Always polite, food is amazing !I it's a new take on Peirogies! Location Downtown Monaca. Peirogie sandwiches,Platters the taco and scallop platter are my favs Except Thursday the Only day of the week you can get 2 stuffed cabbage which is so delicious, homemade mashed potatoes! 2 cabbage rolls,for $13.00! Of course other items still available. Please give them a try they wont disappoint. Gyros are 10.00.I didn't see a dinner over $15.00 read more

Good fish on Fridays. Good pierogis. Cole slaw tasted like cheap store bought (ie, not good). Haluski nice and tender but very lacking in cabbage. Overall pretty good but not great. read more

Stop what you are doing. Go to Monaca. Enjoy some Comfortably Yummm. They have incredible perogies, fish, wings and more! I love their Friday fish special. My dad will come to visit from TN and that's the first place he always wants to go. The fish is HUGE and comes with 2 sides. I usually get the perogies and halushki and save the haluskhi for the next day. They have great service and portions are huge. I just wish their dining area made more sense, but they are definitely geared more towards takeout/uber/doordash than eat in. read more

Not sure if they are normally slow on Monday but they where tonight. The breaded mushrooms where not to bad but the owner was not happy with them so was no charge. The Pergio Ruben platter was interesting and good. read more

Comfortably Yummm - Ruben Platter - New American Near Me - Monaca, Pennsylvania

See all

We stopped in person this time and the experience was even better! Talking to the owners made it feel like we were stopping in at a good friend's house. We enjoyed their dozen wings and dozen pierogi special along with the Philly Steak Platter and of course some halushki. The wings were great and the recommended BBQ with Cajun dust was a real favorite. The entry and dining room are wheelchair accessible from the street and so is the bathroom. Make sure to stop in or order soon! read more

See all

Another fun meal. I always get 2 items and first time I finally had the will power to stay away from any of the Reuben based go to's in order to try new ones. The gyro platter was delicious...had a nice little black peppery heat in the gyro meat that went over 8 jalapeño pierogies. The pierogi sandwiches are always fun (this time I got the double sausage). I prefer the Reuben and burger variants more but glad I tried it. Staff always friendly and attentive! read more

See all

Went back to this establishment for the first time in a few years and had the same great experience again! Last time we did take out. This time we ate in. Quick service, delicious food, clean, and they even had a basket of toys to keep my kids entertained! read more

Anytime I have a craving for homemade perogies I visit Comfortably Yumm! I have visited here many times and always have great experiences! I have tried a variety of perogie flavors! Definitely the best! The staff is very friendly and the foods always DELICIOUS! The atmosphere is warm and cozy, which I love! I highly recommend trying their perogie platters! Definitely a good portion of food and alot of flavor! I love how this perogie dish comes with tasty toppings! I look forward to visiting again! read more

I ate here for lunch a couple of weeks ago with seven of my work friends, and we all really liked our food. The owner was so nice and friendly as well as our waitress being prompt and so helpful. We were the only people in the restaurant, but we did have to wait for a little bit of time. We think it was because of the ton of to go orders. I got the kielbasa bowl which had kielbasa, sauerkraut and of course pierogie. I can't wait to go back and try some more options! read more

See all

The name perfectly describes this place. The food was amazingly unassuming in its flavor and comfort. I highly recommend if you need some great homemade comfort food. read more

Good food at a good price! Once you get through the front door it will surprise you . The dining area bigger than expected. read more

We are Ohioans that were spending a day/night in Pittsburgh area ... looking for an out-of-the-big-city lunch stop. WHAT A GREAT SURPRISE in little Monaca ... my wife's maiden voyage of using YELP, and she said ... they do all sorts of stuff with pierogies ..... so we stopped. From the super-friendly owner/server to the neat diner interior styling : to the AMAZING REUBEN pierogie bowl; we were impressed. Hope to visit when back this way! read more

Comfortably Yummm - Reuben pierogie bowl; 1/2 were jalapeño potato!! - New American Near Me - Monaca, Pennsylvania

Delicious! We were visiting from Florida and stopped in for take out. Pirogies were so good. Fried zucchini was excellent too. Definitely glad we stopped in read more

Food and service great!!! Pierogis with fried chicken gravy and corn over it was sooo gooood.

Ordered delivery and was very happy. Loved the pierogis! Haluski was average. Gyro was delicious. Only complaint was the lettuce on the gyro. I've never had lettuce on one and it seemed out of place. Super easy to take off. Excellent food and would visit again. read more

I ordered pierogis from here for lunch! I got 1/2 dozen potato and 1/2 dozen kraut. Heads up though - their half dozen is 5. They came swimming in butter, which I am not a huge fan of, but it didn't stop me from eating every single one. I just put them on a different plate. The flavor was great and I really enjoyed both flavors. The butter is the only reason why it's 4 instead of 5 stars. I'd like to try more things on their menu and will order from them again! read more

Ordered takeout for a big group, everything was ready on time and tasted great! Cheese steak and gyro platters were a highlight. Would definitely order from here again. read more

A perogie palace small cute a must stop by in a little town called manoca 1st time me and my son a quick bite before heading to Neville Rome Dome for some skating the food was good and is so many perogies combinations to pick from and they are adding to the menu weekly my only this is you have to buy cans of pop so need a fountain machine but the new spot is great the owner and the staff is very friendly it like having lunch or dinner with family and friends me and my crew will become regular stop in tell the Z and his mom sent you read more

See all

Cozy and gGreat ambiance. Wonderful service and yummy good food, especially Fish fry Fridays!

Staff is amazing and communitive. The food is always extremely enjoyable! Would definitely recommend

Gotta go to this restaurant. They have a pierogi Burger! Yes you read that right! And bless the owners for serving a tired tourist @closing time. Comfort food - yumm! read more

So I went to this place on a whim! My thoughts were " I like pierogies! Why not! Well the hostess/ waitress sat me and she was a very nice old lady. I asked her what is popular and she said the Kabasa and pierogies! So that's what I ordered. Well after a few minutes here they come in a bowl. At first I looked at it and thought ok looks good it was pierogies sauerkraut and cut up Kabasa. I cut up a pierogi stab the Kabasa and in the mouth it went! Well the Kabasa was way overcooked and dry. The pierogies were undercooked and doughy, the sauerkraut was fried in oil which laid in the bottom of the bowl. The pierogies were potato and cheese, but tasted like potato. Only a few bites just to make sure it wasn't that piece and or that single pierogi I decided to grab my check. The restaurant was in need of repair and when the door opened to the kitchen it gave me the feeling of not being very clean. The owner also had multiple visitors ask for her but not eat and one even went into the kitchen to talk to her. Good concept but not good food. read more

Saw on Facebook they had a stuffed cabbage special and got it to go and it was SOO good!! Hadn't had stuffed cabbage in years.

Stopped by for a quick bite after checking into our AirBnB. Service was quick, efficient, and friendly. Food was delicious, generously portioned, and very reasonably priced. (We got a half dozen potato and cheese pierogi, a Philly cheesesteak, and a chicken salad -- all delicious!) Would definitely recommend! read more

Awesome homemade food! Owner is cool and waitress did a fantastic job! This is a must if you are close!!!

Just tried this lil spot service very friendly and helpful Food is awesome got 2 platters so far I think these are the best rogies in the area way better than perogies plus I will definitely be back for more read more

If you enjoy a good pierogi you've come to the right place. Just enjoyed their kielbasa and krat platter. Owner had us try a sample of his newest concoction, pot roast and pierogies. Not on the menu yet, but no doubt it will be an instant classic. read more

Wonderful! If you love pierogies, kraut, onion and butter (mouth watering at the thought) you will LOVE this menu! Hand made and pinched (not made with a dough stamp) with passion for the dish. They also have keilbasa, which I sure is good if you eat meat. A great place to order out from or to eat in for a cozy bite. Next time I need to take some pictures to upload! read more

Tried this little restaurant for the first time last week. Server was excellent, knew her menu and made good recommendations. Little country "hole in the wall" with great atmosphere. read more

Delicious Food! We had the stuffed cabbage and also the Rueben and the kids had chicke. all were excellent! We will be back. great service and food was prepared fresh. you can tell! read more

Delicious, hearty servings! Family business that deserves our support! I will return and so should you!!

Wow!!! wish we found this place sooner. We had the perogie plates. It was superb everything was made fresh and was delicious. The service was also terrific. The owners were so nice. Also got the homemade cheesecake. Yumm!!!! read more