Waitlist - Colter Bay
Order Colter Bay Takeout or Delivery
Colter Bay Photos
Business Info
Colter Bay Popular Dishes
COLTER BAY ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Colter Bay
Recommended Reviews - Colter Bay
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
After a long day of sight-seeing, we needed a place to rehydrate and refuel. Our server (friendly and pleasant) must have seen how quickly we guzzled our first glasses of water, because she then brought a pitcher to the table. God bless her, as I was so dehydrated I was starting to feel like a raisin. The atmosphere here is pub-style. We felt perfectly comfortable eating there as a family. Obviously I had to try a local specialty, and I was not disappointed! The Beef on Weck was fantastic. Something about the combination of flavors just works. Plus the beef was tender... not an ounce of tough bits or gristle. And the au jus was so flavorful! Big Daddy actually drank some of it straight like a beverage. The poutine was fantastic! The wings were hot and juicy. The other sandwiches we ordered (chicken mushroom swiss and prime rib) were also top tier. The only oddity was that the salad was arugula. Our server warned us of it so we were prepared, but it still seemed odd. Overall, this was an excellent meal! Would definitely visit again!
Pretty cool bar and restaurant lots of TVs to watch sports games. A good beer selection as well. Ordered the beef on weck and the buffalo chicken salad. The buffalo chicken salad was really good! Very refreshing the ranch and buffalo flavor was so good! The beef on weck came with fries, horseradish, and au jus sauce. The beef was pretty tasty along the the au jus sauce, but I couldn't eat the bun. It was topped with sea salt and rosemary which looked good, but it was just so salty. I know this is how it's supposed to be made but it was so salty that it was a pain to eat. I recommend using a lot less salt.
We go to Colter bay from time to time as we live quite nearby. Their salmon on shaved brussels sprouts salad is one of my favorite restaurant dishes. Colter Bay is also the only place I've ever seen a scotch egg since the British fish and chips place closed down. Theirs is divine and I highly recommend you indulge in one or two. We were looking for a place for brunch on my birthday weekend and noted that Colter Bay had posted about brunch so we headed over to give it a try and we're not disappointed. I had shrimp and grits that were to die for. Creamy, cheesy, and full of perfectly cooked shrimp. The bf had a brunch burger that was a massive smash burger with sunny side up eggs and cheese and added bacon. Colter bay also has an impressive selection of beers and other drinks. And while I haven't had it many of my friends are in love with their Mac and cheese.
Decided to stop in here on a whim and glad we did! The elk burger was delicious! The flavors of the goat cheese and berry was soooo good. My sister got the steak sandwich special which was great as well. Beat my expectations definitely recommend!
They did such an amazing job remodeling this place with all kinds of ski equipment to give it that nice ski lodge feel even when it's 85 degrees outside. Great selection of beers on tap and in cans they had their own Other Half drop, who does this?? Incredible!! Went on servers recommendation with the BBQ Chicken sandwich, delicious, just hold off on the lettuce as this was unnecessary. Oh those Brussel Sprouts Listen even if you HATED these as a kid please give these a try, they are all flaky and crispy and whatever sauce they put on there really pulls it all together. Great menu choices and amazing service makes this place a can't miss!
Colter Bay is an Allentown staple with an impressive brew selection and a tasty menu! While I sure do miss meeting a crowd of friends for fun and drinks, the current sit down socially distance set up is not bad at all! You feel some sort of normal with the people inside but safely spaced, staff is totally masked and masks are required to enter and any time you are not seated. I think they are doing a great job with this! We strolled down to Allen on Friday and decided Colter was the perfect cozy setting to grab a brew and some snacks. Hostess seated us ASAP (there may be a wait if you come at busy times) and got us menus. We did have to wait quite a while for our waitress but she was the only one working so she was swamped with all the tables (at half capacity of course, but still alot!). When she did come by we got brews and ordered the firehole nachos, which came in an okay time frame (again a little bit of a wait but not her fault). The Brew Menu: MASSIVE selection of local brews, like very long pages of both cans and drafts which you can also order packs to go as well which is nice if you find something you really like. They have everying from a DIPA to a sour to a stout, from 4% to 11% there is something for every beer lover + local cider options, wines, and mixed drinks. This beer menu ROCKS and offers so much room to explore new brew options. The Nachos: this MOUNTAIN clocks in at $13 which is a great app size or good for 2-3 people in a meal. You can add a protein for like $3-4 but otherwise comes with thin and crispy house fried tortilla chips perfeclty salted, real melted cheese, creame, pickled reds, generous serving of pickled jalapenos, and cilantro. My only issue with this is the need for better nacho layering game here, no ones likes the naked chips that never get the opportunity to carry those beutufl toppings or melted cheeses... Colter will remain one of my fav places in downtown/allen area for solid brews.
Super cool corner bar, a block from my hotel. Low key atmosphere. Thoughtful draft list of 30+ handles. On the road, I make myself eat salads. This one, however: pure pleasure. Will be back!
First time here, love it! As any Shatzel place you'll find a great attention to beer, great list and choices. Great location and vibe
This place has grown on me and I love it. It is cozy, homey, and comfortable. This is a great hang out spot. Stopped here for a bite during the week. I ordered The French Connection. Oh my goodness, it was divine. It comes with a bowl of French onion soup, a French dip, and French fries. Get it?! Ingenious! The beef was tender and done perfectly. The soup was very good, and the fries were average. The only thing that could have been improved upon was the temperature of my food. It came out luke warm. It would have been a five star experience if my food was hotter. I usually get the old fashioned here, and this visit was no exception. It was a very good experience too.
Plans changed and so glad they did! Colter Bay is so great! They had a large drink selection and the food was delicious! The décor of a bar with a cabin twist made it welcoming and fun to be around. I had plans to play trivia at a different location, but they told us they cancelled it and that we should have known (never asked if we wanted to stay either). Myself and the group I was with, do not care for the food where trivia is. If Colter Bay had trivia - I think we would be there every week! I had the beef on weck and added 5 wings for an additional $6. The beef on weck was one of the BEST I have ever had. It was tender and cooked just right. My family has them often for parties and it tasted like home. It was piled high, but just enough to get the full effect. They gave you the au jus and horseradish on the side. Which is perfect so you can use as much or as little as you want. They also give you a ton of horseradish - not those tiny things most places give you. It also came with fries. The fries looked homemade and were crispy. The 5 wings were ok. I got them hot and for someone who loves spicy - they were spicy. Usually hot isn't hot enough for me. The heat factor was just right. The only problem, is it is street parking. This is what caused me to give Colter Bay only 4 stars and not 5. There is a parking lot behind it, but only after a certain time are you able to park there. I wish I remembered the time to put it in. Hopefully next time I will remember and can put it in here. read more
3 years ago
3 years ago
Been here a few times since they remodeled the place a few years ago. It was nothing more than and college bar back then. This may be my new favorite spot for brunch. They have a very extensive list of beers and ciders on tap. Wide variety from stouts to IPA's to Ciders and Mead and everything in between, so everyone will find something they like. Food is also very good. Got the scotch egg. Nicely done with runny yolk. Other brunch options looked good as well. Will be back soon. read more
Loving the new Colter Bay -- if you fancy an amazing sandwich, come here and order the Meatloaf Sandwich! The review could simply end here. Colter Bay has reopened under Shatzel's ownership (of ABV, past Blue Monk, Cole's and Liberty Hound) and it's definitely hopping. With a large beer menu and a cozy environment, it's a great place to catch a game or hang out with your friends. The food menu is one-page, but features some interesting items, including an Elk Burger and a variety of entrees (from Meatloaf to steak to fish) that are reasonably priced. The sandwiches are $14-16 each and the Meatloaf Sandwich came highly recommended. It's one of the best open faced sandwiches in Buffalo. Meatloaf, gravy and mashed potatoes on top of Texas toast (basically just a thicker bread). The meatloaf is delicious and the mashed potatoes and gravy make this sammy more of a heavy meal. If you're hungry, one should tide you over. When we came on a Sunday during the Bill's game, there were a few open tables, but the restaurant was at least 75% full. The noise level is on the louder side, so be aware of that. Service was great, but they weren't able to serve any hot drinks yet (so no hot tea, coffee) and they also didn't have unsweetened ice tea. By the time you read this review, they may have already worked that out and you may be enjoying a hot drink right now at Colter Bay! Either way, the renovations are great; both on the environment side and the food side. Colter Bay is definitely back to its former glory. Come enjoy a delicious meal at the new Colter Bay! read more
Went here on a cold, crappy, raining night and this was the perfect place to fall into for warmth and comfort food. We did have reservations and were glad we did because there was live music. We got a great booth with a window and far enough to enjoy the music and still be able to talk. The waitress was great even tho it was very busy. Their beer list is extensive; no disappointment here! The food menu had a specials sheet and a regular menu. We ordered pretzels as an appetizer and they were wowzers! So crispy, yet soft and perfectly salted. That came with a side of hot cheese and a side of beer mustard. We all loved our entrees and said we must come back soon! read more
2 years ago
Stopped in with some friends for lunch during the week to check out the "new look". Although the remodel has been done for some time now, I had not seen it yet, so was happy with how everything looked. I especially like the sliding windows around the outside of the restaurant that were open so you felt like you were sitting outside, without actually having to sit outside. The draft beer list was very extensive and we each chose an IPA to start. Our server Shelby was nice and very attentive, and didn't let our glasses stay empty for long. I ordered the 561 Short Rib Melt and it was one of the yummiest sandwiches I've had in a while. It had great flavor, the bread was not over toasted, and the fries were so delicious! My friends both enjoyed their sandwiches as well. We had such a nice meal and loved the beer selections. We will definitely be back since I'm now craving that sandwich! read more
8 years ago
The Shishito Peppers are one of my favorite items on the menu! It's an appetizer, but I like to get it as my main dish for lunch because it's just that good. Perfectly hot (sometimes it's a little spicier depending on the batch of peppers). Either way, the peppers are covered in cheese and it's a great savory dish! read more
Hubby and I decided to stop by the new Colter Bay on our way home from a Sabres game a few Saturdays ago. There was a table set up with 2 hostesses near the entrance who greeted us right away, but we opted to just grab a drink at the bar - which was packed. It had a decent vibe, decorated with a ski lodge-like feel. Much cleaner than the old Colter Bay, obviously, although I'm not sure if the crowd has changed much. I ordered the EBC blueberry beer, good as usual, and hubby ordered the Great Lakes Christmas ale - although he got some strange beer that was NOT the Christmas ale. With the bar being so busy, hubby hating sending things back, and me in a weird mood - neither of us wanted to make a fuss about it. We weren't really hungry so we just ordered the nachos to share - onions, sour cream, cheese, jalapeños, picco de gallo... they were pretty good, although the amount of toppings just didn't justify the $10 price tag. we studied the rest of the menu for when we return to try out the rest of the food, but nothing really jumped out at us, and some of the prices rivaled that of a pub in NYC. Maybe it's just me, but if I'm going to pay $16 for a steak sandwich at some gastropub, I'd rather pay twice as much for a real piece of steak elsewhere. Overall - friendly service, cool vibe, decent beer list, limited and somewhat overpriced menu. We'll return for drinks, but not likely for food. read more
5 years ago
Let me say I am a total foodie, home and boat chef and not always easy to please. This chef is spot on! The scotch egg was perfection and the chicken sandwich with fries! OMG! This chef needs to challenge Bobby Flay because he's winning! Bravo! read more
After over a year of driving by Colter Bay pretty much every day, Saturday was the day that I finally stopped in and had some dinner. Located on the corner of Delaware and Allen, this cool restaurant is usually pretty busy and this night was no different (especially when the Leafs were in town to beat the Sabres. We came in around 6:00PM and even with the crowd we were seated right away. The menu here features plenty of sandwich, seafood, salad, and appetizers options to satisfy just about anyone. I ended up ordering "The Frontiersman" which was BBQ chicken breast with cheese and Applewood smoked bacon (I'll order anything that has Applewood smoked bacon) with a side of French fries. How was the food you ask? The food was fantastic! The sandwich was hot, juicy, full of flavour, and so good that once I picked it up.....well, the sandwich never saw the plate again. The French fries were really good as well, crispy and tasty. On top of the good food and the quick service, I really enjoyed the atmosphere of Colter Bay (minus the drunk girls screaming, I'll never like or appreciate that). Simply put, it just looks cool inside and the logo is pretty cool as well. Overall, Colter Bay is the type of place that when friends and family visit me in Buffalo, I'll take them here. The food is fantastic, the staff was friendly, and the atmosphere makes for a fun night out. I highly recommend checking this place out if you are looking for food in Allentown. read more
2 years ago
My partner had a craving for steak, but the lines at the steak houses were too long. We happened by Colter Bay and decided to give it a whirl. We don't drink, so the review is just for the food and service, which is good. The potato soup came with cheese and chives, and was tasty. My partner's burger and fries satisfied him. My steak sandwich was good, too. The roasted Brussels's sprouts could have done with a little less roasting. read more
7 years ago
I can't believe I've been in Buffalo for so long and haven't been over to Colter Bay yet! Super cool atmosphere, and I really liked how they had a base menu with an entire list of daily specials. My lobster roll was a special, and coming from someone who lived in Rhode Island for a while, this was the BEST lobster roll I've ever had! I wasn't too much of a fan of their corn chowder, but it wasn't bad by any means. My mom had the scotch egg, and that's absolutely a MUST HAVE - so good! Definitely will be taking my husband back soon, and hopefully eating outside if the weather cooperates! read more
6 years ago
Love this bar. Always new beer on tap. Great craft brews to go. Every food item is scrumptious. Awesome location and environment. Whether you are grabbing a quick drink with friends, enjoying happy hour, or want a cool place to have dinner, Colter never ceases to please read more
I went to Colter Bay for the first time, supporting a Diamonds in the Ruff animal rescue event. There is (paid) street parking, outdoor seating, and a decent sized bar inside. I cant say enough how impressed i was by the owners and cooks at Colter Bay. They went out of the way to make sure the event went smoothly. They donated Colter Bay dog collars, catered the rescues other event across the street at Buffalo Big Print, and donated to the cause. They continuously kept the catered food replenished across the street, and kept making sure everything was going smoothly. Their customer service alone gets a 5 star review from me. The food and drinks were fairly priced and very well made as well. A live band started around 6, and i really enjoyed them. Overall, Colter Bay gave me a really great first time experience and i look forward to going back read more
Great location right on the corner. I come here for the beer selection. Large range of different types of craft beer and it changes too. Bartenders and waiters are attentive and pleasant. I did eat here once. Overall, the food was good. Nothing that blew me away. During the warm months, you can sit outside at a table or there are bar stools on the other side. Great option. Sat outside during the Allentown Art Festival and was an outstanding place to people watch and enjoy the festivities. read more
3 years ago
5 years ago
I ordered takeout and got the short rib melt. Service was good and the food was ready quickly The sandwich was really good, though I wish it'd had a little more flavor from the short rib. The fries were average. I would definitely eat here again! read more
I came to Colter Bay specifically for the Impossible Burger a vegetarian sandwich that is only served at one of 3 area restaurants I've had the sandwich plain and wasn't impressed this version (a special) with veggie cheddar fried onions and cole slaw on a bun served with fries turned out to be much better. if you're expecting beef flavor I didn't feel it but everything is better with Weber's mustard Service was great thanks Sarah everyone was friendly and helpful. Another great place for a selection of beers and potables. Haven't been here since the new version of the Colter Bay Shatzel magic was put in place. Well done and pleasant atmosphere. read more
8 years ago
7 years ago
5 years ago
This was out first visit to this place and we left pretty impressed. The atmosphere was rustic and comfortable. It was our waitresses 2nd day on the job and she provided courteous, prompt, friendly, & attentive service. Food was pretty good I had a burger with sweet potato fries and my fiance had the meatloaf. We both had a side of brussel sprouts. They have a small menu but do have daily specials to switch things up a bit read more
So let's be real... Summer is right around the corner and what is else to do but to enjoy eating at an outside patio for lunch. Don't waste another sunny day without stopping at Colter Bay. Ever since my workplace moved to downtown Buffalo I've been enjoying local restaurants more often. I went to Colter Bay a couple days ago to get lunch and refreshments. Our sever was very attentive and helpful, my drink was decent (aka. it needed a little bit more of the good stuff), and the food didn't disappoint. Why four stars? One of my friends has dietary restrictions and the menu didn't supply her needs. Hope this changes in the future... read more
I've come here a lot through the years. Always has a good selection of beers and consistently good food. The salmon salad I had this past time was pretty good. The salmon itself was delicious but pretty small, the salad was also quite dry. I've had it before and it was better so it's not going to totally effect my star rating. The burger looked amazing and tasted amazing as well. The Mac and cheese portion was massive. Colter bay as far as salads and burgers go is a little pricey, but the ingredients are far superior to most burger and salad spots. The beer selection is top notch if you like beers from all over. Only caution is this place can get busy and crowded so my advice is go on a weekday. read more
8 years ago
Me and my boyfriend came here on St. Patrick's day eager to try The Impossible burger. It was rowdy and crowded as expected . But to our great surprise the service was good and quick. We got seated quickly, got our order in and a few minutes later enjoyed our first Impossible burger All the burger lovers, you must give it a try - it's DE-LI-CIOUS, juicy, satisfying and is totally worth the price. read more
3 years ago
I was traveling back to Chicago and wanted to grab lunch with my sister before flying out of Buffalo International Airport. We wanted to get something a Buffalonian would eat and tried to get wings at Duff's but it was closed because it was Labor Day. A bit of a let down but what can you do? We turned to Yelp, spotted Colter Bay and ventured off to see if it was open. We were in luck! When we arrived at 2:30pm or so it wasn't terribly busy and we were seated immediately. The waiter brought over the menus and waters right away. I spotted the wings immediately and my mind was made up. The poutine sounded good as well, with the short rib of course, as did the macaroni and cheese. So there it was! Our hunger and frustration of running around Buffalo trying to find lunch met it's match in the way of 3 appetizers. The waiter said we made great choices and that poutine was one of their most popular dishes. In about 5 minutes the poutine arrived and it didn't disappoint. I don't get the appeal of gravy on fries but can definitely get behind fries, cheese curds, and super tender beef short rib. It was all delicious and If I am ever back in Buffalo I'm coming here for poutine. The wings and mac and cheese arrived next and they were good too. Wings in Buffalo, NY seem very appropriate and you can't go wrong. They were crunchy on the outside and tender inside and the BBQ had a tangy kick to it. Definitely delicious. As for the mac and cheese, it was very simple to me and didn't knock my socks off but I think that's because the poutine and wings were so good that they overshadowed the mac and cheese. Definitely a good last meal in Buffalo. Overall the service was great, the food delicious, and the restaurant and bar area clean and accommodating. If I'm ever back in town I'm coming back. I would have loved to have checked out the beer menu but I'll save that for next time, along with the elk burger which sounded intriguing too! read more
4 years ago
7 years ago
This is probably my medium favorite restaurant in the area. Came here to pass the time while I waited for my cousin to finish up at his AA meeting. I got the beef on weck and my friend got the bbq chicken sandwich . They had a wide variety of beers and what not to select from. The atmosphere and decorations is like a northwestern feel like your in Idaho or Montana. They have bison and elk and duck meat if that tickles your fancy. My sandwich was good. they also have live music Friday nights, they had the ramones today, they were old but still good. All in all not bad but not great ", good place to get beer tho lots of good selections and wide selection of food. read more
7 years ago
Amazing tap list on a fantastic space! Very decent vibe here. Very tasty bar eats. Luv their flight paddles with the built in chalk board! Super friendly and helpful staff! Their poutine with braised short ribs is delish! read more
5 years ago
9 years ago
I was excited to hear that Colter Bay was serving the Impossible Burger, the magical vegan burger that looks and tastes like beef. Let's get to what you want to know the most: the Impossible Burger doesn't taste exactly like a beef burger, but out of all the vegan burgers I've tried, it comes the closest. For me, the texture that gives the Impossible Burger away, but I'm still glad I tried it. Vegans and vegetarians who miss real burgers should give the Impossible Burger a try. I haven't missed burgers that much myself, but I like that Colter Bay offers this and a bean burger on the menu (the bean burger, while not the most outstanding one I've had, isn't bad at all). Omnivores considering the Impossible Burger for health reasons: you should just enjoy your beef burger and just balance it out with other healthier foods. I gave my meat-eating husband a bit of my Impossible Burger, but he just went back to eating his regular burger after tasting it. I also appreciate that Colter Bay offers 5 oz servings of any of their tap beers/ciders in addition to the standard 10 oz. This way, you can create a flight completely of your own choosing, try a drink you're not sure about-or, if your alcohol tolerance is terrible like mine, you can at least finish a little glass on your own. The staff is friendly, and I like the cozy ski lodge decor. The one thing I don't like is the acoustics. I've been here in the evenings when it's not too crowded, and I still have to lean across the table to hear dining companions. I haven't tried Colter Bay for lunch, but maybe the noise level is better then. read more
7 years ago
Colter bay in summer time 81° still feels like a ski lodge. The playlist is fire. The pictures on the wall are legit. The view of the allen Delaware interaction makes this joint prime real estate. The beer list is strong approximately 35 beers on tap. Prime buffalo establishment. I'd love to share a beer with Grizzly Adams here. Nice and quiet during the week. read more
More info about Colter Bay
561 Delaware Ave
Ste 565
Buffalo, NY 14202
Allentown, Main Street
Directions
(716) 436-5197
Call Now
Visit Website
http://colterbaybuffalo.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
More Info
Health Score
Ask the Community - Colter Bay
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
6 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
5 years ago
4 years ago
8 years ago
4 years ago
9 years ago
