunch. Our favorite go tos are the eggs your way and we are…read moreobsessed with the avocado fries. Food is always very delicious no matter what you order. Our favorite thing to get are the iced coffees! They always have unique flavors that are named after characters from a show or movie! You are also able to customize your latte with up to three flavors. Everyone that works here is friendly and the service has never been an issue for us. I prefer this location to the stony brook one, I feel like it's more low key. We always have a great time here!

Lots of parking, nice and clean inside, interesting decor…read more The menu offers a nice selection of atypical diner/breakfast fare with an almost overwhelming selection of coffee, cocoa, and seasonal cocktails. You'll feel like you want to try everything. We had the pancake quesadillas, short rib sandwich, a bacon cheeseburger (one of the things I have to get when trying a new place, as kind of a gauge. It was pretty good), and the duck hash with eggs over medium. The food came out in a timely fashion, and was fantastic. I ate all of my duck hash and the burger #thisiswhyimfat. The others in my party took home leftovers because they always do. I'd go back again, even though this isn't close to me. I'd even go to the one further out East if I can count on the same experience.

Just had lunch there with my mom and my son. Food was amazing as per usual. I've been a waitress…read moreand in the service industry for 10 years and our waitress here absolutely sucked. Waitress forgot to bring our coffee had to ask a different server for it, had to ask bus girl for a box. Wasn't busy so no excuse for only coming to our table 3 times.

This was our first time at Toast in Port Jefferson. We did the on line waiting and it was…read moreperfect-we arrived and got a seat in 10/15 minutes. That was awesome considering it was Easter Sunday. Our waitress was Antoinette. In light of the crowd she handled the order very well. Thumbs up to her. The food was amazing especially the cinnamon bun pancakes. I would say the potatoes were a bit on the salty side but everything else was great. We will be back and hands down the best breakfast place I have been at in awhile.

Seeing a lot of reviews of this place are negative within the last year or two I thought maybe I…read moreshould write a more current one. I will admit a lot of those negative reviews I could agree with around those times because I have been getting bagels from here for at least the last ten years and there were issues. In 2021 I have noticed a huge difference in their sandwiches and bagels. I usually get bacon on a roll with lettuce and Mayo. The bacon has been cool perfect and there's always been plenty of bacon. At one point I used to order extra because there seemed to not be much on the roll but now within this last year there's been more than enough. My wife usually gets a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel and those have been great as well. One time this year we tried a place everyone raves about closer to our house and we couldn't have been more disgusted so I'll never get a BEC from anywhere else than bagels 101. My son loves the bagels and he couldn't believe how big his strawberry bagel was when he took it out of the bag. My only 1 thing I did not like which is why I can't give it 5 stars is their salads like macaroni and potato salad. Whoever's making it now needs to find a new recipe. The macaroni salad being the worst. Evaporated milk, Mayo, salt and pepper, sugar maybe a little vinegar is all macaroni salad needs. But the most important things are the bagels and they are great!

after seeing all the silly commercials on streaming tv for this place i figured id try it out. went…read moreto one in Yaphank this morning, ( Sunday, 5/17) there were 3-4 people in it, i ordered 2 everything bagels with nothing on them and one plain bagel with lox spread, also order a regular coffee, a touch of milk and no sugar, this took 25 minutes to get, im an easy person tho please but that was crazy, AND the cost of just under$14? once i got my order i went back to my car as was about to travel i opened the bag for the bagel with lox and found it had an inch thick slab of cream cheese and no lox to speak of, a few little pieces, i bout it for the lox actually, as that wasn't bad enough when i tried the coffee it tasted like warm milk. i stopped at 7/11, tossed the expensive cup of coffee in the garbage and got my usual from 7/11 lastly they advertise a one free bagel which didn't get but that really didnt bother me, ALL I CAN SAY IS ID NEVER GO BACK

Old-fashioned, cozy diner with yummy Greek specialties. One of our favorites for breakfast or…read morebrunch.

Good food. Breakfast lunch and dinner time are good times to stop by. The service is friendly. The…read moreambience is cozy.

I had previously stopped by Greek Island Diner to pick up soup for a sick friend, and after that…read moreexperience, we decided to come back for an early Friday dinner. Wow, we were seriously impressed. Parking was easy with plenty of space, the diner itself was spotless, and the interior was bright and welcoming. The staff was friendly from the moment we walked in, and we were seated right away with no wait. Edgar took care of us and was fantastic. He was super friendly, attentive, and genuinely welcoming (and yes, "took care of us" feels more accurate than "waited on us"). We started with two soups: beef barley and lentil. Both were absolutely delicious, comforting, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Of course, I had to try the mozzarella sticks, and they did not disappoint. Perfectly cooked, and the marinara sauce was thick, tasty, and not watery at all. For our entrees, we ordered the Philly cheesesteak melt and a beef/gyro panini. The portions were generous, and the flavor was even better than expected. Even when we were full halfway through, we still wanted to keep eating because they were just that good. We couldn't leave without dessert after walking past the display on the way in which showed so many options. We went with the chocolate layer cake, and holy moly. The slice was massive (looked like half a cake) and absolutely amazing. We couldn't finish it, probably should've skipped the fries , but it was hands down one of the best cakes we've had in a long time. Overall, an excellent diner experience from start to finish. We'll definitely be back and will likely become regulars. It's that good.

A lot of gluten free options available for those who are on a restricted gluten free diet.read more

Amazing food & service! Hidden gem! Can't wait to come back…read more Only open for breakfast and lunch. Very small cafe with a few tables, counter service too. Like an old fashioned coffee shop. Kinda place you can come alone or maybe with a friend or 2. Definitely not a group spot. It's tiny. Love watching the small planes take off and land. Service was fast & friendly. Portions are very generous and priced right. Loved everything about this place!

Very cute little cafe with courteous and friendly service. I…read morehad 2 eggs over easy and french toast- was hoping for the really fat sausages, but it was thick long links, which wasn't bad. Maybe friend had the burger which she said they got the medium right, unlike many places. Actual meat hand shaped and tasty. We enjoyed our time here.