Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Common Tart

    4.9 (43 reviews)
    Closed 12:00 pm - 6:00 PM
    Updated 3 months ago

    Common Tart Bakeries Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Common Tart

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Peanut Butter Mousse
    Terry B.

    My first time visiting this quaint pastry place! It's had a small seating area with maybe 5-6 tables. However, don't let the size distract you from the elegant desserts that await! We arrived after the lunchtime hour so my group of four were able to sit at the largest table. With Coconut Cream Pie being my favorite I had to have a slice and it did not disappoint!! I'm my opinion it's all about the crust then the filling. This crust was amazing and the coconut filling was perfect! I had to order a slice to go for my wife. I also ordered a Peanut Butter Mousse - another amazing pie! The staff were wonderful and pleasant and that made you feel welcomed to be there! I would be a regular here if I lived in the Tulsa area. So good!!! I would highly recommend this place . . . if for nothing else to try for yourself and see!

    Key Lime
    Sarah D.

    I'm always on the hunt for good desserts, and I came across the cutest pie shop called Common Tart. It's tucked off 17th and Utica and their slices look heavenly! I grabbed the peanut butter mousse, lemon tart, Key lime pie and oatmeal cream pie. They were all so naughty (in the good way!) Each slice costs $7 - definitely worth checking out!! (Pardon the key lime pie shot, took photo after eating a bite!)

    Molly B.

    I stopped by today to celebrate Pi Day, and it was the best choice. This is easily the best pie I've ever had, and they are the nicest crew! I got it to go, but the shop is so cute, and I can't wait to go back and dine in and try more. If you see Peanut Butter Mousse on the menu, GET IT!

    Peaches  & Cream Refrigerator Pie
    Charlotte G.

    The Ambience is stunning here!! And it starts even before you get inside!! Such an extravagantly decorated place and the service is impeccably Sweet!!! The pies are Amazing!!! The People who work there are the sweetest ever!! I Want to go back NOW!!

    Peanut Butter Mousse
    Bobby B.

    Peanut butter mouse pie is heavenly. I'll set the bar high and it'll still exceed. Everything else looks great!

    Pie Sampler
    Michael E.

    Wow this place is fantastic. Stupendous pies, a quite cool space inside to enjoy the delicacies, and they even show movies outside. We ordered a sampler plate with slices of four different pies (Ambrosia, Blueberry, Lemon Merengue and Peach) and a Strawberry Merengue Tart to go...about $24 for the whole shebang. A bit pricey but my taste buds didn't mind, just my wallet. What stood out for me with all the pies was that the fruit was firm, not overcooked and mushy like so many other pies. And the crusts were done to perfection. I'd say it's in sort of an unlikely location for decidedly awesome pie.

    Apple Crumble a la mode and a puzzle!
    Katrina R.

    What a Tulsa gem! I can't wait to come back here again. Common Tart is a cozy bakery with beautiful decor - there's lots of gold accents, a baby grand piano on the way in, and lots of puzzles and books to keep you occupied while you wait on your dessert! They have a list of pies behind the counter as well as on display, and they run about $7 a slice (which is like 1/5 of a full pie). I tried the Apple Crumble a la mode (warmed), and it was spicy and delicious with oats baked into the crust. My friends tried the butterscotch pie and said it was delicious! The cashier and staff were polite and service was exceptionally quick! There is a powder room at the back of the restaurant as well. I wish we had a spot like this back home, and I can't wait to return! (P.S. for Tulsa area locals - they have a rewards system that allows you to work up to a free slice of pie!)

    Oatmeal Cream Pie
    Andrew F.

    If you have a sweet tooth and love pie this is your place! Found this place while driving around and had to stop. We tried three on this visit. The oatmeal cream pie, the banana nutella and my favorite the fudge brownie pie. They were all awesome and delicious and we are already counting the days til we return!

    Kayla P.

    Very yummy! The Key Lime pie was my favorite. It's a little pricey for a slice, but that would be my only complaint

    We always get a few pies to share
    Eileen S.

    Probably the best pies in Tulsa. We like everything we have tried. It's funny how my husband and I got the same pies last evening like we did in 2022 when I was uploading the photos onto Yelp. I am happy Common Tart is open till 10pm on Fridays so we can pop by after dinner.

    Key Lime, Fudge Brownie, and Apple Crumble
    Melia F.

    The pies were fabulous, everything was really pretty and tasty! Flavor was great, the brownie and key lime really stood out, so make sure to give them a try! The decor inside was adorable and the board games to play while you eat were a lovely touch! Staff was all super sweet and made great recommendations, I will for sure be visiting again when I'm back in town! My only feedback is maybe a larger outdoor sign? But parking lot was spacious and location was great!

    Pear Almond

    See all

    3 years ago

    The pies are pretty good. The coconuts probably the best coconut. I've gotten in Oklahoma. Definitely the best pie place in Tulsa.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    The pies and tarts here are anything BUT common. Come for the food, stay for the atmosphere -- Buy Local -- Highly recommended!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Honestly the best fudge brownie pie I've had. Perfectly flaky and rich! Definitely coming here again.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Common Tart

    You might also consider

    Ludger's Bavarian Cakery

    Ludger's Bavarian Cakery

    4.4(171 reviews)
    8.1 mi
    $$

    I recently ordered a custom party cake (funfetti) with traditional buttercream from Ludger's, and…read moreit absolutely exceeded my expectations. From the beautiful presentation to the delicious flavor and outstanding customer service, the entire experience was wonderful. After submitting an online quote request, I was contacted quickly with detailed information, and the ordering process was seamless when I called to finalize. The cake was thoughtfully and beautifully crafted with realistic bark texture along with detailed greenery; it was the perfect forest-style centerpiece for my son's Gravity Falls party. When guests saw the cake and learned it was from Ludger's, several of them raved about how amazing their cakes are. This was the first birthday party we've had where nearly the entire cake was eaten! Thank you Ludger's!

    So the business owner reached out to me about my previous review and offered to refund me for my…read morelemon bar that I was not able to enjoy. So I went in today to do this and not only were the staff yet again amazing and friendly and helpful, but they offered to let me try something else and the manager told me they're known for their cakes. since I have never tried their cake before I decided to go for that. I tried the strawberry lemon cake and I am not a cake person, usually because they have tons of icing which is just not my thing. However, this cake does not have icing instead it has this lemon strawberry cream in the middle of the cake with some whipped cream and it is the best thing. This is now the only way that I want someone to give me cake is like this. My next birthday, I'm gonna be asking for a cake like this and I officially will be back to this place. I'm just been blown away by the customer service but also I'm thrilled that they corrected their lemon bars and now I found a place where I can actually like cake.

    Photos
    Ludger's Bavarian Cakery
    Ludger's Bavarian Cakery - Blue bird (turkey and swiss on blueberry bread)

    Blue bird (turkey and swiss on blueberry bread)

    Ludger's Bavarian Cakery

    See all

    The Coffee House On Cherry Street - Coconut Creme Pie

    The Coffee House On Cherry Street

    3.8(417 reviews)
    0.3 miCherry Street
    $

    The Chai Latte with a generous amount of cinnamon on top is a perfect blend and mildly sweet. The…read moreFarmers breakfast can be a burrito or bowl with a choice of bacon. Sausage, or chorizo. With it being Resurrection Sunday, they had a rush prior to my arrival so I had to request the table outside on the patio to be wiped off. Within a minute it was address. The Coffee house on Cherry Street lives up to its peaceful slow paced ambience. If your palate is looking for something sweet there is an extensive selection of baked goods.

    I love this place. The easiest five stars I've ever given in a review. This is a very unique…read moreindependent coffee shop. The coffee is great. The pastries are great. You can get sandwiches too if you'd like. And the atmosphere is great. Relaxing and very tastefully designed. Now what really makes it special is the expansion they are doing. They're expanding into the space next door. Adding a new bigger kitchen. AND they now sell all kinds of really nice items to make your kitchen special. None of these are mass produced items. They are made by local artisans. Tea pots. Cups. Vases. Very special handmade gift cards and gift tags. The kind you would keep as a keepsake. Awesome coffee mugs. Just really nice stuff. Today we ended up buying two of our Christmas gifts there along with some very unique Christmas cards. The service throughout the entire process was great. We're from out of town and today was only our second time there, but we'll come back every time we visit. Highly recommend.

    Photos
    The Coffee House On Cherry Street - More pastries- sweet and savory

    More pastries- sweet and savory

    The Coffee House On Cherry Street - Quiche for lunch. Gluten free!

    Quiche for lunch. Gluten free!

    The Coffee House On Cherry Street - The coffee tasted mediocre.

    See all

    The coffee tasted mediocre.

    Common Tart - bakeries - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...