Step through the doors of Common Tart and you would think you're in a quaint village neighborhood, not across the street on the back side of St. John's. While it might be off the beaten path, one can easily find it if you look for the PIE sign off Utica. It's definitely worth the U-turn! It was almost closing time when I was there but I was still able to get a slice each of the apple crumble and an orange-pistachio cream pie to go. The staff was so friendly and the interior (and exterior) is so inviting. I loved the Pride and Prejudice puzzle that was in the middle of the shop just asking to be put together. I would love to come back and dine inside and try multiple slices. The to-go boxes came out tied with a ribbon and a fresh flower. read more

See all

Nice pie shop. Service pleasant each time. Tried several of their offering since in laws got me into it last year. Coconut cream - solid! Chocolate chip cookie pie - wow. So decadent (a little too sweet). Chocolate spice cookie pie was interesting but not my jam on the spice. Fruit crumble pies get the job done. Living a charmed life, however, I prefer Pie junkie in OKC on this front. Saving best for last: the maple brown butter chocolate pie is something special. My fave ! read more

A great little shop with amazing treats. Staff is super helpful and friendly. The atmosphere is casual and peaceful. When is Tulsa, this is a great local option to satisfy your sweet tooth read more

The cutest little dessert spot ever!! And the pies are sooo delicious! We had the fudge brownie and oatmeal cream. Both were perfection!

My first time visiting this quaint pastry place! It's had a small seating area with maybe 5-6 tables. However, don't let the size distract you from the elegant desserts that await! We arrived after the lunchtime hour so my group of four were able to sit at the largest table. With Coconut Cream Pie being my favorite I had to have a slice and it did not disappoint!! I'm my opinion it's all about the crust then the filling. This crust was amazing and the coconut filling was perfect! I had to order a slice to go for my wife. I also ordered a Peanut Butter Mousse - another amazing pie! The staff were wonderful and pleasant and that made you feel welcomed to be there! I would be a regular here if I lived in the Tulsa area. So good!!! I would highly recommend this place . . . if for nothing else to try for yourself and see! read more

See all

I'm always on the hunt for good desserts, and I came across the cutest pie shop called Common Tart. It's tucked off 17th and Utica and their slices look heavenly! I grabbed the peanut butter mousse, lemon tart, Key lime pie and oatmeal cream pie. They were all so naughty (in the good way!) Each slice costs $7 - definitely worth checking out!! (Pardon the key lime pie shot, took photo after eating a bite!) read more

See all

This quaint cute cottage like pie shop is so adorable inside. There's a table with a community puzzle. Little bistro tables and chairs fun art work on the walls. The kindest warmest people work here. Every pie I've had here has been to die for. 10/10 recommend trying a pie or five if you're ever in the area! They will not disappoint! read more

I stopped by today to celebrate Pi Day, and it was the best choice. This is easily the best pie I've ever had, and they are the nicest crew! I got it to go, but the shop is so cute, and I can't wait to go back and dine in and try more. If you see Peanut Butter Mousse on the menu, GET IT! read more

Common Tart - Bakeries Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

The Ambience is stunning here!! And it starts even before you get inside!! Such an extravagantly decorated place and the service is impeccably Sweet!!! The pies are Amazing!!! The People who work there are the sweetest ever!! I Want to go back NOW!! read more

Common Tart - Peaches & Cream Refrigerator Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Peanut butter mouse pie is heavenly. I'll set the bar high and it'll still exceed. Everything else looks great! read more

Common Tart - Peanut Butter Mousse - Bakeries Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Wow this place is fantastic. Stupendous pies, a quite cool space inside to enjoy the delicacies, and they even show movies outside. We ordered a sampler plate with slices of four different pies (Ambrosia, Blueberry, Lemon Merengue and Peach) and a Strawberry Merengue Tart to go...about $24 for the whole shebang. A bit pricey but my taste buds didn't mind, just my wallet. What stood out for me with all the pies was that the fruit was firm, not overcooked and mushy like so many other pies. And the crusts were done to perfection. I'd say it's in sort of an unlikely location for decidedly awesome pie. read more

See all

What a Tulsa gem! I can't wait to come back here again. Common Tart is a cozy bakery with beautiful decor - there's lots of gold accents, a baby grand piano on the way in, and lots of puzzles and books to keep you occupied while you wait on your dessert! They have a list of pies behind the counter as well as on display, and they run about $7 a slice (which is like 1/5 of a full pie). I tried the Apple Crumble a la mode (warmed), and it was spicy and delicious with oats baked into the crust. My friends tried the butterscotch pie and said it was delicious! The cashier and staff were polite and service was exceptionally quick! There is a powder room at the back of the restaurant as well. I wish we had a spot like this back home, and I can't wait to return! (P.S. for Tulsa area locals - they have a rewards system that allows you to work up to a free slice of pie!) read more

See all

This pie shop is so adorable -- from the quaint decor to the friendly staff, it's very charming. Lots of different pie flavors available and all that my friends and I tried were delicious. You can tell they are made from scratch and with love. read more

If you have a sweet tooth and love pie this is your place! Found this place while driving around and had to stop. We tried three on this visit. The oatmeal cream pie, the banana nutella and my favorite the fudge brownie pie. They were all awesome and delicious and we are already counting the days til we return! read more

See all

Very yummy! The Key Lime pie was my favorite. It's a little pricey for a slice, but that would be my only complaint read more

Common Tart - Bakeries Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Probably the best pies in Tulsa. We like everything we have tried. It's funny how my husband and I got the same pies last evening like we did in 2022 when I was uploading the photos onto Yelp. I am happy Common Tart is open till 10pm on Fridays so we can pop by after dinner. read more

See all

The pies were fabulous, everything was really pretty and tasty! Flavor was great, the brownie and key lime really stood out, so make sure to give them a try! The decor inside was adorable and the board games to play while you eat were a lovely touch! Staff was all super sweet and made great recommendations, I will for sure be visiting again when I'm back in town! My only feedback is maybe a larger outdoor sign? But parking lot was spacious and location was great! read more

Common Tart - Key Lime, Fudge Brownie, and Apple Crumble - Bakeries Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

A hidden gem! It's the only pie shop in Tulsa, that I'm aware of. It's a cute little shop! There isn't a ton of seating, but I've gone with friends and have not had any issue finding a place to sit. Their pies are some of the best! You can taste that they're homemade with love. read more

Common Tart - Pear Almond - Bakeries Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

This place has the best pies by far! The place is small and cute. Does have a few tables indoors and outdoors . If there is no room inside you can get your piece of pie to go! Either way so worth the trip! read more

Great S'more pie. Perfect combination of all that makes this snack a food favorite. A thoughtful treat to share with family and friends.

Yes. This pie is freaking fantastic. And pricey. We tried 7 different kinds. The favorite of all was the peanut butter. Definitely coming back for more of that. Very cute inside, good amount of seating. Great stop for true pie fans. read more

We went last night and it was fabulous! I highly recommend the giant oatmeal cream pie slice! It is to die for!!!

This is a sweet midtown spot owned by locals who have taken photographs of their hands at work in the kitchen and placed them on their calling cards and walls. It's such a nice touch for so many reasons. The pies are baked from scratch with their own hands and those of their loved ones. They have created a space that welcomes folks of all ages in a warm atmosphere that beckons you back. And the pie...well, it's just incredible!!! My uncle and grandfather had a mom and pop restaurant in a small TX town when I was growing up and we always said, "No-one can make a pie like Granny!" But Common Tart is proving me wrong. Granny is long gone, but every time I don the door of Common Tart, I'm reminded of what it was like to eat a piece of pie in her kitchen. I'm also reminded of the labor of love that was behind every slice. Get the coconut cream or the French silk and take a seat inside. Linger awhile. You won't regret it! read more

I was impressed by the cottage-like exterior of this place and the grander, almost Art Deco theme inside the shop. The waitress was very friendly and helpful as I considered their many pie options before settling on an excellent slice of apple pie. The crust was just right - not too doughy and not too dry. The apples were stewed perfectly and well-spiced. I plan on returning! read more

Common Tart - Apple Crumble - Bakeries Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

This is a spot I'll come back to try everything they have on the menu. The menu they had during this visit was French Silk, Apple Crumble, Peanut Butter Mousse, Pear Around, Key Lime, Banana Nutella, Fudge Brownie & Coconut Cream. Yes, imagine that on deck with it being your first visit. I ended up with the Apple Crumble. The Apple Crumble was incredible. Flaky, buttery, sweet crust. It was more apple & no type of pie filling, which is something I'm not used to & the only way I'd like my pies. Plenty of apple in every bite, comes in a nice-sized slice. The place smells very good as soon as you walk in. The pies are sitting in front of you, making it hard for you to just choose one (got very close to also getting a slice of Key Lime). The lady who took my order was super sweet. Slices are $6.50. read more

See all

Absolute perfection ! My first time to try CT - I was craving a really good chocolate pie and they did not disappoint. I got a whole pie and they were quick to get it ready for me. Very nice people. read more

The best pie ever! I love their always changing menu which allows me to try so many different flavors. It is the cutest atmosphere and so picturesque! Also this women-owned business is amazing in general. The owners are so sweet and remembered me after coming here twice! read more

See all

"Atmosphere of creativity" is my best description of the Common Tart. I am unsure how their business is structured, but they appear to be more than an excellent bakery (pies); a jewelry presentation as well as a flower arranger were displaying their "art". read more

Was just there and bought 2 whole pies for pi day. The apple crumb is one of the best apple pies I've ever eaten. The consistency of the French silk was dreamy. The perfect balance of chocolate and sweetness of whipped cream. I'll order pies for Easter here!!! read more

I love homemade pie, and I even more love not having to make it to have it. I knew I had to try - and I absolutely approve so far (apple crumble pie for starters). Such a lovely little shop to sit and enjoy, and friendly workers who clearly love their job. Thank you!! read more

Common Tart - Apple crumble pie - Bakeries Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Without a doubt some of the best artisan pies in Tulsa. Featuring a rotation of one savory pie and a handful of fresh sweet pies, Common Tart elevates the humble pie to a meal-worthy destination. From perfectly flakey crusts to delicately balanced custards, the pies here leave nothing out. Tulsa may have tons of bakeries serving classic pies, but none that can stand toe to toe with the care and attention to detail of Common Tart. read more

Many options to choose from of Delicious homemade pies and professional service and clean atmosphere.

Delicious, awesome service! I wish the smell when you walk in was able to be made as a candle. Thanks for great pie!

This is now my new favorite dessert place in Tulsa. We stopped by for a mid-afternoon snack. Between us, we tried the pear almond tart, the chocolate silk pie, and the special buttermilk pie. The pear almond tart was beautiful with perfectly balanced flavors. The chocolate silk had a great rich, dark chocolate flavor. The person with the buttermilk pie refused to share, which I take to mean it was amazing. The vibe was also perfect. Everything was cute and simple. We loved all the copper bakeware and the player piano. Also the owner was lovely, and doing a great job handling a busy afternoon all by herself. She clearly has put a lot of care into this place and all of her recipes. read more

I've been here twice and it is wonderful! Small seating area but cozy and pretty. The pie (coconut cream) is excellent. I'll try something different next time. I would recommend this to everyone. read more

Amazing pie and crust. Best pie in Tulsa by far. We also like the shop itself, it's small and cozy. read more

What a wonderful and charming place. The service was outstanding, as soon as you walk in you get hit with a wonderful delicious smell. We ordered a brownie and key lime pie and they were amazing. Too bad we were just visiting for the football game but if we lived in Tulsa we would be in this place everyday. Keep it up! read more

It's great pies although they don't have a large selection!! And they don't keep regular pies from day to days!

Try the brownie pie its amazing! I'm looking forward to coming back and trying the savory pies.

The pies are pretty good. The coconuts probably the best coconut. I've gotten in Oklahoma. Definitely the best pie place in Tulsa.