I'll admit it... I went to Colonna's years ago when they first opened and wasn't impressed. Fast forward to now, and I'm glad I gave them another shot because this pizza was really good. I got the white pizza, and they did it the RIGHT way. Dollops of ricotta, fresh mozzarella, and that classic New York-style approach. No weird overloaded white sauce situation. Just really good pizza. The place was absolutely packed, which isn't surprising once you taste the food. The guys behind the counter were hustling, and watching them toss the pizza dough in the air definitely adds to that old-school pizza shop feel. There's a reason Colonna's has been around this long in Parker. Pizza places come and go around here, but they've managed to stick around and keep people coming back. read more

Colonna's Pizza - Pizza blanco.... Sorry a slice is missing - Pizza Near Me - Parker, Colorado

Gotta say I love Pizza First time here we came in from California have friends that own an Italian Restraunt in Pasadena Cal 4.5 star this place definitely compares to it would recommend it to anybody that comes here definitely a 4 star place love there Pizza read more

The meatball parm hero is next level! Perfectly toasted, saucy, cheesy, and packed with flavor -- a sandwich even Joey Tribbiani would approve of. Lunch specials are a win too, whether you're craving pizza, Alfredo, or a cheesesteak. Portions are generous, and for $1 extra, you can swap fries for a side salad Service could be friendlier; I've been helped by the same person a few times, and while he's not rude, it's very "down to business." The ambiance is fun though, with kids' games and food on display. Overall, still a solid stop for delicious comfort food! read more

See all

Ordered pick up which was quick and easy! We got a large pep mush, garlic cheese knots and mozzarella sticks. It was a bit pricey but definitely worth every cent! The pizza is NY style which I'm not usually a fan of but yummy yummy! The mozzarella sticks were huge and amazing. Cheesy garlic knots were so flavorful and super cheesy which is everything you'd you'd want in a garlic stuffed pillow of yum. We Will definitely be back! read more

See all

We have been looking for a pizza place that serves a good New York style pizza. We decided to give Colonnas a try. The restaurant is a "walk up to the counter" place and the food is brought out to your table. When it's ready. We ordered a large cheese pizza, sweet and spicy habanero wings and a Caesar salad. The wings were good. The sauce on the wings were more sweet than spicy. The salad was a standard Caesar salad and quite tasty. When the pizza came out, it was hot and fresh. I felt the pizza was good but needed a bit of doctoring. After adding parmesan and a bit of salt, the pizza was delicious. The restaurant was kept clean. The employees were constantly checking on us to see if we needed anything. read more

In Parker for lunch and wanted pizza. The reviews are dead on. A great NY style pizza place with lots of options. The slices were big and delicious. The full menu looks great and I was a bit jealous of the folks next to me with their subs! I Restaurant is clean and bright. They have beer and wine with Coke Products. Staff were friendly and quick. read more

Colonna's Pizza - Lunch special for $10. 2 slices and a medium Doet Coke. Great pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Parker, Colorado

My usual go to, the food is always so delicious, the staff is very friendly. The restaurant is spotlessly clean. They are always in here making sure tables are washed, their food surfaces cleaned, and it's an amazing place! Family owned and if you live in the Parker area, definitely give them a try. My daughter and her family live in Parker and I drive up from Colorado Springs to eat their. read more

Colonna's Pizza - Spaghetti with meatballs and always free garlic knots. Side salad and a glass of their house red wine. Excellent dinner. - Pizza Near Me - Parker, Colorado

Are you a cheese stick lover?? Then look no further, this is the ONLY place, I mean ONLY place I will go for cheese sticks!!! They are amazing!! Perfect in size and worth the money along with a coke and a smile and some extra marinara sauce and you've got the best snack, the best meal. Walk in or call in the service is pretty quick And your order is usually ready in about 12 minutes. The restaurant is clean and it's a quick Experience! If you or your kids love cheese sticks then welcome to my world! I order to be cooked a little longer for a crispness to them ! read more

See all

Some of the best Pizza in Parker! The plain cheese pizza is exceptional, crisp crust. Good service, staff is friendly and fast. The salads are fresh, and full of toppings. Perfect for Pizza night. read more

One of our favorite take out joints for NY Style pizza in Parker, the staff here is always super friendly, our food has been made quickly and the pizza is tasty. Personally, I am actually a bigger fan of their sandwiches as NY Style pizza isn't my preferred style, but their Philly's here are outstanding! The prices are reasonable and their portions generous. They tend to have both lunch and dinner specials to help make it even more affordable as well. If you live in the Parker area and you haven't given Colonna's a try it is worth it and it won't break the bank. read more

Take out pizza was on time and beyond delicious. We love this place to dine in and take out when necessary . Family owned quiet

Colonna's pizza is a standard family pizzeria. I could see it being good for a soccer/sports party, for example. Loud, friendly, bright. Pizzas are large and flavorful. I tried the meat one, the veggie and the cheese. Veggie was the best by far. The cheese garlic knot things were a must get, and the Caesar was pretty good too if you want something green! Quick and friendly service, good food...what more could you need? read more

Pizza sizes appear larger than stated... the large felt like an extra large, which is great! We ordered a large Tuscany and large Florence for a family size of 6 adults and 1 child. The large was plenty and we pretty much had an entire large pizza for leftovers. I ordered plain fetuccine alfredo, which came with 2 garlic knots. I like the flavor of the dough of the garlic knots and pizza. Must be the reverse osmosis water they include with the dough. Pizza dough was soft on the inside and slightly crisp in the bottom. The place is large with plenty of seating for groups. read more

Colonna's Pizza - Fetuccine - Pizza Near Me - Parker, Colorado

See all

Great service and very friendly and accommodating. Fresh and very good tasting. The pizza has a good sauce flavor but is over sauced. Ive never had to tell a pizza place to go lighter on sauce before so thats why i docked a star. I will do so next time. The place has a good vibe to it. Very welcoming and the price/specials is decent. I chose the personal pie (4 toppings) with a drink for $11.99. The single slices and the bigger pies looked like they tasted much better. I will remember this for next time as well. Mine definitely did NOT taste bad. It was empty at the start of lunch but busy after we sat down and i took the pics. Garlic knots were tasty as well. read more

Colonna's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Parker, Colorado

See all

Ordered has it delivered and ate in under a hour. Crust was nice a crispy. Garlic knots were garlicky and meatballs were filled with flavor and tender. Will order again!!!! Reminded me of real new York style pizza. read more

Excellent pizza and calzones. Mostly have ordered takeout, but have dined in a couple of times and service was great and place was spotless.

This pizza is really good, the lathes are MASSIVE, I'm used to large pizzas looking underwhelming but I order 2 from here and I was blown away by how huge they are. Not only are they huge but the crust is perfect, the sauce is delicious and the cheese and toppings are fresh. Highly recommend this spot. read more

I am so DISAPPOINTED in my dinner tonight, I expected so much more from this restaurant. $22 for chicken fettuccine Alfredo, the portion size was so small and the chicken didn't have ANY flavor. The Caesar salad was OK, it came with one small container of dressing. I didn't have Caesar dressing so I had to put Ranch dressing and on it. What a complete FAIL this was!!! And for $43!!! read more

Colonna's Pizza - Unseasoned chicken - Pizza Near Me - Parker, Colorado

See all

I've never had the chance to eat inside the restaurant, but every time I've ordered takeout from here I've never been disappointed. There's some good pizza places in Parker, but there's also GREAT pizza places in Parker, this is one of them. Food has always been made hot and on scheduled time. It was so good I ended up showing my parents and they've even claimed it's the best pizza they've had here in Colorado. I've personally never had a pizza made incorrectly here, my garlic knots always turn out perfect. Super garlicky that's actually put on top and not just a flavoring. A lot of people order pizza out rather than dine in, and I'm one of those guests that usually get take out, so next time you're getting take out pizza heavily consider getting this pizza. read more

This place is AWSOME. Some of the best pizza in Colorado! The staff are super nice and helpful, and I just loved the bibles and newspaper you can get at the front! The place is super well decorated and the ambiance is perfect. We will be back VERY soon. read more

Locally owned by a true New Yorker who uses his mamas recipes for authentic Italian flavors in his dishes. We tried the Meatball parm sub. It was huge. The meatballs are homemade with rich marinara sauce and topped with mozzarella. Excellent. The pizza was crisp crusted pie loaded with toppings. Reasonably priced. Also sold by the slice at lunch. They have a gluten free version crust as well as dairy free cheese options. Well worth a visit. read more

Went to this place yesterday with my two Great Grandsons. BAD news at the start. Woman behind counter taking orders was EXTREMELY rude. Combative behavior, and yes completely got order wrong, Double charged for Pizza. Ordered Large pizza, Half Pepperoni and pineapple, Half Meat Supreme. She charged as two large size. argued to no resolve. My Grand Sons were hungry after a day four-wheeling. Pizza arived, Half pepperoni NO Pineapple, Half Sausage, and pepperoni NO Salami NO Canadian ham. She took the pizza back to fix. They threw COLD pineapple and cold salami. Spoke with Manager. He became combative. Said he would remake pizza, but was going to charge full price again. Obviously I demanded a refund. Left Premises to NEVER RETURN!!! Most reviews seemed good, Go there if you like to be treated that way, GOOD LUCK. read more

Right on time. So delicious. These pizzas are quite big and very delicious. I ordered 2large one vegetarian and one trio. read more

Would recommend this restaurant. Good food. Prompt service. Friendly staff. Very clean.

Really miss this place since moving to Idaho. They do a great slice and have a solid menu overall. I came mid afternoon and the pizza was ready in about 5 minutes, one slice of meatball, one pepperoni. They also do a great Hawaiian slice if that's your thing (no judgment)! I'm glad they made it through the pandemic and hope they do well in the future. Always like stopping by when I'm in town. read more

Colonna's Pizza - Meatball Slice - Pizza Near Me - Parker, Colorado

The food here is always great. The service is always amazing. There's a decent amount of seating. This place is very consistent and always delicious. The best pizza in Parker. read more

Colonna's Pizza - Nice statue - Pizza Near Me - Parker, Colorado

Had their pizza to go. It's absolutely delicious and great red sauce! Apparently I need 85 characters. I'm not a food cretic just an average customer who loves good pizza. read more

Food was great. Service was good although it took quite awile for the food but the decorations are awesome so much to look at and see while you wait would come again. read more

Man ... I REALLY wanted to get behind this place. The crust is good. New York style 100% I just can't get over that cheese. Beyond greasy. I'm not certain it's dairy based cheese. The actual restaurant is pretty cool! Seems like a great place to have a team sports get together after games. Service was polite. I would wonder if this rating changes any by ordering a pizza to go and not doing slices. read more

Colonna's Pizza - Greasy stuff ... a bummer - Pizza Near Me - Parker, Colorado

Don't order a Deluxe Cheesesteak Sandwich. They believe one slice works. Pizza great, Sandwich needs work. read more

Colonna's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Parker, Colorado

Great pizza, salads, specials and even cannoli! But if you're eating in house, be prepared to wait, the take out is so busy that in house patrons wait forever for their food! read more

Christian Italian restaurant, everyone is so sweet & the food is amazing! would 100% recommend the lunch special is so affordable & really good! will definitely be coming back. read more

See all

A little on the expensive side but always worth it! Their pizzas are huge and they never skip on the toppings!

Dropped in for a quick slice and ended up with their slice, salad and drink special. The pizza was better than I expected and the Caesar salad was crisp and fresh. I'll visit again and get a whole pie. read more

Food is ok, but every time I get Colonnas, I end up with a sour stomach the next day. Prices are a bit on the high side, especially for the desert's. I'm probably never going back again. read more

Absolutely amazing and the best pizza so far I have ever eaten in my entire life! The flavor, the sauce, the cheese, the meats just all perfect! Our server was amazing and very quick and gave us what we needed. Very good seating and I love the old Chicago style feel they had in the restaurant! read more

See all

Another terrible dinner via delivery! The food was less than marginal. Bland Italian and hard garlic knots. We ordered salads with blue cheese dressing and got ranch and Caesar instead. In the menu it said you must select a side of pasta so we selected rigatoni and spaghetti but got NEITHER. Either they don't update their Uber Eats menu or they just put random things in bags to be delivered. I even called telling someone there that the menu did not have an area to put salad dressing choices and that we wanted blue cheese. He asked my name and said he found the order and would put the dressings in.... Nope! Didn't happen. 1st and last time ordering or going to Colonnas!! read more

Colonna's Pizza - Dried and hard garlic knot - Pizza Near Me - Parker, Colorado

See all

Pretty good pizza! I've only had the pizza so not sure about other food items but I go occasionally. Chill, causal, laid back vibe, friendly staff. If you're looking for simple, quick pizza, this is a good choice. read more

carry out of super large 18 inch cheese pizza was super delicious. actually, it was better than the NY Manhattan cheese pizza. Armed with buy a large pizza and get a 10 inch pizza for free (Facebook special), I called and got the code and ordered above. When I saw the 18 inch pizza, I was like.. mesmerized at this gigantic looking box and instantly worried about able to fit into my car door. Actually it did but I was very careful about not hitting the side and damaging the pizza. after 15 minutes drive home, me and the whole entourage was ready to dig in. I grabbed slice of the awesome looking 18 inch pizza, carefully tried to fold in half like I usually do and took the first bite and yes, I was in heaven.. that is pizza heaven. To make it short, I had to fight to fend off others to grab more than my share and .... I am ready for some more read more

Colonna's Pizza - Thank you Ralph. It was awesome - Pizza Near Me - Parker, Colorado

As a genuine natural born Italian I am extremely picky about what Italian restaurants I will enjoy a good meal at. Like if you tell me about you Olive Garden loves you might catch hands..... I absolutely would tell everyone to eat here! The owner is a New York Italian, clearly grew up cooking with Italians. The sauce, yes SAUCE, again if you say gravy you're gonna catch hands, has a good flavor and they used to make stuffed shells. The only thing they are missing is a good Cavatelli, not sure people not from the east coast know how to make that anymore. Love that Sunday's are closer for family, god and rest! Anything moral in today's society is greatly rewarded by my pocket book. #supportitalianbusinesses read more