That was the worst chili I've ever had in my life. It didn't even qualify as chili. you would think a place like that would make homemade chili from scratch. read more

Traveling is always a challenge to find good food that doesn't impede the schedule. This fit the bill perfectly. Easy on off for us from the highway and large enough to handle a truck and trailer. The fixings are ready to go and you choose your options cafeteria style. Two chili dogs with cheese and a drink for under $10 and back on the road. read more

Coney I-Lander - 2 chili dogs - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Love this Hot Dog stand, I drive over from Roger's, AR to enjoy 4 hot dogs with chili and cheese. Plus onions!!!!

Coney I-Lander isn't pretty, but damn if it isn't good!! The chili on the coneys is Cincinnati style, so there is a cinnamon flavor to it and no beans. Every time I'm back in Tulsa I make a point of going every Thursday and getting three cheese coneys because they are just that good. read more

Traditionally a great meal. Although I like their hotdogs, love the tamales even more. Either way get their excellent chilli on either one.

I'm not sure how many Coney I-landers there are in Tulsa, but the one I go to most often is the one on South Peoria in Brookside. It's always clean and well-maintained... even the sparse bathroom. 3-Cheese Coneys with onions do it for me. Hey, we're not counting calories, OK? So that's a grilled hot dog on a soft roll with chili, mustard, diced onion and a huge pile of shredded cheddar cheese. Oh yeah baby! That's all I get here. I love my Coneys. read more

See all

Been coming here since I was 10 and I'm now 21, I genuinely haven't had a bad experience ever and if you want great food for a reasonable price then this is the place to go read more

Very good for cheap hot dogs. Just wish the workers had even a slight sense of urgency. Would recommend if you have 45 minutes to sit and stare at the workers while they talk amongst each other read more

I've been eating lunch here off and on at this location for years. Recently I was working in the area and needed some tasty quick lunches. The coneys are spot on for taste, the service is always nice and the tables are always promptly cleaned. There are a lot of places in that area for lunch and I've been to them all but Coney Island is my first choice for quick tasty food. read more

Coney I-Lander - Cheese Coney - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

A Tulsa classic! I recommend getting one (or several) cheese coneys with everything. Service is quick, friendly, and the seating area is pretty clean at this location. read more

Coney I-Lander - Cheese Coney - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

This place rocks!!! Not because of the best food ever but because of the food, good customer service, and the locals working here. I ate Coney I-Lander since I was kid, always loved it....well, in my 20's, I stopped eating pork. Hard transition but even harder giving up "coneys". No matter how well I do at home, can't match the authentic taste. On one family trip to Coney I-Lander (downtown Tulsa location), I was just gone order a frito pie (insert sad emoji), well I guess the guy behind the counter saw it in my face. I told him my dilemma and he said no biggie, just bring your own dog and we will put it on a fresh steamed bun and top it off (whether its chicken, beef , or veggie dog - as they only serve one kind of hot dog and its pork). I was elated!!! Ever since, I have been stopping by with my own dogs at every location and they have never said no!!!! So, what makes this place special? They use steamed buns that are never hard or stale. The chili they use is slightly sweet and not too meaty or thick. The onions are chopped so fine, you think its a part of the chili. AND....the best part - the cheese!!! very finely shredded and in abundance...yeeessssss!!! Each time I walk in, the smell is like amazing. I immediately become hungry. The fact that I have traveled the world and only found them in Tulsa makes it that much more of a treat. I can't explain it to folks who haven't tried it. It is like Tulsa's own little magic. Don't visit Tulsa without stopping at one of their many locations where the people are nice and friendly. read more

See all

It's our Saturday go-to... and even moreso after an evening of overindulgence! Let's face it, coneys are the best hangover cure. But I like them other times too - they make a great quick lunch or mid day snack. Coneys, frito pies, 3-4 way spaghetti options - several ways to enjoy their unique chili, onions, cheese, and your favorite hot sauce. I usually get my coneys without cheese - just stopped years ago for no good reason. Now load my tamale up with cheese! Service is always friendly, quick, and they are a good value. Try these little gems for a nice surprise. read more

Coney I-Lander - My go to - 3 regulars, no cheese. - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Great service unique place with a unique menu. I got one of everything but I would recommend keeping towards the Coney dogs they were much better than the other two items I got. Solid over all nothing out of this world. read more

See all

The best tasting coneys I've ever had. Service is always fast and respectful. The price is still affordable after all these years (since 1926)! read more

When I think of landmark places to eat in Tulsa, this is on my list. The reason for that is because it's tasty as f*ck. I came to this one for the first time in 1979. Since then, it's stayed the same. It's never changed. Well, except for the drink machine. That's changed. I'm sure there is such a thing as an addiction to coneys, so be careful. Don't fly too close to the coney sun, man. read more

Coney I-Lander - Check out these tasty-ass coneys. - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

can't go wrong with coneys and a strawberry pop. The chili was warm and i asked for extra mustard. good quick meal if you're not watching your figure lol read more

Coney I-Lander - 3 coneys with everything no onions - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

If you're a hot dog fan then you are in for a treat! Coney I-Lander has been around in Tulsa since the 1920's and once you try their food you will figure out why. This location is clean, associates are friendly and the prices are so SUPER affordable. My dad and I had lunch there with drinks and the total cost was $14 can't beat that for lunch! I got 3 plain hotdogs with ketchup and mustard. I'm not a big chilli and cheese lover but I guarantee you that 95% of the people that come in are and swear by it, so order them that way! Their buns they use for are so fresh and soft it's like you're eating air when you bite into one. The meat they use is delicious it definitely doesn't taste like any other hot dog you get anywhere else. They have chip options such as lays or Cheetos just your typical chips and all the regular soda and tea options. The highlight of this chain is their hot dogs. Amazing. I always get 3 because they are tiny. Even though I probably could eat 4 and be a piggy. read more

Coney I-Lander - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

My husband has to have a coney when we are going through Tulsa. The buns were different but OK. They were out of Dr. Pepper; no other soda will do. read more

My favorite Coney restaurant in America. However, the new young man behind the counter was a little shy w/ the chili. Won't stop my return, we all come for the chili tho. read more

Good coneys and good service. They know what they are doing. I really enjoy their tamales as well,

I love coming here with my family when we are in town!! We play no games when it comes to coneys lol. The service and atmosphere = 10/10. & it's affordable for everyone. Check them out.. I promise you'll be happy that you did :) read more

Coney I-Lander - Cheese coney(mustard, chili, onions and chz) - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Great coney dogs, reminds of the skyline chili dogs I grew up eating. The chili is unique and tasty, Love it!

We love this place!!!!! The dogs are simple and easy to eat and those buns are so soft and loveable!!!! The chili has a hint of curry that just kind of kicks you in the mouth announcing its arrival LOL totally worth the trip. read more

Sorry guys, I guess I didn't grow up on this so it doesn't hold a special place in my heart. It really lacked flavor for me. aaaand that doesn't make sense because it's a hot dog, chili, onions, and CHEESE! All of those are amazing, especially put together! but no thank you... quite bland... read more

Coney I-Lander - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

I want a coney for my honeeey....I used to date a lady who could really suck these puppies down so within that context I enjoyed a trip to the I-LAND. The hotdog is one of those foods that varies by region in some ways similar to BBQ. I'm a Georgia boy who moved to Carolina and then Oklahoma. I've eaten less BBQ and hotdogs since moving to Oklahoma than any other food group. I've tried to really get excited about eating a coney but I prefer the "scrambled dogs" of Georgia or the chilli and slaw dogs of Carolina. I recently learned that Coney I-lander is a native of Tulsa and a true tradition rather than a Yankee Franchise. Even when armed with that incentive I'm able to drive by and let the dogs bark on. read more

Coney I-Lander - Fooling folks since 1926 - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

The best part about this place is the staff. They are the absolute best. If you go in there in a bad mood, you will leave feeling much better. Their employees appear truly happy to work there, which reflects in their service and quality read more

Ordered lunch for everyone at work, and all 28 hotdogs were burnt to a crisp on one side. This was a delivery order through this app, so I had no way of inspecting the order before leaving the restaurant. read more

Coney Islander... Why don't you have French fries? Why have I only in the couple times I have been here my coney hasn't been hot but rather 'almost warm.' Why when I took one home to heat up more turned hard as a rock? Until I hear about some of these remedies, I won't know what to do with my thoughts on this Tulsa staple but keep it at 2 stars. Ps- your staff is really nice! read more

The perfect coney. Mustard, Chili, Cheese and Onion for me please. The chili is not runny. It stays perfectly on the bun. Cheese is finely grated. Add some cayenne pepper on top and you have the perfect dog. These haven't changed in over 30 years. Thank you Coney Island! read more

Best diarrhea of my life. Within 30 minutes of 3 coneys I was running for the toilet and it flowed like the Mississippi. Must have if you are in Tulsa. Avoid if you are about to have sex... Trust me. read more

What more can I say about Coney I-Lander coneys that hasn't already been said? They're quite simply the best tasting hot dogs that I've ever had with no exception. My wife disagrees. The last time we came here together she took one bite of her Frito pie and said, "remind me next time that I don't like their chili." It took everything in me to not call a divorce lawyer then and there. The one downside of this location is that it's always way too cold inside, no matter what time of day/year. Otherwise it's conveniently located on Brookside, clean, and staffed with very friendly employees. read more

Coney I-Lander - Missing one because I got excited. #prematuremastication - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Absolutely the best coneys. It's a semi-recent discovery for me (maybe 4 years). The steamed buns, sweet chili, and fine shredded cheese make for a satisfying meal. They are small, but two fills me up. And at less than $1.50 each, it's a pretty good deal. Don't forget the cayenne. read more

Coney I-Lander - Always add the cayenne pepper. - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Dang, I love me some Coney I-Lander!! Don't be confused by the many other places that have the same sounding name. They don't have the sign with the mixed up letters and they don't have the best coneys. I have been going here since I was a little one. So, it's possible I'm just hooked because it's what I know, but I don't thinks so. Their cheese coney's have the same flavor they have always had. Amazing! If you are wanting coney's, then this is the place. read more

This is by far the most disgusting coney I've ever had. Wish I would've just went a block down to Sonic. Lady had her mask under her chin, they were serving chili out of a white bin bucket . It looked disgusting behind the counter. I knew it was a bad idea when I walked in but I figured if they've been in business since 1926 it must be good but it was gross. My husband said the chili tasted musty. The one star is only because I couldn't post without it. Also whoever has been rating this place high should get their taste buds checked. I strongly don't recommend. read more

Today's lunch was fighting my childhood memories, as I've been back in Tulsa over 15 years and I think I've only been one other time. The people that work there are GREAT. You'll rarely find a friendlier group. The food itself doesn't quite live up to my memories. I seem to recall steamed buns that were impossibly soft. These weren't hard, but they didn't have the "chewing is almost optional" experience I was expecting. Also, I was surprised that it needed some heat. Maybe I'm getting old, but I seem to recall these things never needed a boost of anything. Fortunately, I remembered Paul P's suggestion to sprinkle some of that cayenne pepper on it (which is not something I would have tried) and it seemed to fill in the flavor gaps nicely (although now I'm eating yogurt because the cayenne is burning my mouth!). So, it's three stars for food, five stars for staff. I'm not disappointed that I went, but I'm curious to try other coney places in Tulsa to see how they compare. read more

I can't come to Tulsa without getting a few coneys!! Don't get a phoney coney. :-) It hasn't changed since I was a kid and that's why I keep coming back. Nom Nom Nom read more

This hot dog joint is ok. I feel as if the chili is a little bland. I grew up around Muskogee and they have a hot dog place called Chet's. Their homemade chili has flavor and is complimented by their use of cheese whiz. I have been searching for a hot dog joint that compares and have been referred to this place, but sadly it didn't even come close. I honestly prefer Sonics chili dogs over these. And so the search continues for a comparable chili dog joint . read more

Oklahoma's only redeeming quality and it's a damn good one. This location has the best coney's, IMO. I can knock down 5 easily, they're so good. read more

Was extremely disappointed, chili tasted like cafeteria food. Employees were rude and inattentive.

Best coneys are the real Coney I-Lander . Everything is just as it should be. Enjoy