Great place to grab a meal when you need something quick or you just got done partying at or near TU and don't want to eat Taco Bell, Taco Bueno or Mazzio's. The staff is also friendly. read more

Undeniably the worst place to get a hot dog I have ever encountered Cheap hotdogs, BAD CHILI,mushy buns and nothing else that's not pre packaged available. It's a mystery to me how this place is still open read more

A Tulsa Classic! A throw back to another time. Great dogs for a great value! I had 2 chili cheese dogs and loved every bite!

Delicious. Love going when I'm in town! It's my favorite spot to go with my niece in Tulsa. Big fan!

Classic coneys always hit the spot. Take a little step back in hotdog history and do yourself a favor and get you some coneys! Service is friendly and the ambiance is as expected . read more

Coney I-Lander - Quad coney stack w/ everything - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

This is tge best tasting coney island hotdog I have ever eaten. I usually eat 3-4 and am so satisfied when done

I was incredibly disappointed with Coney I-Lander. Not only was the staff incredibly rude but the food was mediocre. I have heard how good their coneys are from numerous people, and walked away underwhelmed. If you want a good coney, go to Coney Island in OKC. read more

Best coney ever consumed 10/10 aesthetic staff fast and nice and funny. Love this place would go again. read more

Coney I-Lander - I sign - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Always dependable good coneys. Great meal or snack. Love their Fritos pies and tamales too.

What went well?! Well, everything, of course, as usual for 30+yrs! I try to closely watch my figure, but with Coney I-Lander right down the street from my new house that's impossible. I had family replant to Colorado years ago & as soon as their bags are unpacked we're out the door for coney's!! I would give a 5+ if possible! read more

Austin behind the counter was super nice. I don't like hot dogs but my boyfriend took me here on a romantic date and the experience was everything I could've asked for. the simplicity of just serving coneys. and the tamales are very straightforward and delicious. read more

Service is always quick and employees are friendly. I love this place, I've tried eating other Coney's and nothing compares to this place. I've been eating at this location since high school and that was a while ago lol. But this place hasn't changed a bit!!! read more

Coney I-Lander - Partial menu as of 3/6/23 - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

I was so impressed by the quality of this food for the price! As a chili and hot dog loving girl, this place hits the spot. It's a unique layout and has a retro feel to it, and the diner/seating area is surprisingly spacious and very clean. The food is delicious and affordable, and the staff were super down to earth and friendly! read more

I've been at various Coney I-Landers around Tulsa 35 years or more. This location as well as the others have always been great. I love the size of the coneys and the chili has always been great. Better than the place that rhymes with pike. Service is always friendly and fast. I'm hesitant to try other coney places. read more

The food is always consistent and delicious. Very quick spot to get in and out if you are in a hurry but they also have a nicely sized dining area. read more

So the place was dirty and someone needed to wipe tables and booths and seats -- 12:45pm I arrive you had time! The man assembling the hot dogs had big scruffy nasty beard... long hair and hat ewwww hair in my food I thought. Hot dogs were semi warm. Chili was not hot as he was scooping from a small pot that was not heated... this was gross but I was hungry Decent dog and left in a hurry . Parking lot is crappy tight knit and hard to squeeze in read more

This is the ONLY coney-islander. Jim's was close, but now this location stands apart. Staff is wonderful, food is always on point. Just moved back, left in 07. One of the first places I went read more

After a not so great experience at a restaurant down the street this past weekend we decided to go to ol' reliable: Coney I-Lander. The coneys at this location are always hot, fresh, with soft buns. Employees are always friendly despite being overworked I'm sure. By far my favorite place to get coneys in Tulsa! read more

The inside is really nice and clean, pleasant surprise. The food keeps your stomach from growling, served only warm. For fast food coneys, it is okay, small frank on small bun. The frito pie okay, tamale was best thing between coney, frito pie and tamale. You tell them if you want chili, cheese and onions. Employees nice, but not geniuses. read more

See all

I have been coming to this location for several years. Last two times I have been I ended up leaving. Was waiting in line for more than a few minutes and the only thing one of the employees said to me was "What's up?" but then crickets. I was upset and an employee perhaps the manager did talk to me and said they were sorry and the meal was on the house but .... I work and do not take charity. All I expect is the order to be right and with this free food nope, I ordered a small container of chili and two hot dogs my standard order for years. They brought the chili and brought out a large container, so being free I should not complain? Only expecting my order to be correct is not too much to ask. I just left. I am not coming back. read more

I've bought food from here only a couple of times. It was never great, and nothing to recommend to friends. Yesterday my sister picked me up 2 coney's with extra cheese and no buns. This is what I got. read more

Coney I-Lander - This picture here is the reason people need a triple bypass. Who eats this shit? Or the real question is "Who made this shit?" - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Great service great dogs, great chili. I prefer guldens mustard and not there mustard. Dogs are small but great. Wish they had pickles.

We went to the location at 41st & Yale, they have the BEST loaded potato! It was huge! It had extra everything! Service was great, as usual. read more

Coney I-Lander is the best damn food you will ever try in your life. Count yourself lucky if you have ever experienced the flavor miracle of a coney with "the works". When I'm feeling fancy and want to treat myself, I get Coney I-Lander for lunch. Never, in my 30 years of going there, have they ever disappointed me. read more

I've been coming to this Coney Islander since I was a freshman at TU back in 2006. Coney I-Lander are the best hot dogs I've still had in my all 30 years of being alive. Their freshness is out of this world. I could just eat their buns and be satisfied! This location is small, clean and always friendly staff. The dogs are small so if you order 3 don't be ashamed. I always eat three and secretly wish I had a fourth. read more

I don't think this is the right location to go to. A friend and I were having lunch in the back corner and a roach just crawls right across the table. Threw my whole meal away out of disgust I'm not usually a picky about restaurants but roaches is where I draw the line lol read more

No issues. Have eaten here for 28 years. Prefer this location over Peoria.

Whats a trip to Tulsa without visiting coney I lander!? Best dog this side of the Mississippi! read more

Coney I-Lander - What's a visit to Tulsa without visiting coney I lander! Best dogs around! - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

I really like this location because it is close to a few places I frequent. I have never dined-in, but you have to order inside; it is very clean and well kept. The staff is always friendly and helpful. I also get speedy service every time I visit. Now, they are known for their coneys, but I like to get the tamales (with cheese and light on the onions). They are super tasty. I want some now! Thank you Yelp! ;-P read more

I read they had $1 coneys on Sunday's well that is March not February. It has been quite a while since I have been there. The coneys are as good as they were back in the day. The bread is soft, the hotdogs yummy and the chili, onions and mustard makes it the best coney around. read more

Coney I-Lander - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

in 1972 I was introduced to coneys and cayenne pepper here by my step father. Every Saturday after the chores were done we would load up and go get coneys. Since that time I have dined here at least every couple of weeks and like they say, it hasn't changed a bite. Made fresh and hot just the way you want them and as many as you want to eat. It's said that the secret is in the chili and while that may be, the fresh ingredients and dogs cook to just the right "snap" when you bite into them adds up to the best coneys in town! read more

Super solid Tulsa landmark, easy in, easy out and on my way home! Stop in at least once a month for my "cheese coney w/everything" fix. As a bonus, super cool mural on the side of the building! read more

Coney I-Lander - 11th Street Coney I-lander mural - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Idk they was closed I guess I should've figured but moms like coneys too it said they were open on the map I'm tired of Yelp asking me how it was I'll get back there one day that drive tho dang read more

Nothing beats a Coney. I moved out west, but come for a Coney every time I return to Tulsa. read more

Coney I-Lander - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

This has always been a favorite for a great coney. However on May 28th, we had our normal great food. Staff friendly but into my first coney they had rap music on and the singer if you'd call him that dropped the F bomb. We picked up our food and left never to come back. Another couple with a young child also left. Too bad such a nice place ruined their reputation and future business by allowing such disturbing music which ran away business. read more

I love this place. Serving in the U.S. Army, every time I come home, this is my first stop... after seeing my family of course. Coneys are always hot and delicious and always provides the feeling that I'm home. Thank you for the nostalgic feeling of my childhood and the feel of Tulsa every single time. read more

Coney I-Lander - Got my drink! - Hot Dogs Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

*As good as it gets for a classic Coney. First off, get your expectations in the right spot. This place is old and dated, pretty sure they have never remodeled. You will not find 'gourmet' hot dogs here. I found out the harsh reality that coneys are not a commodity after moving to Houston, so when I'm in town I try to hit this place up for a coney or four... If you're a first timer here is what you get: - A soda - 2-4 hot dogs, Toppings: Chili (yes, onion (yes), shredded cheddar (yes), mustard (meh, some people will tell you this is a must) - chips if you want them. Got it? Now go find a table, it's just around the corner from ordering, if there isn't a completely empty table, just sit with someone already there, they shouldn't mind. On the table you'll find a red powder in a shaker, use it, this is cayenne pepper and it makes these go from average to superb. I hope you like it! There are many of us around the country who don't have access to such luxuries all the time. read more

I grew up eating at Coney I-Lander with my grandma. She would tell me every time we went in about how she used to get 2 coneys and a drink for a quarter. She also said that in all of the years they have stayed consistent and haven't changed a bite. I love these little hotdogs. I prefer just chili and cheese. If you have never had a coney before, know this, coney chili is a little thinner and more tangy than a normal chili some people love it some people hate it. Another excellent menu item is the tamales. I get them smothered in chili with cheese on top. They also have chili three way though I have never tried it. The staff is always friendly and welcoming. The dinning room section also has a word scramble puzzle. They are usually quotes. I like to sit and figure out the puzzle while eating my coneys. When in the mood for a coney/ hotdog stop by Coney I-Lander. read more

I guess I'll throw my hat in here. I'm sure it's not healthy. I'm sure it's probably got stuff in it that I don't want to know about. But they sure do taste good. The first "Coney" I ever had was back on the east coast, in a town called Cumberland, Maryland. What was so funny about it, from what I've heard, was that the two brothers who owned it got into a fight, which lead to one of the brothers opening up a shop two or three doors down from the other, serving the exact same thing. As far as I know, they are both still there today. The other thing about those Coney's was there was no cheese to be seen. I had never even heard of such a thing until I got to Tulsa. My relatives who come to visit are just shocked that you would ever put cheese on a coney. Now, as a Tulsan who has moved and returned, I can tell you I used to crave these stupid hot dogs more than you can know. My Mom would meet me at the plane with a order of them. Are they great? That's for you to decide. But are they a taste of Tulsa? No doubt. It's a signature food, like it or not. read more

This place is my favorite thing to eat, the last 2 times I have made it to Tulsa it has been after closing time. I am now living in Houston and I find every excuse to go to to Tulsa for these Coney. I wish you could ship me a monthly subscription of coney dogs, or let me buy in because I would open one here in Houston. We need good coney... thanks for the yummy food, and the excuse to come back home read more